Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Life Worth Living

Rate this book

Are some white lies simply too big to forgive?

Eve and Leah are identical twins—but beyond that, they’re polar opposites. Struggling journalist Leah envies Eve’s seemingly perfect life—the loyal husband, the beautiful twin daughters, the stellar career—little knowing that what Eve longs for most is Leah’s independence.

When a shocking event upends their world, one woman seizes a split-second chance to change everything and follow her sister down a different life path. It’s a spontaneous choice, but there’s no going back. How will she deal with the fallout when covering up one untruth means lying to everyone—about everything?

One thing is clear: both twins have secrets, and both just want to be happy. But what price will they pay to live the life they’ve always wanted?

Revised edition: This edition of A Life Worth Living includes editorial revisions.

369 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 16, 2018

947 people are currently reading
2862 people want to read

About the author

Louise Guy

33 books49 followers
Louise Guy, bestselling author of six novels, blends family and friendship themes with unique twists and intrigue. Her characters captivate readers, drawing them deeply into their compelling stories and struggles. Previously published by Lake Union, she lives in Australia. Her latest book My Sister's Baby is published in 2024.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,488 (43%)
4 stars
1,134 (33%)
3 stars
588 (17%)
2 stars
148 (4%)
1 star
58 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 153 reviews
Profile Image for Brenda.
5,074 reviews3,012 followers
October 14, 2020
Leah was excited about the upcoming anniversary dinner she had planned with her boyfriend of six years, Grant. She expected a proposal but was shattered when the opposite happened. He left her with no explanation whatsoever. Six years of her life wasted – at least she had Lewis, her devoted and adorable cat. Leah’s identical twin sister Eve had a wonderful husband, Sean and twin daughters, seven-year-olds Ava and Harriet. But she was the complete opposite to Leah, not happy with her life, strict with her children, snappy with Sean and spending more and more time on her career.

The night Leah and Eve drove from the city to the Dandenong Ranges for Eve’s best friend’s 40th birthday party was the night everything changed. A chance decision – wanting to do the right thing – saw life’s journey alter dramatically. Secrets would build, mistakes would be made, dreams would be shattered. Was there any going back from that unplanned and impulsive choice?

A Life Worth Living by Aussie author Louise Guy was spectacular! This is only my second by this author, but I’ll be looking at her back titles now! Well-written characters, from the not-so-nice Eve to the compassionate and caring Leah; plus Eve and Leah’s parents as well as Sean and the twins – in other words, most of the cast 😊 I absolutely had no idea what the outcome could possibly be and have to say I was satisfied with the ending. Highly recommended.

With thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my digital ARC to read in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Carolyn.
2,747 reviews747 followers
November 1, 2020
Leah and Eve are identical twins. Identical in looks that is, but not in personality. Leah is a journalist, frustrated at being stuck with reporting on real estate. A kind and caring person, she adores Eve's seven year old twin girls and longs for children of her own, but unfortunately a long term relationship she thought would lead to marriage has just ended. Eve, although married with children, is a committed career woman, putting her job as a real estate agent before her family. Where Eve is dressed in high fashion and immaculate make-up, Leah is more homely in comfortable clothes and a touch of lipstick.

When a situation arises which gives Leah the chance to change her life forever, she leaps at it but without considering the lies she will have to tell and the moral dilemmas that will arise from her decision. This is an interesting and well written family drama with carefully crafted characters, including Eve's delightful twin daughters. The ethical issues that arise from Leah's decision and the effects they have on her friends and family are carefully examined and make for a provoking and enjoyable read.

With thanks to Amazon Publishing and Netgalley for a digital copy to read
Profile Image for Amanda - Mrs B's Book Reviews.
2,230 reviews334 followers
February 10, 2019
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
4.5 stars
Louise Guy first burst my reading bubble in mid 2017 when I read her first contemporary adult fiction novel, Everyday Lies. I have since read and highly rated her second novel, Fortunate Friends. A Life Worth Living is Guy’s third and latest novel. It is an intense and absolutely captivating novel that follows the lives of identical twins pitted against the odds when a terrible accident occurs. A Life Worth Living is about honour, unconditional love, sacrifice, secrets, lies and hope.

