Rating: 1.5 🌟 (mostly because it didn't make me angry like the books that I actually gave one (1) star to)
ARC Review: Received for free via Netgalley for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
CW/TW: ableist slurs, mention of bullying, ableist language, cisnormative language/mindset,
Firstly: R. I. P. planet Pluto 💔😪 we will always love you.
Secondly: This book is really white. And that's not a bad thing or anything, but the working, the situations, the whole, I don't know, feel of it, the energy, is very, very white.
The book itself is not bad, but it's not really that great either. It's kind very meh. The dialogue is kind of cringe and the way the kids act is taking me back to 2002, which isn't bad, but like, it's 2020, things be different.
I feel like 12 year old me would've eaten this kind of thing up in 2002, but now it's kind of weeh. Like, I can't completely judge it because I. Am. Ooold, but you get what I mean. I feel like kids now are a little different, even just looking at TV shows now, like the way they act as 12 year olds is very different to how 12 years olds from 2002 acted. And the ones in the book give me more of a 2002 feel more than a 2020 feel. So.
Also, while reading this, I figured out who Edward reminds me of (it took a while, but I got). He reminds of Ricky from Nicky, Ricky, Dicky and Dawn. He's not as (I don't want to say annoying because this is a h*cking child, ma'am!) in your face about being smart, but that's exactly who he reminds me of!
In as much as I have my complains though, this book works as middle grade. I feel like if they'd aged up some of the things would've been unrealistic or even annoying, but as a middle grade it all works. Like the kids make some questionable decisions but as a middle grade book I kind of believed their questionable decision, so there's that.
Side note: There's this 'joke' Dr G makes whrn he finds Edward sashaying around 'like a girl', you know the way, and he says something like "Do you have a secret to tell me" and then it keeps going and I was kind of like nah to that whole interaction. I don't know, it's not bad, it may be I'm being overly sensitive about it, but I didn't feel it. And the whole thing about Edward 'not being a girl' comes up a lot and— *sigh* it's 2020.