As a young underground cadre in 1980s Durban, Moe Shaik endured detention, following orders for the good of the organisation. Little did he know that this stint in the police cells would lead to his lifelong relationship with The Nightingale, a Special Branch policeman turned enemy secret agent whose files were so accurate, Oliver Tambo named them The Bible. Shaik morphs from being a timid optometrist to leading a critical, high-tech intelligence operation, supplying information to the ANC top brass in exile and in South Africa. He becomes party to the secrets of both the state and ANC operatives. This thrilling first-person account brings into sharp focus the role of Jacob Zuma, Shaik's brother Schabir and other players, and sheds new light on some of South Africa's most turbulent years.
This probably isn’t going to be the easiest review to write.
The ‘ANC Spy Bible ‘ brought to the surface long-dormant memories from the 1980s, and a recollection of as yet unhealed distant traumas.
I recalled the SADF bombing raids in 1985, the subsequent air raids and hunt for dissident teachers at my school that followed (the ugliness that marred an otherwise extraordinary teenage life, lived to the fullest, in golden, glorious sunshine), and most of all, the awful political violence that followed, even after the supposed detente, the release of Madiba from prison, and the unbanning of the ANC.
It is an important story, and needs to be told, given the not-so-subtle revisionism now underway. We’re all made to imagine that from 1990 on, it was all A-ok. Not so.
For me, the recollection was of the murder of a family I had known, who had lived in the border village of Sikwane, where I had once gone on a fishing trip. The entire family: home help, father, mother, disabled kids were executed at point-blank range, and their home bombed, in what was set up to look like a PAC reprisal killing of a possible double-agent. The heck it was. This prompted me to search for the TRC report on the Chand family killing for the first time, only to find that all perpetrators had been granted amnesty.
—— Shabbier Chacha who lived nearby in Mayfair, knocked on our door after Taraweeh that cold Johannesburg night, to tell us - gravely - of the news he had just heard about what happened in Sikwane. I can still recall that night at the end of Ramadan.
I had only ever been to Sikwane for the odd fishing trip.
(There was bilharzia in the water they said, so don’t fall in the river. ‘Bilharzia’ to my child’s mind was visually represented by the sawdust- like stuff everyone sprinkled on the surface of the river, some kind of fish-food like thing, random debris floating on the surface of the water, that had come in sacks loaded on to the back of a bakkie - to draw the fish closer to where they were fishing. I’ve quite forgotten the Setswana word for it now, and I realise that memory is an unreliable thing. We learn new ways of communicating, move to London, work in the City, hammer things out on our keyboards,, far, far removed from where we grew up.
I was initially trained to try be a hafidha. Perfect recall was meant to be my thing.
The thing about them being double-agents - it was almost certainly a convenient lie made up by the apartheid security forces, just like those apartheid forces would kill, and then blow up MK operatives to create false flag narratives about what they were about to do. It was intended to attract violence, to pile violence on to violence.
It was an ugly, brutal time.
The younger brother died in a car accident, on his way from the funeral in Gabs, driving back to South Africa. An accident?
Today, I read the TRC (Truth and Reconciliation Committee) report for the first time and read the lead commando’s lame excuse that he was not really involved in the execution of the family, because he had tripped on a stone outside the house and had not been involved in the actual killing. Or something. He tripped on a stone. Someone else slipped on a bar of soap.
My only recollection of the boys who were murdered was that they could not speak. They were disabled or mute. I was too polite to ask. They would make these throaty, raspy sounds to communicate, but they were understood. They were nurtured by their family, taken care of. They may have helped me with my fishing rod.
Everyone involved in their murder was granted an amnesty.
And so it goes.
Like I said. It was an ugly, brutal time. I am still trying to process it all.
———- The book makes an important point about recall, the killings that continued after the supposed peace, the attempts to destabilise everything (witness the KZN violence), and on this basis, I would have given it five stars. It also begs the question, why should we assume that the attempts at destabilisation ended in 1994? Maybe they didn’t.
And that is why I find what could be interpreted as the book’s whitewashing of later events so frustrating. Was the ‘Mac and Moe show’ (as Ronnie Kasrils put it to refer to Moe Shaik and Mac Maharaj’s actions stay the time), the use of intelligence operatives by Zuma, to discredit Bulelani Ngucka, just as Schabir Shaik was about to be charged, entirely a mistake? Or is there another story to tell? (‘Ah, we made a mistake. Agent blah blah blah who was a double- agent for the apartheid forces, was someone else. Not Bulelani). Ok, suddenly Rev Frank Chikane’s assertion at the end of ‘Eight days of September’, makes a lot more sense.
The book makes an important point about not forgetting what happened during apartheid, but it treads way too lightly on the attempts by so many to destroy the institutions of a newly-democratic South Africa. There’s more that needs to be written. Surely.
From a growth perspective, South Africa is still paying the price for what went wrong during the Zuma years.
A real-life spy story that is as gripping and exciting as any novel.
Moe Shaik was a member of the African National Congress (ANC) underground in South Africa in the 1980s when the movement was banned and being a member was illegal. He was arrested and detained for questioning about the whereabouts of an ANC courier, and after being tortured by the Special Branch was eventually released, but not before making contact with someone in the Special Branch (SB) who was sympathetic, and after his release began feeding him with information from within the SB.
This resulted in Moe Shaik starting a special intelligence unit within the ANC. Just as the Special Branch tried to collect information on the ANC, so the ANC began collecting information on the SB -- what they knew and what they didn't know, and some of their sources of informatio0n within the ANC. It was dangerous work, and there was always the risk of being caught.
When the ANC was unbanned in 1990, and political prisoners were released, people like Moe Shaik had to continue underground for a while. The National Party politicians might be willing to negotiate with the ANC, but there were many in the security services who continued to fight the war, perhaps in the hope that they could change the minds of their political bosses.
As the new democratic South Africa was born, Moe Shaik and his colleagues were faced with a different question: what was the role of an intelligence and security service in a democratic society?
This is one man's view of events, one man's memoir, but it is just such personal views that make history come alive and be more than a boring chronicle that reads like minutes of a meeting. It gives valuable insights into the history of the period, and if you like spy fiction, you'll probably also enjoy it.
A sobering reminder of the apartheid regime and its impact on SA and its people. Interesting reading it from an underground agent’s point of view, although I was hoping to understand a bit more about Mo’s brother Shabir Sheik and his relationship with Zuma, bit this book skimmed passed the details.
The book rehashes information that was already in the public domain. There is little if any, exclusive information. It would have made an impact back in 1996 not now