Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Amish Newcomer

Rate this book
Can an Englisch city girl ever become one of the Plain People?

She needed a safe place to hide.
Instead she found a place to call home…

Television journalist Leah Porte never imagined her career would end with her witnessing a murder. Now she’s temporarily living among the Amish in witness protection. Instead of feeling alone and adrift, Leah is warmly welcomed by the close-knit community—and Amish bachelor Isaac Sommer. But caught between two very different worlds, choosing love would mean leaving her Englisch life behind forever…

368 pages, Paperback

Published August 25, 2020

29 people are currently reading
111 people want to read

About the author

Patrice Lewis

65 books43 followers
Living on a remote self-sufficient homestead in North Idaho, Patrice Lewis is a Christian wife, mother, author, blogger, columnist and speaker. She has practiced and written about rural subjects for almost thirty years. When she isn’t writing, Patrice enjoys self-sufficiency projects, such as animal husbandry, small-scale dairy production, gardening, food preservation and canning, and homeschooling. She and her husband have been married since 1990 and have two daughters.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
97 (50%)
4 stars
68 (35%)
3 stars
19 (9%)
2 stars
6 (3%)
1 star
3 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
Profile Image for Paula.
545 reviews7 followers
September 7, 2020
A very enjoyable and sweet romance about Los Angeles television journalist, Leah, who witnesses a murder and ends up in witness protection, temporarily sent to live in an Amish community in Ohio. While living amongst the Amish and trying to blend in, Leah slowly learns and comes to embrace the Amish way of life. She also meets a handsome Amish man, Isaac, who she has a lot more in common with than she’d expect. This story was filled with so many lovely characters. Leah and Isaac made such a cute couple and I liked how they really took to each other. The family that Leah stayed with, The Bylers, were so kind and considerate and really made Leah feel like one of the family. I loved the sense of community that was felt throughout the story, and it was interesting to learn a lot about the Amish way of life.
Profile Image for Jeanie.
3,093 reviews1 follower
August 31, 2020
The Amish forged through their strong ties with each other. They didn't compete, they cooperated. They didn't tear town, they built up. They had community.

Leah Porte is in the Witness Protection Program. She had witnessed a brutal murder while on the job as a reporter in Los Angeles. Now her life in in danger. She has been put in an Amish community living with the Bylers in Pikeville, Ohio. The Bylers have six children and another on the way. Amos and Edith welcome Leah into their family and know Leah's background. Leah knows some of the Amish lifestyle but living with the Bylers she learns so much more about sustainable living and faith. She also learns about love in community.

Leah wonders about the Amish lifestyle and how they can be happy without the conveniences of the English world but as she experiences the plain life she experiences the beauty of a life not hurried, a meal that was planted, canned, and shared with. How work brings family together and how gratitude changes everything. The Byler's farm hand Isaac has more in common with Leah and challenges Leah in faith.

I loved how the prose taught you about the simple faith of the Amish and why it is so hard for the English to become Amish. The Amish is such a lifestyle of faith, hard work and gratitude and how the pull of the English world keeps us from God's blessing.

A special thank you to Harlequin and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
Profile Image for Robin Reynolds.
927 reviews38 followers
April 2, 2021
I’ve only read a handful of Amish themed romances, all Love Inspired I believe, and I find that I don’t really remember any of them particularly well. I don’t think the subject has ever especially appealed to me, but I do enjoy the Love Inspired line so when one would fall into my hands I didn’t mind reading it. That being said, I went into this book not really knowing what to expect, other than a fish out of water story, which does appeal to me. The heroine, who is not Amish, is placed into witness protection after witnessing a murder, and finds herself moving into the home of an Amish family.

Well, it was much more than I expected, and I feel I have a deeper understanding of the Amish after reading this.
"...One of the problems we experience is outsiders tend to romanticize our way of life. We’re seen as throwbacks to a happier time when people lived in harmony with each other, with Gott, with the earth..."
I can’t imagine not having electricity, a washing machine, TV. For Leah, it’s not easy in the beginning. She was a high profile television journalist, and suddenly she’s learning how to make homemade laundry detergent and cheese, how to garden, to cook, to skim milk. The work and the chores are never ending. But her hosts have a completely different attitude about the constant busyness.

It is a romance book, and there is a handsome man who is taken with Leah. She’s quite surprised when one of her hosts tells her he is courting her, when she’s only known him a very short time and of course, she isn’t Amish so the only way they could be together would be for her to convert or him to leave the Amish community. I won’t tell you which one happens, though I suspect you already know.

