Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Strange Case of Donald J. Trump: A Psychological Reckoning

Rate this book
The Strange Case of Donald J. Trump provides a coherent and nuanced psychological portrait of Donald Trump, drawing upon biographical events in the subject's life and contemporary scientific research and theory in personality, developmental, and social psychology. Dan P. McAdams, renowned psychologist who pioneered the study of lives, examines the central personality traits, personal values and motives, and the interpersonal and cultural factors that together have shaped Trump's psychological makeup, with an emphasis on the strangeness of the case--that is, how Trump again and again defies psychological expectations regarding what it means to be a human being. The book's central thesis is that Donald Trump is the episodic man. The chapters, structured as stand-alone essays each riffing on a single psychological theme, build on each other to present a portrait of a person who compulsively lives in the moment, without an internal story to integrate his life in time. With an emphasis on scientific personality research, rather than political rhetoric, McAdams shows that Trump's utter lack of an inner life story is truly exceptional. This book is a remarkable case study which should be of as much interest to psychologists as it is to readers trying to reckon with the often confounding behavior and temperament of the 45th President of the United States.

315 pages, Kindle Edition

Published February 17, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Dan P. McAdams

36 books47 followers
Dan P. McAdams is the Henry Wade Rogers Professor of Psychology and Professor of Human Development and Social Policy at Northwestern University’s School of Education and Social Policy. A leading expert in personality psychology and narrative identity, McAdams explores how people construct life stories to shape their sense of self. He is the author of several influential books, including The Redemptive Self: Stories Americans Live By (2006), which examines themes of redemption in American life narratives, and The Strange Case of Donald J. Trump: A Psychological Reckoning (2020), a psychological analysis of Trump's personality. His research has significantly contributed to understanding personality development, identity, and life storytelling.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
52 (40%)
4 stars
56 (43%)
3 stars
18 (13%)
2 stars
2 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Profile Image for Irene.
596 reviews18 followers
August 2, 2020
This book was far better than expected. Written by a psychology professor from Georgetown University, it describes Trump's personality using a variety of models. It is a scientific study, not a tabloid style profile. It includes his family background, describes what he was like as a child, and analyzes events that occurred when he was very young that may have factored into his future persona. A lot of time is given to the way he interacts with the world, especially his perception that it's an unsafe place in which it's never okay to show weakness. In fact, he sees his life as a series of battles which he must win. And he will say and do whatever it takes to make that happen. There is much more. Why he tells so many obvious lies. What's at the heart of Narcissistic Personality Disorder. His leadership style and why so many people respond favorably to it. Having finished the book I still feel he's dangerous and unfit for office, but I have more compassion for him as a human being, and for the people who follow him.
Profile Image for Wallace Kaufman.
Author 24 books7 followers
June 16, 2024
While Macadams has left wing sympathies and implies that only the right has authoritarian leanings, his explanation of Trump fits like one of Melania's dresses (fits on Melania). So far the only book or any piece of writing I've read that is both fair and precise. People with Trump derangement syndrome will still prefer to rant and vent instead of understand. In a nutshell, Macadams defines Trump as an "episodic" man and at the far end of the bell curve as a narcissist. Episodic means he has no past or future interests, only being in a battle and at the center of attention and winning by whatever means at hand. This explains why in some battles he belittles the very people he once hired with great praise. The past doesn't matter. Nor does any coherent policy or story, just winning.

Macadams quotes Trump as saying something like, "I am the hero of my own comic book." That seems to fit the facts of Trump's life and behavior, "an authentic fake".
Profile Image for Dr. Lloyd E. Campbell.
192 reviews12 followers
August 20, 2020
Dan McAdams is a Psychology Professor at Northwestern University. His specialties are personality and human development, with a particular interest in narratives. Unlike every other book on Trump, McAdams only wants to understand him, without diagnosis or political slants. As much as learning about Trump, the book is a good example of how McAdams thinks about people. I understand Trump and how McAdams thinks more than I did before I read this book. For me, McAdams achieved his goal. The repetition irritated me some, it cost McAdams a star from me.
Profile Image for Karen.
608 reviews52 followers
June 27, 2020
Fascinating in a “can’t pull your eyes from the trainwreck” kind of way, this would have been a ‘4’ for me if the author hadn’t repeated his points over and over and over.
493 reviews
October 24, 2024
The Strange Case of Donald Trump was, for me, a surprisingly compelling read. I wasn't sure at the outset that I'd be willing to wade through 252 pages of dense type--my eyes tire easily these days--but the journey turned out to be easier than I'd expected.

I only wish Dan P. McAdams had waited another couple of years before writing his book. Covid hadn't happened at the time it went to press, or the 2020 election, or January 6. And now, today being October 23, the tumultuous presidential campaign of 2024 is drawing to a close and with it, depending on the results, quite possibly our democracy as we know it.

I am grateful for this book for, at the very least, offering a reasonable explanation for the strict divide between Trump lovers and Trump...well, we weren't "haters" to start with, but he has managed to make haters of us. Good going, man.

The explanation? Well, some of us never watched The Apprentice, back in the day, or if we did (I didn't), we were smart enough to know it was just entertainment, in other words, fake. "After statistically controlling for a range of other factors, Gabriel (Shira Gabriel, cognitive scientist, as stated in the article, 'From Apprentice to President') found that American television viewers who established parasocial bonds with the host of The Apprentice were disproportionately likely to vote for Donald Trump in the 2016 presidential election, even if they were Democrats.... If it were not for The Apprentice, Gabriel suggested, there would be no President Trump." (p 19)

Trump's so-called accomplishments during the first two years of his presidency, much touted by himself and his supporters, might more accurately be called counter-accomplishments. They include withdrawing the United States from the JCPOA (Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, less formally known as the Iran nuclear deal). The result has been that Iran has stepped back from complying with the restrictions of the deal, increasing its nuclear program to the point where its uranium stockpiles are 20 times what they are allowed under the JCPOA.

In addition, he "took the United States out of the Paris climate accords. Adopted by the consensus of nearly 200 nations, the grand deal affirmed in Paris in December 2015 marked the first-ever international agreement to confront the mortal threat of global climate change. (He) walked away from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade deal. From NAFTA to NATO, (he) questioned the need and the very legitimacy of a number of other landmark deals forged by the United States since the end of World War II." (p 47)

Not great for the history books. But, to give the devil his due, he did lower taxes for his cronies--the very wealthy--and for large corporations, also not a laudable achievement for the history books.

I was appalled, dismayed, unnerved, and all manner of similar things to read that in the 2016 election, even after the Access Hollywood tapes were revealed, Donald Trump received "53% of the votes cast by white women. Yes: Over half of the white women voters in the United States in 2016 refused to support the first white woman ever to run for president and cast their votes instead for a man who boasted of grabbing pussy."

As a direct result of the Access Hollywood revelations, Billy Bush, into whose eager ears Donald Trump had directed his offensive comments, went down in flames. Bush was promptly relieved of his job as a host on NBC's Today show, and has struggled in the years since to rekindle his career.

Meanwhile, the scandal slid off Trump like an egg slides off well-oiled Teflon. Four weeks later, the aforementioned 53% of white women voters, ladies who apparently admire spoiled, rich, white bullies--we're talking a grown man here, not a 17-year-old--who like to "grab pussy" and boast about it, voted with their menfolk to ensure that Donald Trump, now the world's most famous pussy-grabber, would triumph in the presidential election of 2016. (p 141)

I was fascinated by the comparison McAdams drew between populist presidents, Donald Trump and Andrew Jackson; the latter's election in 1828 shocked the "elites" of the day. (pp 185-187)

It was not surprising to read that, "White Americans with especially strong authoritarian tendencies form the rock solid base of Trump's political support. While only a small percentage would consider themselves white nationalists, they nonetheless perceive that the influence and power of traditional white culture have begun to wane in the past couple of decades.... Whereas being 'white' has always been the default identity in American society, by virtue of its overwhelming majority, as white people sense a decline in numbers and power, they may begin to see themselves as akin to a minority group.... " (p 199)

Never mind MAGA. Trump's red hat might more rightly bear the letters, MAWA, "Make America White Again." As the leader of a white 'us,' Trump seems incapable of even faking a concern for the 'them'.... (He is) unapologetically fighting to make America white again. Trump is the arch champion of a declining majority in its waning years of hegemony. He is 'the glorious leader' of a fading majority, who will soon be a minority. Many of those American who most strongly and blindly identify themselves with the besieged us of white people perceive him as their savior." (p 200)

There is a lengthy effort to explain the conservative evangelical Christian right's love affair with Donald Trump. I call it "the end justifies the means" syndrome, but I am not a psychologist or a scholar. McAdams writes, "(Trump) exudes power, as the Christian God does in the minds of highly authoritarian Christians. Trump promises to protect... (A)sked how she could vote for a man who has repeatedly cheated on his wife, Peggy Young Nance, an evangelical Christian who is president of Concerned Women for America, had a ready retort: 'We weren't looking for a husband,' she said. 'We were looking for a bodyguard.' (p 205)

Donald Trump is like Pigpen, who spreads filth around him, in the Charlie Brown cartoon. Only Donald Trump's medium is fear and hatred, rather than literal dirt. "To create the psychological conditions of constant warfare, Trump creates chaos on nearly a daily basis, and revels in the chaos he has created.... By creating chaos in the moment, Trump establishes the conditions of warfare in which a strongman is expected to rise.... Fear and chaos work in Trump's favor. They are his best friends for sustaining the authoritarian dynamic....fear and chaos capture well how Donald Trump has always experienced the world. This is how he has always lived. And now we are living it, along with him.... Basking and raging in the disorder he creates, this strangely antagonistic human being seems perfectly made for the strangely authoritarian times in which America and the world find themselves." (pp 208-209)

Phew. Now for comic relief. I laughed out loud at McAdams's reference to Mike Pence as "the beta chimp-in-chief...." Just one amongst many, many beta chimps. (p 217)

A profoundly ignorant man, Donald Trump is "(A) man who does not read books and shows virtually no curiosity regarding human achievements in the arts, humanities, and sciences, Donald Trump has little appreciation for experts of any kind, writing them off as elitists.... In derogating experts and ignoring the prestige that they have traditionally earned, Trump has effectively channeled a rising populist suspicion of intellectuals and other elite professionals. This dominance strategy has won him many supporters among poorly educated white Americans." (pp 221-222)

This begs the question: "Why is Donald Trump so mean? Where does the venom come from? ...(Being a non-reader) Donald Trump never transported himself away from the bellicose world he created through reading stories or other exercises in imagination. Research shows that reading good fiction exposes us to the perspectives of others while nurturing empathy and psychological understanding.... Trump has never been able to escape the angry moment, or else he has never wanted to." (p 325)

We wonder why Trump's constant lies, often outlandish and obviously false, do not bother his devoted followers. I came closest to understanding--though I still don't--when I read the following:

"Why do Trump's supporters put up with his lies? Even when they concede that a Trump statement is inaccurate or even a bald-faced lie, many Americans nonetheless believe that what he says conveys a deeper truth, or else could be true. Others revel in his lying because they believe it helps him win, and they believe he is fighting to win for them." (p 236)

"For Trump and his most loyal supporters, the us includes those white Americans, trending male and older and less educated, who feel dispossessed and disenfranchised in 21st-century America. The them includes...the mainstream media, the scientific establishment, the educational establishment, the legal establishment, Hollywood..., Democrats, people of color, and nearly any other group or constituency that questions Mr. Trump's hegemony. Importantly, them also includes Muslims and other groups who are perceived to threaten America's Christian heritage. And, most important, the them is immigrants. Trump imagines hordes of immigrants invading America at the southern border. They are criminals, rapists, drug dealers, and terrorists." (p 239)

Two weeks till election day 2024. If Donald Trump wins, we are doomed. If he loses, he will claim he won. We may still be doomed.
355 reviews
March 7, 2023
This is a strange but useful book.

