Excellent introduction to an approach to sermon writing that is both clear and concise, an approach that will lead to captivating preaching!
To be fair, my rating is 4.5 out of 5, and I would highly encourage preachers, Bible teachers and Christian communicators of all stripes to read this book.
Starting with the focus on one-point sermons, Talbot argues convincingly for an approach to sermon development that emphasizes clarity over clutter and practices "self-editing" as if it were a spiritual discipline.
Crammed full of numerous sermon and sermon series examples, Talbot certainly practices what he preaches. The book is only 122 pages long! And I am convinced that he proves his point -- that a simplified approach will improve the learning impact of the sermon.
I do, however, have three small critiques:
1) Davis, while he gets close to, misses an important concept in his discussion of applications, choosing instead to focus on an experiential "bottom line" rather than connecting to an experiential activity that will further maximize learning and spiritual development (p. 50).
2) He focuses a lot on preaching without notes (chapter 7), which has been a back-and-forth argument in communication and homiletic circles for generations, rather than promoting a delivery model that draws from the preacher's personality (i.e., Robert Stephen Reid's The Four Voices of Preaching).
3. He outright repeats material without any explanation. I am hoping this is an editorial issue, however content from p. 78 is repeated word-for-word on p. 111-112.