One strength of Johnathan Rand's American Chillers is that they provide special incentive for kids to follow the series closely. If you live in the U.S., the series will eventually arrive at your home state, and Tennessee gets its turn in this book. Ten-year-old Eric Carter lives in the easygoing city of Murfreesboro with his parents and four-year-old sister Madeline. Eric and his friends—ten-year-old Shayleen Mills and nine-year-old Mark Bruder—regularly go fishing at a local ravine on off days from school. This year's summer break starts like any other until Eric notices signs for a new store coming soon, Maxwell's House of Terrific Toys, in a building that has been abandoned for years. Having a toy store close to home should be fun, but Eric's enthusiasm takes a downward turn when he spots a walking, talking doll inside the currently empty store building. It sounds as though the doll is saying his name...but that's not possible, right?
Some of Eric's fear is assuaged when he meets Maxwell P. Kleagle in the alley behind the building that will soon be Maxwell's House of Terrific Toys. The talking doll—called Priscilla—isn't saying Eric's name, Mr. Kleagle insists, it just sounds that way. He presents the doll to Eric to give his little sister as a gift. Madeline loves her, carrying Priscilla everywhere she goes, but Eric can't shake the ominous feeling he has. His suspicions increase when his friend Mark tells him something strange: years ago Mark owned a monkey stuffed animal with mini clashing cymbals in its hands, but he found the toy unsettling and gave it away a long time ago. Now the monkey has shown up on Mark's front porch, with no explanation. Eric senses that Mr. Kleagle is behind it, but how would the man know Mark's history with toys? Mr. Kleagle seems nice, offering Eric, Mark, and Shayleen a guided tour of his shop before the grand opening, but Eric's instincts are right: something insidious is happening at Maxwell's House of Terrific Toys. Eric and his friends are the only ones with the opportunity to stop it, but can they end the menace before it spreads to the rest of Murfreesboro?
The past few American Chillers were pretty good, but Terrifying Toys of Tennessee reverts to the previous pattern of rampant plot implausibility. In the context of the series the book also lacks originality, with a narrative that closely resembles Terrible Tractors of Texas and Nebraska Nightcrawlers. The obligatory in-series reference on page twenty-seven, to Dangerous Dolls of Delaware, is almost necessary in this case, given how similar the first half of this book is to that one. I appreciate the veiled nod on page thirty-three to Barney & Friends, a classic of children's television in the 1990s. Another thing I like is how this book transitions to the next in the series, Nuclear Jellyfish of New Jersey, which will feature Shayleen as the main character. That's a divergence from the typical American Chillers formula, and I look forward to her further adventures. For all its awkward writing and plot holes, I still rate Terrifying Toys of Tennessee one and a half stars; the ending is good, and I enjoyed hanging out with Eric and his friends. This isn't one of Johnathan Rand's better books, but I had fun.