Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

LRB Collections #7

Broom, Broom: Writing about Witches from the London Review of Books

Rate this book
‘the witches eat your book
then you
then everything’
– Rebecca Tamás

Witches in history were usually poor, ill, weak and uneducated, yet they instilled fear in learned, highly placed men in churches and law courts, academies and council chambers. Witches in fairy tales are also poor, often old and ugly, yet they inspire delighted shivers of terror and a strong desire to emulate their witchy powers. The essays in this collection explores cases from Renaissance Germany to New England and South Africa as they puzzle over the contradictions of a desire to dismiss witches as foolish and deluded, while punishing them for the harm they are believed to be able to do: it’s a cruel paradox that the most dedicated believers in witchcraft were not the witches and their clients, but their persecutors. Throughout these rich essays, ‘never again’ whispers between the lines, but one can’t be sure.

Featuring: John Bayley, Wendy Doniger, Malcolm Gaskill, Jeremy Harding, Hilary Mantel, Rosalind Mitchinson, Rebecca Tamás, Robert Tashman, Lee Palmer Wandel, Marina Warner and Leslie Wilson.

102 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2019

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (9%)
4 stars
14 (32%)
3 stars
19 (44%)
2 stars
5 (11%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
Profile Image for Caleb.
197 reviews11 followers
May 10, 2020
The witch never really goes away, they always remaining lurking in the imagination. At least that is what is suggested by this collection of writings and reviews from the past couple of decades taken from the London Review of Books. It demonstrates the range and malleability the witch has in culture as the pieces cover a broad spectrum of issues and publications. It was a great collection to read through and encouraged me to pull a couple of forgotten books of my shelf to read again and to go on a (witch)hunt for a couple of new additions to the shelves.
Profile Image for Rosemary.
2,318 reviews103 followers
September 24, 2020
This is a short but dense collection of ten articles and one poem from the London Review of Books. The articles are mostly non-fiction book reviews, some more than ten pages long, and most of the reviewed books are histories of a particular "witch" or trial. For example, Hilary Mantel reviews Hellish Nell: Last of Britain's Witches, which tells the story of England's last trial for witchcraft, which amazingly took place in 1944.

These are not the sort of reviews that would be popular if posted on Goodreads, since they tell the whole story of each book with no qualms about spoilers. But then this is non-fiction, and anyone seriously interested in the subject would probably still want to read the book. For me, however, this collection was enough, in a good way.
Profile Image for Alice.
26 reviews
October 15, 2019
Everyone should read this if you want to understand the suppression of women’s rights.
Profile Image for Yousseif Abdellatif.
50.5k reviews4 followers
November 2, 2026
I started Broom, Broom on my lunch break and went back to work forty minutes late with zero regrets. Sam Kinchin-Smith writes a small-town mail carrier who starts reading the return addresses on the letters nobody picks up, and the scene where she finds the same handwriting on three envelopes in three different mailboxes gave me actual goosebumps. It's quiet, it's creepy, and it never raises its voice. What bugged me was the mayor, who shows up just to look suspicious and then vanishes. Who this is for: readers who like slow-burn mysteries with a lot of mood. Who should pass: anybody who wants a chase scene by chapter three.
Profile Image for qiansustc.
68 reviews1 follower
September 14, 2024
黑色星期五这天终于读完了writings about witches。盛行几百年的witch-hunt 代表了女性地位的崛起(因为在这之前女性连犯罪都不配),是资源匮乏的替罪羊,是贫困年代人们痛苦和愚昧的宣泄,甚至可以是在战火纷飞的年代给人们带来一丝慰藉的精神鸦片。在古早的岁月里,科学的发展其实和神学炼金术密切交织,原来聪明的人虽然领先了时代探索出了宇宙自然的奥秘,然而他们会虔诚的认为这完美的自然现象都是神创造的,他们只是恰好做了神的布道者,展示给众人,这一点还挺有意思的。书中有一篇文写的是开普勒的妈妈被指控是witch,遭受到了非人的折磨和逼供,开普勒通过搜集证据利用逻辑辩论帮妈妈推翻了指控,而并非他是一个无神论者。相反,他学的是神学,认为自己是神的Priest of the Book of Nature。是残暴的中世纪的欧洲是落后的18世纪的新英格兰是二十世纪里依旧愚昧的非洲,是一直都被压制的女性。
50k reviews4 followers
October 30, 2026
Not gonna lie, I rolled my eyes a couple of times at Broom, Broom: Writing about Witches from the London Review of Books. Some of the lines try way too hard to sound deep. But Sam Kinchin-Smith also lands a handful of moments that got me right in the chest, and those carried the whole thing. Worth a shot if you can forgive some overreach, pass if cheesy bugs you.
Profile Image for Nihar Mukund.
246 reviews1 follower
August 27, 2026
Honestly, despite the fascinating topic, many of the essays felt less diverse in their framing and focus, which, yeah, is less an LRB collection problem and more an LRB framework limitation, but at times, it felt as if I were hearing the same points across different essays without anything different. Nonetheless, the essays are still good, and there are some pieces that are quite different. In addition, have been piqued by many of the texts reviewed, even more so than in my prev LRB collection read. My super biased ranking is as follows:

12. Transformation (Rosalind Mitchison): 3.5/5
Decent opener, but the two texts (I didn't even realise it was supposed to analyse two texts until the end) are unevenly focused on, and Mitchison really wants some Calvinism rep.

11. Toto the Villain (Robert Tashman): 4/5 (originally gave it 3.75)
It is genuinely well-crafted and entertaining to read, especially since, in hindsight, it provides a more unique focus compared to most other pieces (making me question, why didn't the collection continue with this?). However, I'm struggling to get over what is likely a minor misreading of Rushdie's work (DON'T MAKE ME TAKE HIS SIDE, TASHMAN), which unfortunately propels the piece forward.

10. Stand the baby on its head (John Bayley): 4/5
Love the title, and the piece is a fun read, but I cannot stand the Angela Carter slander.

9./ 8./ 7. The steady 4.5's
Broom, Broom (Leslie Jones): The titular piece is fun, but wish we could look a bit beyond.
The dead are all around us (Hilary Mantel): I feel bad, coz the piece is genuinely sharply written. But, owing to its position, I felt the exhaustion of samey-ness setting in. [To clarify, I would read one piece a day when travelling, so I wasn't just speed reading]
Interview with a Dead Man (Jeremy Harding): How do you write a whole chapter tying witchcraft and AIDs, and not once mention sex or sexuality? Is it a source problem, or a review one? Good read, tho.

6. Money, Sex, Lies, Magic (Malcolm Gaskill): 4.5/5 (Was gonna give it a 4.75)
It does not read like a review, and honestly, it works in the essay's favour. Problem is, the framing is kinda throwing me off, and misses the opportunity to stand out a bit more.

5./ 4. Le 4.75's
Crazy About Horses (Wendy Doniger): Doniger is genuinely a good writer. Like, literally, the only thing I wish for was a bit more of her writing and thinking.
Noonday Devils (Marina Warner): Fascinating stuff.

3. Nobody Liked Her (Lee Palmer Wandel): 5/5
My fav review essay of this collection. Perhaps, the most thoughtful one.

2. Introduction (Marina Warner): 5/5
A brilliant essay, and an even better introduction (with a banger closing line) by Warner in this collection. Normally an introduction can quickly go sour because its objective is relatively dull compared to the essays, but for Warner to make the introduction better that, or at least as strong as, the essays it describes is an achievement. Hence, it goes above Wendel's piece.

1. Two Spells (Rebecca Tamás): 5.5/5
In contrast to the dismal poetic addition to the collection about sex, this is my fav set of poems, and perhaps the best bow-tie to this collection.

The average seems to be 4.5-4.6, but the samey-ness of most essays drags it down to less than 4.5, hence the Goodreads 4.

Edit: Given the quite late introduction of quarters and halves, thus is a 4.25.
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews