My insight from this book is that Butch Dalisay needs to write another novel—and I need to get around to reading Soledad's Sister.
Any short story collection that is 500 pages long is bound to have some stretches, even some long ones, of stories that don't really catch your eye. Because this collection is arranged chronologically, you can some of the repeated themes that are played around with—the lustful yet introspective male character, the gamblers, the abrupt tragic endings that leave all the emotions under the surface. (Hilariously in one of the short stories, he even comments on his own repeated usage of one of those tropes.) I didn't think all of these tropes worked, as in some of the stories their relevance was difficult to spot. But it was interesting to how they get refined over time or are used in different ways, somewhat challenging your expectations.
The stories that jumped out at me were the ones with more fantastical settings or characters. Butch Dalisay is a very eloquent man, and I liked reading his prose describing characters with very strong personalities, or in unusual situations. They helped create some narrative momentum that pushed the stories forward, instead of getting too caught up in some clever descriptions. One thing I found particularly cool was that some stories made me realize how untapped certain eras of Filipino history are in fiction. Stories about datus and warriors in pre-colonial Philippines, or those set in the era of post-World War II Reconstruction, or in the midst conflict during the Philippine-American War. Loved the long descriptions that managed to bring these places to life. Perhaps I just don't understand subtlety, but I grew a bit tired of the nth description of some brooding guy in a generic Manila setting—go back to the exciting bits!
And stupidly for a short story collection, I generally found the longer stories more interesting. He has a very immersive writing style, and I found myself drawn deeper and deeper into the worlds of little mysteries he would set up, even as I knew that there was no chance they would be resolved with a neat little bow. I'd end a lot of the short stories wishing everything was explored a little more, or that the tension was kept up for just a few more pages just to make the endings more satisfying.
My last comment is that a lot of these stories try to make some sense of the Filipino identity, and I felt that a lot of the most successful ones did this from a perspective adjacent to Filipinos. Maybe about Filipinos in another land, or foreigners in the Philippines, or some mixture of the two. There's something about that juxtaposition that raises a lot of questions, or alternatively makes the reader see some aspect of Filipino culture in a clearer, more objective light.
Anyway, I recommend this book even if I didn't always enjoy it. Any book that gets to me write this many words about it must have been a fulfilling experience!
My top five stories of the collection (in chronological order):
1) The Mirror
2) Oldtimer
3) Under the Dinosaurs
4) Penmanship
5) Voyager