Adultery is a choice…among many others.
Andre Dubus
Adultery & Other Choices
Open Road, New York, 2010
Adultery and Other Choices consists of nine short stories and a novella. The book is broken into three parts, in which Dubus skillfully depicts the strifes and challenges of real life, and at the same time, mirrors the progression of complex obstacles as we age through each part. Part one contains five short stories with the theme centering around the struggles of the characters in their youth. An Afternoon with the Old Man, Contrition and The Bully focus on Paul Clement, a young boy who lives in Louisiana, and shows his struggles transitioning into manhood. In An Afternoon with the Old Man, the mother says to Paul, “You should talk more with Daddy. He loves y’all very much, but he doesn’t know how to talk to children,” (p.8). This depicts the relationship between them, and what the three short stories ultimately center around.
Graduation focuses on a girl, Bobbie, struggling with her reputation, as well as her high school relationships. Her problems center on her learning about boys, and getting through high school as a misunderstood girl, and reinventing herself when she goes to college.
The Fat Girl was by far my favorite short story in this book. It follows Louise and her struggle with obesity since childhood, through college, and after. It really captures a problem that is prominent in society today.
Part two has four short stories, focusing on military stories and the characters’ struggles, which are more adult in nature. In Cadence, the reader once again sees Paul Clement, but as a young man entering the Marine Corps. The story follows him and his decision to enter the marines and his having to stick to his decision, even though he wants to quit.
The other three stories, Corporal of Artillery, The Shooting and Andromcahe all center on married life in the military. Andromache is the only story in this section that follows mostly the wife. Ellens pilot husband dies, and she recalls times before her husbands death “Her memories of Joe were alive: he was talking, he was smiling at her, he was stern, he was walking on the cold beach at Whidbey Island, or kissing her and going to the plane.”(p.103).
The final part of the story, Adultery, is a novella about Edith, a wife who commits adultery with an ex-priest and her internal struggle along the way.
The immediacy Dubus writes with is incredible. He portrays his characters--all ordinary people in ordinary places--with ease. This book is most appropriate for young adults or older, because the diction is easy to follow, but every word used in each story was tactfully placed and holds meaning. Everything said is done so on purpose, and Dubus doesn’t add any fluff to clutter his short stories. Dubus’ writing is clean, and his sentences vary in structure, adding to the books tempo. In each story, he narrates as an observer, which says even more about his writing. Without allowing the reader directly into his characters minds, the reader still understands so much about them through their small, revealing moments. This book was one unlike any other I have read. The stories work together in the recurring theme of distant relationships, and keep the reader intrigued until the end.