Personally I think it's more of a 2.5 but since I didn't like the childish writing and it's for teens I don't wanna take too much credit away from it lol. See, I know that there are good, strongly written, important books out there for kids with good representation and nuanced takes on social issues, which makes me feel off the bat that this book isn't good because it's just fluffy. But I have to remind myself that some teens just WANT to read a fluffy book sometimes and don't want to be reminded of how tough the world is all the time.
This book is about Ellie, who when the book opens is dating Hunter. She tells him she's finally ready to have sex with him... and he dumps her the next week for a girl named Brynn who he may have potentially even hooked up with while he was dating Ellie. She ends up in the same home ec class as the happy couple, and changes groups to be with the "delinquent" group - Luke, Isaiah, and AJ. She naturally learns that the bad boys aren't all that bad, Luke is cute and sweet, and that she has a life outside of Hunter. She joins the school news team, spends time with her class group outside of school, and just does some stuff because she wants to and not because she's trying to impress Hunter or his friends.
There's some hints of serious topics - Ellie's parents are poor all of a sudden because her dad had a restaurant, hired a manager, it was mismanaged by that person, and all the money is gone now. AJ is also poor and lives with his grandma and does a lot of the household duties. Luke's dad died of cancer when he was 13. Isaiah's mom is really strict on him. All of it just sort of exists as backstory, but I appreciate the diversity in peoples' home lives.
It was a cute story and all, it was just written very childishly and none of the characters were deep enough for me to fully care about them. The boys in her group were sweet but it was almost corny the way none of them were actually bad lol. Luke did BMX stunts in his spare time, Isaiah wanted to be a horse handler, and AJ wanted to be a baker. Like I wanted at least one of them to not have a hobby to humanize them and for them to still be worthy of being liked without having something to soften them up to the masses lmao. I also do not like a lot of how the relationship stuff was handled - Hunter was awful to Ellie. Brynn was also. Ellie's stuff about sex only came up at the beginning when she agreed to have sex with Hunter and then later when she was bullied for being a virgin and even Hunter made a jab at her for being a virgin later. I think sex should have fully been left out of this book just because of the very light and childlike tone of the rest of it. I mean, it could easily be realistic to a teen's life, so I don't wanna discount it, but it just didn't vibe well with the rest of the tone of the novel. Luke had a girlfriend when he liked Ellie but he didn't act on it until they'd broken up and then Ellie had insecurities tied to that because of what Hunter and Brynn did to her. So then Ellie treated Luke poorly and it was all just a big mess. So to be a romance book, it was quite non-romantic.
Despite all that, it was cute. I think it would make a cute TV show just because there's a pretty big cast of characters and there were definitely hijinks involved.