What do you think?
Rate this book
The Echoes Saga #7
The Knights of Erador
“HERE IS TODAY’S LESSON; HEROES DIE…”
It’s fifteen years since the Orcs were defeated. Fifteen years since a new king rose from the battlefield. Fifteen years since Illian knew the horror of war.
Fifteen years of peace are about to end.
Something is coming. Shadows gather. Whispers of rebellion have reached the king. Darkness stirs beyond Illian’s borders.
Beyond the mountains, Dhenaheim has lost a quiet war. Refugees pour into Illian, bringing suspicion and unrest. For Doran Heavybelly, Dhenaheim's war means facing a personal tragedy that demands his attention... and his axe.
A simple job for too much coin should have been warning enough for Asher but, like Fate, trouble always has a way of finding him.
Conspiracy. Rebellion. Betrayal. Time to find out who the real heroes are.
THE KNIGHTS OF ERADOR CONTINUES THIS UNMISSABLE EPIC FANTASY SERIES.
It’s fifteen years since the Orcs were defeated. Fifteen years since a new king rose from the battlefield. Fifteen years since Illian knew the horror of war.
Fifteen years of peace are about to end.
Something is coming. Shadows gather. Whispers of rebellion have reached the king. Darkness stirs beyond Illian’s borders.
Beyond the mountains, Dhenaheim has lost a quiet war. Refugees pour into Illian, bringing suspicion and unrest. For Doran Heavybelly, Dhenaheim's war means facing a personal tragedy that demands his attention... and his axe.
A simple job for too much coin should have been warning enough for Asher but, like Fate, trouble always has a way of finding him.
Conspiracy. Rebellion. Betrayal. Time to find out who the real heroes are.
THE KNIGHTS OF ERADOR CONTINUES THIS UNMISSABLE EPIC FANTASY SERIES.
608 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 20, 2020
1241 people are currently reading
2332 people want to read
About the author
Philip C. Quaintrell
22 books1,544 followersPhilip started his career as an emergency nurse and began writing the books he’d want to read as a hobby between shifts.
He published his first novel in 2016, and soon began his epic fantasy series, The Echoes Saga which went straight into the Amazon bestsellers list in 4 countries.
Now one of the best-selling indie authors worldwide, Philip lives in Manchester, England with his wife and two young children and is hoping this is just the beginning.
He published his first novel in 2016, and soon began his epic fantasy series, The Echoes Saga which went straight into the Amazon bestsellers list in 4 countries.
Now one of the best-selling indie authors worldwide, Philip lives in Manchester, England with his wife and two young children and is hoping this is just the beginning.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews
February 20, 2023
4.5/5 stars
Wow. The Knights of Erador is the best first installment in the three trilogies in The Echoes Saga.
I know. Not even a month has passed since I claimed Age of the King, the sixth book in The Echoes Saga, as the best book of the series so far. And, already, I have to take back my word. The Knights of Erador, the seventh book in the series, marked the beginning of the end, and it managed to top Age of the King. It is the first installment in the final story arc of the nine-book series, and yes, this is the finest book in the series so far. I can't make any promises this statement will hold for a long time. Based on what I've read here, my instinct tells me the final two books in the series will be superior. But for now, I will say that I am happy and proud to call myself a Quaintrellians.
Remember how The Fall of Neverdark, the fourth book in the series and also the first book in the second trilogy of the series, begins 15 years after the end of Relic of the Gods? Well, Quaintrell implemented a similar time jump here. The story in The Knights of Erador starts 15 years after the end of Age of the King. And in a similar style to The Fall of Neverdark, the first half of The Knights of Erador can be categorized as the calm before the storm. It is, however, much more accessible than The Fall of Neverdark, in my opinion. And more importantly, this is a much superior book compared to Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark; both are the first installment in a trilogy of the series. Conspiracy, rebellion, betrayal. The most terrifying enemy to ever enter Illian is here, and once I reached the halfway point, I couldn't put the book down to the end.
Honestly, the only reason I didn't give The Knights of Erador a 5/5 stars rating was due to the pacing in the first half, which can feel slightly like a slog sometimes. This isn't to say there weren't any intriguing events in the first 300 pages. However, those who've read the series Age of the King will know what will happen soon in the story, and it can make readers (like me) feel impatient to see it unfold quickly. But more on that later soon. I think one of the main factors, other than Quaintrell's improved skill as a writer, why I love this one so much more than Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark as a new start of the series can be catered down to the characters. One of the difficulties of reading Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark is getting used to and acclimating ourselves to the number of new characters. In The Fall of Neverdark, we were introduced to Alijah, Inara, Vighon, and The Crow. This took me a while to feel familiar with. But that is not the case with The Knights of Erador. Only one new POV character, Kassian, was introduced here, and most of the novel revolved around the main characters that appeared for the first time in The Fall of Neverdark. Only two main characters from the first trilogy played a dominant role in the narrative of The Knights of Erador, and I loved reading their POV chapters thoroughly. That's all I can say to avoid spoilers. Please understand. This is the seventh book of the series, after all.
To continue what I said earlier regarding the second half of the novel. Those who've read the series up Age of the King will most likely predict who will be the main villain in The Knights of Erador and most likely the remaining of the series. And so far, the villain in The Knights of Erador and hopefully the rest of the series is the best for me. The resurgence of this character as a villain was predictable considering how Age of the King ended. But to see it unfolding and written so well was nothing short of breathtaking. All the planning, the betrayals, and seeing him becoming the main villain also signifies extensively why the series is titled The Echoes Saga. It reminded me of the first time I watched Revenge of the Sith. I knew what would happen to Anakin Skywalker. But that did not detract my excitement from seeing it happen. Plus, for readers who've read Solo Leveling manhwa, imagine the main character there becoming the main villain. You will know just how terrifying it is. And the combination of these two comparisons is indeed the kind of villains we're getting in The Knights of Erador, and as I repeatedly said, hopefully, the rest of the series.
Quaintrell genuinely amazed me The Knights of Erador. Quaintrell has mentioned several times now how he's mostly a pantser rather than a planner type of writer. And somehow, the world-building, lore, character development, and plot progression felt like everything was planned since Rise of the Ranger. As I said earlier, the pacing in the second half of The Knights of Erador was excellent. The villain's blind justice and self-righteous commitment to supposedly bring order to the chaos was so entertaining and immersive to read. Unlike all the previous books in the series, we did not have any POV chapter from the villain here. However, witnessing the villain's actions through the eyes of his victims and opponents made the narrative more engaging, powerful, and emotional. With all the attempted assassinations, dragons, undead abominations, and elemental monstrosities, the second half of The Knights of Erador somehow ended up being the best section of The Echoes Saga, so far, for me. And I have no doubt this will be toppled over soon in Last of the Dragorn or the final book of the series, A Clash of Fates.