I picked this book up because I wanted something light to counter my recent reads, a steamy series about former military men and their women. I got much more than I bargained for. A character study about a woman rediscovering faith while confronting an uncertain future and the possibility of never being able to return to her former life. I still would not want to live an Amish life, but I have a greater respect for the Amish people.
Profile Image for Carla.
7,737 reviews178 followers
August 17, 2020
This was a very quick read, I basically read it in one day, not wanting to put it down. There was a very interesting plotline to this story. Leah witnessed a brutal double murder and was in danger of being murdered herself. She had already escaped with her life after she was viciously attacked with a knife, so her story of recuperating from a serious car accident was easily believed. Ending up in an Amish Community was an interesting twist on an Englischer ending up living with the Amish. Leah was a wonderful character. She did not want to be a burden on the Byler family, so she pitched in and learned much about the Amish ways. While assimilating with the family, their faith also slowly took root and she found herself believing in God for the first time. She was smart, yet felt inferior which was a bit fun seeing her wide-eyed interest in all the Amish ways to complete chores. Isaac, a neighbour who was helping Ivan in his word-working shop, found himself drawn to Leah almost immediately. I enjoyed the slow developing relationship between these two. The other members of the Byler family played an important role in the story and I also enjoyed how they accepted Leah and helped her become the person she ends up being at the end of the book. This was a sweet, interesting story. It has great character development, nice plotlines and a wonderful Christian message about finding what is important in life. If you enjoy Amish Romance, then I definitely recommend this story to you. The publisher generously provided a copy of this book upon request. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
Profile Image for Carol (Reading Ladies).
941 reviews200 followers
August 21, 2020
3.5 Stars

Thanks #netgalley @harlequinbooks for a complimentary e ARC of #theamishnewcomer upon my request. All opinions in this review are my own.

Because of dire circumstances, an English city girl finds herself living in an Amish community with an Amish family. A former television reporter whose career is suddenly jeopardized when she inadvertently witnesses a murder, Leah is living in witness protection without a phone (and its access to 24 hour news) and adjusting to a different culture. Even though Leah is an outsider and is lonely for her friends, routines, and lifestyle, she is warmly welcomed in the Amish community. As she begins to adapt and feel useful, she also develops a friendship and fondness for an Amish bachelor, Isaac.

The Amish Newcomer is inspirational (uplit) and definitely told from a Christian perspective. The foundation of the Amish community and culture is strongly religious. I feel like the author does a good job here explaining their lifestyle choices as they are integrated with their beliefs. Like all stories, this represents one experience in the Amish culture. It doesn’t seem like the author is an Amish “own voices’ author (although she has practiced and written about self-reliance and preparedness for over 24 years), so I would be interested in reading reviews or reading from other Amish perspectives. The straight forward writing, one timeline, and one point of view help this to be a fast-reading experience. I finished in one day. It’s an engaging and lovely “uplit” and inspirational read.

Leah is a likable character who overcomes a challenging situation. She finds some answers to questions about life that she might not have realized she had. She is conscientious, responsible, innovative, kind, and compassionate.

Thoughtful and poignant themes include faith, a self-sustaining lifestyle, the simple life, family, community, and second chances.

I’m enthusiastically recommending The Amish Newcomer for fans of Christian fiction, for readers who are looking for a light and uplifting story, and for those who love a gently brewing romance (completely closed door). Readers who have a background with the Amish community or are curious to learn more might especially enjoy this.

For more reviews visit my blog www.readingladies.com
Profile Image for Dianne.
1,866 reviews159 followers
August 25, 2020
This book was much different than the usual Amish romance that I am used to. I must admit that I did love it because of that fact. The idea of an Englisher hiding out with the Amish and falling in love with God, the culture, and a man was different for me. You see, I am not a believer, and I enjoy Amish books because of the culture, and any book that 'pushes' religion down my throat is not one I enjoy. This book had a lot to do with questioning faith and came close to pushing but never crossed that line.


The ending was a tad rushed, but you can clearly see why. I also was a little concerned that the author did not find a way to incorporate the criminals into the story, or at least let us know just what happens to them in the end.

*ARC supplied by the publisher and the author.
Profile Image for Maureen Timerman.
3,247 reviews493 followers
August 4, 2020
I really enjoyed this read, and the pages flew, read in one sitting, but will linger.
Awesome premise, and it seemed so real. The characters were living their faith, and sharing. An eye opener for a city girl, seeing and experiencing where our food comes from, and living with and enjoying the basics.
Acceptance and love for everyone, no matter their problems or disabilities, something to emulate!
I will be looking for reads by this author again, she has a gift and she is sharring!

I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Love Inspired. and was not required to give a positive review.
Profile Image for Pamela Pavkov.
1,263 reviews22 followers
September 3, 2020
The Amish Newcomer is a great story written by Patrice Lewis. This is my first story by this author. There is a lot of good information about the Amish in this story as Leah Porte learns to live Amish. This author's writing style shows another side to the Amish and their willingness to help those in need. I loved the characters as they appear very realistic.

Leah Porte has been placed in witness protection because of a threat to her life from a California gang. She not only witnessed a double murder but caught it accidentally on film. When she is placed in an Amish home for protection she realizes she has a lot to learn not only to blend in but also about her trust in God. She struggles to learn the lifestyle but finds herself attracted to an Amish man, Issac. This story takes the reader step by step in the everyday life of Amish women but also in the healing process and forgiveness needed to survive. Leah wonders if she will ever be able to return to her normal life. When she receives a devastating letter her life is completely shattered.

I was not given a complimentary copy of this book to read and review. I was not approached to post a favorable response. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.

Congratulations to Patrice Lewis on her release of this intriguing story.
Profile Image for Faith.
2,233 reviews
September 6, 2020
After the witness of a murder, Leah Porte, a TV journalist takes refuge among a community of conservative Amish people.

Leah finds her whole life upturned in but a few moments, she cannot go back to her old life because of the public nature of her job. She is challenged by the simpler ways of the Amish, and intrigued by furniture maker, Isaac Sommers. I admired her ready to help attitude and how she is open to learning and trying new things.

An enjoyable read, with a wonderful community of people who make Leah feel welcome. Though at times it felt like parts of this book were written for someone who has never read an Amish book before. Isaac is a caring and thoughtful hero. This is a pleasant and heartwarming read for fans of Amish fiction.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Janet.
3,380 reviews24 followers
September 15, 2020
This may be a quick read but it was wonderful. I was pleasantly surprised that this is the author's first book. Leah Porte is a television journalist who is now in witness protection and hiding in the Amish community. She ends up finding much more than she had ever hoped for. It's the perfect book to read when unwinding from your day.
Profile Image for Lori.
1,892 reviews134 followers
June 24, 2020
A wonderful read by this new to me author that I really enjoyed!
A short read that will pull you into this novel from the beginning and not let go until you're finished with it.
I loved the plot and the characters were wonderful! I loved making friends with them and I hated to say goodbye but the best thing is this book is so worth the reread because there's scenes in the book that you might've missed the first time around!
I especially liked how Lewis has made her characters seem real and believable and I felt their emotions come from the pages out to me. I also found myself rooting for them too and to me that's the best part of the book! Seeing where the characters will come out at the end. Of course, we all know what that will be and I feel that's what this book offers is hope. Hope for better things. Love and Forgiveness too.
Isn't it funny where and how life takes you? Only the Lord knows. He has purpose and a good reason for where He places us at any gjven time!
I look at it this way. Life is changing every day and I figure you can take it or leave it but you can also choose to see it as an adventure. I choose to see it as an adventure!
I found myself rooting for Leah and Issac through the whole entire story!
I couldn't imagine witnessing what Leah did. I think I'd be a nervous wreck! Yay Leah!
This little story deserves more than 5 stars because it's engaging, fun and very very good!
My thanks goes to Netgalley for this cute little story that I really enjoyed and I highly recommend!
All opinions are my own
Profile Image for Nancy Carty Lepri.
Author 4 books18 followers
August 7, 2020
I have reviewed this title for New York Journal of Books where it will be published the evening before the release date.


"The Amish Newcomer" by Patrice Lewis
Love Inspired
August 25, 2020
10-1335488369
224 pages
Contemporary Amish Romance


Leah Porte works diligently for years to accomplish the enviable position as a television journalist reporting the down-and-gritty news in Los Angeles. Though having no social life, she is fulfilled while concentrating on her career. Until . . . .

While on a scene, Leah is brutally attacked and left fighting for her life, causing the Witness Protection Program to relocate her to the small Amish community of Pikeville, where she is least likely to be discovered by the thugs after her.

It's difficult for a professional city woman to get accustomed to Amish ways, learning to live a sustainable life without the comforts of electricity, running water, cars, phones, and even computers. Taken under the wing by the Byler's, Leah is graciously welcome, now dressing in Amish attire, and treated like kin. Neighbors are told she is a distant relative recovering from an accident, for in her present situation, the less known about her the better, not only for her safety but for that of the Byler's, too.

As Leah enters the Byler household, consisting of pregnant mother, Edith, father, Ivan, and their three boys and three girls, Leah feels overwhelmed. An only child whose parents divorced when she was young, she's not used to a large family, though she is captivated by the devotion and compatibility they share, as well as the respect of the children.

What will happen when she can leave and get back into the world? Because of the disfigurement she received to her face, she'll never be able to be behind a TV camera again, and this is something she's worked for her whole life.

Unused to manual labor, Leah learns the domestic chores inherent with everyday living: washing clothes by hand, cooking on a wood stove, preparing meals from home-grown preserved food, as well as other household duties the typical "Englisher" completes easily by using appliances. Leah realizes she loves working in the garden, weeding, and harvesting fruits, and vegetables, but most of all—doing chores with others, where there is a camaraderie among everyone. A new experience for Leah, she is surprised she enjoys every second of the back-breaking work, and the silent evenings while Ivan reads the Bible as everyone listens attentively. Leah finds something she never experienced before: the love of community and a newfound family.

Leah is drawn to Rachel, the Byler's daughter, who was born with a physical disability. Wise beyond her years, she gives Leah insight into her faith and the principles they all live by. Never having any formal religious training, Leah is amazed and impressed by their dependence on their Lord.

Rachel describes her experience during her "rumspringa”:

"'On my rumspringa, I missed having friends around all the time. It seems a lot of Englisch people are lonely. I know I would be, if I didn't have the church community around me all the time.'

"The words were simply spoken, but they made Leah blink hard for a few moments. Short or not, Rachel knew where she belonged. She had a place in this community. She knew what her role was in life.

"Where do I belong? Leah had a moment of profound loneliness. She belonged nowhere. She no longer knew what her role was in life. She was rootless, without the community or even faith that sustained these daughters of the Byler family.

"What would it be like to be so unquestionably accepted. Leah had clawed her way to the top for so long that the thought of sinking quietly into a society that accepted its members with love and loyalty was intriguing."

Leah discloses the truth to Rachel of what brought her to the Byler's:

"'I was filming a story on gang violence in L.A. It was the night of January first, New Year's Day, a cold night out on the streets. I saw two gang members kill a woman and her child. They just knifed them down in cold blood. . . .’

"'They didn't see me or my cameraman, and we filmed the whole thing.' Leah's voice trembled. 'I'll never forget it. It was pure accident they were killed on camera, and it happened so fast neither of us could have stopped it. But they saw us. Suddenly we were running for our lives down a dark alley. They caught up with us when I tripped and fell. . . .’

"'One . . . one of them started slashing my face. I thought he was going to slit my throat, but my cameraman, Ted, kicked him in the head, so he was knocked out. Ted saved my life that night. He decked the other guy, dragged me to my feet, and we made it back to the news van and got out of there. He took me straight to the hospital, where they had to do some reconstruction work on me, but it was clear from that moment my career in front of the camera was over. . . . ‘

"'. . . My station aired the footage of the murders, and from then on, I've been hunted. They had to post a guard at my hospital room door after some people tried to get in. I wasn't safe at my apartment. It took no time for my address to become known. They want me dead. Finally, the authorities put me in witness protection, which is how I ended up here, through the kindness of your parents."

Leah meets Isaac Sommer, a neighbor who helps Ivan with his furniture-making business. Like Leah, he is also in his late 20s and unmarried unlike most of his peers. During his rumspringa to the "English" world, he attended school, but realized he missed his old lifestyle, so he returned. In addition to working with Ivan, Isaac creates leather articles and cares for his widowed mother. Now, with permission from the Bishop he produces a magazine not only for the Amish but for those wanting to live off the grid and get back to nature.

Isaac is drawn to Leah. They share "Englisch" living, so she understands things others in his group cannot. Wanting nothing more than to marry and have a family, many of his contemporaries are already married, but the younger women are not interested in him.

Isaac requests Leah's assistance with his publication. Well versed in writing and computers, she would be a great help to him. Though hesitant, she starts jotting down facts about her new lifestyle from her perspective, realizing she can offer something new to promote the magazine's circulation, particularly outside the "Plain" community.

As time passes, Leah becomes attached to the locals, especially Isaac. She realizes:

"She was beginning to see something of the strength the Amish forged through their strong ties with each other. They didn't compete; they cooperated. They didn't tear down; they build up."

Leah thinks this is a wonderful way to live, but she is not one of them. Though Isaac shows interest in her, he is baptized and will not leave his faith. Could they possibly have a future? Could she become a member of the church? Leah considers this and visits the Bishop to discuss her thoughts and with him. He tells her this:

"One of the problems we experience is outsiders tend to romanticize our way of life. We're seen as throwbacks to a happier time when people lived in harmony with each other, with Gott, with the earth. Those who seek us based on those terms don't last because Gott isn't the center of their lives. But Gott is the center of our lives. One of the reasons we do adult baptism is because it's critical our members understand the seriousness of their commitment, something children can't do. It's far better not to make a vow than to make a vow and later break it. That's why we take both baptism and marriage seriously. There's no going back."

This last paragraph says a lot about these people. Their selflessness, compassion, and care of others make this appear to be an ideal way of life. But can an “Englisch” American renounce modern convenience and live this way? Regardless that this is seemingly a perfect world, they too must face obstacles and hardships as with any group. The heartwarming aspect of this novel is the unconditional love, acceptance, and peace shown—a blessing in our current turbulent world.
Profile Image for Nancy Lepri.
137 reviews5 followers
August 25, 2020
The Amish Newcomer
by Patrice Lewis
Love Inspired
August 25, 2020
10-1335488369
224 pages
Contemporary Amish Romance


Leah Porte works diligently for years to accomplish the enviable position as a television journalist reporting the down-and-gritty news in Los Angeles. Though having no social life, she is fulfilled while concentrating on her career. Until . . . .

While on a scene, Leah is brutally attacked and left fighting for her life causing the Witness Protection Program to relocate her to the small Amish community of Pikeville, where she is least likely to be discovered by the thugs after her.

It's difficult for a professional city woman to get accustomed to Amish ways, learning to live a sustainable life without the comforts of electricity, running water, cars, phones, and even computers. Taken under the wing by the Byler's, Leah is graciously welcome, now dressing in Amish attire, and treated like kin. Neighbors are told she is a distant relative recovering from an accident, for in her present situation, the less known about her the better, not only for her safety but for that of the Byler's too.

As Leah enters the Byler household, consisting of pregnant mother, Edith, father, Ivan, and their three boys and three girls, Leah feels overwhelmed. An only child whose parents divorced when she was young, she's not used to a large family, though she is captivated by the devotion and compatibility they share, as well as the respect of the children.

What will happen when she can leave and get back into the world? Because of the disfigurement she received to her face, she'll never be able to be behind a TV camera again, and this is something she's worked for her whole life.

Unused to manual labor, Leah learns the domestic chores inherent with everyday living: washing clothes by hand, cooking on a wood stove, preparing meals from home-grown preserved food, as well as other household duties the typical "Englisher" completes easily by using appliances. Leah realizes she loves working in the garden, weeding, and harvesting fruits, and vegetables, but most of all—doing chores with others, where there is a camaraderie among everyone. A new experience for Leah, she is surprised she enjoys every second of the back-breaking work, and the silent evenings while Ivan reads the Bible as everyone listens attentively. Leah finds something she never experienced before. . .the love of community and a "new-found" family.

Leah is drawn to Rachel, the Byler's daughter who was born with a physical disability. Wise beyond her years, she gives Leah insight into her faith and the principles they all live by. Never having any formal religious training, Leah is amazed and impressed by their dependence on their Lord.

Rachel describes her experience during her "rumspringa:"

"'On my rumspringa, I missed having friends around all the time. It seems a lot of Englisch people are lonely. I know I would be, if I didn't have the church community around me all the time.'

"The words were simply spoken, but they made Leah blink hard for a few moments. Short or not, Rachel knew where she belonged. She had a place in this community. She knew what her role was in life.

"Where do I belong? Leah had a moment of profound loneliness. She belonged nowhere. She no longer knew what her role was in life. She was rootless, without the community or even faith that sustained these daughters of the Byler family.

"What would it be like to be so unquestionably accepted. Leah had clawed her way to the top for so long that the thought of sinking quietly into a society that accepted its members with love and loyalty was intriguing."

Leah discloses the truth to Rachel of what brought her to the Byler's:

"'I was filming a story on gang violence in L.A. It was the night of January first, New Year's Day, a cold night out on the streets. I saw two gang members kill a woman and her child. They just knifed them down in cold blood. . . .’

"'They didn't see me or my cameraman, and we filmed the whole thing.' Leah's voice trembled. 'I'll never forget it. It was pure accident they were killed on camera, and it happened so fast neither of us could have stopped it. But they saw us. Suddenly we were running for our lives down a dark alley. They caught up with us when I tripped and fell. . . .’

"'One. . . one of them started slashing my face. I thought he was going to slit my throat, but my cameraman, Ted, kicked him in the head, so he was knocked out. Ted saved my life that night. He decked the other guy, dragged me to my feet, and we made it back to the news van and got out of there. He took me straight to the hospital, where they had to do some reconstruction work on me, but it was clear from that moment my career in front of the camera was over. . . . ‘

"'. . . My station aired the footage of the murders, and from then on, I've been hunted. They had to post a guard at my hospital room door after some people tried to get in. I wasn't safe at my apartment. It took no time for my address to become known. They want me dead. Finally, the authorities put me in witness protection, which is how I ended up here, through the kindness of your parents."

Leah meets Isaac Sommer, a neighbor who helps Ivan with his furniture-making business. Like Leah, he is also in his late 20’s and unmarried unlike most of his peers. During his rumspringa to the "English" world, he attended school, but realized he missed his old lifestyle, so he returned. In addition to working with Ivan, Isaac creates leather articles and cares for his widowed mother. Now, with permission from the Bishop he produces a magazine not only for the Amish but for those wanting to live off the grid and get back to nature.

Isaac is drawn to Leah. They share "Englisch" living, so she understands things others in his group cannot. Wanting nothing more than to marry and have a family, many of his contemporaries are already married, but the younger women are not interested in him.

Isaac requests Leah's assistance with his publication. Well versed in writing and computers, she would be a great help to him. Though hesitant, she starts jotting down facts about her new lifestyle from her perspective, realizing she can offer something new to promote the magazine's circulation, particularly outside the "Plain" community.

As time passes, Leah becomes attached to the locals, especially Isaac. She realizes:

"She was beginning to see something of the strength the Amish forged through their strong ties with each other. They didn't compete; they cooperated. They didn't tear down; they build up."

