從書名可以輕易推測到,這本《拿破崙並不矮︰歷史寫錯了!埃及金字塔不是奴隸建的、美國獨立不是因為增稅、諾貝爾沒有發明炸藥,揭開那些一直被誤解的史實真相》,是一種「歷史趣味輕鬆讀」之類的書籍,原文標題《Napoleon Wasn’t Short & St Patrick Wasn’t Irish: When History Gets it Wrong》一樣落落長……整體來說,大概就是「故事性過強」的歷史,事實的成份通常都比較低。——自從我讀過各種《太史公史記》的研究之後,認定這應該是中外歷史的定律了。
A light interesting read about events in history that are accepted as fact but may not be actually true. Some of the things were clear that they weren't true but somethings were a surprise and there were a few things that could be argued for being true. On somethings I was convinced after reading her explaining but on others I wasn't. The same source was also quoted A lot. But it's a quick read for anyone looking to know more about history.
This "history light" book probably receives very different ratings, depending on the reader. In short tellings, popularly held beliefs are debunked. The research behind the truth is interesting, but instead of pleasurable enlightenment, I found I already knew what was coming, this, no doubt, because I'm an older reader who has already come upon most of the stories. Without the fun of surprise revealings, I didn't find the book as entertaining as it would be for others.
A few controversial topics and the author seemed to source the same sources is each section. Some were falasies without a doubt but others could easily be argued against. Very interesting read though
This book offers corrections to ninety historical inaccuracies or downright fabrications that are commonly repeated to such an extent that they have become the received story. Two of them are mentioned in the title of the book. Although I found most of the corrected narratives interesting, I also found myself thinking that the correct version often makes a less memorable story and fails to serve as a vehicle for an important principle of morality. When narratives are fabricated, it is often for a reason; the fabrication makes a point that a more accurate telling of the event would not make as well.
This was a pretty light read, and contained some interesting historical tidbits. The research seemed pretty good, but the overall writing was fairly dry. There were some things that I remember hearing before, and others that I had not. Overall, nothing to really write home about, but worth reading nonetheless.
Although a good premise, many of the "myths" of the book are already well-known to be debunked. Add to that several snide comments and offensive jokes on the part of the author, and the resulting book is not as enjoyable or informative a read as the title would imply. Also, there's nothing in it about Lucrezia Borgia, just in case anyone was specifically looking for that tidbit.
my friend got me this book for my bday (after she couldnt find ice like fire) so I was p excited to read this book but honestly... I just cant lmao, like yeah it has interesting facts but I am not drawn to the book in general. ofc, that's probs just bc there's no story at all it's obvs just a history book.
anyway i will continue reading it, definitely, just. a little bit every once in a while
A good go to book to pick up and put down,use it as a reference book.some of things I did know taught at school by teachers who should have known better.