Oh how I hoped this book would be different. For the majority of it I deliberated rating it one star, feeling like I was too harsh to then setting on three. Two stars feels like a reasonable compromise.
Unfortunately, despite my willingness to like this book and learn from it, I did not like it. It did not help me or enlighten me with a worthwhile point of view. Here is why:
- I often felt the title of the book should have been "How to Get Over a System" rather than a boy. The author focused a lot of her ideas on how the system is built on favouring men over women. I could not relate to her ideas since she frequently used terms such as "all men" etc... It is difficult to find value in a book that is founded on generalised terminology and blanket ideas, as well as being open to everyone whilst simultaneously serving no one. (In my opinion☺️)
- What was striking to me was that unknowingly the book is another by-product and symptom of the modern/current ethic of morality: the ethic of the self, which is the corresponding ethic of soft capitalism that presently dominates our social systems - which, the author so often criticised as the root of the imbalance between men and women!!
- Eggerue's ideas lacked evidence, explanations and research. Once or twice I felt that she stumbled upon an interesting idea and how I wished that she covered it in more depth or explained it better! However, all her advice would be whittled down to short and catchy slogans that, for me, hold no substance.
- I disliked how in her effort to empower women, Eggerue be-littled men to the extent that I felt it was unhealthy. She often announced that women deserve love without having to lift a finger and that we should not jump through hoops to deserve love. I agree with this an extent that in my experience women often try to mould themselves to be more lovable. However, the author then went on the explain how men should jump through hoops to deserve the love of a woman. This goes against my own belief in equality and seems a toxic way to fight injustice we may experience. The man should not jump through hoops to deserve love and equally, neither should the woman.
- At one point she claims that "a lot of women are jealous of sex workers" with no explanation of why she makes such a statement. This was unsettling to read because I had no idea where she got the statement from. I have never come across it myself. This type of narrative made her philosophy weak and unfounded and the major reason why I did not enjoy the book.
- Lastly, the book was a quick read. Mostly due to wasteful pages used as "fillers" to bulk out the book covering pages and pages of superficial slogans that lacked true depth. It felt that the book was written as quickly as it can be read.
I do realise that other women, with different experiences, may find some comfort or help in this book. Unfortunately it was not the case for me.