Maybe this fifth book in the Veronica Speedwell series had too much pressure on it given the previous book's cliffhanger. I know that I, for one, began it with much anticipation: would Veronica and Stoker finally become a sexual couple after many books of dancing around their undeniable attraction? If so, would the couple become a truly romantic detective duo? What role would Jack the Ripper play in a brand new mystery? And, would this new installment live up to previous ones? This book answers all of these questions -- but not, unfortunately, anywhere close to the hype.
Instead, it dutifully trudges through a pretty mediocre mystery that, in addition to being rather boring, even dragged in previous villains rather than create new and exciting ones. I never became interested in the central mystery of why someone was attempting to frame the Prince of Wales or why Veronica cared enough to go undercover to investigate. The pacing too is off in this book because one setting - a scandalous brothel (of sorts) - consumes way too much of the plot. Initially I thought that this scene in the book would be a fun sleuthing adventure before moving onto the next one, not realizing 200 pages later, we're still there. There's also a hectic and unintentionally farcical scene toward the end that left me in all states of confusion about who's doing what, when, and where.
And what about Jack the Ripper? He is here in this book, sort of, but kind of more on the periphery, and in spirit. I think he's meant to exist here more for atmosphere than actuality. Londoners are in a panic and Ripper-fever grips the city - or so we're told. Sadly, I wanted to feel some of that fever, but alas, I did not. There is though one cool scene where Ripper fleetingly appears, and that one scene really worked for me. It was ever so brief though before the pedantic return to the central mystery.
This fifth book does also address the unresolved tension between Veronica and Stoker, eventually. The writing during these scenes felt distanced though as we're told more than shown. Also, I felt Stoker's love for Veronica a bit less in this book, and I'm not sure why. A good part of the book is spent detailing Veronica's thought process on commitment, and so perhaps the absence of Stoker's perspective took a little away from the romance for me. There are scenes in the book where I had trouble reading Stoker, as does Veronica, and those moments are never fully explained later. It's hard for me to say with any certainty what kind of couple they will make in future adventures.
I'm giving this three stars because I do think Raybourn is a nice writer, and I was happy to revisit characters I've grown fond of over the years. Overall though, this is probably my least favorite of the books in the series.