What do you think?
Rate this book


287 pages, ebook
Published August 1, 2019
"You have five seconds to explain to me why I'm picking you up from a hospital without any knowledge of you needing to be there. And I swear to God Nor, if you're hurt, I'm gonna be pissed that you didn't call me sooner."
"You have five seconds to explain to me why I'm picking you up from a hospital without any knowledge of you needing to be there. And I swear to God Nor, if you're hurt, I'm gonna be pissed that you didn't call me sooner."
Book overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Plot: 📖📖📖
Comfort: 💖💖💖💖
Angst: 💔💔💔💔
I think I may have just found one of my new favorite authors?? And I know it’s probably a little early to say that after reading only one book by Cindy Pike, but I genuinely loved the way this was written. There was something so refreshing about how organic everything felt, the characters’ interactions, the progression of the story, the way their relationships developed… nothing felt forced or like it was happening simply because the plot needed it to. Everything just flowed, and I think that was a huge part of why I connected with this book so much.
I think what I loved most was that this is essentially a wounded bird story, but one that focuses on healing through people rather than being “saved” by them. Nora has been through something horrific, and watching her slowly begin to feel safe again was honestly one of my favorite parts of the book 🥹 The men don’t try to erase what happened to her or treat her like she’s fragile all the time. They respect her boundaries, they listen to her, and they constantly make sure she feels seen and welcome in their already-established group. And tell me why these men are ALL such green flags?? 😭💕 It was honestly so refreshing to read. They are protective and supportive without becoming controlling, and I loved that their affection never felt conditional. They repeatedly make it clear that they like Nora because of who she is and because being around her has made them better people too, rather than making her feel like she owes them something in return.
I also really loved the group dynamic. Four of the guys already have this established friendship, and getting to see that friendship alongside Nora slowly becoming part of their little world was such a comfort 💖 The fifth guy doesn’t really have a proper position yet when it comes to his romantic relationship with Nora, but he’s still there, still trying to be a good friend for her, and I liked that his place in everything is being allowed to develop rather than being forced. And because the romance is still very much in its early stages, we don’t get a fully established relationship here. It’s more of a “I like you, I want to be with you, but I’ll wait until you’re ready” kind of situation. Which honestly worked REALLY well for this book. We still get cuddles, words of affirmation, emotional support, and all those little moments that made me feel incredibly comfortable with this group even though the romance itself hasn’t fully developed yet. Like… this was serving comfort personified and I was absolutely eating it up ✨🥹
And that’s probably where a lot of my love for this book comes from. The angst is there, and there is A LOT for Nora to deal with, but the angst isn’t being manufactured through her relationships with the men. They are consistently her safe place 💕 The drama comes from her trying to regain control over her life, dealing with the trauma that keeps resurfacing, and confronting the things that happened to her. And I think that’s SO important for this kind of story because I don’t want the romance to become another source of pain when the FMC has already been through enough. Here, the men are the people standing beside her while she deals with everything else, and I loved that dynamic.
I also think Nora herself was handled really well. I genuinely connected with her and felt incredibly protective of her throughout the book. She’s strong, but not in the unrealistic “nothing can touch me because I’m a badass” way. She’s funny, she’s resilient, and she obviously has moments where she breaks down, but the book doesn’t constantly rely on crying scenes to remind us that she’s traumatized. Her reactions and the way she sometimes interacts with people are actually connected to what she’s been through, and I really appreciated how the book allowed the other characters to understand that instead of treating her behavior as random or frustrating. It made her trauma feel present without completely consuming her personality.
If I had one criticism, it’s that I think Nora becomes part of the guys’ group a little quickly. I can understand why it happens, especially considering everything they’ve gone through together and the whole trauma-bonding aspect of it, so it didn’t really take away from my experience, but I could definitely see someone who prefers a very slow, painstaking progression of trust feeling like it happened a little too fast. The romance itself, though, is still pretty slow burn, so I don’t think that necessarily applies to the romantic progression.
I also want to mention that this book feels very much like a setup for the rest of the series. We get to know the characters, their personalities, their established lives, their jobs, their relationships with each other, Nora’s situation, and all the pieces that are going to become important later. I don’t think the book is necessarily trying to give us the full payoff yet, and honestly, I was okay with that because I really liked the foundation being built. I already want to see Nora get more of her life back, and I especially want to see how her relationships with all of these men continue developing in the next books.
And if you’re picking this up because it’s a Why Choose/RH, please don’t go in expecting a ton of spice yet 🌶️ There really isn’t spice in this one, which makes sense considering where the characters are emotionally and where the relationships currently stand. They’re still building trust and figuring each other out, and I actually think introducing a lot of sexual content at this point would’ve worked against what the book was trying to establish. So if you’re someone who needs spice from Book 1, just know what you’re getting into. This is much more about emotional intimacy, healing, friendship, comfort, and setting up the romance than actually getting into the romance itself.
The ending isn’t even the kind of cliffhanger that had me screaming I WILL DIE IF I DON’T KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NEXT 🤭 I just… really want to know what happens next because I’ve become attached to these characters. That’s honestly the best way I can explain my experience with this book. I wasn’t obsessed because every single plot point was perfect or because the romance had already reached its full potential. I was obsessed because I loved being with these characters. I loved watching Nora slowly find people who made her feel safe. I loved seeing this group make room for her. I loved the little moments of comfort, the affection, the reassurance, the friendships, and the promise of everything that’s still to come 👀
So yeah, 4 shiny pink hearts from me 💖 I have a feeling the next books are going to lean even harder into the comfort + romance combination that I was already craving here, and considering how attached I became to Nora and these men after just one book… I NEED to see where this goes. This book may have started with so much darkness, but somehow I finished it feeling like Nora had finally found a little pocket of safety, and I think that’s exactly why I loved reading it so much 🤩
✦ ── Tropes & Vibes ── ✦
✧ Why Choose
✧ Hurt/comfort
✧ Trauma Recovery (Wounded bird)
✧ Protective MMCs
✧ Found family
✧ Slow-burn romance
✧ Green-flag men
✧ Words of affirmation
✧ Emotional healing
✧ “You’re safe with me” energy
TW ⚠️ (because this book has a VERY hard start): there is detailed on-page rape, and the story continues to deal heavily with the aftermath of trauma, including memories and situations that bring Nora’s past back to the surface. So definitely check the trigger warnings before going in, because while I found this book incredibly comforting, the subject matter itself is very heavy.