Examining the potential benefits and risks of using artificial intelligence to advance global sustainability. Drones with night vision are tracking elephant and rhino poachers in African wildlife parks and sanctuaries; smart submersibles are saving coral from carnivorous starfish on Australia's Great Barrier Reef; recycled cell phones alert Brazilian forest rangers to the sound of illegal logging. The tools of artificial intelligence are being increasingly deployed in the battle for global sustainability. And yet, warns Peter Dauvergne, we should be cautious in declaring AI the planet's savior. In AI in the Wild, Dauvergne avoids the AI industry-powered hype and offers a critical view, exploring both the potential benefits and risks of using artificial intelligence to advance global sustainability.
Dauvergne finds that corporations and states often use AI in ways that are antithetical to sustainability. The competition to profit from AI is entrenching technocratic management, revving up resource extraction, and turbocharging consumption, as consumers buy new smart devices (and discard their old, less-smart ones). Smart technology is helping farmers grow crops more efficiently, but also empowering the agrifood industry. Moreover, states are weaponizing AI to control citizens, suppress dissent, and aim cyberattacks at rival states.
Is there a way to harness the power of AI for environmental and social good? Dauvergne argues for precaution and humility as guiding principles in the deployment of AI.
Peter Dauvergne is Professor of International Relations at the University of British Columbia. He is the author of the award-winning books, Shadows in the Forest (MIT Press, 1997) and The Shadows of Consumption (MIT Press, 2008), as well as Loggers and Degradation in the Asia-Pacific (Cambridge, 2001), and (with Jane Lister) Timber (Polity, 2011). His most recent books are (with Jane Lister) Eco-Business (MIT Press, 2013) and (with Genevieve LeBaron) Protest Inc. (Polity, 2014). In addition to publishing 13 books and more than 50 refereed journal articles and book chapters, he is the founding and past editor (1999-2007) of the MIT Press journal Global Environmental Politics.
Sometimes a science book can highlight a totally new connection between two disciplines, and that was certainly the case here - linking environmental science and sustainability with artificial intelligence. Peter Dauvergne shows how (as is also in the case in many other fields) AI can both be a positive and a negative influence on the environment.
On the plus side, we see how AI is being used for everything from sending semi-intelligent drones out to look after the Great Barrier Reef to detecting illegal activities in protected areas by monitoring sounds and identifying those identified with, say, illegal logging in a forest. Perhaps the biggest impact comes from the use of AI in smart resources to reduce climate impact of everything from domestic houses to data centres.
This is all great stuff, but Dauvergne also shows the dangers that AI can present to the environment. This can come from misuse of the technology, but also from the resources needed to make the technology work. Often this results in a balancing act. So, for example, self-driving electric cars are good for the environment when used, but have a negative impact when the raw materials for the batteries and electronics are mined. What we don't really get is a feel for how to quantify this balance. This is a notoriously difficult activity - see, for example, the (failed) attempts to assess which is more environmentally friendly of reusable and disposable nappies.
The subject, then, is important, and Dauvergne uncovers some real positives and issues than many readers will not find familiar. However, the way he goes about it is not great. I was struck by one of the blurb comments on the back where a professor says 'this book is as fast-paced and thrilling as any sci-fi storyline.' All I can say is, this professor must read really boring novels, as the writing style here is classic dull academic: the book is packed with fact statements and is almost entirely lacking in any narrative flow.
To make matters worse, a lot of these statements that are thrown at us are not backed up with evidence or balance. As an example, there are dramatic statements of the way AI is sweeping the world, for example in the deployment of self-driving cars - but very little about all the issues self-driving car manufacturers face in going from localised trials to proper implementation, for example, the limitations of computer image recognition which can be fooled by small constructed patterns and the lack of consideration of resistance to the very idea of self-driving cars as more people are killed by them.
The author's politics also come through extremely strongly, which leads to the extension of the argument well beyond the environment, diluting the thrust of the book. So, for example, we are told (without evidence) that ‘Global sustainability is going to require a fairer, more just distribution of wealth and resources’. I am not saying this is necessarily untrue, but it’s not an obvious conclusion and it's not really about the environment. Dauvergne emphasises the existence of inequality but doesn’t mention the vast improvements in the circumstances of many at the bottom end of this scale - it's almost as if Hans Rosling's Factfulness didn't exist.
There's a core of interesting and useful information here, but it's a shame it's not presented better.