Leah thinks this is a wonderful way to live, but she is not one of them. Though Isaac shows interest in her, he is baptized and will not leave his faith. Could they possibly have a future? Could she become a member of the church? Leah considers this and visits the Bishop to discuss her thoughts and with him. He tells her this:

"One of the problems we experience is outsiders tend to romanticize our way of life. We're seen as throwbacks to a happier time when people lived in harmony with each other, with Gott, with the earth. Those who seek us based on those terms don't last because Gott isn't the center of their lives. But Gott is the center of our lives. One of the reasons we do adult baptism is because it's critical our members understand the seriousness of their commitment, something children can't do. It's far better not to make a vow than to make a vow and later break it. That's why we take both baptism and marriage seriously. There's no going back."

This last paragraph says a lot about these people. Their selflessness, compassion, and care of others make this appear to be an ideal way of life. But can an “Englisch” American renounce modern convenience and live this way? Seemingly a perfect world, but surely, they too must face obstacles and hardships as with any group. The heartwarming aspect of this novel is the unconditional love, acceptance, and peace shown—a blessing in our current turbulent world.
59 reviews
June 30, 2020
I greatly enjoyed this novel by Ms. Lewis. I've seen stories before (tv and books) where the Amish served in witness protection. I was surprised that none of the drama from anyone searching for Leah entered the picture. There was a moment when a newspaper reporter came into contact with Leah in a library, and I was expecting that to turn into something more when he noticed the scar on her face, and the fact that she was comfortable with writing and creating a website on a computer. I'm not sure why the author didn't pursue any of this further into the storyline. I found this as a little bit of a letdown, because a small amount of mystery and excitement can be a fun addition to a story. This was my only reason for giving 4 stars instead of 5. I felt Ms. Lewis missed a wonderful opportunity to further develop the storyline. However, it appeared she chose to keep it "short" and "simple".

I really enjoyed how the author developed Leah's character. Leah discovered value in a depth that far exceeded material things or shallow personalities. She had no family of any kind before entering the Amish world. She quickly discovered the deep sense of community and family outside of the blood relatives. I also enjoyed how the author pointed out how books and "Englishers" tend to "romanticize" the life of the Amish. It is clearly a great deal of hard work in their world. However, the work is handled by many hands, and in a family/community fashion that lessens the hardship. Overall, I truly enjoyed this book, and will be watching for more by Patrice Lewis!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from HARLEQUIN - Romance (U.S. & Canada) through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Heather 123.
955 reviews8 followers
November 19, 2022
Some of this story was a slight stretch. You had to ignore some things that didn’t make sense. For example, witness protection but without a new name? Witness protection who sends details about the case via postal mail? Witness protection with no contact with anyone?

I also expected a little more to come from the case. But it just ended quickly and quietly.

Overall though it was a good story. It was interesting to learn about the process to become Amish

Arc received from netgalley
Profile Image for Kristina Anderson.
4,095 reviews84 followers
September 6, 2020
An Amish Newcomer by Patrice Lewis is unique Amish novel. We get to see an Englischer adapt to living in an Amish home. It is an uphill battle for Leah who is used to keeping abreast of the news and reporting it. She is unused to doing domestic chores without the aid of modern conveniences. Leah is also dealing with the loss of her career thanks to the scar inflicted by a gang member. She has no idea how long she will be living with the Byler’s. I thought An Amish Newcomer was well-written and an engaging novel. It was a quick read and hard to put down. I am amazed at how much work it takes to run an Amish home. The family in this story make most of their own food. We see sustainable living at its finest. It was fun watching the worldly Leah at awe of an Amish home and all the hard work. She felt inferior because she did not know how to accomplish tasks that a twelve-year-old easily accomplished. Isaac Sommer was an interesting character. A man who lived in the Englisch world for a time, but he returned to his Amish roots. He created a magazine for Plain people that has wide distribution. This Amish tale has developed characters and good plotlines. I liked the Christian messages in the story especially about discovering what is important in life. I liked how the Amish looked past Leah’s scar to see the person inside as they did with one of the Byler daughters. Our world would be a better place if this philosophy is widely followed. I liked how the relationship between Isaac and Leah slowly developed. I also enjoyed seeing the changes in Leah. I look forward to reading Patrice Lewis’ next Amish novel when it comes out in the spring. An Amish Newcomer is an uplifting Amish novel with continuous domestic chores, woodworking woes, curious children, computer conundrum, and God’s generous gifts.
Profile Image for Vickie.
2,269 reviews75 followers
August 29, 2020
This is a very quick and entertaining book! The premise is that a former newscaster from LA is in witness protection, and the U.S. Marshalls hide her with an Amish family. Dressing like the Amish is not a big problem for Leah, but learning the Amish way of life was a bit of a challenge. Much of the book reads like a primer about the Amish lifestyle and religious beliefs and I found it all very interesting. The characters were believable and likable as well as presented realistically for that culture. My favorite character was a young woman named Rachel who had physical problems but who tackled life with zest and wisdom. The plot also includes drama, conflict and a romantic interest between Leah and a young Amish man named Isaac who is devoted to his faith. Both of them know that for her to have a relationship with him would be almost impossible since she is “Englisch” and he tried that world and returned to his Amish life. I really enjoyed the descriptions of how the Amish do things like laundry and healthcare, things that we take modern conveniences for granted. I learned more about reading this book than I thought possible and was entertained as I read it. Fans of light, clean romance will enjoy this book and the light that it sheds on a group of people who live a different kind of life.
Disclaimer
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from Harlequin via Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255, “Guides Concerning the Use of Testimonials and Endorsements in Advertising.”
Profile Image for Lynn.
559 reviews3 followers
September 8, 2020
Leah Porte is a television news reporter that witnesses a brutal murder and is now in witness protection living with an Amish family. Everything about the Amish lifestyle is different than how she was raised. It is such a change to go from a celebrity living in Los Angeles, to living on a farm in the Amish countryside with the Yoder family. This may be the biggest challenge she has ever had to face. Having a handsome friend of the family always around makes it even more of a challenge.

