Soul Eater is a weird series for me, in my personal history. At some point in ninth or tenth grade, I decided I was "too old for anime," and so stopped following things. Really, the big thing was the channel number for Cartoon Network changed and was no longer included in my family's cable package, so I could not keep up with dubs; when I learned how to torrent not long after, I felt it was best used for "Film" (capitalization necessary for the time period). In eleventh-ish grade, I got bored of life and school and friendship, and thought it would be funny to get back into anime. I mostly watched artsy-ish stuff (Bakemonogatari), but also some things I remembered from [adultswim] which I hadn't seen in full (Cowboy Bebop, Trigun). I do not know how or why I learned of the BONES adaptation of Soul Eater. I think maybe it did run on [as] at some point, but never when I had access. It's not really artsy. It's the only shōnen battle series I tried watching at this time, and it should also be noted I did not then enjoy Gurren Lagann because it was "stupid" compared to Evangelion. So, surely, Soul Eater is even dumber? Well, anyway, I dropped the anime about halfway through because I was watching it in English dub (Jesus fucking Christ), and after a certain point I decided I could not stomach Blackstar any longer. I think this actually coincided with the anime spinning into original plotlines, much like the studio's first crack at Fullmetal Alchemist, (co?)incidentally another Square-Enix manga. It's also maybe important to note that when I was sixteen I was in a mindset when I thought it was foolish/childish to be sexually attracted to cartoons, as I had been when I was like twelve (and which I'd get back into at eighteen or nineteen ¯\_(ツ)_/¯), so I could not at the time appreciate stuff like Blair. So it's a bit funny and possibly-ironic that I would watch the adaptation of Ohkubo's next manga, Fire Force, enjoy all its fanservice, and feel intrigued about returning to Soul Eater....
I can find no evidence of it, but around 2010/2011 there was a Wikipedia page for an aesthetic named some shit like "Neo-Goth Expressionism." The poster-child was Jhonen Vasquez. I think the Burton/Selick stop-motion flicks as well. And, most relevant here, an image of the moon (or was it the sun?) as drawn by Ohkubo, or, I think, actually, the BONES version. This, I'm quite sure, is why I started watching the anime, having been a fan (well, I still am, I guess; I just haven't read it in a while) of Johnny the Homicidal Maniac. There's this super-stylized "I listen to Mindless Self Indulgence" vibe to the art-style. It intrigued me as a teen, when it did actually also border on "cringe," but it interests me much more at age thirty for strongly Nostalgic reasons.
Being partly familiar with the BONES adaptation of this manga, as well as DavidPro's adaptation of Ohkubo's next major manga series, it seems I've developed a preconception about the man's art-style. I have a vague and unimportant memory of having seen copies of Ohkubo's earlier B.Ichi in a Books-a-Million, and its style looks very different indeed from what I expected of Ohkubo from the anime adaptations' character design. But, being Ohkubo's second serialization, Soul Eater more closely resembles the jankier art I recall from B.Ichi (which, by the way, I haven't yet read). Put another way, BONES wholly disrespects Ohkubo's art-style, unless he changes/evolves too drastically as this manga continues, in which case maybe BONES is more faithful than I'm assuming, based on having seen half their show versus reading these first few manga chapters. As it stands it feels like a "Madhouse versus Togashi" level of disrespect and utter disregard for a mangaka's unique vision. (I cannot attest to Fire Force's manga based on what I know of the anime, but I will mention I am currently reading Rave Master by Hiro Mashima, which looks quite a bit different from how that author's later Fairy Tail and Edens Zero look, so it's possible the post-B.Ichi style here will eventually grow to meet the appearance of DavidPro's character design for Fire Force.)
(New paragraph, less because it's strictly warranted and more because I felt anxious having a long wall about character design.) With the above, I have to say... the women here look far sexier to me in spite of the janky art-style versus their... sanitized(?) appearances from what I remember of the anime. When I say "janky" I really just mean the faces look weird. Or... they remind me of like a distant cousin of Hajime Ueda, which I would say is a weird thing for battle manga. Or, like, the way Ohkubo is drawing faces here might work better for some kind of absurdist gag manga, but stands out for a battle manga being read by a person more familiar with the DNA of Jump manga? But, anyway, the boobs all look fantastic, and other parts (legs, thighs, hips, butts, tummies) are great, too. But take Blair, for example; her anime version is maybe more "palatable," more "lowest common denominator"; her manga version could "filter" anime-onlies from her face alone, but there's also an inherent "otaku-ness" to her boobs et al. that I would say may be likewise off-putting to casuals. These aren't boobs for "people who are watching the series firstly because it has fights," they're boobs for "people reading the series firstly because it has boobs."
