Sayaka Saeki has had three very formative, if not entirely pleasant, encounters on her way to becoming a young woman. Now, in college, a fourth encounter has happened entirely by accident. Then again, there are worse things in the world than fate...
My relationship with Bloom Into You is not complicated - it is one of a couple books that renewed my long dormant interest in manga and also sent me down a yuri rabbit hole. It remains, full stop, my favourite manga series ever (although challengers lurk in the shadows).
My opinion of these light novels and Sayaka herself is more difficult to parse. Having more story in this universe is no bad thing and while I am not the fan of Sayaka that I gather many others are (I understand what caused her to stumble and, while it’s not her fault, per se, she still has to take responsibility for what she did or did not do), I certainly didn’t begrudge seeing her story come to a happier conclusion than where the manga left her.
It doesn’t start out so great though. There are a couple problems I have with it - one has been the Achilles heel of this entire novel trilogy while another is unique to this book in particular.
First, for such a short book it really feels like a slog during the first half. Sayaka gets way too wound up in herself, as befits her character, but waiting for her to untangle her thoughts can be excruciating at times. It offers a contrast to what comes later, sure, but possibly drags things out longer than they should. Sayaka’s never been one to be rushed, but waiting for her to overcome that isn’t particularly stirring.
It’s also a lot of retread of the problems she’s had from the very beginning. That said, I do like the way they integrated Touko into this as an almost invisible antagonist that Sayaka has to overcome. That aspect of her working through her trauma does work well (even if they kind of club you over the head with the symbolism of word choice during the text messages between them).
The second problem is the fan service. I noted this in the second volume especially where that book spent too much time broadly hinting at future events. Yes, we see Touko and Yuu, which is admittedly pretty great. I knew we weren’t going to get away without the coffee shop showing up. However, once it’s down to cameo appearances by the planetarium projector that Touko bought Yuu, it feels a little gratuitous.
What really saves this book is Edamoto Haru, the underclassman who Sayaka met at the end of the last book. She is the complete opposite of Sayaka - she’s like a hyper bunny who follows her heart without letting her head get in the way and doesn’t let the past hold her back. She’s utterly unlike any of the characters in the manga and their burgeoning ‘opposites attract’ romance is fun. She’s a large part of why any of this works as well as it does.
Once it really kicks off in the back half of the book, well, this truly comes alive. Sayaka is forced by virtue of Edamoto’s sheer forward facing attitude to work through her past, lest this opportunity slip away like so many others.
It’s here that the book’s use of its predecessors is at its best. There’s an unnecessary but wonderfully romantic callback to the very first novel, plus some very cute scenes featuring Yuu (there are two unexpected friendships here that I truly enjoyed).
And then it ends on yet another especially sweet note. It’s hopeful, yet realistic, and rather moving, all things considered. It took its time, but the journey ended up being worth getting to, though it was close at points.
I think this ended up being better than the middle book, which was a companion piece that I don’t know the manga really needed. As a minor epilogue I felt this worked better once it started to be a bit less navel-gazey. I was sad to see it end, I can say that much, and that’s definitely worth something in my estimation, even if I would certainly not call it perfect.