What do you think?
Rate this book
Kindred #1
Mountain Laurel
North Carolina, 1793
Ian Cameron, a Boston cabinetmaker turned frontier trapper, has come to Mountain Laurel hoping to remake himself yet again--into his planter uncle's heir. No matter how uneasily the role of slave owner rests upon his shoulders. Then he meets Seona--beautiful, artistic, and enslaved to his kin.
Seona has a secret: she's been drawing for years, ever since that day she picked up a broken slate to sketch a portrait. When Ian catches her at it, he offers her opportunity to let her talent flourish, still secretly, in his cabinetmaking shop. Taking a frightening leap of faith, Seona puts her trust in Ian. A trust that leads to a deeper, more complicated bond.
As fascination with Seona turns to love, Ian can no longer be the man others have wished him to be. Though his own heart might prove just as untrustworthy a guide, he cannot simply walk away from those his kin enslaves. With more lives than his and Seona's in the balance, the path Ian chooses now will set the course for generations of Camerons to come.
A story of choice and consequence, of bondage and freedom, of faith and family.
Ian Cameron, a Boston cabinetmaker turned frontier trapper, has come to Mountain Laurel hoping to remake himself yet again--into his planter uncle's heir. No matter how uneasily the role of slave owner rests upon his shoulders. Then he meets Seona--beautiful, artistic, and enslaved to his kin.
Seona has a secret: she's been drawing for years, ever since that day she picked up a broken slate to sketch a portrait. When Ian catches her at it, he offers her opportunity to let her talent flourish, still secretly, in his cabinetmaking shop. Taking a frightening leap of faith, Seona puts her trust in Ian. A trust that leads to a deeper, more complicated bond.
As fascination with Seona turns to love, Ian can no longer be the man others have wished him to be. Though his own heart might prove just as untrustworthy a guide, he cannot simply walk away from those his kin enslaves. With more lives than his and Seona's in the balance, the path Ian chooses now will set the course for generations of Camerons to come.
A story of choice and consequence, of bondage and freedom, of faith and family.
464 pages, Hardcover
First published September 1, 2020
110 people are currently reading
1060 people want to read
About the author
Lori Benton
18 books984 followersLori Benton was born and raised east of the Appalachian Mountains, surrounded by early American and family history going back to the 1600s. Her novels transport readers to the 18th century, where she brings to life the Colonial and early Federal periods of American history, creating a melting pot of characters drawn from both sides of a turbulent and shifting frontier, brought together in the bonds of God's transforming grace.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 161 reviews
August 20, 2020
Started 2004, April 10
Finished 2019, December 31
Release date: 2020, September 1
Dates reflect how long this book took to research, write, wait for a publishing home, edit, and release.
[6/28/20] I want to share about Mountain Laurel's very long journey to publication, and my hope for this book. Although this will be my seventh published historical novel set during the 18th century, it's actually the first I wrote. Because I came to it largely ignorant of the time period (I couldn't have told you the year the Revolutionary War started), and for other reasons that had nothing to do with my woeful lack of knowledge of my own nation's history, it took me nearly five years to research and write Mountain Laurel (2004-2009). By the time I'd finished I felt as if I'd given myself a history degree.
That early research consisted of reading hundreds of books on topics ranging from 18th century life (what people wore, ate, lived in, did for work and play), the history of Colonial North America in general and North Carolina specifically... to more specialized topics like plantation economy, slave laws, the Underground Railroad, Eli Whitney’s cotton gin, the Dismal Swamp Canal, the Scottish Jacobite Rising, Scottish immigration to North Carolina, how to construct a dovetail joint, treat malaria, and fire a black powder rifle. I talked to an acquaintance who was stalked by a mountain lion, and to my own mother who picked the worms off tobacco plants when she was a little girl. I watched every documentary and YouTube video on the 18th century I could find, spent hundreds of hours Googling subjects and historical figures, and took a memorable road trip through western North Carolina, visiting the story’s setting.
Then I took a couple more years to whittle down a very overwritten manuscript which, after reading it, convinced my agent to sign me as a client. Then for nearly a decade we could not sell this book. We wondered why. We speculated. We set it aside. But we held onto our passion for the story. A little over a year ago we decided to give it one more try, and Tyndale made us an offer.
Now here's a thing about timing. Mine and God's. For years I thought Mountain Laurel would be my debut novel. Obviously God had other ideas. He chose it to be my seventh, and for it to reach readers in 2020. Until a few weeks ago I presumed it was because I would need to write five more novels before I finally wrote my sixth, The King's Mercy, which perfectly sets up Mountain Laurel (two characters in TKM (Alex and Jemma) visit the plantation, Mountain Laurel, some 50 years prior to the eponymous book’s setting). I still believe that was part of the delay in timing. But now I believe there's more to it.
In all my books you will find characters who have, willingly or not, crossed a line between cultures and changed because of this experience. Mountain Laurel might be the deepest I’ve ever gone with this theme of transformation via a deepening of empathy for those who are in some way different. How aware we are becoming of a need for such empathy in our own lives these days! My heart as a storyteller has always been to work myself under the skin and into the heart and mind of a life I haven’t lived, to feel the suffering of wounds I haven’t taken, to rejoice in triumphs I haven’t known. In other words, to stretch my human empathy as far as it will go across the pages of my novels. No matter if that character from whose point of view I’m telling the story is a Native American man, an African American child, or a white woman who sees the world through the lens of her 18th century upbringing. None of them is me. None of them think like me. Yet with each one I endeavor to see with their eyes, feel with their heart, and re-embrace the light and truth of the good news of Jesus dying on the cross in humanity's place through their specific set of needs, longings, and hopes. Each human being who hears His call and answers it reflects a facet of His nature that is unique and precious, and it's to our benefit to bend our empathy as far as it will go in understanding the heart of a brother or sister who looks different, speaks differently, or has had an upbringing unlike our own. The enrichment flows both ways and is eternal.
My awareness of this need expanded in the writing of Mountain Laurel, and is expanding still. My prayer is that yours is too, and that the journey you take when you read Mountain Laurel will be another small step toward that end. I stand back in some wonder at the timing of this book releasing this of all years. Be assured that, as with all my novels, healing and hope are woven through the sometimes unflinching rawness of these pages. I invite you on this journey of transformation with me and the characters, Ian Cameron and Seona. And more than ever before I wish you happy reading. ~Lori
Finished 2019, December 31
Release date: 2020, September 1
Dates reflect how long this book took to research, write, wait for a publishing home, edit, and release.
[6/28/20] I want to share about Mountain Laurel's very long journey to publication, and my hope for this book. Although this will be my seventh published historical novel set during the 18th century, it's actually the first I wrote. Because I came to it largely ignorant of the time period (I couldn't have told you the year the Revolutionary War started), and for other reasons that had nothing to do with my woeful lack of knowledge of my own nation's history, it took me nearly five years to research and write Mountain Laurel (2004-2009). By the time I'd finished I felt as if I'd given myself a history degree.
That early research consisted of reading hundreds of books on topics ranging from 18th century life (what people wore, ate, lived in, did for work and play), the history of Colonial North America in general and North Carolina specifically... to more specialized topics like plantation economy, slave laws, the Underground Railroad, Eli Whitney’s cotton gin, the Dismal Swamp Canal, the Scottish Jacobite Rising, Scottish immigration to North Carolina, how to construct a dovetail joint, treat malaria, and fire a black powder rifle. I talked to an acquaintance who was stalked by a mountain lion, and to my own mother who picked the worms off tobacco plants when she was a little girl. I watched every documentary and YouTube video on the 18th century I could find, spent hundreds of hours Googling subjects and historical figures, and took a memorable road trip through western North Carolina, visiting the story’s setting.
Then I took a couple more years to whittle down a very overwritten manuscript which, after reading it, convinced my agent to sign me as a client. Then for nearly a decade we could not sell this book. We wondered why. We speculated. We set it aside. But we held onto our passion for the story. A little over a year ago we decided to give it one more try, and Tyndale made us an offer.
Now here's a thing about timing. Mine and God's. For years I thought Mountain Laurel would be my debut novel. Obviously God had other ideas. He chose it to be my seventh, and for it to reach readers in 2020. Until a few weeks ago I presumed it was because I would need to write five more novels before I finally wrote my sixth, The King's Mercy, which perfectly sets up Mountain Laurel (two characters in TKM (Alex and Jemma) visit the plantation, Mountain Laurel, some 50 years prior to the eponymous book’s setting). I still believe that was part of the delay in timing. But now I believe there's more to it.
In all my books you will find characters who have, willingly or not, crossed a line between cultures and changed because of this experience. Mountain Laurel might be the deepest I’ve ever gone with this theme of transformation via a deepening of empathy for those who are in some way different. How aware we are becoming of a need for such empathy in our own lives these days! My heart as a storyteller has always been to work myself under the skin and into the heart and mind of a life I haven’t lived, to feel the suffering of wounds I haven’t taken, to rejoice in triumphs I haven’t known. In other words, to stretch my human empathy as far as it will go across the pages of my novels. No matter if that character from whose point of view I’m telling the story is a Native American man, an African American child, or a white woman who sees the world through the lens of her 18th century upbringing. None of them is me. None of them think like me. Yet with each one I endeavor to see with their eyes, feel with their heart, and re-embrace the light and truth of the good news of Jesus dying on the cross in humanity's place through their specific set of needs, longings, and hopes. Each human being who hears His call and answers it reflects a facet of His nature that is unique and precious, and it's to our benefit to bend our empathy as far as it will go in understanding the heart of a brother or sister who looks different, speaks differently, or has had an upbringing unlike our own. The enrichment flows both ways and is eternal.
My awareness of this need expanded in the writing of Mountain Laurel, and is expanding still. My prayer is that yours is too, and that the journey you take when you read Mountain Laurel will be another small step toward that end. I stand back in some wonder at the timing of this book releasing this of all years. Be assured that, as with all my novels, healing and hope are woven through the sometimes unflinching rawness of these pages. I invite you on this journey of transformation with me and the characters, Ian Cameron and Seona. And more than ever before I wish you happy reading. ~Lori
July 20, 2020
When you come across an author of this caliber, you rush to read every book they've written. I have been an admirer and vocal supporter of Lori Benton ever since reading The Wood's Edge (2015).
One thing that endears me to her is how she consistently pens sympathetic characters who have to stumble down the wrong path in order to find their way—The Way. Often times, as it was with Ian Cameron, self-reliance and fleshly desires lead to heartache and forced humility. The destruction left in the wake of Ian's choices frequently made me wonder how his world could ever be set right. As I read, I allowed myself to imagine each character's motives and actions in light of the times. This process was made possible by the author's skill blending relevant historical details with emotionally captivating scenes.
So far, I've only mentioned Ian but I should also mention Seona, the woman of mixed heritage who wins his affections as well as my two favorite secondary characters, Lily and Judith. I liked Seona from the start. In some ways she's naive, yet in others, she has experienced too much darkness for her age. Despite this, she possesses an indomitable spirit and effervescent hope. As for Lily and Judith, I caution readers not to mistake their meekness for weakness because underneath their calm demeanor beats the heart of resilient women with incredible faith.
The truth is we all long for stories about people who are flawed and fallen because we see ourselves in them and when they triumph we celebrate their victory. I continue to read Benton's works because I relish such stories. Once you read Mountain Laurel, you'll understand why I'm such a fan of this author and you'll join me in waiting for the conclusion of the Kindred duology. There is more of Ian and Seona's story that needs to be told!
I received this book from the publisher through the NetGalley review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
One thing that endears me to her is how she consistently pens sympathetic characters who have to stumble down the wrong path in order to find their way—The Way. Often times, as it was with Ian Cameron, self-reliance and fleshly desires lead to heartache and forced humility. The destruction left in the wake of Ian's choices frequently made me wonder how his world could ever be set right. As I read, I allowed myself to imagine each character's motives and actions in light of the times. This process was made possible by the author's skill blending relevant historical details with emotionally captivating scenes.
So far, I've only mentioned Ian but I should also mention Seona, the woman of mixed heritage who wins his affections as well as my two favorite secondary characters, Lily and Judith. I liked Seona from the start. In some ways she's naive, yet in others, she has experienced too much darkness for her age. Despite this, she possesses an indomitable spirit and effervescent hope. As for Lily and Judith, I caution readers not to mistake their meekness for weakness because underneath their calm demeanor beats the heart of resilient women with incredible faith.
The truth is we all long for stories about people who are flawed and fallen because we see ourselves in them and when they triumph we celebrate their victory. I continue to read Benton's works because I relish such stories. Once you read Mountain Laurel, you'll understand why I'm such a fan of this author and you'll join me in waiting for the conclusion of the Kindred duology. There is more of Ian and Seona's story that needs to be told!
I received this book from the publisher through the NetGalley review program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
November 9, 2020
It is 1793, and Ian Cameron has returned to Mountain Laurel, his uncle’s plantation in North Carolina, where he spent time as a boy. Now a grown man, he is being groomed as his uncle’s heir. When Ian sees Seona for the first time, he is immediately captivated by her green eyes and does not realize she is enslaved to his kin. When he learns of Seona’s hidden talent as an artist, he encourages it and finds ways for her to hide it from his cruel step-aunt, Lucinda. Lucinda does not believe slaves should read, write, or do anything to take time away from their chores. The story is told from the alternating viewpoints of Ian and Seona, who has hidden her art all her life. “Every slave has a secret. This one is mine.” As time progresses, Ian finds himself conflicted between his growing feelings for Seona, his loyalty to his family, and his responsibility to all those enslaved on the plantation.
This heart-rending book from Benton shows us all the horrors of slavery. In addition to the beatings, rapes, terror, and torture, it shows the true effects of taking away someone’s will and refusing to let them have any dreams or desires. It shows how some people of that time watched slaves being paraded down the road in chains, did nothing, and then went to church on Sunday. Lori Benton writes about this as if she were there, laying bare the pain of someone else owning your body and your soul. However, faith and the desire for redemption are also present, especially in the quiet faith of the slave Lily and the redemption Ian desperately seeks.
This is the first book in the Kindred series, and I cannot wait to see these characters return.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers via Historical Novels Review Magazine. My opinions are my own.
This heart-rending book from Benton shows us all the horrors of slavery. In addition to the beatings, rapes, terror, and torture, it shows the true effects of taking away someone’s will and refusing to let them have any dreams or desires. It shows how some people of that time watched slaves being paraded down the road in chains, did nothing, and then went to church on Sunday. Lori Benton writes about this as if she were there, laying bare the pain of someone else owning your body and your soul. However, faith and the desire for redemption are also present, especially in the quiet faith of the slave Lily and the redemption Ian desperately seeks.
This is the first book in the Kindred series, and I cannot wait to see these characters return.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers via Historical Novels Review Magazine. My opinions are my own.
July 25, 2024
I finally finished this beauty after three years on my shelves 😅. It was a very good and emotional read. There were times I didn't enjoy the character of Ian, but I could also see the growth he was going through and his journey back to the Lord. I really like Seona and I hope we get to see more of her in book 2.
June 30, 2020
Every year, there are two or three book releases I look forward to more than any other...and Lori Benton's books are ALWAYS on that list. She is one of my very, very, verrrrry favorite authors and I truly believe she is one of the most gifted storytellers writing today. I'm really not exaggerating when I say every one of her books has felt like a masterpiece to me. So needless to say, I was so ridiculously and excitedly impatient to read Mountain Laurel...and now that I have, I really don't know how to review it in any way that does it any kind of justice! But I'll try my best...
As always with Benton's books, the writing of this novel is exquisite and the historical detail is rich and vivid. Both Ian and Seona captured my heart so quickly. One of the things I loved about Ian in particular is what a perfect mix he is of noble intentions and, at times, flawed actions. I felt his moments of desperation so deeply as I read—as well as his joy and Seona's long-suffering hope. I felt so much! And to me, that's the very best sign of an amazing book—the feelings it evokes. The emotional layering in Mountain Laurel is superb.
I also loved the plot. It went places I absolutely did not expect and took twists and turns that kept me captivated page after page. It was both heart-rending and tender, and by the end I was caught in that wonderful sort of reader exhaustion and exhilaration that comes from having journeyed with the characters. The forbidden romance, the moments of desolate hardship, Seona's gentle strength and Ian's unending desire to make things right...all of it made for a story that swept me away entirely and completely. And woven throughout is a spiritual journey—especially on Ian's part—that stirred my soul in a way I was (and still am) thinking about weeks after reaching The End.
This is the first in a two-book series, so I'm thrilled to know the story will continue! And I've heard we might see a familiar and much-beloved face from a past Lori Benton book!! (Joseph Tames-His Horse!!!! 😍😍😍)
One last note: This story takes place during an especially harsh time in our country's history, which meant it wasn't necessarily easy to read at times. But I appreciated that the author didn't shy away from portraying the ugly realities of that time period, including slavery, but also that she didn't glorify or just lightly gloss over it. She handled it deftly and in a way that personally impacted me.
As always with Benton's books, the writing of this novel is exquisite and the historical detail is rich and vivid. Both Ian and Seona captured my heart so quickly. One of the things I loved about Ian in particular is what a perfect mix he is of noble intentions and, at times, flawed actions. I felt his moments of desperation so deeply as I read—as well as his joy and Seona's long-suffering hope. I felt so much! And to me, that's the very best sign of an amazing book—the feelings it evokes. The emotional layering in Mountain Laurel is superb.
I also loved the plot. It went places I absolutely did not expect and took twists and turns that kept me captivated page after page. It was both heart-rending and tender, and by the end I was caught in that wonderful sort of reader exhaustion and exhilaration that comes from having journeyed with the characters. The forbidden romance, the moments of desolate hardship, Seona's gentle strength and Ian's unending desire to make things right...all of it made for a story that swept me away entirely and completely. And woven throughout is a spiritual journey—especially on Ian's part—that stirred my soul in a way I was (and still am) thinking about weeks after reaching The End.
This is the first in a two-book series, so I'm thrilled to know the story will continue! And I've heard we might see a familiar and much-beloved face from a past Lori Benton book!! (Joseph Tames-His Horse!!!! 😍😍😍)
One last note: This story takes place during an especially harsh time in our country's history, which meant it wasn't necessarily easy to read at times. But I appreciated that the author didn't shy away from portraying the ugly realities of that time period, including slavery, but also that she didn't glorify or just lightly gloss over it. She handled it deftly and in a way that personally impacted me.
