The end of the season brings tourists to Misty Harbor and all the businesses are eager to showcase the best of Blueberry Bay. None more so than the Little Dog Diner. Dani is up for the Best Business Award and rumor has it, the diner has the lead. The other award finalists, all men, hold a grudge against Dani, insisting that since Rose is a committee member, Dani should be disqualified. Dani (and Pip) are eager to show them how she deserves that award. The only hitch in Dani's plan is Wilhelmina Joy, Misty Harbor’s dedicated environmentalist, who is protesting single use packaging used in local businesses, including the diner. While Dani agrees with the cause, Wilhelmina's methods leave a lot to be desired and she won't listen to reason or be bribed by diner treats. Wilhelmina remains firm in her desire to "save" the town. Would her protest be enough cause for murder? It seems like it when Pip finds Wilhelmina stabbed to death with her own sign at the Savory Soup & Sandwich Café. It doesn't look good for the local business owners. It's up to Dani and Maggie (plus Pip) to find out who killed Wilhelmina before it can ruin Dani's business.
Hooray! This series is back on track! No evil twins or random long-lost relatives to be found. The mystery is complicated with enough red herrings to make figuring out the right motive difficult. I thought I knew WHO, based on Pip's reaction, but I wasn't totally positive even up to the end when the killer confronts Dani. The motive was lame! I was surprised. There's a little bit more lightheartedness in this one with Maggie's big 3-0 coming up and Maggie and AJ's rivalry over their kittens. I don't like the author inserting ageist and sexist comments into Dani's mouth. Dani is supposed to be young. She's prejudiced against mamajuana smokers, thinking they're all ageing hippies. No way! Maine borders Massachusetts and pot is legal there. Everyone I know who uses it for recreational purposes is Dani's age or younger. It's now legal in Maine and she would totally know people who smoke joints. I think it's disgusting and harmful and she can think THAT but ageing hippies? No, that's not right for New England these days.
Dani is kind of stupid. She gets involved in this mystery to save her business but she nearly loses her life doing it. She keeps saying she'll be careful but she never is careful enough. She doesn't figure out whodunit until it's too late and the killer catches up to her. Her grandmother rather encourages her sleuthing habit but Rose is a little more cautious than Dani. Luke is super sweet and supportive but I still find the romance too thin to be believable. He was still married and widowed only a few months ago! I didn't care for Maggie and AJ's rivalry in the previous book but here they seem to have worked things out. I don't get a romantic vibe between them though. AJ has lightened up anyway and I like Maggie a lot more. Lily is hardly in the story now she has her own business but she does get one important scene. Chad and his wife seem to be eager beavers and quick learners. They're a huge help. They learned the ropes a little too quickly to be believable, in my opinion, and I'd like to see Dani back at work actually baking something!
The animal scenes have increased - hooray! Pip is adorable and eager to go go go as always. There were too many cats in this story for a book about the Little DOG Diner. Rose now has Trouble, a one-eyed street cat and Maggie and AJ have their kitties. I was horrified they let Pip play with the kitten! Pip can try to make friends with Trouble, he can take care of himself but terriers often see small animals like kitten as prey and should not be left alone with them. Also, terriers are not scent hounds and can't follow the scent of another dog unless that dog leaves a pee trail and they recognize that dog's scent well enough to follow it. Misty, Wilhemina's dog, is sweet but I wouldn't rehome a dog with a senior. Even with a fenced yard, dogs need exercise and socialization. I would have liked Dani to offer to take Misty for a walk on the beach with Pip. Even at 10 or so, I think Misty would enjoy that.
The rest of the cast is comprised of new characters. Wilhelmina Joy is a killjoy. Seen as the town crank, she's opposed to anything she perceives as ruinous to the town. While Dani (and I) agree with her sentiments about single use packaging and trash on the beach, Wilhelmina doesn't go before the town council, she doesn't try to reach out to the business owners and work on a solution together. She's very self-interested. Her protests are designed to harm the local economy so I'm not sure why that's a good thing for the town. Would she make all the humans go away and live off the ocean alone? That's not practical. I think she enjoys being cranky.
Suspects include Brett and possibly Josie Hiller. Josie is the new dispatcher at the police station and her husband owns the Savory Soup & Sandwich Café. He is also a finalist for the Best Business Award and a target of Wilhelmina's wrath. I don't know what to make of him. He's trying hard to make a living but he isn't all that nice or supportive of Dani. He wants and needs to win that award, but at what cost? His wife doesn't like cats so I think she may be a suspect as well because she took the job at the police station because they need the money. If the café closes, they lose everything.
The other award finalists and suspects are John Harmon, souvenir shop owner and Larry Sidwell,, who owns and operates a boat tour company. Neither of them really need to win the award as much as Dani and Brent but they're competitive and Larry really wants to expand his business. Larry is especially nasty and certainly seems like he could be the murderer. John is also a little intense.
There are even more new characters and possible suspects. Marcus Willoby is Wilhemina's boat neighbor at the Misty Marina. He runs a blog of Misty's Harbor news to compete with Rose's Grapevine. However, Marcus likes to stir up trouble and pit people against each other. He loved baiting Wilhemina and arguing with her. She provided fodder for his trashy blog. His readers sound like internet trolls, looking for something to gripe about. Marcus keeps pushing for the Best Business Award to go ahead as planned after Wilhemina's death. Why is he so eager for the awards ceremony? Why are his readers so invested? Marcus is just an all-around unpleasant person. Kyle Johnson, the marina manager, seems nice and the only family member who cared about his aunt. He seems a little overly concerned about a dog who doesn't even wag her tail and greet him. Why is that? Does he think she may be hiding the secret of the murder and wants to make sure no one else discovers it? Other people claim Kyle isn't as nice as he seems. I feel a little wary of him and more so of his father. His father doesn't sound nice at all and would have a good reason to want Wilhelmina out of the way. Which one of them killed Wilhelmina?