Isaac Sommer is back living with his family in the Amish countryside after living away from their lifestyle for a few years. He is helping his aging mother and the Yoder family. His dream is to have a wife and a family and continue to live a quiet life devoted to God. What he does not count on is the spunky independent woman who has come to live with the Yoder’s who catches his eye.

Patrice Lewis wrote a brilliant story of family, faith, and community. This was not only a beautiful story of the journey of Leah, but the book educated the reader about what life is like in an Amish community. As I was reading the book, I reflected on what a simpler lifestyle would be like. One without technology and social pressure. It really made me stop and think. This is one of the best books I have read this year, one that touched my heart and soul. Thank you so much to the author Patrice Lewis, Harlequin Publishing and NetGalley for an advanced copy of the book to review. It was fabulous! All opinions expressed for this review are unbiased and entirely my own.
Profile Image for Robin Loves Reading.
2,938 reviews433 followers
August 11, 2020
Leah Porte is a television journalist who was critically injured by a ruthless gang while reported on a story. They left the job undone, and the only way for her to stay alive is to become part of the Witness Protection Program. The Marshall's decided to hide Leah among the Amish. As it is, Leah's injuries mean she could never face the camera again, but she must now give up her life as English, for as long as it takes. What will it take not only for her to fit in as Plain, and for how long?

She lands in Pikeville, Ohio and is taken in by Edith and Amos's loving family. Edith is more than kind to Leah, helping her to change her appearance and to learn their ways. Leah cannot help but feel drawn to the tight-knit and loving community. When she meets Isaac Somer, they realize that they have quite a bit in common, especially as during his rumspringa Isaac spent time among the English and has adapted several of those ways to Amish culture once returning.

What a lovely story! Leah and Isaac are more than drawn to one another, but of course Leah is not Amish so there is no hope for anything to develop between them. What ensues in this book is how things do develop, what bonds them together, and what decisions Leah makes. These Amish stories are among my favorite reads and The Amish Newcomer is right there among the best of them.

Many thanks to Love Inspired and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Michelle .
1,106 reviews35 followers
June 10, 2022
The Amish Newcomer is an Amish inspirational by author Patrice Lewis.

I really, really loved the English to Amish inspirational. Leah Porte is living among the Amish while under witness protection. Leah was a journalist until she was a witness to a double murder. Isaac Sommer publishes a magazine for the Plain people.

I appreciated learning more about the Amish. Most Englishers think the Amish have an easy, simple life. As Leah learns, it’s not that easy. However, they have a trust in God that Leah doesn’t have. Isaac is allowed to have some modern technology so he can publish his magazine. Some Amish communities are stricter than others.

Leah is Agnostic, while Isaac is a man of Faith. Leah is used to the climb of a career, while Isaac is used to working in the community. Leah is from Los Angeles and has seen lots of crime, though Isaac lived in the English world for a while he prefers the Amish community.

I would highly recommend The Amish Newcomer to the Love Inspired books fans. I give The Amish Newcomer 5*/5*. Author Patrice Lewis is now on my author watch list.

Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
Profile Image for Leslie McKee.
Author 8 books72 followers
August 21, 2020
It's hard to believe this is the author's Love Inspired debut! I've read a number of Amish stories, and this is one of my favorites 🙂

It's easy to love Leah, and you can't help but cheer her on. Her growth is inspiring, and the story overall is heartwarming. There's a depth to the characters, particularly as Leah learns that her new community (Amish) see beyond her physical scars and look at her instead. (An important reminder for everyone!) Many Englishers have heard of the sense of community in the Amish world, and Lewis does a wonderful job of showing that in her book. It's touching to see people pull together, help each other when needed without expecting something in return, and being kind-hearted ... all of which are often lacking in today's society.

Lewis accurately depicts the Amish lifestyle, which is sometimes romanticized as a "simple life." It's clear that the truth is far different, as Leah realizes just how hard the Amish work ... and she comes to appreciate and embrace that.

I look forward to reading upcoming books from this author.

Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book, but I wasn't required to leave a positive review.
Profile Image for Books and Spoons.
1,612 reviews32 followers
August 31, 2020
A heartfelt, warm, and sweet tale of an urban city woman escaping a dire situation in LA to the Amish community where she learns new ways to look at life, about faith in God, and falls so adorably in love with the neighbor.
This story had such a welcoming inclusive vibe, it was truly a pleasure to read and experience. The community was helpful, kind, and considerate, they embraced Leah Porte, took her in, and taught her their ways, as she requested and wanted to learn more.
I loved Leah's development in this story as she gains an understanding of Amish ways she learns about her self as well. For the first time, she truly hears about God and is intrigued, wanting more. Leah is easy to like, she is smart and kind and considerate and assimilates so easily into the new culture and ways of the Amish. She yearns to know more, to understand, and as she does she accepts the simple ways herself.
The romance with Isaac is a delightfully precious slow process, yet the feels they have for each other are real, believable, and on a strong foundation.
A solid, admirable tale of searching for meaning, learning to trust, to have faith, to love, and live your life's purpose.
~ Four Spoons
Profile Image for Patti Whitson Stephenson She Lives to Read.
1,199 reviews27 followers
August 27, 2020
I loved the unusual storyline of this book. I also thought the author did a good job with the pacing of the story as Leah finds her place as an Englisher living in an Amish community. The author also did an excellent job of showing the reader how the everyday routine and work of an Amish household appeared to a young lady whose whole world has revolved around city living and technology, rather than country farm living. I liked that Leah was always respectful of the Amish and determined to fit into the community as best she could. But the most touching part of the book or me was Leah’s journey of coming to faith in God and His provision in her life. This is the first book I’ve read by this author, and I’ll be looking forward to her next book.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Momma Says: To Read or Not to Read.
3,441 reviews113 followers
September 16, 2020
The Amish Newcomer is one of those books that was exactly what I needed when I needed it. When I started, I expected more suspense, considering how Leah comes to be in the Amish community. As it turns out, that wasn't really a big part of the story - it's primarily the vehicle for getting her there. So, rather than finding a suspenseful story, it turned out to be uplifting and thoroughly engaging. The faith of the Amish comes through and is almost a tangible thing, especially if you believe as I do. The romance blooms slowly, and I really enjoyed Leah becoming part of the community. Patrice Lewis paints a picture with her words that drew me in to this world she's created and held on tight. The book is very well written, the characters are engaging, and the story is entertaining. It's one of those books that just makes you smile, and we could all use some of that right now.
Profile Image for Rachel DeVaughn.
1,100 reviews32 followers
September 11, 2020
This was my first book by this author but I love “Love Inspired” books and the book description sounded great, so I decided to give it a try. I really enjoyed it!!

Leah goes into witness protection in an Amish community in Ohio and learns alot about faith, family, community and love. While she is there it gives her a chance to reflect on her own life and what she wants. I really enjoyed reading more into the Amish community and faith-how they do things on a daily basis, how they help each other, their chores, the Amish way of living versus English.

Easy to read, clean romance, Amish fiction book. Highly recommend!

I received a copy of this book complimentary for blog and social media review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Katherine Hayward Pérez .
1,702 reviews79 followers
August 31, 2020
When Leah, an ex TV journalist enters an Amish community, it's a complete life change for her.

Amish life is eyeopening for the Englischer and the challenges of living in the community are good and bad just like life itself.

When she meets Isaac she may get more than she bargained for. Or will they get on? will she get used to Amish life or will she want to return to her old life while searching for a new job?

Thanks to Patrice Lewis and Harlequin Love Inspired for my ARC in exchange for an honest and voluntary review.

5 stars.
Profile Image for Jen.
486 reviews18 followers
September 30, 2020
Mini-thoughts:

A great book to learn about Amish ways and traditions: my biggest take away from this book is the power of healing and forgiving not only yourself but those who hurt you to be able to see the world a better place. Leah and Isaac are perfect together despite their differences, and the author makes sure that we will be able to read and see the whole nine yards of their romance. The story is very intriguing and inspiring.
Profile Image for Melanie.
Author 11 books22 followers
December 23, 2021
This was my first time reading an Amish romance. It was sweet and interesting and I enjoyed reading about how the Amish community worked. I did find it a bit slow-moving with Leah iterating how she didn't know how to do anything and felt there should be a bit more to the story than just learning how to live off the land in the Amish way, but over all, a sweet read.
Profile Image for Dali Castillo.
688 reviews19 followers
May 21, 2024
Lovely Story

A lovely story of love, new beginning, faith, and learning to trust in God.

Book Quote:
“I can’t save the whole world. That’s Gott’s job, not mine. My job is to save my own soul, and perhaps influence the souls around me.

“It’s a powerful thing, isn’t it, to know Gott watches out for us,”...
Profile Image for Melanie .
11 reviews
August 30, 2020
Such a heartwarming read. I felt happy the whole time reading it and it even made me happy in my own life. I kept that warmth with me. Finding faith in God, family, friends and community. The way I wish things always would be.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.