Premise: Now that they know of the great prophecy, Firestar's grandchildren are struggling with its implications for them as a whole and as individuals. Lionpaw longs for glory in battle; Hollypaw desires a leader's wisdom; and Jaypaw is determined to discover more about their warrior ancestors. Their dilemma is made all the heavier when an ominous stranger arrives – and tensions between all four Clans explode in a bloodbath. But an even greater darkness is yet to come. And when it does, the Clans' collective faith in StarClan could be shaken to its core.
Story/Writing: Let me start this review by saying I've been looking forward to reading this particular book for a LONG time, ever since I got back into the series almost three months ago (Not to mention I got to read it on my birthday!). Not just because I knew a solar eclipse happens in it but also because of what this solar eclipse leads to. Ancient civilizations viewed events like a solar eclipse as a sign of an apocalyptic catastrophe, and since the cats of the Clans view the world in a similar way, how would it be any different for them? Anyway, how's the book itself? Honestly, with no exaggeration, I think this may be one of the best books in the entire series. Again, the authors take something we know is uncommon but not abnormal and write a story around it to make it a truly defining moment in the history of the Clans. The "New Prophecy" arc had the destruction of the forest, and this book has the titular eclipse. I've always been fascinated by astronomical events and the impact they can have on a story as well as the symbolism they can convey. And this story is no exception! Not only have the Clans never in their history seen something like this – it was foretold not by StarClan but by Sol. All of these factors rock the cats' faith in StarClan in a way that – even if it is regained – guarantees it'll never be the same again. I remember reading "The First Battle" and "Shadowstar's Life" with this sense of dread, the kind you get when you know a disaster is coming and all you can do is watch. I got the same feeling reading "Eclipse," except it was much, much worse. I got chills when ThunderClan found themselves fighting for their lives and even more so when the solar eclipse happened. It's funny how I come to these books with a sense of what will happen, but actually reading it and experiencing it for myself really engages my emotions. In this case, this installment has convinced me that these authors have a passion for their craft and have put so much time and care and love and effort into this series. I felt it on every page.
Characters: I love how quickly this arc has gotten me attached to the characters featured, particularly the ones featured in this book. They feel the same as they've always been, yet at the same time, they've grown and come so far already while also still leaving some room to grow further. They're written supremely well and I felt all their emotions and conflicts on every page. The amount of time given to each of the siblings to tell the story is still pretty well-balanced. Not to mention, this book actually got me to feel for characters I was never particularly sympathetic for. But more on that in awhile. Before I get into individual characters though, I just want to say that, for this book review, even if a character I discuss does get a new name later on in the story, I'm just gonna refer to them by what they're called for most of it.
Jaypaw – Until further notice, from here on out, I'm just gonna consider Jaypaw the main character in this arc, since he knew about the prophecy long before his brother and sister did and was the first of the three to discover his powers. That said, I love how this character has been endearing me to him more and more with every book. Even if he always remains a grump, he's proven that he does in fact have a heart and he does care. He would clearly lay down his life for his siblings. But he also has a medicine cat's desire to help and heal others. He's willing to go quite literally blind into the thick of battle to find cats who need his help. He gets so adorably excited when he helps Millie deliver her kits. But my favorite thing about him in this book is how much he cares for and about Cinderpaw. I liked how he was willing to stand up to Leafpool, and I absolutely love how the authors lead into him coming up with the idea to have Cinderpaw re-strengthen her leg by swimming. Not only do they build on things that have already occurred or been established. They do it in such a subtle and organic way that I did not see it coming. And when Jaypaw does come up with the idea, I was just as giddy as he was. I loved how it was built up, I loved how brilliant the idea itself was, I loved that Jaypaw was so determined not to give up on her, I loved that I was feeling what he was feeling, and I loved that this usual grump was getting so excited about something. I loved everything about it! Not only that, but even if you disagree with how he views StarClan, you can't help but admire his determination and the lengths he's willing to go to get the knowledge and answers he wants. And the fact that he even manages to convince his siblings to go with him on his search for Sol is pretty impressive.
Hollypaw – Once again, Hollypaw is my favorite of the siblings, though I will admit that could be because she's the most like me. Anyway, even if Hollypaw's ambitions are different from those of her brothers, she's just as ambitious as they are nonetheless. You can tell how much the warrior code means to her and that she would very likely be willing to die to defend it. I totally felt how distraught she was when Blackstar announced that he and ShadowClan were renouncing StarClan. I felt how betrayed she was when Sol decided to stay with ShadowClan rather than go to ThunderClan with her and her brothers as he promised. But probably my favorite moment of hers in this book is arguably her best moment, when she practically sprints to ShadowClan to plead for help on behalf of her Clanmates. She very likely knew that ThunderClan and ShadowClan never have been particularly friendly toward each other. But her Clanmates for now were on death's door for all she knew. And if she had to do this to save them, then nothing was going to stop her. I also wanted to cry for her when she falls asleep beside Squirrelflight. Even though I know that Leafpool is really her mother, I felt just as sad as I probably would've been had Squirrelflight truly been her mother. That all said, while Hollypaw is arguably the most morally-minded of the three siblings, like her brothers, she has a little bit of a dark side as well. When Sol says that she doesn't necessarily have to use her power to destroy the warrior code, she wonders if it would be such a bad idea to use her power to ensure a secure future for all the Clans, not just hers. I thought that was an interesting angle to her character and made her just as complex as her brothers.