It is cliche and repetitive to say this, and I can't make any promises I won't repeat this again in the next two books, but The Knights of Erador is the finest installment in the series so far. The exciting actions and battles felt both epic and intimate. It is surreal and awesome to witness how much Quaintrell has improved as a storyteller since Rise of the Ranger. I've been reading The Echoes Saga for almost the entire year of 2022, and I can't believe I only have two books left in the series to read. I am undoubtedly looking forward to reading the next book. If the last two books in the series somehow managed to supplant The Knights of Erador as the better book, well, I think at that stage, you will be hearing me stating The Echoes Saga as one of my favorite completed series of all time for many years to come.
You can order this book from: Amazon UK | Amazon US
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions | I also have a Booktube channel
Special thanks to my Patrons on Patreon for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Andrew, Andrew W, Annabeth, Casey, Diana, Dylan, Edward, Elias, Ellen, Ellis, Gary, Hamad, Helen, Jesse, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Kristina, Lana, Leigh, Luis, Lufi, Melinda, Meryl, Michael, Miracle, Nanette, Neeraja, Nicholas, Radiah, Reno, Samuel, Sarah, Sarah, Scott, Shawn, Xero, Wendy, Wick, Zoe.
Wow. The Knights of Erador is the best first installment in the three trilogies in The Echoes Saga.
I know. Not even a month has passed since I claimed Age of the King, the sixth book in The Echoes Saga, as the best book of the series so far. And, already, I have to take back my word. The Knights of Erador, the seventh book in the series, marked the beginning of the end, and it managed to top Age of the King. It is the first installment in the final story arc of the nine-book series, and yes, this is the finest book in the series so far. I can't make any promises this statement will hold for a long time. Based on what I've read here, my instinct tells me the final two books in the series will be superior. But for now, I will say that I am happy and proud to call myself a Quaintrellians.
“Nobody is born evil… It festers and grows in the shadows, always hiding. Trust us, we’ve met enough tyrants to know they didn’t start out that way.”
Remember how The Fall of Neverdark, the fourth book in the series and also the first book in the second trilogy of the series, begins 15 years after the end of Relic of the Gods? Well, Quaintrell implemented a similar time jump here. The story in The Knights of Erador starts 15 years after the end of Age of the King. And in a similar style to The Fall of Neverdark, the first half of The Knights of Erador can be categorized as the calm before the storm. It is, however, much more accessible than The Fall of Neverdark, in my opinion. And more importantly, this is a much superior book compared to Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark; both are the first installment in a trilogy of the series. Conspiracy, rebellion, betrayal. The most terrifying enemy to ever enter Illian is here, and once I reached the halfway point, I couldn't put the book down to the end.
“The life of a king isn’t one of banquets and balls. Your every word carries weight. And your sword must bring justice wherever it goes.”
Honestly, the only reason I didn't give The Knights of Erador a 5/5 stars rating was due to the pacing in the first half, which can feel slightly like a slog sometimes. This isn't to say there weren't any intriguing events in the first 300 pages. However, those who've read the series Age of the King will know what will happen soon in the story, and it can make readers (like me) feel impatient to see it unfold quickly. But more on that later soon. I think one of the main factors, other than Quaintrell's improved skill as a writer, why I love this one so much more than Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark as a new start of the series can be catered down to the characters. One of the difficulties of reading Rise of the Ranger and The Fall of Neverdark is getting used to and acclimating ourselves to the number of new characters. In The Fall of Neverdark, we were introduced to Alijah, Inara, Vighon, and The Crow. This took me a while to feel familiar with. But that is not the case with The Knights of Erador. Only one new POV character, Kassian, was introduced here, and most of the novel revolved around the main characters that appeared for the first time in The Fall of Neverdark. Only two main characters from the first trilogy played a dominant role in the narrative of The Knights of Erador, and I loved reading their POV chapters thoroughly. That's all I can say to avoid spoilers. Please understand. This is the seventh book of the series, after all.
“Hope isn’t going to change a damn thing. You’re the only Dragorn - you need to give more than hope. You need to fight and you need to make a difference.
To continue what I said earlier regarding the second half of the novel. Those who've read the series up Age of the King will most likely predict who will be the main villain in The Knights of Erador and most likely the remaining of the series. And so far, the villain in The Knights of Erador and hopefully the rest of the series is the best for me. The resurgence of this character as a villain was predictable considering how Age of the King ended. But to see it unfolding and written so well was nothing short of breathtaking. All the planning, the betrayals, and seeing him becoming the main villain also signifies extensively why the series is titled The Echoes Saga. It reminded me of the first time I watched Revenge of the Sith. I knew what would happen to Anakin Skywalker. But that did not detract my excitement from seeing it happen. Plus, for readers who've read Solo Leveling manhwa, imagine the main character there becoming the main villain. You will know just how terrifying it is. And the combination of these two comparisons is indeed the kind of villains we're getting in The Knights of Erador, and as I repeatedly said, hopefully, the rest of the series.
“Sacrifice without hesitation… This is what a good king must do. You can’t see it yet but that’s exactly what I’m doing.
Quaintrell genuinely amazed me The Knights of Erador. Quaintrell has mentioned several times now how he's mostly a pantser rather than a planner type of writer. And somehow, the world-building, lore, character development, and plot progression felt like everything was planned since Rise of the Ranger. As I said earlier, the pacing in the second half of The Knights of Erador was excellent. The villain's blind justice and self-righteous commitment to supposedly bring order to the chaos was so entertaining and immersive to read. Unlike all the previous books in the series, we did not have any POV chapter from the villain here. However, witnessing the villain's actions through the eyes of his victims and opponents made the narrative more engaging, powerful, and emotional. With all the attempted assassinations, dragons, undead abominations, and elemental monstrosities, the second half of The Knights of Erador somehow ended up being the best section of The Echoes Saga, so far, for me. And I have no doubt this will be toppled over soon in Last of the Dragorn or the final book of the series, A Clash of Fates.
“That’s why I’m still here. That’s why I’m still fighting and bleeding. That’s the hand fate has dealt me - to endure. It also imparted me with a set of skills... So I’m going to use what I have and set things right.”
It is cliche and repetitive to say this, and I can't make any promises I won't repeat this again in the next two books, but The Knights of Erador is the finest installment in the series so far. The exciting actions and battles felt both epic and intimate. It is surreal and awesome to witness how much Quaintrell has improved as a storyteller since Rise of the Ranger. I've been reading The Echoes Saga for almost the entire year of 2022, and I can't believe I only have two books left in the series to read. I am undoubtedly looking forward to reading the next book. If the last two books in the series somehow managed to supplant The Knights of Erador as the better book, well, I think at that stage, you will be hearing me stating The Echoes Saga as one of my favorite completed series of all time for many years to come.
“A good story, dear ranger, is all that will remain. Years from now, be it centuries or millennia, your actions here will be naught but a tale.”
You can order this book from: Amazon UK | Amazon US
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions | I also have a Booktube channel
Special thanks to my Patrons on Patreon for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Andrew, Andrew W, Annabeth, Casey, Diana, Dylan, Edward, Elias, Ellen, Ellis, Gary, Hamad, Helen, Jesse, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Kristina, Lana, Leigh, Luis, Lufi, Melinda, Meryl, Michael, Miracle, Nanette, Neeraja, Nicholas, Radiah, Reno, Samuel, Sarah, Sarah, Scott, Shawn, Xero, Wendy, Wick, Zoe.