Read
October 5, 2020Wow. Lori Benton is an extremely talented author (one of the very best living today), but this book also proves how brave she is. The historical context of North Carolina in the 1790s is a rather painful one, but with unflinching detail, Lori has given us a story of slavery and redemption, bondage and freedom, of slow corruption and of spiritual transformation. I had a hard time rooting for the hero in this book because of his perspective and choices, but taken in the world in which he lived, it's easier to understand him. One of the most moving scenes in the novel for me came when he finally recognizes his brokenness and asks one of the slaves to tell him about his Jesus. Seona, as a heroine, comes across to me as reluctant for us to get to know her. This fits with her characterization as a slave who has been trained to hide true emotions and thoughts. This is not to say I didn't like Seona. I really did. She simply seems cautious about letting readers in for a while before she opens up. Flaws and all, I couldn't help but ache for these very real characters as I read their story. Being human means we make mistakes, and even the noblest of intentions can have unintended consequences. How we carry on after stumbling is still, always, up to us.
I can't wait for the next book to continue this family's story, and I really hope we get to know Judith better. She is stronger than she seems.
I can't wait for the next book to continue this family's story, and I really hope we get to know Judith better. She is stronger than she seems.
September 9, 2020
Lori Benton's writing is beautiful and it's clear she has researched the time period and setting. I am glad there will be a sequel (Shiloh) as there is a lot left to be sorted out.
November 4, 2020
I am impressed every time I read a book by this author.
Each new book I read by Lori Benton becomes my favorite by her and I think to myself she couldn't possibly top her last book but somehow she manages to do it.
The research she puts into each book is incredible and I was interested in reading more about her research in the author notes in the back of the book.
Mountain Laurel is a book written from the heart, it's the good,the bad and the ugly of the time period. While it may not always be pretty it resonates true to the time period. Just fantastic . I highly recommend Mountain Laurel.
Published September 1st 2020 by Tyndale House Publishers.
I was given a complimentary copy. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Each new book I read by Lori Benton becomes my favorite by her and I think to myself she couldn't possibly top her last book but somehow she manages to do it.
The research she puts into each book is incredible and I was interested in reading more about her research in the author notes in the back of the book.
Mountain Laurel is a book written from the heart, it's the good,the bad and the ugly of the time period. While it may not always be pretty it resonates true to the time period. Just fantastic . I highly recommend Mountain Laurel.
Published September 1st 2020 by Tyndale House Publishers.
I was given a complimentary copy. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
September 26, 2020
Mountain Laurel is the first book I've read by Lori Benton, although I've heard wonderful things about her previous books and have a couple on my TBR.
I didn't really have any expectations for Mountain Laurel. I started it curious to see what the story would bring...I feel like it was one that slowly sucks you in and takes you on a journey unlike any other.
The characters were deep and felt realistic; they made questionable choices and had some challenging moments. The ending left me slightly confused and I'm eager to read the next book to see what happens next.
All in all, Mountain Laurel was difficult to read in some ways and not always a happy read, but I really enjoyed it.
Note: this story does contain some content that I wasn't a fan of and I only recommend it to mature readers.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
I didn't really have any expectations for Mountain Laurel. I started it curious to see what the story would bring...I feel like it was one that slowly sucks you in and takes you on a journey unlike any other.
The characters were deep and felt realistic; they made questionable choices and had some challenging moments. The ending left me slightly confused and I'm eager to read the next book to see what happens next.
All in all, Mountain Laurel was difficult to read in some ways and not always a happy read, but I really enjoyed it.
Note: this story does contain some content that I wasn't a fan of and I only recommend it to mature readers.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
August 11, 2020
Lori Benton has penned an expertly crafted tale. I cherished every word and emotion as the magic of its prose whisked me away to frontier America. Benton does not shy away from the tough subjects of right and wrong, handling the issues of slavery and immorality with grace. Mostly, it chronicles the spiritual journey of Ian Cameron, as he comes to grasps with his role as his uncle's heir on Mountain Laurel.
Ms. Benton crafts characters who wound their way into my heart. With each page, I uncovered layers of truth, revealing grace and mercy throughout. I am so grateful that this is the first in a two book series, so that I can spend more time with characters that populated the pages of Mountain Laurel.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Ms. Benton crafts characters who wound their way into my heart. With each page, I uncovered layers of truth, revealing grace and mercy throughout. I am so grateful that this is the first in a two book series, so that I can spend more time with characters that populated the pages of Mountain Laurel.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
April 14, 2021
Whew, this was a rough one! Lori Benton is in my top three favorite authors, so I snapped up the audiobook in order to listen to it while I travel. I just finished it.
Shaking my head. What to say?
Was it a bad story? Certainly not!
Was the writing sub-par? Oh my, no!
Was the flow or plot difficult to follow? Meh, once in a while until she takes the reader down the road to background explanations.
Was it enjoyable? Hm... this is where I struggled.
I had a hard time setting this book down because I expected wonderful outcomes around every corner. But bad things seemed to happen...lots. What kind of sweet outcome could there be without coming off hokey?
Really bad choices were made by several main characters and I cringed when, of course, repercussions resulted. Other characters were just this side of evil, laying waste to unsuspecting innocents.
I wanted to shake a few main characters and show them the right way to do things. Then I thought of the many mistakes I’ve made because of wrong choices, and I settled in to see how Ms. Benton made things right. Thankfully our God has a way of getting our attention, and He offers reconciliation.
Was there an ending that made me sit back and sigh? Not really. But it was the right way to end this story.
Perhaps not my favorite book by this author, but it’s a matter of the feelings evoked while reading it, not a matter of her writing!
************ ************ ************
I do this a lot after I finish a review. I think about parts of the story I may have puzzled over during the reading. Here's the answer to one, but to find out why this puzzled me, you’ll have to read the book. 😁:
Corvids (Wikipedia)
Several members of the corvids or crow family, such as ravens, can mimic human speech. The best talking crows may be the ones found in captivity at zoos and wildlife centers.
Another thing I want to say. Be sure to check out Lori Benton's own review of this book on Goodreads. It’s terrific and helpful for me in understanding what I just finished.
Shaking my head. What to say?
Was it a bad story? Certainly not!
Was the writing sub-par? Oh my, no!
Was the flow or plot difficult to follow? Meh, once in a while until she takes the reader down the road to background explanations.
Was it enjoyable? Hm... this is where I struggled.
I had a hard time setting this book down because I expected wonderful outcomes around every corner. But bad things seemed to happen...lots. What kind of sweet outcome could there be without coming off hokey?
Really bad choices were made by several main characters and I cringed when, of course, repercussions resulted. Other characters were just this side of evil, laying waste to unsuspecting innocents.
I wanted to shake a few main characters and show them the right way to do things. Then I thought of the many mistakes I’ve made because of wrong choices, and I settled in to see how Ms. Benton made things right. Thankfully our God has a way of getting our attention, and He offers reconciliation.
Was there an ending that made me sit back and sigh? Not really. But it was the right way to end this story.
Perhaps not my favorite book by this author, but it’s a matter of the feelings evoked while reading it, not a matter of her writing!
************ ************ ************
I do this a lot after I finish a review. I think about parts of the story I may have puzzled over during the reading. Here's the answer to one, but to find out why this puzzled me, you’ll have to read the book. 😁:
Corvids (Wikipedia)
Several members of the corvids or crow family, such as ravens, can mimic human speech. The best talking crows may be the ones found in captivity at zoos and wildlife centers.
Another thing I want to say. Be sure to check out Lori Benton's own review of this book on Goodreads. It’s terrific and helpful for me in understanding what I just finished.
July 19, 2021
Forbidden love in the wilds of Appalachia.
Cabinetmaker Ian Cameron comes to Mountain Laurel in hopes of claiming a place as his uncle's heir, but that title comes with more than a few entanglements. Ian is a man struggling to make sense of where he stands after coming from a complicated past, and an uneasiness about becoming a slaveholder. This is a well crafted novel, with well-built, complex characters good and bad, and more than your average amount of heartache.
While I appreciated the well drawn characters and their well developed plights within the larger plot, the attention to detail and how the pieces fall, I can't honestly say that I enjoyed this book as it was a heart-rending read. There were times when I honestly didn't want to keep reading because of the direction that things seemed to be headed, but I am glad that I persevered. This book is a bittersweet one, filled with heartache, secrets, and forbidden love, and while we don't quite get a resolution in this volume it leaves the door open for a much richer conclusion when the duology is complete.
Overall, it is a bit of a mixed review from me, and I think that I will be able to form a more complete picture of how I feel about this book once I read the next one. This was a grittier read than the author's past books, but it fits the narrative of the story arc. But there is no doubt to the quality of this story, well written, with characters that had my heart breaking along with them. I liked how the events in this story force many of the characters to grow and confront their beliefs as they must reconcile their realities. A poignant and heartrending read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Cabinetmaker Ian Cameron comes to Mountain Laurel in hopes of claiming a place as his uncle's heir, but that title comes with more than a few entanglements. Ian is a man struggling to make sense of where he stands after coming from a complicated past, and an uneasiness about becoming a slaveholder. This is a well crafted novel, with well-built, complex characters good and bad, and more than your average amount of heartache.
While I appreciated the well drawn characters and their well developed plights within the larger plot, the attention to detail and how the pieces fall, I can't honestly say that I enjoyed this book as it was a heart-rending read. There were times when I honestly didn't want to keep reading because of the direction that things seemed to be headed, but I am glad that I persevered. This book is a bittersweet one, filled with heartache, secrets, and forbidden love, and while we don't quite get a resolution in this volume it leaves the door open for a much richer conclusion when the duology is complete.
Overall, it is a bit of a mixed review from me, and I think that I will be able to form a more complete picture of how I feel about this book once I read the next one. This was a grittier read than the author's past books, but it fits the narrative of the story arc. But there is no doubt to the quality of this story, well written, with characters that had my heart breaking along with them. I liked how the events in this story force many of the characters to grow and confront their beliefs as they must reconcile their realities. A poignant and heartrending read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
May 5, 2021
In the author's beautiful way of describing life and bringing history alive, I was swept into the beginnings of this story. Halfway through I thought I might give up, I felt like the story was going nowhere and the main hero was just annoying. But I told myself to hold back my judgement and watch how the rest of the story progressed. While I didn't love the story and didn't find it an extremely memorable story, I found the the beauty of grace and redemption to once more stand strong like it did in her other books. I appreciated the truth of freedom in Christ being presented.
This book is not a favorite, but the historical accuracy is great and I know many others will love this story. Seona and Ian's story will continue in the next book.
{plenty of sexual desires in this book, almost too much to read a couple of scenes. Subjects matters dealing with wedlock, slavery, and freedom }
This book is not a favorite, but the historical accuracy is great and I know many others will love this story. Seona and Ian's story will continue in the next book.
{plenty of sexual desires in this book, almost too much to read a couple of scenes. Subjects matters dealing with wedlock, slavery, and freedom }
July 15, 2020
From Endorsement:
With a masterful pen, Lori Benton creates a poignant story that will have readers flipping pages late into the night. Filled with historical authenticity, heart-touching romance, and inconceivable circumstances, this book is a celebration of freedom—both the physical and the eternal. I finished Mountain Laurel with both a sigh of satisfaction and a longing of expectation for what comes next for these characters. I highly recommend this novel!
With a masterful pen, Lori Benton creates a poignant story that will have readers flipping pages late into the night. Filled with historical authenticity, heart-touching romance, and inconceivable circumstances, this book is a celebration of freedom—both the physical and the eternal. I finished Mountain Laurel with both a sigh of satisfaction and a longing of expectation for what comes next for these characters. I highly recommend this novel!
June 14, 2020
No Spoilers!
Author Lori Benton has written an emotive, literary masterpiece as hauntingly beautiful as it is disturbing—the forbidden romance between its pages timeless, all consuming, and powerfully passionate—despite dire, insurmountable circumstances.
Ian Cameron is a kind, compassionate man, easy on the eyes, but uneasy with the role of slave owner—especially when he meets the beautiful, light-skinned, green-eyed Seona. I loved her grit, quiet strength, and compliant spirit, and I literally cried at the unfairness and cruelty she endured because of her pleasing looks and station in life. As a matter of fact, all the slaves became like family to me—Lily, Seona's mother, clothed with dignity & strength, Malcolm, with a tender heart for the Lord, simple-minded Ally, and Naomi, who could sure cook some good vittles! And ladies...you'll swoon over the tender love story between the romantic Ian and lovely Seona!
As I was left bereft and staring into space with tears in my eyes at the conclusion of this heartrending story, I was quickly thrown into a state of euphoria when I read the author's note. Certain memorable characters will return in a sequel and I cannot wait! This novel wasn't an easy one to read by any means because of the slavery issue, but I'd like to think it'll make better people of us all and draw us closer to Him. 'Mountain Laurel' is a beautifully written, well-researched novel, destined to win many an award. You absolutely do not want to miss this one!
*I received a complimentary copy of this novel from Tyndale House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. All thoughts expressed in this review are my own.*
Author Lori Benton has written an emotive, literary masterpiece as hauntingly beautiful as it is disturbing—the forbidden romance between its pages timeless, all consuming, and powerfully passionate—despite dire, insurmountable circumstances.
Ian Cameron is a kind, compassionate man, easy on the eyes, but uneasy with the role of slave owner—especially when he meets the beautiful, light-skinned, green-eyed Seona. I loved her grit, quiet strength, and compliant spirit, and I literally cried at the unfairness and cruelty she endured because of her pleasing looks and station in life. As a matter of fact, all the slaves became like family to me—Lily, Seona's mother, clothed with dignity & strength, Malcolm, with a tender heart for the Lord, simple-minded Ally, and Naomi, who could sure cook some good vittles! And ladies...you'll swoon over the tender love story between the romantic Ian and lovely Seona!
As I was left bereft and staring into space with tears in my eyes at the conclusion of this heartrending story, I was quickly thrown into a state of euphoria when I read the author's note. Certain memorable characters will return in a sequel and I cannot wait! This novel wasn't an easy one to read by any means because of the slavery issue, but I'd like to think it'll make better people of us all and draw us closer to Him. 'Mountain Laurel' is a beautifully written, well-researched novel, destined to win many an award. You absolutely do not want to miss this one!
*I received a complimentary copy of this novel from Tyndale House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. All thoughts expressed in this review are my own.*
Read
January 21, 2021Love forbidden, sacrifice, redeemed. Mountain Laurel casts long shadows of kinship through generations of a society that breeds slaves and secrets. Only Divine wisdom can unravel this web of human passions and intrigue so tightly woven. Only Divine mercy can pave a road to loosen the chains of bondage—those worn by the enslaved, and those binding the hearts of slavers. Exquisitely penned, with all the beauty of a highland song, Lori Benton throws wide the door of a culture born in Scotland and wedded to the American south in years before that region dreamt of abolition. Stunning portrait of a past made real.
September 5, 2020
"I wanted what I wanted, thought I knew what was best, and found a way to make it happen."
Ian Cameron's return to Mountain Laurel causes quite a stir. . . .among his kin, among those his kin own, but ultimately within the deepest recesses of his weary soul. Had he run away again, or had he found home; it seemed a mighty peculiar combination of both, especially after he discovers the one for whom his heart must have been longing for all along; Seona.
Seona's green eyes and fair skin taunted the truth of her heritage behind a curtain of secrecy that most slaves were unwilling to discuss. There was something else that Seona was good at hiding. Since her youngest of days, Seona had cautiously developed her artistic talents, carefully sketching in obscure places when no one else was around. Then along comes the one who had unknowingly been her first subject, recognizing her talent and growing to cherish it, along with her. When Seona's relationship with Ian evolves into something they dare not ignore, the repercussions drive Ian along a path that covers too many trails.
"Mountain Laurel" is not a story, it's a journey; one fraught with the sort of danger and complication that result from one man owning another, where forbidden loves hope for futures that were never meant to be theirs. Then again, are "our failures ever an insurmountable barrier to grace"? Never. "The Father's been waitin' for ye to come home. Spirit's calling. The Son blazed the trail. All ye need to do is walk it". . . . . . welcome into a "new kindred".
Prepare to be spellbound; though you may reluctantly close its cover, this epic tale will beg to remain within your heart and mind for days, even months, to come.
Ian Cameron's return to Mountain Laurel causes quite a stir. . . .among his kin, among those his kin own, but ultimately within the deepest recesses of his weary soul. Had he run away again, or had he found home; it seemed a mighty peculiar combination of both, especially after he discovers the one for whom his heart must have been longing for all along; Seona.
Seona's green eyes and fair skin taunted the truth of her heritage behind a curtain of secrecy that most slaves were unwilling to discuss. There was something else that Seona was good at hiding. Since her youngest of days, Seona had cautiously developed her artistic talents, carefully sketching in obscure places when no one else was around. Then along comes the one who had unknowingly been her first subject, recognizing her talent and growing to cherish it, along with her. When Seona's relationship with Ian evolves into something they dare not ignore, the repercussions drive Ian along a path that covers too many trails.
"Mountain Laurel" is not a story, it's a journey; one fraught with the sort of danger and complication that result from one man owning another, where forbidden loves hope for futures that were never meant to be theirs. Then again, are "our failures ever an insurmountable barrier to grace"? Never. "The Father's been waitin' for ye to come home. Spirit's calling. The Son blazed the trail. All ye need to do is walk it". . . . . . welcome into a "new kindred".
Prepare to be spellbound; though you may reluctantly close its cover, this epic tale will beg to remain within your heart and mind for days, even months, to come.
August 19, 2020
Another epic historical tale by Lori Benton, rich with unique characters and a beautiful narrative. The early American setting of a North Carolina plantation showed how entrenched slavery already was in a country who fought for and won freedom from England just a decade before. Part one of a series, the book was a satisfying read full of human drama, passion, and inspiration.
The author does a wonderful job of pulling the reader into the lives of the characters--both slave and free. A glimpse of the early Underground Railroad and Abolition movement came into play as the plot revolved around the plight of the characters on the Mountain Laurel plantation. I felt for Ian and Seona who were caught in between it all. The faith element is brought out in a natural way in conversations and their personal struggles. I loved old Malcolm with his Scottish brogue, sharing pearls of wisdom with Ian, helping him see true freedom comes through faith in Christ. "’Tis your own soul’s freedom ye should be worrit over...Every man makes himself a slave to someone, or something." Ian was a man in need of God's grace and guidance, for sure.
Recommend for readers who enjoy a story steeped in history with some grit and romance. Looking forward to the continued story in the next book, with a possible crossover to the author's other novels.
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
The author does a wonderful job of pulling the reader into the lives of the characters--both slave and free. A glimpse of the early Underground Railroad and Abolition movement came into play as the plot revolved around the plight of the characters on the Mountain Laurel plantation. I felt for Ian and Seona who were caught in between it all. The faith element is brought out in a natural way in conversations and their personal struggles. I loved old Malcolm with his Scottish brogue, sharing pearls of wisdom with Ian, helping him see true freedom comes through faith in Christ. "’Tis your own soul’s freedom ye should be worrit over...Every man makes himself a slave to someone, or something." Ian was a man in need of God's grace and guidance, for sure.
Recommend for readers who enjoy a story steeped in history with some grit and romance. Looking forward to the continued story in the next book, with a possible crossover to the author's other novels.
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
September 20, 2020
"Every man makes himself a slave to someone or something. Your white skin doesna spare ye that."
Mountain Laurel is an amazing revolutionary war time epic. If you enjoyed Lynn Austin’s Refiners Fire series or Francine Rivers Redeeming Love, you will love this incredibly heartbreaking historical fiction novel set in a 1790’s plantation. The story revolves around a young man named Ian, who comes back down to the south after living in Boston to take over his Uncle's plantation. He falls desperately in love with Seona, an incredibly gifted slave with a knack for art who has served the house since she was a child. As much as Ian tries to do the right thing he continues to fail and he cannot outrun his station nor the rules and racism of this time period.
The book is filled with a rich abundance of love, loss, moral dilemmas, and a consistent theme of redemption. The over arching message of having faith over fear is as timeless as ever. This novel is incredibly researched and I found myself completely immersed in the sounds, smells, and history of the time period. It must have been such a frustrating time to be alive!!! But as with every period there was beauty and joy as well. This was a well balanced story of choice and consequence, bondage and freedom, faith and family.
Thank you to @tlcbooktours
@tyndalehouse @LoriBenton for my #gifted copy to read and review. I am looking forward to this becoming a series!
Mountain Laurel is an amazing revolutionary war time epic. If you enjoyed Lynn Austin’s Refiners Fire series or Francine Rivers Redeeming Love, you will love this incredibly heartbreaking historical fiction novel set in a 1790’s plantation. The story revolves around a young man named Ian, who comes back down to the south after living in Boston to take over his Uncle's plantation. He falls desperately in love with Seona, an incredibly gifted slave with a knack for art who has served the house since she was a child. As much as Ian tries to do the right thing he continues to fail and he cannot outrun his station nor the rules and racism of this time period.
The book is filled with a rich abundance of love, loss, moral dilemmas, and a consistent theme of redemption. The over arching message of having faith over fear is as timeless as ever. This novel is incredibly researched and I found myself completely immersed in the sounds, smells, and history of the time period. It must have been such a frustrating time to be alive!!! But as with every period there was beauty and joy as well. This was a well balanced story of choice and consequence, bondage and freedom, faith and family.
Thank you to @tlcbooktours
@tyndalehouse @LoriBenton for my #gifted copy to read and review. I am looking forward to this becoming a series!
April 15, 2021
I think the author did a great job of graciously write about a time period which was one of the low lights of America (and the world's) history.
This was a story about slavery and freedom (physical and emotional), hidden secrets and then also about hope and love. Ian made a few decisions from a place of passion and reacting first before thinking things through. Some of these decisions caused so much loss. A loss of what could have been and on love. My favourite characters were Judith - she loved Ian unconditionally even knowing everything about him and Malcom - a slave but someone more free than his masters because of his faith in God.
The story started out slow and build with suspense and pace. At the end there was a few questions left answering which hopefully will be concluded in the second book in this series.
I listened to the audiobook on Scribd. The narrator did a great job with delivering a strong, emotional and entertaining story.
This was a story about slavery and freedom (physical and emotional), hidden secrets and then also about hope and love. Ian made a few decisions from a place of passion and reacting first before thinking things through. Some of these decisions caused so much loss. A loss of what could have been and on love. My favourite characters were Judith - she loved Ian unconditionally even knowing everything about him and Malcom - a slave but someone more free than his masters because of his faith in God.
The story started out slow and build with suspense and pace. At the end there was a few questions left answering which hopefully will be concluded in the second book in this series.
I listened to the audiobook on Scribd. The narrator did a great job with delivering a strong, emotional and entertaining story.
December 9, 2020
Mountain Laurel is a story woven so perfectly, bringing history and people who may have lived together. Perhaps what I loved most is that the book isn’t all sunshine and roses. There are heartaches and challenges. Tough decisions were made and evils were done. I am now anxiously awaiting the second book. I’m so glad that the story will continue. This may be my favorite Lori Benton book. I didn’t think Burning Sky could be topped, but this one was so good!!! Romance. History. Mystery. Gut wrenching at times. I laughed. I cried. I can’t wait to read more!!!
October 23, 2020
I had to mull over this one a few days before I rated it.
The writing is a solid 5 stars.
Character development, 5 stars.
A page turner, 5 stars.
Characters feel like real, 5 stars.
Historical accuracy, 5 stars.
BUT... I didn't like the story.
There's huge mistakes and huge consequences... misunderstandings... more mistakes, heartache and more consequences. I get that the story is about a faith journey, real life situations in an unfair world (esp the history of our country at that time), humans making human choices and living with the consequences. I almost threw the book across the room... twice! A most unsatisfying ending. A bit too much description of intimate moments was disappointing as well. I MIGHT read the sequel, if only to see what happens and to read more about Joseph Tames His Horse (from Burning Sky..I heard he'll be in it)...
The writing is a solid 5 stars.
Character development, 5 stars.
A page turner, 5 stars.
Characters feel like real, 5 stars.
Historical accuracy, 5 stars.
BUT... I didn't like the story.
There's huge mistakes and huge consequences... misunderstandings... more mistakes, heartache and more consequences. I get that the story is about a faith journey, real life situations in an unfair world (esp the history of our country at that time), humans making human choices and living with the consequences. I almost threw the book across the room... twice! A most unsatisfying ending. A bit too much description of intimate moments was disappointing as well. I MIGHT read the sequel, if only to see what happens and to read more about Joseph Tames His Horse (from Burning Sky..I heard he'll be in it)...
November 9, 2020
Gutted. This book. Has left me gutted.
There were times reading this when Mountain Laurel and I were not on speaking terms with each other. I was so angry, conflicted, heartbroken, hopeful, and amazed... Like every other book I've read from Lori Benton, this story takes you into the early heart of America, and you feel. Every. Gritty. Throb of that heart. You go through the emotions that the characters are feeling, because they are real and understandable. Relatable, in the truest human sense of the word. You hope with them, rejoice with them, wonder and hurt with them. You anguish with them, and are led to cling tighter to Jesus with them. So here I am, back on speaking terms and giving this tragic, beautiful, soul-searching book 5 stars. Because it truly is a book readers must experience.
Oh... Dear Fall 2021 - please hurry. I need Shiloh.
There were times reading this when Mountain Laurel and I were not on speaking terms with each other. I was so angry, conflicted, heartbroken, hopeful, and amazed... Like every other book I've read from Lori Benton, this story takes you into the early heart of America, and you feel. Every. Gritty. Throb of that heart. You go through the emotions that the characters are feeling, because they are real and understandable. Relatable, in the truest human sense of the word. You hope with them, rejoice with them, wonder and hurt with them. You anguish with them, and are led to cling tighter to Jesus with them. So here I am, back on speaking terms and giving this tragic, beautiful, soul-searching book 5 stars. Because it truly is a book readers must experience.
Oh... Dear Fall 2021 - please hurry. I need Shiloh.
November 12, 2021
Beautiful and touching!
April 8, 2021
It didn't take me long to get swept away in this novel. I was at once intrigued and heartbroken by the relationship between Ian and Seona. There were many twists and turns, some of which I did not see coming, some of which were painfully obvious in their coming.
I liked both Ian and Seona, though I wanted to shake some sense into both of them by turns. I think, also, that the minor characters brought an important dimension to the storyline. Malcom, in particular, stood out to me as a 'father figure' for the enslaved community at Mountain Laurel, and I was grateful to read of his wisdom and leadership.
The only 'problem' I have with this novel is that the sequel doesn't come out until this autumn, and I've got to wait far too long to find out what happens next! *grins*
4.5 stars
I liked both Ian and Seona, though I wanted to shake some sense into both of them by turns. I think, also, that the minor characters brought an important dimension to the storyline. Malcom, in particular, stood out to me as a 'father figure' for the enslaved community at Mountain Laurel, and I was grateful to read of his wisdom and leadership.
The only 'problem' I have with this novel is that the sequel doesn't come out until this autumn, and I've got to wait far too long to find out what happens next! *grins*
4.5 stars
October 30, 2020
Loved this historical fiction masterfully written by Lori Benton. Set in late 1700s North Carolina, slavery was among several serious topics Benton built her story around. Lyrical storytelling style, characters that come to life, and emotional depth that kept me fully invested definitely make Mountain Laurel a book that historical fiction fans won't want to miss.
This story will continue in a second book, but Benton handled this in expert fashion in my opinion -- no cliffhangers, but instead a natural break that does indeed have readers hoping for a continuation. Can't wait to meet these characters again in the follow-up! Highly recommend.
This story will continue in a second book, but Benton handled this in expert fashion in my opinion -- no cliffhangers, but instead a natural break that does indeed have readers hoping for a continuation. Can't wait to meet these characters again in the follow-up! Highly recommend.
April 13, 2021
As always Benton has delivered another wonderful story! She's my go to for historical fiction.
I always look forward to seeing what she comes out with next and I'm never disappointed! She's fabulous and I highly recommend her.
I love how her research is turned into stories so that we can enjoy them too.
Her characters were so very real that I could feel their feelings coming to me from out of the book. I couldn't out the book down until I had finished Ian and Seona's story.
The many turns of this story surprised me in a lot of areas. Benton has done an excellent job with this.
I'll be honest. I dislike slavery! It's wrong in the way they were treated.
Parts of this book made me very sad that I wanted to cry.
I especially appreciated the way she described the scenes in the story that it made me feel like I was "seeing" the land for the first time.
I actually could relate to Seona on one thing and that's her love of drawing things. Such talent!
I really admired Ian. I liked him for his loyalty to Seona.
I didn't like the overseer in this story at all!
I'm glad to see that there will be another book after this one! I so can't wait!
more to come later
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review and all opinions are my own
I always look forward to seeing what she comes out with next and I'm never disappointed! She's fabulous and I highly recommend her.
I love how her research is turned into stories so that we can enjoy them too.
Her characters were so very real that I could feel their feelings coming to me from out of the book. I couldn't out the book down until I had finished Ian and Seona's story.
The many turns of this story surprised me in a lot of areas. Benton has done an excellent job with this.
I'll be honest. I dislike slavery! It's wrong in the way they were treated.
Parts of this book made me very sad that I wanted to cry.
I especially appreciated the way she described the scenes in the story that it made me feel like I was "seeing" the land for the first time.
I actually could relate to Seona on one thing and that's her love of drawing things. Such talent!
I really admired Ian. I liked him for his loyalty to Seona.
I didn't like the overseer in this story at all!
I'm glad to see that there will be another book after this one! I so can't wait!
more to come later
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review and all opinions are my own
November 21, 2020
Lori Benton weaves a narrative that is rich in history, people and emotions. It will take you on a journey of love and heartbreak, freedom and bondage, and truth and secrets. Lori Benton’s descriptions are so rich in detail that they’ll take you back in time to a world so far removed from ours. There you meet Seona (pronounced shona), a woman who’s been a slave her whole life and never dreamed of a life beyond it. Ian is running from his past when he arrives at Mountain Laurel, only to encounter new obstacles that will challenge his moral fibre. Seona is trying to maintain her faith in seemingly impossible circumstances. Ian is a man who doesn’t seek God until he reaches his lowest point and has no where else to turn. Their attraction is instantaneous and forbidden as they search for a path that will allow them to be together without losing those they care about. This novel seriously divided me and pitted my romantic heart against my moral compass. I’m usually quite good at predicting what is going to happen in a book but this story genuinely surprised me with an ending that was not entirely satisfying and yet was so perfect. It makes me so impatient for the sequel!
November 26, 2020
I know I’m supposed to love novels like this but I just can’t. Too much heartache. And I don’t like Ian at all. Well-written, though. I hated the love triangle/marriage/children thing. HATED it.
September 22, 2022
A riveting tale. Lori Benton weaves together masterful stories set in the late 1700s. Also, heart-wrenching! Mountain Laurel is of secrets and a haunting past. Of joy and grief. Of bad choices with excruciating consequences. Of bondage, freedom, faith, and strength. At times it had me crying, and other times wanting to scream at a certain character for making such disturbing choices. But I feel like the right and true was chosen in the end. A hard story, but very well-written. And, thankfully, not done yet! I look forward to reading book two, Shiloh.
This book did deal with things such as infidelity, sexual abuse, and other things of that nature. So it gets a mature rating from me.
This book did deal with things such as infidelity, sexual abuse, and other things of that nature. So it gets a mature rating from me.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 161 reviews