Forbidden Letters, Men of the North 0, by Elin Peer.
It took a while for the message of this book to sink in. That's because it started slow-- merely a bottle with a message in it tossed over a 200-year-old border barrier. (Shades of Trumpian's Wall.)
The story built slowly, rising through complications and non-physical cultural barriers to a tremendous crescendo, and then a resolution totally unexpected and incredibly satisfying. As the final book in a series, its end is its beginning; its beginning is its ending.
It's designed to be a precursor to the brilliant Men of the North series by author Elin Peer. It defines the situation of the world following a horrific Toxic War that nearly destroys civilization. Instead, it creates two vastly different cultures--the Motherlands (most of the world) ruled by women, and the Northlands, ruled by men who refuse to live under any sort of female domination.
It's a simple story. A bottle with a letter in it is tossed over a forbidden border barrier. The protagonist is a woman writer, Devina, from the Motherlands who's curiosity gets the better of her and prompts her to return the message, which she has interpreted as a call for help from a Northlands woman about to endure a forced marriage.
Throwing all her cultural cautions to the wind, the young woman crosses the border illegally and sets up a sequence of events that results in a major shift in Northland society. I'm not going to elaborate on that change because that would give away the whole story. It's enough to say here that the change is tremendous.
It begins with a love affair between Devina and a Northman, Tyton, in whose society women are few, treasured, and protected. As she visits, Devina becomes Devin, a young boy of 14 or so, because to be seen as a woman opens the possibility of being claimed for a bridal tournament.
Along the way, much is revealed about both cultures, and here is the novel's true brilliance. Elin Peer has created differing societies so consistent that once you accept her premise, events follow almost automatically.
Motherland society, while it appears gentler and in some ways more admirable than the culture of the Northlands, verges on paranoia when it comes to relationships involving men. Women vastly outnumber men. Their society fears violence, alcohol, technology, and language. While non-violent, it comes down hard on the use of language, makes swearing an indictable offense, and thinks nothing of imposing censorship if it thinks language may incite violence or reformation.
Northland society, by way of contrast, is rough and ready. Swearing is part of the culture. Beer drinking is a national sport. Violence is common. What technology is available is used, and Northmen are always on the lookout for new forms of it. Women are so scarce and valued that tournaments to the death are held to procure wives. Women are assigned "protectors," and a death penalty can result from touching a woman without the consent of her protector.
It's not difficult to see that given these circumstances, the insertion of a catalyst like a Devina can result in a cataclysm. But I said that it took a while for the lesson of the novel to sink in, and it did.
The lesson is that no society is perfect, just as personal relationships are rarely idyllic. A society ruled by women (like any society ruled by men) is only as good as its rational thinkers. A non-violent society can be as repressive as a violent one, for entirely different reasons. It's like the old argument about the death penalty. Which is worse? Death or Life Imprisonment? One is final. The other is pretty final, too.
All in all, I think this novel is a fitting conclusion to the Men of the North series. It's also an appropriate introduction to the series if you're coming at Elin's books for the first time. But if you're not interested in probing for deeper meanings in an author's work, Forbidden Letters is a breathtaking romance and a riveting read. Moreover, it proves women can be as tough as men when the chips are down.