Classic mystery and enjoyable characters in a vivid setting
The Other Half, a charity race that is a spinoff of the immensely popular Bath Half-Marathon, is about to take place, and thousands of people are expected to participate. The authorities are anxious to prevent an incident like the terrorist attack on the Boston Marathon, so all available law enforcement personnel are called upon to provide security. Needless to say, Detective Superintendent Peter Diamond is not thrilled, but who can object when terms like “terrorist threat” are bandied about? Of course, violence does take place at the Other Half, but not the sort the authorities were anticipating.
After a short introduction in which we meet both the sinister unnamed Finisher and Diamond and his coworkers, the book opens at a leisurely pace, and we meet a number of ordinary but interesting people, Maeve Kelly is a primary school teacher who is training to run a marathon to raise money for the British Heart Foundation, both to punish herself and to compensate for a gaffe she had made involving her coworker Trevor. We also meet Olga, another runner whom Maeve helps when Olga is mugged while they are both out on training runs. There are also Spiro and Murat, Albanian refugees who have escaped from a slave labor group in Bath and are on the run, and an ex-con named Tony Pinto that Peter Diamond would love to see behind bars once more. The characters are well done, but the inquiring reader asks, “Why are they here? What do they have to do with each other? What do they have to do with the murder? And when will it happen?” In lesser hands, I would be impatient, but in the hands of a master, I am intrigued and read on.
Finally the race begins, and the intrigue turns to suspense, which Lovesey draws out beautifully. The question is not just who done it, but did it happen? Poor Peter Diamond of course has a hard time convincing his bosses and colleagues to take him seriously. I will not spoil your enjoyment by saying any more.
Peter Lovesey’s portrayal of his setting is as well crafted as his characters. His loving descriptions of the town of Bath always make me want to go back for a visit. Bath is more than just a backdrop, though. Lovesey likes to weave elements of Bath into his story, and I frequently find myself stopping to look up a place or historical event or person he mentions. Usually I find they are real. In this book, the Bath Half-Marathon is a real race, but the Other Half, around which the book’s events occur, does not seem to be. I especially enjoyed The Finisher’s opening lines, “The city of Bath isn’t all about Roman plumbing and Georgian architecture. It offers unrivalled facilities for getting rid of unwanted corpses.”
A question readers have in a series is whether you should read them in order. It is always nice to have the background of previous books to catch the nuance of things like competition within the police force, but the lack of background will not significantly affect your ability to enjoy this book. You can feel free to jump in with The Finisher and get to know the younger Peter Diamond later.
Peter Lovesey is known for writing “classic” mysteries, my favorite kind, where the reader and the detective both follow the clues, and the reader tries to solve the puzzle before the detective does. I was initially a bit disappointed as I was reading The Finisher, because it was clear to me fairly early whodunit. Until l I realized I was wrong. But another obvious culprit emerged. And I realized I was wrong again. This kept happening until there were few suspects left. And I still didn’t get it. But Peter Diamond did. Great job, Peters, both of you!