May 17, 2020
Kind of mad you wrote such an amazing series
About 6 weeks ago we had the shutdown and while I worked still all my evenings were free so I looked for an epic. Looked at the ratings and said hey, I'll give this guy a try. People seem to like him. So I sat down and began with Rise of the Ranger.
Usually I can't stay with an author, even if I like their storytelling, for each book, successively, because I need a break from the story and the little annoying things, like editing, or character developed not in the direction I liked, until I can come to terms with it and return.
Well, none of that happened and I went thru your seven books in about six weeks.
Where my self pity or pettiness comes in is now I'm out of a story. I'm trying to figure out the whys, the hows, the where is this going to go. And I no longer can satisfy that desire. I have to WAIT. finally I find an author who can capture this ADHD brain, and draw me fully into his world, where his characters do stuff and the story flows from them rather than a story where the characters are confined and limited because an author used them and then discarded them.
If that makes sense?
So now I'm on literal tenterhooks and need to know NOW how things will end and dangnabbit, i.have.to.wait.
I'm impatient.
And I also want to know what happened in Erador for the last 15 years too if you could just add that as well lol.
Tongue in cheek most of the review, but with all seriousness, thanks for what you do and giving me a world to escape to while this real one we live in went to the covid crapper.
I read alot and you are now up in my 5 top authors. Don't let it go to your head. ;)
About 6 weeks ago we had the shutdown and while I worked still all my evenings were free so I looked for an epic. Looked at the ratings and said hey, I'll give this guy a try. People seem to like him. So I sat down and began with Rise of the Ranger.
Usually I can't stay with an author, even if I like their storytelling, for each book, successively, because I need a break from the story and the little annoying things, like editing, or character developed not in the direction I liked, until I can come to terms with it and return.
Well, none of that happened and I went thru your seven books in about six weeks.
Where my self pity or pettiness comes in is now I'm out of a story. I'm trying to figure out the whys, the hows, the where is this going to go. And I no longer can satisfy that desire. I have to WAIT. finally I find an author who can capture this ADHD brain, and draw me fully into his world, where his characters do stuff and the story flows from them rather than a story where the characters are confined and limited because an author used them and then discarded them.
If that makes sense?
So now I'm on literal tenterhooks and need to know NOW how things will end and dangnabbit, i.have.to.wait.
I'm impatient.
And I also want to know what happened in Erador for the last 15 years too if you could just add that as well lol.
Tongue in cheek most of the review, but with all seriousness, thanks for what you do and giving me a world to escape to while this real one we live in went to the covid crapper.
I read alot and you are now up in my 5 top authors. Don't let it go to your head. ;)
July 16, 2023
What I enjoy most about this series of books is the way the characters not only develop by their experience’s but throughout their lives as is now clear in this book. Since the last it has been 15 years and some characters are now in their 40’s (the ones that aren’t immortal, elves or dwarves.)
The author has an excellent grasp of time and how it effects relationships and families/clans. This is greatly reflected in his writing and the way he portrays the characters and the ever evolving world in which they live.
The characters continue to charm, delight, shock and surprise in their own way and I love the way new characters are introduced seamlessly. This story flows very well due to its pace which is a tad above medium. The plots and schemes are very detailed and I’m glad the story doesn’t get bogged down or padded out.
As always the world building is beautiful, detailed and thought provoking adding to the stories overall appeal. Another thoroughly enjoyable, gripping read with lots of twist and turns and details to digest.
The author has an excellent grasp of time and how it effects relationships and families/clans. This is greatly reflected in his writing and the way he portrays the characters and the ever evolving world in which they live.
The characters continue to charm, delight, shock and surprise in their own way and I love the way new characters are introduced seamlessly. This story flows very well due to its pace which is a tad above medium. The plots and schemes are very detailed and I’m glad the story doesn’t get bogged down or padded out.
As always the world building is beautiful, detailed and thought provoking adding to the stories overall appeal. Another thoroughly enjoyable, gripping read with lots of twist and turns and details to digest.
May 7, 2024
The Knights of Erador
Sétimo livro da Saga dos Ecos e aqui mais uma vez temos um salto temporal desde o final do sexto livro dessa vez 15 anos se passaram e voltamos a acompanhar os personagens que já conhecemos tanto os mais antigos como Asher, Reyna, Nathaniel e também os mais recentes como Vighon, Inara e Alijah e dessa vez o livro já começa com um conflito e com o novo rei tentando fazer todo o possível pata deixar o reino em paz mas nem tudo é o que aparece pois um novo inimigo se levanta pra trazer a guerra e o caos mais uma vez um inimigo que ninguém esperava mas que todos foram avisados no passado e assim sem entrar em spoilers pra quem não leu mas que ódio QUE ÓDIO DESSE VILÃO VAGABUNDO E DAS MERDAS QUE ELE FAZ EU FIQUEI MUITO LUTO COM CAPIROTO, eu ia lendo e não acreditava mas deculpinhas que ele soltava e que tudo que ele tava fazendo era por X questões nossa eu espero que uma morte de milhões aguarde ele nos próximos dois livros porque sem condições e também espero quem seja o responsável por essa morte seja o maior de todos Asher que mais uma vez viu o que o destino não vai deixar ele descansar então ele deve se levantar mais uma vez e ir pra guerra e tentar slave Verda de uma vez por todas e é claro que pra isso ele irá contar com todos os seus companheiros e está chegando o final dessa saga que tem tudo pra ser épico espero que venha algo grandioso e conhecendo o autor tenho certeza que vem e mal posso esperar para ver a batalha épica que ele escreveu no final dessa série e que venha o penúltimo livro da saga The Last Dragorn.
Sétimo livro da Saga dos Ecos e aqui mais uma vez temos um salto temporal desde o final do sexto livro dessa vez 15 anos se passaram e voltamos a acompanhar os personagens que já conhecemos tanto os mais antigos como Asher, Reyna, Nathaniel e também os mais recentes como Vighon, Inara e Alijah e dessa vez o livro já começa com um conflito e com o novo rei tentando fazer todo o possível pata deixar o reino em paz mas nem tudo é o que aparece pois um novo inimigo se levanta pra trazer a guerra e o caos mais uma vez um inimigo que ninguém esperava mas que todos foram avisados no passado e assim sem entrar em spoilers pra quem não leu mas que ódio QUE ÓDIO DESSE VILÃO VAGABUNDO E DAS MERDAS QUE ELE FAZ EU FIQUEI MUITO LUTO COM CAPIROTO, eu ia lendo e não acreditava mas deculpinhas que ele soltava e que tudo que ele tava fazendo era por X questões nossa eu espero que uma morte de milhões aguarde ele nos próximos dois livros porque sem condições e também espero quem seja o responsável por essa morte seja o maior de todos Asher que mais uma vez viu o que o destino não vai deixar ele descansar então ele deve se levantar mais uma vez e ir pra guerra e tentar slave Verda de uma vez por todas e é claro que pra isso ele irá contar com todos os seus companheiros e está chegando o final dessa saga que tem tudo pra ser épico espero que venha algo grandioso e conhecendo o autor tenho certeza que vem e mal posso esperar para ver a batalha épica que ele escreveu no final dessa série e que venha o penúltimo livro da saga The Last Dragorn.