I had low expectations on picking it up. But the doc, while falling into some of these, transcended others, with a truly useful book at times for exploring not personality disorders, but personal behavior, character, development, perception, narrative, transformation.

The doctor does this in such a way that one may learn about these and one’s self, if not so much useful about the 45th President. Except by contrast to what is normative. And that is useful enough.

One of his observations, for example, is the surprising but ultimately persuasive idea that Trump is not just transactional, but almost episodic. In other words, there is less a continuing story of rise and prestige (say, that is one paradigm to understand dominance), than a story of a series of conflicts, in which the result is always, in Trump’s telling, a win, and continued dominance—not thru prestige, but aggressive use of power.

The doc’s point when fully developed was compelling. Trump is not a reflective man. And he does not grow and develop. His striving tho led to a perception of authenticity in a plurality of the electorate, which was highly valued in a time of falsity. So much so that Trump’s untruthfulness did not seem to affect that perception of authenticity. Curious still. But at least a working theory.

Even this brief recap sounds one-sided, I know. But by walking us thru so many aspects of humanity, it helped a little to explain Trump. And a greater amount to explain people’s response to Trump. And to explain our own individuality along these measures (behavior, development, narrative, etc., and just why are more people not like Trump?)—and how we interact with each other. And how other leaders have approached categorically similar problems, tho most often in other ways.

While the book could not help but miss as often as hit I suppose (hit being somewhere on the bulls eye, while miss being the whole wide world), I marked it a 4 star bc it’s overall lessons are worth revisiting. And it argued to me the mechanics of things in human development I did not know or had not considered at the start.

I may revisit some chapters with this broader set of interests now. Not about Trump, but about individual development, stages we ought to revisit in character formation, what of these stages we find in others, and humanity as a whole . . .

Oh. And it in the conclusion reminds us of why Trump did not value some obviously valuable things (like NATO), while other presidents overvalued in that “charming” American way ideals that led to wars that derailed what otherwise could have been a legacy of compassionate conservatism, in favor of wars that — while they may have limited terrorism at home, failed in their other stated objective, of building democratic and human rights oriented institutions, that could have transformed the Middle East. Trump is wrong about one, even as he favors hard nosed one off deals, while Bush II was wrong about the other. Any number of presidents on the left could also have been used in contrast. But Bush is useful bc Trump withdrew (or set the stage to withdraw) from Bush’s conflicts, which set the narrative of the first 2 decades of the new millennia. It is also irony built on irony, since the post World War II order epitomized by NATO made freedom of the seas make deals and even a certain form of American greatness possible (the things which Trump said he embraced). This in turn reminds me of the difference between games and infinite games (aka winning a game, or transaction, vs winning a season, and becoming champions). But this is beyond the book.
10 reviews
August 25, 2026
A book with a great narration. Scientifically based and most of the time somehow entertaining, although it becomes repetitive over time on some points he presents.

The author tries to portray a psychological frame of Donald Trump, focusing in his personality and life story, rather than trying to identify possible mental illnesses such as depression, which is a mental illness. Despite of that beign said, however, one should not confuse mental illness with personality traits. This book will touch possible personality traits that are present within Trump, such as narcissism or high extraversion, explaining what those traits mean for a person's behaviour; also, it will scratch questions regarding why he became what he is now. Why did he run for a career in real estate? Why did he run for president? Why is he such a disagreeable person? What could have been the implications of the education from his father in his professional pursuits?