I really enjoyed this book. I was already somewhat familiar with how AI has been enhancing our lives, but this book takes the reader through lots of detailed examples. The sustainability angle was also a great take. The last part of the book was particularly interesting, and worrisome. I'm hoping our Congress finds a way to avoid funding SkyNet.
Good introduction if you haven’t been exposed to the intersection of artificial intelligence applications and climate change. Technologically it is already outdated in terms of AI capabilities in 2025 and even economically some of the consumerism landscapes and corporate sustainability trends that are discussed were completely changed by the pandemic. The Elon Musk praise and quotes aged very poorly.
I wanted to like this book. I wanted it to be on the cutting edge of global environmental politics. But honestly, it read like a piece written by a journalist for a wide audience. It's little more than a collection of news stories about how AI is being used for good (in the environmental domain) and bad (in all kinds of areas, not just environmental ones). There is no real analysis, no empirical work, and only a loose application of a critical political economy lens, which amounts to arguing that powerful business interests might abuse AI for their own financial gain. I am really hoping that Kate Crawford's book, Atlas of AI: Power, Politics, and the Planetary Costs of Artificial Intelligence, offers a more thorough assessment of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of AI.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Dauvergne is not content that people work and pay taxes so he can have good wages for the special merit of just showing up sometimes at the University. Having servants and secretaries to do his work, also paid by the working people, is nice, but still not enough. Dauvergne needs the people to work harder and pay for hiring corporations to do his plans. And like hundreds of thousands of unelected bureaucrats, if anything goes wrong, it's the corporation's fault and he'll get full pension benefits.
I would have appreciated if the guy has a less vague understanding of what AI is, but in the world of diplomas, knowledge is optional.
Artificial Intelligence en hoe dat samengaat met de natuur en ons denken daarover! Dan verwacht je een baanbrekend boek op het snijvlak van technologie en klimaat, en een kijkje in een mogelijke toekomst voor planeet een mensheid? Nou, niet in dit boek. Mooie retoriek, waardeloze inhoud. Dauvergne heeft de afgelopen jaren heel goed de krant gelezen. Artificial Intelligence gaat heel veel zaken veranderen en verbeteren. Een opsomming van investeringen die grote Amerikaanse en Chinese bedrijven in AI doen is een onderdeel van elk hoofdstuk van het boek. Er wordt driftig geciteerd uit jaarverslagen van die bedrijven, en uit quotes van topmannen die de afgelopen jaren zijn verschenen. Kortom, voor wie het nog niet wist, AI gaat echt groot worden mensen! Daarna komt Dauvergne tot de ontdekking dat de techniek voor alle doeleinden ingezet kan worden. De planeet redden met AI? Jazeker! Maar ook: volautomatische gewapende drones inzetten tegen de eigen bevolking? Ook dat! Dat geldt sinds mensenheugenis natuurlijk al voor elke techniek, en daar zijn boekenkasten over vol geschreven. Dauvergne heeft die boekenkasten nog niet ontdekt en blijft bij oppervlakkige constateringen dat we dus goed moeten opletten met AI. Wat storend is, zijn dat de ‘goede’ voorbeelden eigenlijk alsnog slecht zijn. Het regenwoud redden door afgedankte mobiele telefoons op te hangen, die kunnen horen of er ergens gezaagd wordt, zodat ingegrepen kan worden? Het Great Barrier Reef redden door een drone te laten varen die een ongewenste koraaletende vissoort doodt? Zo staan er meer in het boek: typische end-of-pipe oplossingen, die eigenlijk niks oplossen maar een verschijnsel bestrijden in plaats van de oorzaak. De Bojan-Slat-fallacy; als ik met heel fancy techniek en PR een milieuprobleem oplos, hoeven we het niet meer te hebben over waarom en hoe dat probleem ontstaat. Op een gegeven moment komt Dauvergne bij de behoefte tot regularing van AI. Hij haalt een aantal bekende voorbeelden aan, zoals het Partnership on AI. In de eindconclusie wijst hij er op dat AI, net als andere technologie, een instrument of power is, dus zelfs als the hype can make it seem as if AI is going to resolve the global environmental crisis, het kan net zo goed erger worden. Zo’n tegeltjeswijsheid als conclusie van een boek zou nog vergeven kunnen worden, als het vlot leesbaar was. Door de eindeloze opsommingen van steeds dezelfde berichten en namen is Dauvergne daar helaas niet in geslaagd. Niks geleerd, en een frustrerende leeservaring. Jammer.