July 28, 2023
I absolute love this book. It is only second to the first one, The Rise of the Ranger.
It was wonderful to see how all the main characters have important roles to play in this story. I also enjoyed the new character’s arc, Kassian. I can understand his feelings and will be watching to see how his role evolves.
And the villain! There isn’t anything redeemable about him. He has a couple moments but they don’t outweigh all the horrendous things he has done in his quest to purge the world and create a new one in his image. He’s egotistical and cruel. But I will be continuing this wonderful journey to see what comes next.
It was wonderful to see how all the main characters have important roles to play in this story. I also enjoyed the new character’s arc, Kassian. I can understand his feelings and will be watching to see how his role evolves.
And the villain! There isn’t anything redeemable about him. He has a couple moments but they don’t outweigh all the horrendous things he has done in his quest to purge the world and create a new one in his image. He’s egotistical and cruel. But I will be continuing this wonderful journey to see what comes next.
September 10, 2024
Follow me on X: Twitter.com/wolfmantula
For more reviews, go to: https://wolfmantula.com/recent-posts/
MY ⭐️ RATING: 4.75/5
FORMAT: Kindle Whispersync
I have enjoyed every single one of the entries in The Echoes Saga so far, because Quaintrell has taken me on an incredible rollercoaster filled with love, loss, political machinations and battles galore, from the very beginning. But I have to say, The Knights of Erador, which is set 15 years after the events of Age of the King, might be the best entry of the series to date, which makes me even more excited for whats to come. I could feel my adrenaline pumping because it was that much more epic and intense than anything else, to a point that the last quarter of this almost felt like I was witnessing the finale taking place, while still having two books left!
Vighon, Inara, Asher, Doran, Galanör, Nathaniel, Reyna and Alijah return to face a new threat that’s taking over Verda. Quaintrell has done a fantastic job with the development of each one of them and continues doing so, it’s hard not to like any of them because they each bring a little something to the story that helps make it work. But as I’ve said many times before, Doran continues to be my favorite character, his personality just changes everything when he’s around, and it makes for a more enjoyable time. Along with them, new characters and races are introduced that are quite fascinating and down right creepy, the Drakes and the Reavers. These additions bring an entirely new element to the saga that hasn’t been there before, raising the stakes to an all time high. Alijah has always been a bit of a wildcard for me as well, with what has happened to him, he has always reminded me a bit of Anakin Skywalker and his development has been special.
“Putting the past behind you can be just as difficult as trying to see a future yet to be revealed.”
I really enjoy Quaintrell’s story telling, and I love the direction that he’s gone with this story, as old allies conspire to overthrow the King, new allies are made, and a massively epic showdown ensues. It shows that there’s always going to be something, even when everything feels perfect and running smoothly. One thing is for sure about this story, those Star Wars undertones that I’ve brought up on many occasions are here to stay, and it feels like it’s only getting stronger or maybe I’m just getting more stern about it. With that being said, there was also some Game of Thrones that popped into my head from time to time as well. The only negative thing I can really say is that I was hoping there would be more of Alijah’s time in Erador, rather than skipping over it all with the time jump. Since Verda is more integral to the story, I do understand the need to skip over that part of the story though.
The pacing felt a little faster than previous installments of the series for some reason, not that it blew by, but maybe the battles that take place just made it feel faster because they were so intense and had my focus causing me to keep going to see what happened next. I still have a bit of a love/hate relationship with Steven Brands narration, but I’ve gained a new found respect for him, I’ve always felt that he had a bit of a monotonous voice, but I could feel the intensity at times and it felt very different from previous books, like he was into it a lot more than he was previously, though the voices are still a bit too similar for my taste. The whispersync audio production issues I’ve had are still there, like I said before, it doesn’t hurt my experience with the story, but it does hurt my OCD brain hearing a sentence or paragraph finish and the highlighting several words behind or ahead, Podium really needs to fix this issue.
For more reviews, go to: https://wolfmantula.com/recent-posts/
MY ⭐️ RATING: 4.75/5
FORMAT: Kindle Whispersync
I have enjoyed every single one of the entries in The Echoes Saga so far, because Quaintrell has taken me on an incredible rollercoaster filled with love, loss, political machinations and battles galore, from the very beginning. But I have to say, The Knights of Erador, which is set 15 years after the events of Age of the King, might be the best entry of the series to date, which makes me even more excited for whats to come. I could feel my adrenaline pumping because it was that much more epic and intense than anything else, to a point that the last quarter of this almost felt like I was witnessing the finale taking place, while still having two books left!
Vighon, Inara, Asher, Doran, Galanör, Nathaniel, Reyna and Alijah return to face a new threat that’s taking over Verda. Quaintrell has done a fantastic job with the development of each one of them and continues doing so, it’s hard not to like any of them because they each bring a little something to the story that helps make it work. But as I’ve said many times before, Doran continues to be my favorite character, his personality just changes everything when he’s around, and it makes for a more enjoyable time. Along with them, new characters and races are introduced that are quite fascinating and down right creepy, the Drakes and the Reavers. These additions bring an entirely new element to the saga that hasn’t been there before, raising the stakes to an all time high. Alijah has always been a bit of a wildcard for me as well, with what has happened to him, he has always reminded me a bit of Anakin Skywalker and his development has been special.
“Putting the past behind you can be just as difficult as trying to see a future yet to be revealed.”
I really enjoy Quaintrell’s story telling, and I love the direction that he’s gone with this story, as old allies conspire to overthrow the King, new allies are made, and a massively epic showdown ensues. It shows that there’s always going to be something, even when everything feels perfect and running smoothly. One thing is for sure about this story, those Star Wars undertones that I’ve brought up on many occasions are here to stay, and it feels like it’s only getting stronger or maybe I’m just getting more stern about it. With that being said, there was also some Game of Thrones that popped into my head from time to time as well. The only negative thing I can really say is that I was hoping there would be more of Alijah’s time in Erador, rather than skipping over it all with the time jump. Since Verda is more integral to the story, I do understand the need to skip over that part of the story though.
The pacing felt a little faster than previous installments of the series for some reason, not that it blew by, but maybe the battles that take place just made it feel faster because they were so intense and had my focus causing me to keep going to see what happened next. I still have a bit of a love/hate relationship with Steven Brands narration, but I’ve gained a new found respect for him, I’ve always felt that he had a bit of a monotonous voice, but I could feel the intensity at times and it felt very different from previous books, like he was into it a lot more than he was previously, though the voices are still a bit too similar for my taste. The whispersync audio production issues I’ve had are still there, like I said before, it doesn’t hurt my experience with the story, but it does hurt my OCD brain hearing a sentence or paragraph finish and the highlighting several words behind or ahead, Podium really needs to fix this issue.
March 6, 2022
Wow!!!!!
Wow amazing an a awesome read. Non-stop action, A page turner from being to end. How the lives of all are changed for ever. Not only the friends an family of Aligah but the people. Now that said someone should of took Aligah out to wood shed with a big switch an a bigger stick for is dragon. What all in the hell is he thinking.