A Life Worth Living looks at the very contrasted lives of identical twins, Leah and Eve. Although they may look the same, Leah and Eve have very different personality traits and they lead polarising lives. Leah, a journalist, has been in a comfortable long-term relationship for years now. She hopes her boyfriend Grant will propose soon. Leah adores her cat Lewis and is the perfect Aunty to her twin nieces, Ava and Harry. All that is missing from Leah’s life now she is at the top of her career is marriage and a family of her own. Leah’s twin sister Eve has a marriage, house and two kids. She also enjoys the perks of her lucrative position in real estate. But lately Eve has been unhappy with her home life. Eve and her husband are estranged, they have been sleeping in separate rooms and recently Eve has formed a close relationship with one of her male clients. On the way to a party, Leah and Eve are involved in a life shattering accident. Spur of the moment decisions are made, which has a direct impact on the future of Eve and Leah’s loved ones. The bearing of this decision will weigh heavily on one sister, as the past, present and future all collides.

There are so many questions of morality and family obligations tied up to this latest novel from Louise Guy. It sure is a minefield of secrets, lies and moral dilemmas! I am not a twin and I also do not have a sister, so I found the situation posed in A Life Worth Living completely unknown territory! Despite this, I was able to put myself very easily in the shoes of the main protagonist of this novel. Louise Guy has carefully constructed a set of characters that anyone can relate to. She also sets up a scenario that we just can’t help but attempt to unpack.

I loved the modern Australian suburban setting of A Life Worth Living. Although I live on the other side of Australia, I could very easily see the Melbourne based locale of this novel easily transferred over to my own suburbs of WA. Guy has recreated a setting whereby we can see a ourselves and our homes mirrored in the location and experiences of the characters from A Life Worth Living. The strong setting presence helps to classify A Life Worth Living as a true ‘life lit’ novel.

Louise Guy is an author with many strengths, but I do feel the area in which she truly shines is in her characterisation. Guy devotes plenty of time in the early stages of her book in helping us to see the strengths and the flaws of her leads. I got a very good indication of which twin I was able to relate to over the other, thanks to the thorough exploration of the differences between the sisters. We come to understand their strengths, weaknesses, likes and dislikes. Each was crafted to perfection thanks to the expertise of Louise Guy. Guy’s ability to portray her characters with such conviction also extends to her secondary cast. From the parents of the twins, to Eve’s children, husband, partners, lovers and friends, each is so clearly marked out. I found myself comparing these characters to people I know.

The situation faced by one of the sisters, her decision and the fallout from this choice forms the crux of A Life Worth Living. I won’t delve too much into the scenario itself as I would hate to spoil this aspect for potential readers. What I will say is that Louise Guy treats the situation with insight, sensitivity and authenticity. She draws out the emotions and typical responses to a situation of this nature. As a result, the storyline is both gut wrenching – but very realistic.

The twin dynamic is played out well in A Life Worth Living. The two main characters are twins. Eve also has twin daughters. I dare say Guy has worked hard to build in some extra knowledge about twins. She captures this family dynamic extremely well. I always crave more about sisterly relationships and Louise Guy filled this void perfectly with her new book. I’m just glad I will never have to face the situation the sisters face in this novel, gosh it was hard!

With such a complex moral dilemma at the heart of this novel, I wasn’t sure where Guy was going to take her book direction wise. Each turn of the page delivered a new surprise, or twist to the escalating situation. This aspect definitely kept the pages turning for me. I think readers will be more than satisfied with the final turn of events, I’m not entirely sure it could have gone in another direction.

Rich in feeling, contemplative, encompassing an array of complex emotions and family dynamics, A Life Worth Living is a book you should invest your time in reading.

*With thanks to the author, Louise Guy, for providing me with a copy of this novel, in exchange for an honest review.

A Life Worth Living is book #16 of the 2019 Australian Women Writers Challenge
Profile Image for Akona.
226 reviews27 followers
November 14, 2021
Leah and Eve are identical twins— and that’s where the similarities end. They each envy the other for their life circumstances. Eve is a hard nosed working mum of her own set of twins. She and her husband, Sean have a strained marriage. Leah is newly single, having been unceremoniously dumped by her boyfriend of six years on the night she thought he’d propose. A life altering event forced Leah and Eve into an unusual situation. One which they may never come back from.

I enjoyed Everyday Lies by Louise Guy for her writing style, interesting premises and characters. A Life Worth Living was no different. It requires some suspension of disbelief for one to enjoy the story, but it’s well worth it.

Witnessing a highly consequential decision being made and having my jaw quite literally drop, I knew I was in a compelling story. Add that to the tension of knowing that a whole lot of things were eventually going to come undone. Curiosity as to how it was going to play out made it difficult to put this book down.

I enjoyed the unfolding of this unusual story and how well it was wrapped up. Such a pity it had to come to an end.
4.5 ⭐️ rounded up.
Profile Image for Brooke - Brooke's Reading Life.
902 reviews179 followers
June 4, 2019
*www.onewomansbbr.wordpress.com
*www.facebook.com/onewomansbbr

A Life Worth Living by Louise Guy. (2018).

Leah and Eve are identical twins with completely different lives and personalities. Leah is a caring, compassionate journalist who would do anything for those she loves including Eve's twin daughters. Eve is a real estate agent struggling with her family life which has led to her having an affair. Both sisters envy each other's lives. When a life-altering event happens, one sister will make a split-second decision that will change everything...

This is a very tricky book to review without revealing any spoilers, but I'm going to give it my best shot haha.
I liked Leah; while I wouldn't have done some of the things she did, I think she had a lot of love in her heart and good intentions. On the other hand, I did not like Eve. I really found her to be a very selfish woman and I didn't warm to her at all. Eve's twin daughters were gorgeous and stole the pages they were included in. This book has a very fascinating concept at its heart. It's hard for me to put it into words because I struggled with the concept itself in that I found it quite odd that it would happen at all, BUT it was a great concept to escape into and I enjoyed the book overall. I realise that may sound a bit confusing haha. I would certainly say that the plot is thought-provoking - I've mentioned this book to a few people already because of the intriguing nature of the narrative. I would recommend this book for those looking for a women's fiction/family drama novel that's a bit different and one you won't forget about.
Profile Image for Heidi.
1,239 reviews232 followers
November 29, 2020
The special bond between identical twins combined with tragedy and family secrets certainly made for an intriguing mix in Louise Guy’s new novel A LIFE WORTH LIVING. The book caught my attention early when an unforseen event upended the twins’ lives – I am very careful here not to give any spoilers!

I enjoyed reading about the difference in personality between Eve and Leah, and their vastly different life choices, which influenced much of what came next. Even though the sisters were a little bit too opposite at times, almost to the point of caricature, the story kept my attention and I wanted to find out how the situation would unravel. My main issue here was with pacing, since not much happened after the initial earth-shattering event, and the trapped-in-a-corner situation of one of the twins could have been used to create more tension and drama to bring the focus back on the crazy position her choices had put her in. I also would have loved a bit more insight into how the twins’ overcame their difference in personalities in the past and had arrived at this particular point in time because some of their actions didn’t fully gel with me for that very reason.

Altogether a pleasant and mildly intriguing family drama that made a nice change from my faced paced thrillers.

Thank you to Netgalley and Amazon Publishing UK for the free electronic copy of this novel and for giving me the opportunity to provide an honest review.

*blog* *facebook* *instagram*


Profile Image for anusha.
234 reviews4 followers
September 18, 2020
This was a new author to me plus the book is contemporary fiction which I'm not particularly drawn towards in general. Which makes me wonder why I picked it in the first please. Beats me. Although the review is totally unbiased, assuring you on that.

Eve and Leah are identical twins—but they're polar opposites. While Leah just had a bad breakup, Eve is cheating on her husband. Leah wishes to be as happy as her sister, have a loving husband and a family of her own, little does she know about Eve's imperfect life that only looks good from outside.

While I thought this will be just another story of twins and their jealousy, the book hits with a plot twist around 20% in. And tbh, I was actually surprised. Anything discussed about the book ahead to the twist will be a spoiler so I'll refrain.

The story was good and well written although I rolled my eyes in more events than one. A few parts of the story was not easily believable. The characters were meh, didn't really care for them. The only character I liked was Eve's husband. His character was practical, relatable and realistic.

Overall, I do not see myself picking this book up for a re-read but if you're looking for something light hearted you may check it out.
Profile Image for Susan.
1,027 reviews19 followers
March 28, 2023
Great premise but lots of plot holes. The pacing was erratic, it dragged, then it sped up, then long lulls, etc. A rushed ending. Could have been better altho I did keep turning pages :)
Profile Image for Nicola Marsh.
Author 414 books1,442 followers
Read
November 15, 2020
Eve and Leah are identical twins.
Eve is superficial and glamorous, with the perfect husband in Sean and gorgeous 7 year old twins.
Leah is sweet but at 35, something is missing in her life.

I can't say much without giving away the plot but I picked the twist early on but it didn't diminish my enjoyment one bit, as I had to keep turning pages to see how the story panned out.
A definite page turner!
Profile Image for Kim.
2,722 reviews13 followers
December 24, 2025
Setting: Melbourne, Australia; modern day.
Eve and Leah are identical twins but their lives are very different: Leah is a struggling journalist who envies Eve's seemingly-perfect life with husband, twin daughters and career in real estate - little realising that Eve admires Leah's independence.
But then a shocking incident affects the twins, giving one the opportunity to fulfil her dream of living her sister's life - even if this means lying to everyone....
I found this to be a quite intriguing book and one which I thoroughly enjoyed. Great characters, setting and storyline - 8/10.
Profile Image for Janine.
729 reviews61 followers
November 11, 2018
Oh my goodness, Louise Guy just keeps producing novels that are brilliant. This one is a real page turner! Identical twin sisters Eve and Leah are close but lead very different lives. Eve is a very high achiever in life and work and despite having a wonderful husband and twin girls herself is never satisfied and is determined to live life to the fullest. Leah is much more conservative and just wants marriage and children and to be happy. One fateful night, an accident changes everything for both women and life will never be the same again. Is living a lie worth it? And what becomes of those you love that are left behind, should you continue with the lie or sacrifice everything that you want even though its all wrong.

Louise's writing is wonderful, she creates realistic characters and puts them in situations that could be possible. Even her minor characters are so realistic that you imagine them as someone you may know. The story is set in Melbourne, and coming from Melbourne I could imagine the suburbs and streets that are featured in the book.

I felt so much for the two little twin girls in the story and the way they were treated by their mother, but I was happy that a fluffy cat made up for the hurt they had suffered. This is a thought provoking novel and begs the question - would you do the same if you were in that situation?

This book would stand up against any of the best sellers out there at the moment and deserves recognition far beyond - Louise, you are a talented author and I cannot wait to read all your future novels.
Profile Image for Jennifer (JC-S).
3,533 reviews285 followers
October 30, 2020
‘Identical twins, two very different women.’

Leah and Eve are identical twins, living in Melbourne. Leah has been in a relationship with Grant for six years: they are about to have a celebratory anniversary dinner, and Leah is expecting a proposal. But Grant breaks off their relationship without explanation. Leah is devastated. And her job is not going so well either.

Eve is married to Sean and has identical twin daughters: Harriet and Ava. But Eve is dissatisfied. She is strict with her daughters, distant from Sean, and spending less and less time with her family.
Eve convinces Leah to attend her best friend’s 40th birthday party in the Dandenong Ranges. It is a costume party, and the two of them are identically dressed. But neither of them will make it to the party, and lives will be changed forever.

A spur of the moment decision leads to secrets. And secrets have a way of snowballing and damaging those they are intended to protect.

There are a couple of improbable twists in this novel, but I became some engrossed in the story I really did not care. The main characters are well developed, and I kept reading wanting to know how it would end. I finished the novel satisfied.

This is the first novel I have read by Ms Guy. I will add her others to my reading list.

Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Profile Image for Leanne Lovegrove.
Author 17 books91 followers
November 19, 2018
I loved this latest release from Louise. It's a compelling tale with lots of twists and turns that keeps you turning the pages. It's beautifully written with well-drawn characters and I'd highly recommend it. Can't wait for the next one!
Profile Image for ReBecca.
813 reviews11 followers
December 27, 2023
"There’re times when the truth isn’t always the kindest thing to share with people." - Louise Guy

What I liked about A Life Worth Living:
The first half of the book was engaging and well-written. I felt emotionally invested in Leah's story and was sympathetic to her. The shocking plot twist in the middle was jaw-dropping and one of the major highlights of the first half. Louise Guy had me wanting to know what was going to happen next with her excellent writing and character development in the opening chapters. The first part of this book was spot on, keeping me gripped and engaged with the story.

What I disliked about A Life Worth Living:
The whole second half of the book was disappointing and a total bust. The storyline started to feel old, unbelievable, and far-fetched. It was hard to believe that none of the characters, including Leah and Eve's family and close friends, couldn't tell the identical twins apart. I also disagreed with some of Leah's choices and the reasoning behind her decisions later in the book. Her actions and motivations seemed erratic and absurd.

What I think would have made A Life Worth Living better:
The whole second half of the book should have been rewritten. It completely ruined the strong first half of the book and made the storyline unbelievable. I would have been okay with Louis Guy exploring the aftermath and emotional impact of the accident on the family, and how they coped after the death of Eve. The author could have focused on the grief process and family dynamics rather than taking the plot in such a far-fetched direction in the second half. Reworking the latter part of the book could have saved the story and preserved the emotional resonance of the first half.

Would I recommend A Life Worth Living by Louise Guy:
Sadly I would not recommend A Life Worth Living by Louis Guy. Despite the strong first half, the book ended up being a disappointment due to the poorly executed second part of the story. The plot became unbelievable and illogical after such a compelling start. While the beginning showed promise, the absurd shift later on makes this a book not worth picking up.

****

Identical twins Eve and Leah lead contrasting lives. A shocking event lets Leah spontaneously switch places with Eve, forcing her to lie to everyone. The split-second decision forever changes both sisters' paths. Both twins have secrets and seek happiness, but at what cost?
37 reviews
November 29, 2020
I wanted to like this book, I really did. The first half really hit home on a lot of levels, so after the ‘big incident’ I found it really hard to like the characters. I thought the entire thing was incredibly unbelievable and as far fetched as a story could be without dipping into fantasy. The hilarity of the absurd plot line was the only thing keeping me from tossing this book aside.
Profile Image for marlin1.
728 reviews23 followers
January 17, 2019
Another enjoyable and easy read from this author. I find her characters all relatable and the storylines easy to imagine. One more for me to read, then I’ll be waiting for her next one.
Profile Image for Poppy.
324 reviews13 followers
August 26, 2020
'A Life Worth Living' is my first read by Louise Guy and I certainly enjoyed it enough that it won't be my last. The story is about identical twins Leah and Eve who, despite looking the same and being the best of friends, couldn't be more different. Both are experiencing dissatisfaction with their lives, Leah due to her boyfriend of six years abruptly breaking up with her and Eve struggling to fulfil the role of wife and mother due to having no maternal feelings towards her children. The beginning of the novel builds up the reader's picture of these two lives before a horrific incident which shakes the twins and their family to the core. A decision is made (which I don't want to spoil) which changes everything and the reader is left wondering whether the truth will be revealed.

Guy has carefully plotted an intriguing story here. Don't expect a psychological thriller or anything twisty. It is pure family drama and Guy layers up the raw emotion as lives are altered and morals challenged. I particularly enjoyed the developing family dynamics with Eve's twin daughters and their childish excitement about the world, continually demonstrating their capacity to cope with grief and disruption. All in all, this was an emotional yet ultimately uplifting read. 4 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher who provided an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Craig and Phil.
2,228 reviews130 followers
November 9, 2020

OMG! I’m still flabbergasted at how brilliant this book is.
I just can’t see my reading world without a Louise Guy book to devour in it.
Louise is a intelligent writer and a genius storyteller and a must read for everyone.
Leah and Eve are identical twins and growing up no one could tell them apart.
But that’s the only thing they have in common because they are completely opposite.
Eve has the amazing husband, the twin daughters, the perfect job and a wardrobe to die for.
Leah has a great job, independence and a life of carefree.
They both envy the other and they both have secrets.
When a disastrous incident happens, one twin makes a split second decision that changes everything.
It’s riveting, compelling and spellbinding and impossible to put down.
A plethora of emotions and family dynamics, rich in detail and a plot that’s imaginative, original and downright impressive.
Complex characters that rise from the pages and a setting of busy, urban inner city Melbourne.
Cleverly and masterfully written and a book that left me in awe and extremely elated.
Another WOW read from the domestic drama goddess who has fast become one of my favourite writers.
A guaranteed page turner.

Profile Image for Kristen Pate.
81 reviews
May 7, 2023
Really enjoyed this one! I don’t want to give anything away but it was a very interesting concept and I liked the characters. I also liked the way everything was wrapped up in the end though it did seem a tad rushed.

Hard to summarize without spoiling some of the surprises but basically these twin sisters have an accident and have to deal with some interesting choices in the aftermath. Nice, quick read.
Profile Image for Maggie.
Author 55 books145 followers
October 24, 2018
Another gem from Louise Guy. Ms Guy doesn’t disappoint with this, her third novel. Twins Leah and Eve seem to be living the wrong lives. When a shocking event sends their lives into freefall, can one decision change things forwever? This is a compelling read which I highly recommend.
Profile Image for Natalie.
452 reviews3 followers
October 2, 2020
Thanks to #NetGalley for the ARC! This book comes out October 15th.

Starting off, I really wanted to read this because of the synopsis. It sounded like a great mystery read for October, you know the vibes. Twin sisters envying each other’s lives when a tragedy suddenly happens...
But it’s not that at all 😅 it’s more general fiction and you’d have to suspend your belief to most things happening especially after the first 100 pages. The rest of the book felt like an actual rollercoaster where way too much unbelievable things were happening. None of the stuff that happened would slide in real life. It just felt like the characters weren’t fully present.

The characters come off quite robotic and empty so I was never able to connect with them. I also found it hard to feel the grief that was being portrayed. There are way too many details included that just take you out of the experience, personally, but maybe others would enjoy. There are many 4 and 5 star ratings so this was just a miss for me.

#alifeworthliving
Profile Image for Laura.
532 reviews36 followers
June 26, 2023
I love a good chick lit storyline, as there's nothing that helps me unwind more than an easy, stress-free read. The synopsis for this book sounded fairly mysterious, with twins Eve and Leah having quite different lies and both having secrets, and a split second decision allows them to achieve the lives they've always wanted. Now, that split second decision involving one twin trying to pass herself off as the dead twin, is where the book gets completed ruined. Which parent, husband, or good friend, would truly not be able to tell the difference between two identical twins. The idea that someone would get away with this is frankly absurd, and that element of the story alone means you need to suspend disbelief far too much for this to be a genuine work of fiction; it definitely veers more towards the fantastical. It's hard to enjoy a book when you find yourself scoffing at the outlandishness of the plot. For that reason I would not recommend it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Kelly.
225 reviews2 followers
October 10, 2021
This book is an easy read and almost addictive, but more and more I got a sick feeling, there is so much mother shaming of Eve, for wanting her career, for not breastfeeding, for not loving motherhood, for taking on a nanny, and her husband getting away with being a good father by spending time with his kids on weekends and being the ‘fun one’, without an acknowledgement of her identity as a woman beyond motherhood, particularly when compared to the all-giving Aunty who takes her place. This story relies upon the same old cultural stereotypes of what a mother and wife should be, how they should behave, which does a disservice to women and girls who read these types of books and absorb the messages of femininity and subordination to motherhood that women are meant to represent.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Melanie.
485 reviews5 followers
January 9, 2021
They had me until what Leah does after the accident. I really thought coming into the story that the twins would somehow agree to switch lives, not that one of them DIES and the other assumes their identity. Eve was such an obviously bad wife, mother, and all around person that it astounded me that Leah didn’t seem to realize it about her own sister. And it astounds me even more the absolute bullshit way Leah got out of her lies and that ANYONE believed it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for JLR.
254 reviews
November 18, 2020
Ridiculous premise, unlikeable characters (for the most part), and a predictable yet preposterous ending.

They should write a sequel about how Eve’s daughters are doing 10 years into the future having been raised by this pack of lunatics.
Profile Image for Michael Damen.
297 reviews3 followers
August 18, 2025
This was my first novel by Louise Guy and even though I had some issues with it, I couldn’t put it down (I actually skipped work to keep reading it). And I cried constantly. I felt very manipulated but, I have to admit, I was effectively manipulated. Normally, I don’t like novels that focus on cheaters unless they are hit with a good dose of karma, and this novel featured at least 5 people who had either cheated or knowingly had an affair with a cheater. Because of that, and some dim-witted behavior, implausible scenarios, and an ending that was intended to be “honest” but was, nevertheless, still quite “dishonest”, I’m only giving this 4 stars instead of 5. But it had me riveted.

The novel is set in Brighton, Australia (just south of Melbourne) and tells the story of Leah Donaldson and Eve West, two beautiful 35 year-old identical twins who look the same, but have very different personalities.

Leah is a struggling journalist with a “sexist, nasty little pig” for a boss who just got dumped by her boyfriend Grant after 6 years. And she didn’t see it coming. But she’s caring, compassionate and loves her parents and nieces and visits them often. She loves her cat, doesn’t care about fashion and likes sugar in her coffee and a good dessert. Her best friend Jackie is married with two kids. So is her sister Eve. They both have the life Leah has always wanted but now she feels like she wasted 6 years of the prime of her life on her cheating ex.

Eve seems to have the perfect life. Leah actually went out on a date with Eve’s husband Sean 15 years earlier, but Eve took him away from her mid-date (that scene was cringey and left me disliking both Eve and Sean). But Sean ended up being a good loyal husband and a devoted father to their twin 7 year-old daughters Ava and Harriet (although, as a lawyer, he worked some crazy hours). Eve hated cats, loved fashion, and banned sugar at home. Unlike Leah’s, Eve’s career as a real estate agent was thriving. But it came at the expense of time with her family (they hired a 23 year-old nanny who became a surrogate mother to the kids).

Leah yearned for motherhood but Eve resented being a mother and was distant from her own children who adored their “Aunt Lee Lee.” Leah was devastated that the man she thought she would marry had cheated on her while Eve, unbeknownst to Leah, was cheating on her husband.

Eve envied Leah’s freedom and Leah envied Eve’s family.

Then, there’s a truly horrific and graphically described incident that changes everything. An insane decision is made that has dramatic consequences. The novel explores how that decision affects the woman who makes that decision and everyone around her. The author does an impressive job of making that wildly implausible and irrational decision seem plausible and rational.

I expected everything to unravel but, at one point, there is a discussion that I thought portended a different ending than the actual ending:

“Do you think people should always be honest, Dad?’Is it always for the best?”
“He seemed to think about it for a moment, then shook his head. ‘Definitely not.’”
“She couldn’t help but laugh. ‘I was sure you’d say they should.’”
“Her father shook his head. ‘I like to say I live an honest life, but there’re times when the truth isn’t always the kindest thing to share with people. I don’t condone telling lies for self-advancement or anything of that sort, but I do condone lying if it is done to protect people and basically for the right reasons.’”

This was a captivating novel with a somewhat soapy premise that explored questions of morality, family obligations and the extent to which one can or should make decisions that impact other lives. I thought the novel was very effective in conveying family dynamics and, with the glaring exception of Grant (who was depicted as little more than a cartoon villain), realistic in giving the reader a look inside the mind of a cheater.

One of the little things about Leah’s relationship with Grant that bothered me was the fact that he only 2 boxes to pick up after being with Leah for 6 years and, presumably, living together for some portion of that.

This was a bit of jaw dropper: “For all her sister’s faults, deep down, when it came to Leah, her loyalty was unwavering. She’d seen it first hand when they were four and Leah was being teased by an older, nasty boy at kindergarten.” Granted, she did say “when it came to Leah” but still…

Leah was unrealistically dim witted about the possibility of Eve having an affair and almost willfully blind about her sister and how she lived her life. She reminded me of the lyrics in Bob Dylan’s “Idiot Wind” when he says “you’re an idiot babe it’s a wonder that you still know how to breathe.”

But there many heartwarming moments like this:

“Sean was lying on his back, arms and legs in the air with one of the twins balanced on them. He was pressing his arms up and down as if doing reverse push-ups. Their other daughter stood next to them, squealing with delight. ‘My turn, my turn,’ she shrieked.”

But the most gut wrenching moment was when this line was uttered:

“Promise me…”

Ooof.
Profile Image for Georgina.
345 reviews11 followers
August 29, 2020
This is a tricky one to review. I really wanted to love it, and the idea at the heart of the book was certainly unique and interesting enough to capture my attention initially. Unfortunately, the pacing of the book faltered as it entered its second half, to the point where I struggled to finish it.

It's a real shame, as initially I was really enjoying this book - I was intrigued by the main characters and what happened after the accident (hard to say more without spoilers!) and I always enjoy books about twins, so initially I was a bit fan. It's also more of a family drama than a thriller, which is something I appreciated as I felt it was far better suited to this genre.

However, as I said my interest waned towards the second half of the book, and I think there just wasn't enough happening plot wise to justify the rather long book length. I think my main issue is that there was so much potential and room for the author to further develop the plot further, but instead the focus was very narrow, which combined with a slow pace limited my ability to really enjoy and engage with the book.

All in all, not really my cup of tea. However, the writing the decent enough that I would try the author again in the future.

2.5 stars rounded up to 3.

Disclaimer - I was fortunate enough to receive an advance reading copy of this book from the publisher in conjunction with NetGalley. This has not affected my review in any way, and all opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Joanna | bamabookgal.
133 reviews39 followers
October 9, 2020
Thank you to Net Galley for gifting me an eARC of A Life Worth Living in exchange for an honest review!

Eve and Leah are identical twins—but beyond that, they’re polar opposites. Struggling journalist Leah envies Eve’s seemingly perfect life—the loyal husband, the beautiful twin daughters, the stellar career—little knowing that what Eve longs for most is Leah’s independence.

When a shocking event upends their world, one woman seizes a split-second chance to change everything and follow her sister down a different life path. It’s a spontaneous choice, but there’s no going back. How will she deal with the fallout when covering up one untruth means lying to everyone—about everything?

I went into this one blindly. I didn't know exactly what it was about, but once getting started I was intrigued by the overall concept that is explored in this book. This novel is very thought provoking. The entire time I was reading it I kept questioning if and how someone could really do this? Not going to spoil what I'm talking about, if interested you should definitely check this one out. Just know that a big twist happens, and leads the story in a different direction than I originally anticipated. This ultimately made me want to keep reading. Towards the middle half though, it did feel a little repetitive. I would have liked for there to have been more given to the ending so it didn't seem as rushed and could better close out this story.
Profile Image for Jennifer (JC-S).
3,533 reviews285 followers
October 30, 2020
‘Identical twins, two very different women.’

Leah and Eve are identical twins, living in Melbourne. Leah has been in a relationship with Grant for six years: they are about to have a celebratory anniversary dinner, and Leah is expecting a proposal. But Grant breaks off their relationship without explanation. Leah is devastated. And her job is not going so well either.

Eve is married to Sean and has identical twin daughters: Harriet and Ava. But Eve is dissatisfied. She is strict with her daughters, distant from Sean, and spending less and less time with her family.
Eve convinces Leah to attend her best friend’s 40th birthday party in the Dandenong Ranges. It is a costume party, and the two of them are identically dressed. But neither of them will make it to the party, and lives will be changed forever.

A spur of the moment decision leads to secrets. And secrets have a way of snowballing and damaging those they are intended to protect.

There are a couple of improbable twists in this novel, but I became some engrossed in the story I really did not care. The main characters are well developed, and I kept reading wanting to know how it would end. I finished the novel satisfied.

This is the first novel I have read by Ms Guy. I will add her others to my reading list.

Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith
Displaying 1 - 30 of 153 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.