"Divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived. I'm Henry the Eighth, I had six wives, some might say I ruined their lives." I've always remembered this jingle from grade school, and it definitely played a part in my fascination with the Tudors. As such, I was very curious as to how Henry VIII’s life would translate in today’s time, and I have to say that I thought Hayfield did a pretty good job with it (although no beaheadings!).
Going into it, you know the plot, so there's nothing super surprising about it; but nonetheless, I found myself completely sucked in from page one. Instead of being a king, Harry Rose is a "media king," in the 1980's. The book is told from his POV, and even though you want to loathe him, there is something compelling about him that makes the storyline believable, and at times, I even found myself feeling bad for him. I think he is like many people - he loves the idea of love but once the newness and excitement wears off, he is bored and looking to feel that "high" again. The sad aspect of this (and in "real life"), is that there are unintended consequences to those choices that followed Harry the rest of his life.
I really enjoyed the chapters with his first marriage to Katie - I thought Katie was a spot-on parallel to Catherine of Aragon, and I admired her character. As much as I adored Katie, I found myself the most drawn to second wife, Ana. While I still don't think she was quite Anne Boleyn-tough, Hayfield did a great job of making her a strong, aloof, but still lovable character. I definitely think the book loses some traction after Ana's death. That being said, after two such strong characters, I think it would nearly impossible to match that intensity in the rest of the women. I did still enjoy the chapters focusing on the rest of his wives - with the exception of Janette (who is Henry VIII's third wife, Jane Seymour and rumored to be his favorite wife). I detested her and found her to be the least compelling character, and I didn't get the feeling in any way that she was Harry's favorite wife.
Hayfield put a very creative spin on Anne Cleaves (Henry VIII's fourth wife) with the character of Anki, and with Caitlyn (Catherine Howard). Caitlyn's story was the most tragic, and you couldn't help but loathe Harry as it pertains to Caitlyn. Clare (Catherine Parr) rounded out the wives perfectly, and her character was truly the most interestingly crafted, after Katie and Ana.
I loved how Hayfield included references back to Henry VIII himself, and the parallels were fitting and creative. In the end, Wife After Wife was a fun re-telling of Henry VIII and his wives that I highly recommend to any of my historical/contemporary fiction friends out there. 4 creative, tantalizing stars for Wife After Wife!