I'm not one to do a lot of shedding tears but form the very being Mr. Quaintrell has made the pages wet with them. What has gone so wrong with this half elf?????
Wow amazing an a awesome read. Non-stop action, A page turner from being to end. How the lives of all are changed for ever. Not only the friends an family of Aligah but the people. Now that said someone should of took Aligah out to wood shed with a big switch an a bigger stick for is dragon. What all in the hell is he thinking.
I'm not one to do a lot of shedding tears but form the very being Mr. Quaintrell has made the pages wet with them. What has gone so wrong with this half elf?????
January 16, 2025
Once again just lost for words. I don’t know how Philip Quaintrell keeps putting out books that are somehow better than the one previous. Usually in a long series, an author has a couple hiccups along the way but not this guy haha. Quaintrell is a golden storyteller and the best in his class. He’s honestly criminally underrated and should be up there aside John Gwynne, James Islington, and even Brandon Sanderson (although to be brutally honest, The Echoes Saga blows all of their stuff out of the water). It’s so damn good. You know a series is phenomenal when you literally can’t put the shit down. I keep telling myself to take a break and I find I read another chapter haha which goes on until I fall asleep reading. Knights of Erador was awesome and as usual the next book will be even better. Sadly, I’m just about to start book 8 of 9 and I don’t want this to end. Approaching the end of book 9 will be very depressing. Can’t recommend this series enough.
September 23, 2020
Excitement in the time of isolation
I have always loved dragons. I am 71 years young and still believe they exist somewhere. I want to tell you that your stories are well written and flow like a river. All the characters mesh together to put you there in the story. I can feel the fear, the excitment, hope and joy and even the heartbreak they feel. Keep writing. You are a fantastic addition to fanticy writers.
I have always loved dragons. I am 71 years young and still believe they exist somewhere. I want to tell you that your stories are well written and flow like a river. All the characters mesh together to put you there in the story. I can feel the fear, the excitment, hope and joy and even the heartbreak they feel. Keep writing. You are a fantastic addition to fanticy writers.
April 16, 2020
Great read
I thought the book was slow and I could see what was coming but I couldn’t put the book down. Although my heart was broken at the end, had to continue reading through my sobs! I started this sage with book 1 this year finished book 6 day before this one came out. I dread the thought of having to wait for the next one. This is a Great Saga.
I thought the book was slow and I could see what was coming but I couldn’t put the book down. Although my heart was broken at the end, had to continue reading through my sobs! I started this sage with book 1 this year finished book 6 day before this one came out. I dread the thought of having to wait for the next one. This is a Great Saga.
September 24, 2025
This first installment of the 3rd trilogy in the Echoes Saga seemed like a rehashing of the previous trilogy in many ways. Big Bad wants to destroy everyone and everything to create a clean slate... ostensibly to bring peace to the whole land. Our protagonists battle mightily but futiley as mass destruction reigns. The pacing was uneven and the internal character struggles weren't all that interesting.
**SPOILERS AHEAD**
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
I was also very disappointed in the time skip this time. We didn't get to see anything in Erador... everything was in Ilian. I was pretty intrigued at the end of Book 6 in the glimpse we got of Erador and I was hoping for a lot more in Book 7. I understand that the author wanted to "surprise us" that Alijah was returning as the antagonist, but really....was anyone who read the previous 6 books surprised by this? After his corruption by the Crow. I certainly wasn't.
I will read the next book, but I'm hoping we get to see SOMETHING in Erador...but I'm also thinking I'm probably going to be disappointed again
**SPOILERS AHEAD**
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
I was also very disappointed in the time skip this time. We didn't get to see anything in Erador... everything was in Ilian. I was pretty intrigued at the end of Book 6 in the glimpse we got of Erador and I was hoping for a lot more in Book 7. I understand that the author wanted to "surprise us" that Alijah was returning as the antagonist, but really....was anyone who read the previous 6 books surprised by this? After his corruption by the Crow. I certainly wasn't.
I will read the next book, but I'm hoping we get to see SOMETHING in Erador...but I'm also thinking I'm probably going to be disappointed again
May 2, 2024
The Knights of Erador start the final arc of this Saga.
And it feels like Phillip found his perfect voices to do so. The way he weaves in and out of big and small events make this book one of the most enjoyable one in the series, no small feat considering all the others were superb by themselves.
But now the scope of the world comes together in brilliant fashion. You feel the immense span of lands and time coming together, crashing into conflicts, big and small, full of the "humanoid" (considering we've got so many races here I can't find a suitable word) condition.
The way Quaintrell weaves a story that makes you question the price of peace, the price of loyalty and family, choices and friendship. The Knights of Erador is a highlight in this magnus opus.
I cannot wait to start The Last of the Dragorn.
If you're still in doubt over where to read or not this series, do not. You'll not be disappointed.
And it feels like Phillip found his perfect voices to do so. The way he weaves in and out of big and small events make this book one of the most enjoyable one in the series, no small feat considering all the others were superb by themselves.
But now the scope of the world comes together in brilliant fashion. You feel the immense span of lands and time coming together, crashing into conflicts, big and small, full of the "humanoid" (considering we've got so many races here I can't find a suitable word) condition.
The way Quaintrell weaves a story that makes you question the price of peace, the price of loyalty and family, choices and friendship. The Knights of Erador is a highlight in this magnus opus.
I cannot wait to start The Last of the Dragorn.
If you're still in doubt over where to read or not this series, do not. You'll not be disappointed.
July 29, 2025
Philip C. Quaintrell continues to prove why his saga is amazing & epic, weaving politics, magic, war, and deeply human emotion into every chapter. Tensions soar, relationships are tested, and the lines between hero and villain blur in brilliant, heartbreaking ways.
The pacing has an excellent balance between action and reflection, the dialogue gripping, and the emotional resonance lingers long after the final page. Whether you’re here for intense action, moral dilemmas, or the characters you’ve grown to love and fear, this book delivers on all fronts. The relationships are what shine brightest. Bonds between family, between dragons and dragorn, mentors and rivals—it’s all raw and real. It makes every betrayal cut deeper, and every moment of trust feel hard-won.
If you’re a reader who lives for complicated, beautifully broken characters trying to do right in a world falling apart, this one delivers 💯🥹
The pacing has an excellent balance between action and reflection, the dialogue gripping, and the emotional resonance lingers long after the final page. Whether you’re here for intense action, moral dilemmas, or the characters you’ve grown to love and fear, this book delivers on all fronts. The relationships are what shine brightest. Bonds between family, between dragons and dragorn, mentors and rivals—it’s all raw and real. It makes every betrayal cut deeper, and every moment of trust feel hard-won.
If you’re a reader who lives for complicated, beautifully broken characters trying to do right in a world falling apart, this one delivers 💯🥹
October 17, 2024
3.5/5
بداية الثلاثية الأخيرة، أحداث الكتاب بعد ١٥ سنة من الجزء السادس. في تلك النهاية تم قطع وعد بين شخصين أحدهما بالعودة إلى القصة واحداثها، والآخر بالقضاء عليه إذا عاد.