When I was like twelve, I read a lot of random manga from my local library, and it colored my perception of the medium in general. There are two stand-out series I never actually read much of, but which are firmly rooting in my mind as examples of a specific aesthetic. The manga are King of Bandits: Jing and Peacemaker Kurogane; the aesthetic is "C-list battle manga you will not find on purpose." This is assuming the Jump classics are "A-list" and other shit from lesser magazines (but which had adaptations airing on Toonami/[adultswim]/&c.) are "B-list." There may be anime adaptations of these C-listers, but the average American preteen isn't going to find them by any means but "blindly browsing the DVD shelves at the library." So... basically the same method of discovery as their manga sources. Soul Eater (the manga) has this "hidden gem" sort of quality... except that the anime did air with obvious and accessible presence. It's just the manga itself looks like it would (have) be(en) "niche." I'm actually reminded a bit of Rave Master in an inexpressible way.
****
A manga review would not be complete without autistically noting almost every instance of sexiness:
Blair hips and heavy fucking hangers the first time we see her in the bath...!
Blair's ass, and her boobs squishing against her arm, on the next page...!
Blair's soapy hangers on the adjacent page...!
Blair squishing them together to seduce Soul on the next page...!
Blair's sideboob, thigh-high "skindentation," and the effect that makes her dress fit her body so closely that her tits are clearly separated...!!! 🤤
Rather close-up panel with Blair's boobs taking up roughly 1/12 the entire page, and also her nipples are hard just because...!!! 🥵
Maka panties and her ass looking actually kind of big when she "kills" Blair...! 😯
Tsubaki cleavage...!
Tsubaki cleavage again...!
Tsubaki cleavage again...!
Tsubaki cleavage again, and also her one (1) thigh-high with garter...!
Tsubaki cleavage again...!
Tsubaki squishy boob-meat when standing in the bath...! Also her hips and tummy...! Also it kind of looks like Ohkubo drew a bit of a pussy-cleft if you squint...!
Tsubaki flat butt despite wide hips...!
Tsubaki underboob as she readies a shuriken...!!! 🤤
Tsubaki squishy boob-meat, hips, and thighs after hitting Blackstar...!
Tsubaki boobs and hips in the bath again...!
(Okay, I lied, or else I'd forgotten a bit; I said I didn't care much for Blair when I watched the anime because I wasn't attracted to cartoons at the time, but I think I actually did think Tsubaki was cute and sexy the whole time and didn't want to admit it to myself back then.)
Liz and Patty titties and tummies...!
Kid squeezing Patty and Liz's squishy boobers...!!!
Liz and Patty's legs, tummies, panties, and squishy boobers...!!!!! 🥵🤤🥵 Also, Liz's ass...!!! 🤤🥵
Liz's ass in jeans...!!! Liz's pubic mound visible from the back...!!! 🥵🤤
Liz having a hole in her top, showing off her cleavage...!!! Patty's boobs look great, too, even though her clothing wasn't really ruined...!
Soul's Aphex Twin and Portishead posters are a fun touch.
Blair's heavy hangers draping over a sleepy Soul...! The side-view of Blair's body where we get some hip/ass...! Blair smooshing her boobs in Soul's face...!!! Also, pretty good panty/ass shot I almost didn't notice because I was distracted by the boobs...!!!
Tsubaki boobies and hips...!
Maka pantsu-covered butt when Soul saves her from Sid...!
Blair boobs, tummy, thighs, legs, back, ass, hips on the bath... in color...!!!!! 🥵🤤🥵🤤🥵
Maka panties as she narrowly dodges the Living End...!!! 🤤
Maka thigh and a slight peak of panty when she slams Sid into the ground...!
Tsubaki's surprised tits, thighs, and panties...!!! 🥵
Extreme close-up of Maka's panties, including a bit of butt visible from the front...!!!!!!!!!! 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤
"My queen..." 🤣
Patty pits when she, Liz, and Kid show up to school...!
****
Unironically very excited to see Excalibur.