Lionpaw – Speaking of complexity, wow did my feelings about Lionpaw in this book go all over the place! But at the same time, I didn't get a sense that the way my feelings got tossed about was superfluous and just done for the sake of drama. Clearly his journey into the mountains and especially the time he participated in the battle with the trespassers have changed him, and not entirely for the better. On the one hand, he's discovered that he's borderline invincible and can't get tired in battle. On the other, his desire for battle is growing at an increasingly disturbing rate. I give him points for being so willing to defend his Clan, especially given how he used to meet secretly with Heatherpaw. But speaking of whom, man… I was shocked when Lionpaw nearly slew her and Crowfeather in cold blood. I was really glad she just barely managed to snap him out of it, especially considering she's the one Lionpaw believes has betrayed him. With Crowfeather though, it was even worse when I remembered that he's not only Heatherpaw's mentor but also Lionpaw's real father. I can only imagine how much more heavily it's going to weigh on him when he finds that out for himself. Anyway, I'm glad he's at least trying to fight his darker side. And I'm especially happy that he's trying to rid himself of Tigerstar's influence, even if it's not for the most ideal reason. I must say though I found Tigerstar's reaction when he learned about the prophecy to be pretty interesting. It wasn't what I thought it was gonna be. It's clear to me that Tigerstar knows that if Lionpaw truly believes in this prophecy, that'll toss him out of the picture, and he'll lose his hold on Lionpaw. And he doesn't want that at all. I just hope Lionpaw gets a hold of his thirst for battle and eventually does rid himself of Tigerstar's influence.
Sol – Man, I don't think a character in this series has creeped me out this much since Mapleshade. And that's saying something, given I read Sol's origin story in "SkyClan and the Stranger." In fact, out of all the villains I've read about in this series thus far, Sol is probably the most unique. This character pretty much steals every scene that he's in. He has this almost spellbinding presence. He's handsome and even somewhat likable. Not to mention, even though you can tell that something about him feels off, it's so subtle that it could be easily dismissed. That said, he does kinda show his true colors toward the end, and in a way that reminded me of how he was revealed for who he is at the end of "SkyClan and the Stranger." He promised the siblings he'd go with them to ThunderClan, but when he sees how much of an influence he can have on Blackstar and therefore receive the respect he believes he deserves, he chooses that instead. I'd still like to know how in the world he learned about the solar eclipse, but he's quite nearly effortlessly left a pretty big impression on me already.
Blackstar – Speaking of Blackstar, I was surprised by how much I came to sympathize with this character. He's never been one of my favorite leaders, even though I will give him credit for doing the hard work of ridding ShadowClan of Tigerstar's influence, especially considering he was on Tigerstar's side for a time. That all said, while I strongly disagree with his decision to renounce StarClan, I do see where he's coming from. All the Clans have issues, and ShadowClan's main issue is that they've always had the least prey-rich territory. Blackstar has seen his Clan suffer the rat sickness. His entire Clan could've been killed if ThunderClan hadn't been there to get them out in time. And even though they've found a new home by the lake, their troubles seem to be never-ending. So, once again, even though I don't agree with his decision to turn his back on StarClan, I totally see how he's a weary, aging, and tired leader who just wants his Clan to be well.
Various Other Characters – Speaking of leaders, I LOVE the brief amount of spotlight Onestar and Firestar are given. While I will admit WindClan's attack on ThunderClan felt a bit too sudden, it's not entirely unfounded given how much more tension there's been between the two Clans ever since Onestar became leader. I get that Onestar has a tough job of leading the Clan that's often been considered the weakest, but his attack on Firestar – the cat he used to be friends with and the one who brought WindClan home – felt rather petty. Firestar on the other hand, man do I feel for him. No wonder he's been feeling so disillusioned lately. All his life he's simply wanted to do the right thing. Yet more often than not it just earns him resentment from other Clans. Even so, I'm proud of him for holding onto his faith in StarClan. Speaking of which, I felt for Leafpool as well. She wants Cinderpaw to become a warrior probably more than Cinderpaw does. Yet when her patient's injury seems like it'll just be a repeat of Cinderpelt's, because of her hastily made verdict, she feels so guilty and like she's failed Cinderpelt twice. Not to mention, Sol's fulfilled prophecy has clearly left her confused and uncertain. Speaking of Cinderpaw though, I'm immensely proud of her, too! I'm proud of how hard she's fought to succeed in becoming a warrior where Cinderpelt failed, and that she never gave up even when she got hurt twice. And now that she finally has succeeded, I can't wait to see how her warrior career will pan out!
Overall: This book was just an absolute BLAST to read! All of the other books are of course great but this one was particularly good. I know that nothing is going to be the same in the history of the Clans after this and I can't wait to see how this plays into the prophecy, as well as how things will go for the three siblings in the future.