This book I consider is a compelling urge to diplomats, politicians, analysts and everyone interested in politics and geopolitics to submerge into the personality and minds of those who represent us. The author claims that as we listen to economists for understanding an administration's economical management, or we listen to analysts for understanding diplomatic approachment, among other themes, we may also address to psychologists and other professionals to obtain insight about personality questions regarding our leaders. Obtaining insight about personality, not about mental health, in respect to the Goldwater rule, because we are social beigns who evolved to observe and assess other social actors, much more those who have a position of power in our social environment.

I enjoyed pretty much this book; nevertheless, I felt a bit distrustful for the inclination of the author towards democrats' liberalism and traditional conservatives. For example, he mentions Trump's claims regarding Mexican or Muslim inmigrants. I, as a mexican, would argue: What makes him so different from other presidents, such as Obama or Bush? The relationship between abroad imperial militarism and domestic bigotry towards Islamic and Latin American countries and people has a long history —the Latin American dictatorships that lasted over decades after the Cuban revolution succedeed, which counted with the support of the US, for example—
Profile Image for Ashlie Johnson.
147 reviews1 follower
October 5, 2024
3.5/5 Okay, okay. My bookclub convinced me. Even writing the first few words of this review, I had to go change the stars from three to four. Here’s the deal: would I recommend the book? Not particularly. Did it have compelling ideas and solid arguments? Yes, many.

I’ll start with the good. The author knows personality psych very well and is qualified/skilled in his assessment. There are insights about the life of Trump that put his behavior in context I had never considered (though I never want to hear about his lack of a life narrative again). It was a really fun book club chat, and really intriguing for the current political moment.

The negative is solely the writing. I think it comes down to the fact that I, as a psychology professor, found it hard to focus and enjoy. I EAT UP psych research, theory, etc., but the book so repetitive and dry that it felt like I had to wade through the “meh” a ton to get to the “whoa.” It felt like a peer-reviewed academic book with chapters aimed to reinforce the same thesis over and over. I also found the organization confusing. It bounces around from one idea to the next and then brings up past ideas to build on further. I mean, I have ADHD and it was still jarring.

All and all, with a critical editor and a motivated publicist, I think this book could have been HUGE for the time it was released. It is perplexing to me that it wasn’t, even with the dry nature. Glad I read it, and would recommend a summary of the ideas to a friend. If the author did a podcast or video, for example, I would much more readily recommend that.
Profile Image for Jeff.
331 reviews6 followers
June 30, 2026
Written before the 2020 election, Dr. McAdams's profile of Trump is spot on. His major premise, Trump has no narrative story about himself. He has no past or future story to tell. He lives in the moment, and that moment is viewed as a never ending contest where he must always win.

The book takes readers, from Trumps key principles noted in his book, "The Art of the Deal."
Here the final principle is always winning. Then he views Trump's behavior in five dimensions each within its own spectrum. The dimensions are: extraversion, neuroticism, openness, conscientiousness, and agreeableness. Dr. McAdams tells Trumps's history from childhood through his days in New York real estate. Here he notes three people who deeply influenced him: his father, his high school coach, and Roy Cohen. The author also explores the relationship between Trump and his three wives. The books final chapter explains the importance of individual and group narrative stories.

I was particularly pleased with Dr. McAdams explanation of how Trump can come off so charming and engaging during one-on-one meetings. Remembering Bill Maher's dinner with Trump and how Maher commented we should more of this Trump than the one he plays on TV. The lesson being it is only short termed and can change when it no longer suits him.

Dr. McAdams also presents interest perspectives on diagnosing the president and the Goldwater rule.
Profile Image for Alex.
122 reviews
April 25, 2026
A really interesting read, though it could have been a lot shorter. The basic idea is that Trump is 'the episodic man', a man who has created no broad narrative for his life. Most of us create a narrative as we grow up to help make sense of our successes and failures and to reflect our morals and values. Trump, in contrast, describes life as an endless series of battles that can be won or lost, leading nowhere except to the next battle. It's borderline nihilism, with nothing mattering but victory. It explains why he can change his views and contradict himself so easily: his opinions are whatever seems to be most likely to help in winning today's battle. If tomorrow's battle calls for contradictory opinions then so be it. This might be the best psychological portrait of Trump I have read.
118 reviews
September 30, 2021
I am tempted to give it a five and would easily give it a four and a half if I could, but I'm hard grader. Many years ago I had the author for a grad school psychology class and his approach to adult development intrigued me. Which is why I read the book even though I can't stand the subject. McAdams does an excellent job of not getting caught up in either assuming 'he must be doing something right' admiration or quick dismissal of the subject as narcissist or psychopath. He instead carefully lays out a case for what kind of person our most recent ex-President is and how it fits with psychological theories and how this strange psychology taps into a current void in our American story.
38 reviews1 follower
May 10, 2026
The narrator of the audiobook has a good voice, but is smug. It is unsuitable for a book where the author makes moral judgments, yet is wanting to appear objective. With the narrator’s tone, the author suggests that, he, too, is smug and biased.

Much of the book is interesting. The book could, however, be edited down to half its size. Half. As another reader mentioned, the repetitions went on and on. Was this book actually edited?

The book starts off providing thoughts on personality and the making of personality. I know little about those subjects, and am somewhat curious about current hypotheses of personality.

By the latter part, the book is just another political blog. It is so repetitive, it no longer suggests that the author is smug; rather, the book is a political rant of a superior pol. It’s a political YouTube video.

Will the book ever end?
Profile Image for Paul Szydlowski.
357 reviews9 followers
June 23, 2023
A so-so look at what makes Donald Trump Donald Trump. Perhaps the best explanation comes by way of an anecdote about writer Mark Singer's interaction with the then future president. Asking Trump what he thinks of as he's shaving in the morning, the one-time future president is at a loss for what Singer means, leading to the conclusion that Donald Trump has achieved something remarkable - a life completely untouched by the rumblings of a soul.

But we already knew that, so...
Profile Image for Carl Nelson.
57 reviews4 followers
March 29, 2020
A careful scholarly analysis that should be widely read

Starting from the Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and ending with the alpha chimp Herein Prof McAdams tells a captivating story. In the process he presents strong evidence that Pres Trump is episodic man. The explains a large number of his odd attributes.
Profile Image for Architeacher.
92 reviews52 followers
September 26, 2020
As someone involved in historical fiction and character development, Dan McAdams perspective on Trump's personality was a gift. There are no value judgments here; no "insider" revelation (like Mary Trump's book); and very little "alarmist" language. All of which is why I plowed through it so rapidly and learned so much quite aside from DJT scaring the crap out of me. That was the side benefit.
3 reviews
April 13, 2020
In the Head of Donald J Trump

As I read this book there were some very interesting comparisons that you can see in the daily antics of Donald Trump. He’s scary and he’s going to destroy this country everybody needs to come out in November and vote him out of office
Profile Image for P.
110 reviews7 followers
October 31, 2025
I like this book because it is not politically biased.
It just tries to decode the mystery of Trump.
Trump is really a special case. This book tries to decode how special he is and why.

Spoiler:
It gets a long way with the explanation, but it's still a mystery.
Profile Image for Dewayne Stark.
564 reviews3 followers
October 31, 2020
Have read several books about J. (stands for jackass) and this one is probably the best.
Profile Image for Ben Wikner.
23 reviews5 followers
December 30, 2023
A highly insightful examination of Trump. Author's analysis very much explains and predicts how Trump handled the pandemic and subsequent loss in 2020.
Profile Image for Ruth.
229 reviews1 follower
February 25, 2024
I think I understand now- why he holds the loyalty of both the religious and unreligious. It's a scary story.
Profile Image for Benjamin Henley.
98 reviews2 followers
July 24, 2025
Started slow but that is not reflected in review because the rest was so good. Very interesting perspective while being nuanced.
Profile Image for Michelle.
24 reviews
November 25, 2020
Painful to read. Glad I read it.

"The dominant chimp will always lead" (285). I'm glad, too, that we've exchanged a dominance-oriented leader for a prestige-oriented leader.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews