It was a real treat for me to discover this 2012 entry to a new detective series. A detective with heart, a fascinating mystery, and an exotic location set in an island community in Thailand.
So what is there about this to distinguish it from the crowd? Our hero, a middle-aged Brit David Braddock, is easy to identify with, kind and literate, a man who empathizes with the downtrodden. He is no boy scout, as he is frequently subject to the human weaknesses of lust and the escape from internal stresses through alcohol. He is unusual as a hero in this genre by avoiding violence, yet he can prove himself brave without being macho. I love how he consorts frequently with a Buddhist monk for advice and how his playful mind reaches to examples from fiction to help with his challenges. The customers for his private detective business mostly involve investigations of suspected infidelity in love relationships. While the truths he uncovers provide a needed dose of reality for his customers, he gets more satisfaction from a separate business he runs in provide counseling and problem solving advice.
The steadiness of his life becomes unraveled when the police chief calls him in to help investigate a murder of a foreigner, a man found bludgeoned and burned. It turns out this is a second murder with the same MO. The first was suppressed, but it is now difficult to keep the press from raising the alarm of an active serial killer, news of which threatens the tourist trade. The other challenge for Braddock is that he is having an affair with the police chief’s wife. Do the murders represent a psychotic person’s hatred of foreigners, jealous rage, or financially motivated crimes?
Against the backdrop of this key case, Dolan shows great finesse in juggling the stories of a set of vibrant minor characters in Braddock’s life. A sexy and spiritual housekeeper from Java, a pragmatic and pregnant office manager, a blind old man embittered by the death of a son, and numerous cameo spots that help color in perspectives on Thai culture. The Buddhist themes that Braddock ponders are pervasive but not overdone; they represent a special source of pleasure to me. The monk exhorts him:
If you would only stop listening with your ears you might understand better. …Let me spell it out for you. …Everything is connected. Everyone is connected. Everyone and everything is interconnected. ..Your analysis of your problem will be based on individual things, but your solution will lie in the interdependency of everything.
Braddock has a self-deprecating form of humor that is refreshing in comparison to the irritating wise cracking common to many detective heroes. For example:
“I bet you get lots of women who cry in here.”
“Some. Most women only cry with me in the bedroom. Usually out of disappointment.”
The title of this gem highlights an organizing thread to the diverse elements of the novel:
Everyone burns, as the Buddha says, in their own way. Some burn with anger, some with lust, some with the desire for vengeance, some with fear. But inside us burn many fires, not just one. We are legion, we contain a multitude.
Dolan may be an unknown quantity for most readers, but I think he is worthy of a wider readership. If you stick with just best-seller authors, you will often end up with a lot of formulaic writing and recycled melodramatic plotting.