الكتاب يبدأ بعودة هذا الشخص كصديق عزيز وأخ محب. وانا طوال الوقت أشير بأصبعي وأقول هاهو شرير الكتاب قد عاد.
وعندما حدثت الخيانة لم اهتم سوا بشخص واحد ووعده اللذي قطعه بالقتل.
بقية أحداث الكتاب بطيئة، اعتقد من بعد علامة ال ٥٥٪ بدأ الارك الاخير. وهذا يخليني اقول لو كان الكاتب بطريقة ما قدر يضيف النصف من الاول من هذا الكتاب إلى نهاية الكتاب السادس، هل كان ليكون افضل؟ لا أعلم ابدا.
نهاية الكتاب كانت ممتعه والكتاب الثامن سأبدأه بحماس كبير
بداية الثلاثية الأخيرة، أحداث الكتاب بعد ١٥ سنة من الجزء السادس. في تلك النهاية تم قطع وعد بين شخصين أحدهما بالعودة إلى القصة واحداثها، والآخر بالقضاء عليه إذا عاد.
الكتاب يبدأ بعودة هذا الشخص كصديق عزيز وأخ محب. وانا طوال الوقت أشير بأصبعي وأقول هاهو شرير الكتاب قد عاد.
وعندما حدثت الخيانة لم اهتم سوا بشخص واحد ووعده اللذي قطعه بالقتل.
بقية أحداث الكتاب بطيئة، اعتقد من بعد علامة ال ٥٥٪ بدأ الارك الاخير. وهذا يخليني اقول لو كان الكاتب بطريقة ما قدر يضيف النصف من الاول من هذا الكتاب إلى نهاية الكتاب السادس، هل كان ليكون افضل؟ لا أعلم ابدا.
نهاية الكتاب كانت ممتعه والكتاب الثامن سأبدأه بحماس كبير
December 4, 2023
Quaintrell is definitely getting better books after books.
The depth of characters is there and along with keeping you on the edge, it will also make you ask yourself some very interesting questions.
Not giving a 5 because I think we’re not there just yet, but I’m itching. It’s still slightly too predictable and I sometimes get pulled out by tiny inconsistencies. It can’t be perfect really but that’s also what makes it worth reading.
I just can’t stop before I finish this whole series now, the end (the last 3 books) is just so promising 👏🏼
The depth of characters is there and along with keeping you on the edge, it will also make you ask yourself some very interesting questions.
Not giving a 5 because I think we’re not there just yet, but I’m itching. It’s still slightly too predictable and I sometimes get pulled out by tiny inconsistencies. It can’t be perfect really but that’s also what makes it worth reading.
I just can’t stop before I finish this whole series now, the end (the last 3 books) is just so promising 👏🏼
February 24, 2026
4.5
Awesome start to this last trilogy. The first two thirds were a five and then the last third kinda lost it a bit as it just turned into battle after battle. The intrigue was definitely more interesting to me.
Awesome start to this last trilogy. The first two thirds were a five and then the last third kinda lost it a bit as it just turned into battle after battle. The intrigue was definitely more interesting to me.
January 24, 2023
A few thoughts on whether to read the Echoes saga: https://www.solseit.com/blog-2/why-re...
March 18, 2023
This is easily becoming my favorite series and author. It gets better with every book.
October 2, 2021
Don't get me wrong, the battle scenes and the general plot were great. This book had tons of action and it was overall good! But, there were a few things I didn't like about it. The first and major thing is Inara's bond with Aethes. It's stupid that now that she can "feel attraction" and will end up with Vigon, after she said no so many times to him. The dragorn bond was supposed to be sacred and it just feels like that got put aside just to bring in an unnecessary love story. Also, it was disappointing that Gideon and the dragorn didn't show up. It seemed like Inara didn't try enough to communicate with him. Wasn't the island like a few days flight or something? I think there were opportunities for them to physically go to Gideon. Her ego almost killed her so I guess there's a lesson in there. Hopefully they'll show up in the next book but I'm guessing that Inara is gonna retire so she can become queen and live happily ever after with Vigon. Somehow he'll become immortal too and become the good king that Elijah deluded himself to be. All the dragorn will change into dragon riders so that they can have their separate human lives and they won't die when their dragons die. Lame!
I am sorry for Reyna though and I hope she pulls through. Maybe she'll be the one to kill Elijah? Probably not though since she doesn't have magic and will be locked away somewhere.
I'm so glad Asher is alive!!! Cassius was dumb and I don't like him. Nathaniel is annoying. Galinor's situation is frustrating. He's forcing himself to become someone else and in turn, losing a major part of himself. Hopefully he'll get that figured out. It was kinda unexpected that Doren is now a prince again! Maybe he'll become king in the next book?
Like i said, overall, the book was good but these things are just annoying me. Ehhh, we'll see what happens in the next book!
I am sorry for Reyna though and I hope she pulls through. Maybe she'll be the one to kill Elijah? Probably not though since she doesn't have magic and will be locked away somewhere.
I'm so glad Asher is alive!!! Cassius was dumb and I don't like him. Nathaniel is annoying. Galinor's situation is frustrating. He's forcing himself to become someone else and in turn, losing a major part of himself. Hopefully he'll get that figured out. It was kinda unexpected that Doren is now a prince again! Maybe he'll become king in the next book?
Like i said, overall, the book was good but these things are just annoying me. Ehhh, we'll see what happens in the next book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 10, 2025
Actual rating would be 3.5.
The first half of this book was probably my favorite of the series. A dark army appears and is killing all the dwarves and we don't know what their powers are or where they are coming from. Their is internal conflict happening in illian threatening a civil war. To be fair it was pretty obvious alijah was behind these things especially when he made his return.
However as the story goes on alijah has a chance to kill pretty much every character but doesn't. He defeats Vighon but just imprisons the king in his dungeon, he defeats inara and her dragon but just leave them in the snow and he fights asher one on one in a sword fight instead of just killing him with magic and he is able to portal away.
The few he doesn't kill have a good chance to defeat him, but choose to run away and regroup instead of fighting. Nathaniel and renya choose to run away instead of attacking while he is battling elementals and most baffling of all when Alijah attacks the elves they all run away except for Elloria who by herself is powerful enough to badly hurt alijah and damage his dragon scale armor.
Additionally most of Inara's story doesn't make any sense. She learns of a new path dragorn can take to no longer have their dragons be able to manipulate their mind and instead of waiting for a peaceful moment to explore it she does it before the biggest fight in the book. Additionally even though her communicator doesn't reach Gideon Thorn, the leader of the dragorn, I am not sure why she wouldn't just fly there and get them instead of camping out with Asher. You would think zombies attacking the realm would be reason enough to summon the rest of the dragorn back
If how alijah can summon 20,000 readers and control 4 dragon readers doesn't get explained well I'm going to be super disappointed and will have no understanding of the magic in these books at all.
The first half of this book was probably my favorite of the series. A dark army appears and is killing all the dwarves and we don't know what their powers are or where they are coming from. Their is internal conflict happening in illian threatening a civil war. To be fair it was pretty obvious alijah was behind these things especially when he made his return.
However as the story goes on alijah has a chance to kill pretty much every character but doesn't. He defeats Vighon but just imprisons the king in his dungeon, he defeats inara and her dragon but just leave them in the snow and he fights asher one on one in a sword fight instead of just killing him with magic and he is able to portal away.
The few he doesn't kill have a good chance to defeat him, but choose to run away and regroup instead of fighting. Nathaniel and renya choose to run away instead of attacking while he is battling elementals and most baffling of all when Alijah attacks the elves they all run away except for Elloria who by herself is powerful enough to badly hurt alijah and damage his dragon scale armor.
Additionally most of Inara's story doesn't make any sense. She learns of a new path dragorn can take to no longer have their dragons be able to manipulate their mind and instead of waiting for a peaceful moment to explore it she does it before the biggest fight in the book. Additionally even though her communicator doesn't reach Gideon Thorn, the leader of the dragorn, I am not sure why she wouldn't just fly there and get them instead of camping out with Asher. You would think zombies attacking the realm would be reason enough to summon the rest of the dragorn back
If how alijah can summon 20,000 readers and control 4 dragon readers doesn't get explained well I'm going to be super disappointed and will have no understanding of the magic in these books at all.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 21, 2020
Keep the series going
I keep thinking what a great fantasy tv series this series would make. I hope someone out there agrees and the powers to be put it together.
I keep thinking what a great fantasy tv series this series would make. I hope someone out there agrees and the powers to be put it together.
August 7, 2024
The start of the end, the conflict that was started in the previous trilogy and it does not disappoint. Asher remains to me the best character in the whole series.
August 25, 2024
4.5/5
This one nearly sent me into a early grave
This one nearly sent me into a early grave
December 16, 2025
He definitely knows how to start his trilogies. The big twist here was great. I love a villain with connections to several of the protagonists.
February 28, 2026
Shit! Philip tends to break down the world in a snap! I'm glad to start this book which marks the beginning of the end since this is the last trilogy in the Saga! It is mostly the same characters, we just have a new addition!
The book starts with a jump of 15 years after rthe events of The Age of the King! Vighon is still king and some of his provinces want separation and to be their own kingdoms! So he goes there and faces some weird things! Alijah is back from Erador telling Vighon and Inara that he is the king there, and he is here to help because people are rebelling against Vighon! Valatos is a school of magic that also wants to be separated from the Illian, so Reyna and Nathaniel are send there to convince them otherwise! Doran receives a note that his father is dead so he and Russel decides to check things out there because something else is in the note! Oh and Asher is offered an obscene amount of coin for a simple job?!!
Let me start with talking about the newest character, Kassian, he is a mage in Valatos, he is powerful, a little bit reckless but at least good in his heart and actually listened to Reyna and Nathaniel!
Inara is still the same fierce and protective Dragorn, since she is the last one in Illian she is now called the Guardian of the Realm! I like how she was skeptical of Alijah in the beginning, and how she still loves him but knows that he needs to be stopped!
Vighon in the beginning was kind of annoying, understandably though, his paranoia was actually the right feeling to have! I like how he still loves Inara and that the Realm and the people still important for him!
Asher is still incredible, especially with the fact that he is not aging, the reason is also interesting!!! And his ability to sacrifice himself for the greater good after everything he has been through is amazing, I'm in love with him! Also, the decision he made in order to save the world was really deep, him deciding to be his old self was hard but that didn't stop him!
The last scene with Reyna actually made my heart skip a beat, I will not survive if any of the Galfreys die (except for Alijah)
Alijah! well, he is back, he is evil, and no he was always insufferable even before the crow took him, so I'm not rooting for him, I'm not interested in his redemption, what I want is his death really!
What happened to the dwarves was really scary! especially the prologue, it was so eerie and creepy and the Knights of Erador are really horrible!
I'm curious about the silvyr talk, why does Alijah want a lot of it? why is he moving the dwarves?
We left off with Inara, Vighon, Asher, Galanor, Russell, Nathaniel, Kassian, and the clan of Heavybelly in the woods trying to figure out their next move! Alijah is kind of losing control? I don't know about what's going on with him and Malliath!
Oh I almost forgot! The Drakes, the creatures that are half elf half dragon and used to be orcs! They are really interesting! we met them with Asher and their magic is weird, they are really peaceful but helpful as well! I really need more about them!
Favourite scene is the way Doran went back to warn and save Inara from the Dark Knights! He is like a funny dwarf uncle to her and I love that!
The book starts with a jump of 15 years after rthe events of The Age of the King! Vighon is still king and some of his provinces want separation and to be their own kingdoms! So he goes there and faces some weird things! Alijah is back from Erador telling Vighon and Inara that he is the king there, and he is here to help because people are rebelling against Vighon! Valatos is a school of magic that also wants to be separated from the Illian, so Reyna and Nathaniel are send there to convince them otherwise! Doran receives a note that his father is dead so he and Russel decides to check things out there because something else is in the note! Oh and Asher is offered an obscene amount of coin for a simple job?!!
Let me start with talking about the newest character, Kassian, he is a mage in Valatos, he is powerful, a little bit reckless but at least good in his heart and actually listened to Reyna and Nathaniel!
Inara is still the same fierce and protective Dragorn, since she is the last one in Illian she is now called the Guardian of the Realm! I like how she was skeptical of Alijah in the beginning, and how she still loves him but knows that he needs to be stopped!
Vighon in the beginning was kind of annoying, understandably though, his paranoia was actually the right feeling to have! I like how he still loves Inara and that the Realm and the people still important for him!
Asher is still incredible, especially with the fact that he is not aging, the reason is also interesting!!! And his ability to sacrifice himself for the greater good after everything he has been through is amazing, I'm in love with him! Also, the decision he made in order to save the world was really deep, him deciding to be his old self was hard but that didn't stop him!
The last scene with Reyna actually made my heart skip a beat, I will not survive if any of the Galfreys die (except for Alijah)
Alijah! well, he is back, he is evil, and no he was always insufferable even before the crow took him, so I'm not rooting for him, I'm not interested in his redemption, what I want is his death really!
What happened to the dwarves was really scary! especially the prologue, it was so eerie and creepy and the Knights of Erador are really horrible!
I'm curious about the silvyr talk, why does Alijah want a lot of it? why is he moving the dwarves?
We left off with Inara, Vighon, Asher, Galanor, Russell, Nathaniel, Kassian, and the clan of Heavybelly in the woods trying to figure out their next move! Alijah is kind of losing control? I don't know about what's going on with him and Malliath!
Oh I almost forgot! The Drakes, the creatures that are half elf half dragon and used to be orcs! They are really interesting! we met them with Asher and their magic is weird, they are really peaceful but helpful as well! I really need more about them!
Favourite scene is the way Doran went back to warn and save Inara from the Dark Knights! He is like a funny dwarf uncle to her and I love that!
July 6, 2025
5 Main Takeaways
Here are five main takeaways from The Knights of Erador by Philip C. Quaintrell:
1. The Knights of Erador delivers an epic and intense narrative within The Echoes Saga, with a cinematic feel driven by political intrigue, battles, and betrayals, particularly in its gripping second half, making it a standout despite not being the series finale.
2. Familiar characters like Vighon, Inara, Asher, Doran, Galanör, Nathaniel, Reyna, and Alijah are central, with only one new POV character, Kassian, allowing deep focus on their growth over a 15-year time jump, reflecting changes in relationships and motivations.
3. A 15-year time jump after Age of the King enriches the world of Verda, introducing rebellion, a new threat in Illian, and unrest from Dhenaheim’s refugees, though the slow buildup in the first half sets a “calm before the storm” pace.
4. Themes of betrayal, conspiracy, and sacrifice run throughout, with old allies scheming against the king and a menacing new enemy emerging, highlighting the moral complexities of power and loyalty through key character decisions.
5. The book’s pacing starts slow but accelerates into a fast-paced, emotionally charged climax with a memorable extended fight scene, rewarding patient readers despite some wishing for more focus on events skipped during the time jump.
Here are five main takeaways from The Knights of Erador by Philip C. Quaintrell:
1. The Knights of Erador delivers an epic and intense narrative within The Echoes Saga, with a cinematic feel driven by political intrigue, battles, and betrayals, particularly in its gripping second half, making it a standout despite not being the series finale.
2. Familiar characters like Vighon, Inara, Asher, Doran, Galanör, Nathaniel, Reyna, and Alijah are central, with only one new POV character, Kassian, allowing deep focus on their growth over a 15-year time jump, reflecting changes in relationships and motivations.
3. A 15-year time jump after Age of the King enriches the world of Verda, introducing rebellion, a new threat in Illian, and unrest from Dhenaheim’s refugees, though the slow buildup in the first half sets a “calm before the storm” pace.
4. Themes of betrayal, conspiracy, and sacrifice run throughout, with old allies scheming against the king and a menacing new enemy emerging, highlighting the moral complexities of power and loyalty through key character decisions.
5. The book’s pacing starts slow but accelerates into a fast-paced, emotionally charged climax with a memorable extended fight scene, rewarding patient readers despite some wishing for more focus on events skipped during the time jump.
November 25, 2024
Rarely do I recall impactful scenes or chapters when I read, but chapters 33 and 35 of this book fully entertained me.
I came back to Phase 3 of the Echoes Saga a few months after finishing book 6 and I have to tell you, Alijah might be my least favorite character in the book. I closed my kindle on the first chapter that introduced him. Not because he’s written poorly. Oh no. Quite the opposite. Quaintrell wrote Alijah exactly the way I dislike antagonists written: evil with a hint of a redemption arc. Just let them be BAD.
The beginning was a bit slow to hook me, but when it did, my attention was laser focused on Vighon, Doran, Galanor, and Kassian (new fighter unlocked). Let me put it this way, I thought about commissioning someone to draw me dapping up Vighon. I’m a Vighon fanboy.
The levels of sheer frustration, stress, surprise, and almost anguish just compounded toward the ultimate climax at the end. Hats off to Quaintrell for the long, long, loooong fight scene at the end. I was like watching a movie in my brain.
A suspenseful entrance to Phase 3 of the Echoes Saga. One of the best books of the series but that’s a close race thus far.
I came back to Phase 3 of the Echoes Saga a few months after finishing book 6 and I have to tell you, Alijah might be my least favorite character in the book. I closed my kindle on the first chapter that introduced him. Not because he’s written poorly. Oh no. Quite the opposite. Quaintrell wrote Alijah exactly the way I dislike antagonists written: evil with a hint of a redemption arc. Just let them be BAD.
The beginning was a bit slow to hook me, but when it did, my attention was laser focused on Vighon, Doran, Galanor, and Kassian (new fighter unlocked). Let me put it this way, I thought about commissioning someone to draw me dapping up Vighon. I’m a Vighon fanboy.
The levels of sheer frustration, stress, surprise, and almost anguish just compounded toward the ultimate climax at the end. Hats off to Quaintrell for the long, long, loooong fight scene at the end. I was like watching a movie in my brain.
A suspenseful entrance to Phase 3 of the Echoes Saga. One of the best books of the series but that’s a close race thus far.
September 16, 2023
This has been a fantastic series and Quaintrell's writing has gotten consistently better as the series goes on. I love the worldbuilding and universe this series is set in but the real marvel of Quaintrell's writing has been his character development and the way he has successfully melded generations of characters and moved forward in the story without skipping a beat. This book takes place fifteen years after the events of the last trilogy but the continuity and character development doesn't suffer at all, in fact, it thrives. The pacing of all three triologies, at least up to the start of this one, has been fluid and has been an asset to the story. Part of me wants to know more about Alijah and his time in Erador, how he became a necromancer, how he got/made all the reavers, and came to make his plans, but I understand the rolling along with the main story and it's been amazing. I'm going strong till I finish this series and then I'll probably go back to read the prequals the Ranger Archives.
June 17, 2020
I started reading your Echoes Saga on May 20th of this year. I finished book 7 on June 15th. I very very seldom give 5 stars out of 5 for books, but this series had me riveted, like i have not been for a long long time (so when is book 8 done). Wow, not since the Dragonlance Series and Raymond E Feist's Riftwar Saga, have i been so riveted. ( your are writing no 8 right). I love your writing style, the sly humour, the heroes and the villains .. each of them are uniques, so unique, (book 8 nearly done?) - i like villains and their personalities, i like seeing deeper into their souls, (started book 9 yet) and i just so - ok i have used the work ' love' to much, oh, no, i have not .. so i LOVE the twists and turns of the woven stories, like a never ending fabric, spun around the worlds. Oh and the maps, i get lost there, imagining what it all looks like before i read and then .. it all falls into place. So when does no 8 and 9 come out?
August 3, 2024
Fifteen years have passed since the events of the last trilogy. Disruption and civil strife threaten the peace of the human and dwarven kingdoms. It's not apparent at first, but there is a force at work guiding the events.
A main character from the last trilogy has disappeared into the far lands of Erador. He returns with plans to rule the kingdom and begins forcing his 'ideas' of peace to the land. The reader, of course, saw this coming, but for the characters of the book, it's a devastating blow. The character is not entirely at fault; someone has broken and manipulated him. He uses black magic to create an army of Reavers, the undead who march at his command and who do not know fear.
Asher is still there, doing Asher things, fighting, killing, protecting.
Galanor is there, but where is Gideon?
There is a new point of view character, Kassian, a mage, bent on revenge.
All seems lost, but there's a spirit of rebellion in the land.
A main character from the last trilogy has disappeared into the far lands of Erador. He returns with plans to rule the kingdom and begins forcing his 'ideas' of peace to the land. The reader, of course, saw this coming, but for the characters of the book, it's a devastating blow. The character is not entirely at fault; someone has broken and manipulated him. He uses black magic to create an army of Reavers, the undead who march at his command and who do not know fear.
Asher is still there, doing Asher things, fighting, killing, protecting.
Galanor is there, but where is Gideon?
There is a new point of view character, Kassian, a mage, bent on revenge.
All seems lost, but there's a spirit of rebellion in the land.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews