Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Lady's Reputation

Rate this book
“Mr. Darcy, I am eager to hear your explanation for the fact that quite a few people believe we are engaged.”

It starts with a bit of well-meant advice. Colonel Fitzwilliam suggests to his cousin Darcy that, before he proposes to Elizabeth Bennet in Kent, perhaps he ought to discuss his plans with their families first.
What neither man could have predicted however was that Lord Matlock would write the news to his sister, or that Viscount Saye would overhear and tell his friends, or that his friends might slip a little and let their friends know as well. The news spreads just as quickly through Hertfordshire once Mrs Bennet opens the express Mr Bennet receives from Mr Darcy, and in a matter of days, it seems like everyone knows that Mr Darcy has proposed marriage to Elizabeth Bennet.
Everyone, that is, except Elizabeth herself.
Her refusal is quick and definite—until matters of reputation, hers as well as Jane’s, are considered. Then Mr Darcy makes another offer: summer at Pemberley so that Jane can be reunited with Mr Bingley and so that he can prove to Elizabeth he is not what she thinks of him. Falling in love with him is naturally impossible…but once she knows the man he truly is, will she be able to help herself?

472 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 29, 2019

348 people are currently reading
376 people want to read

About the author

Amy D'Orazio

52 books293 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
635 (48%)
4 stars
458 (34%)
3 stars
183 (13%)
2 stars
30 (2%)
1 star
9 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 149 reviews
Profile Image for Les.
2,911 reviews1 follower
August 2, 2019
This is a book that is so good it will ruin you for other books. Since finishing it several days ago I have started and stopped several books which just can't live up to the style, quality and enjoyment of this read.

I love this story, love it! Read it then read it again and again.


Updated: If you are a wanna be P&P author or a current P&P author who struggles with their writing you need to read this story. Then ask yourself, "Can I write this well?" And if not perhaps you should find another outlet for your passions, especially if you insist upon putting your books up for sale.

This book is simply beautiful. The author has captured Jane Austens voice and style. This book doesn't bog down with details, nor become obsessed with who wore what or who ate what or other filler and self important bs used to demonstrate the study of the era.

yes this book is angsty but it is angst with a purpose. There is real tension not the faux tension so many authors wish to impose upon their readers. I cannot praise this story enough.

Warning- If you are a person who cannot live with the idea that Bingley and Jane aren't HEA don't read this book.

This is a BRILLIANT P&P What if. Beginning at Rosings Darcy is ready to propose to Miss Elizabeth Bennet when he decides that he needs to square away her family and his family. So he travels to London to share his plans for her with the Earl and his wife, Georgiana and other family members, then to Longbourn to secure Mr. Bennet's permission. Alas he forgets to ask his bride to be who is informed of it by Lady Catherine in a less than friendly 'welcome to the family' way.

Lizzy arrives unceremoniously upon the Gardiner's doorstep to their questions about the letter from her father regarding her betrothal. Then she goes to confront Darcy only to meet Georgiana who is overjoyed to meet her new sister. The rumor of Darcy's betrothal is all over London.

When she finally meets with Darcy she turns him down and he begs for the chance to court her and get her to change her mind. Oh this Darcy is a little controlling and a little over self assured. And his plans to reunite Jane and Bingley have gone all pear shaped. As it evolves Bingley has fallen in with a bad crowd and is apparently even more spineless than Miss Austen wrote him. He is a bit of a chameleon or a Zelig, he adopts the personality of his companions... and these companions are feckless.

Eventually Jane, Lizzy & the Gardiner's will spend time at Pemberley where Darcy plans to reunite Jane and Bingley but Bingley has other plans. Luckily for the reader the author has created a new character, Col. Fitzwilliam's older brother Viscount Saye. Saye is hilarious, irreverent and an instigator.

This story is chock full of drama and excitement with out a bit of absurdity and 0 sprained ankles.
Profile Image for wosedwew.
1,337 reviews125 followers
August 1, 2025
Character is much easier kept than recovered. ~ Thomas Paine

But what’s a girl to do when her reputation is affected by events she cannot control – in fact, when she knows nothing about these events!

Fitzwilliam Darcy has made his decision – he will marry Elizabeth Bennet! He will not, however, surprise his family with his decision after the fact. He will speak with his Uncle Matlock at once. His cousin knows … and his cousin’s intended … and then his sister discovers the truth … and Miss Bingley … and … and … and … the whole of London.

He will also request the blessing of his future father-in-law. The letter is intercepted … Mrs. Bennet knows … and Lady Lucas … and Sir William … and Mrs. Long … and Mrs. Goulding … and … and … and … the whole of Meryton.

Everyone knows Elizabeth Bennet is betrothed with the exception of Elizabeth Bennet.

Then the news reaches Lady Catherine in Kent where Elizabeth still visits with her friend, Charlotte Collins.

Darcy has amends to make.

The reputation of a thousand years may be determined by the conduct of one hour. ~ Japanese Proverb

One amend Darcy can make is to repair his error in separating his friend Bingley from Jane Bennet. Unfortunately, Darcy has been out of contact with Bingley for some time and Bingley, always easily influenced, has fallen under the control of Sir Albert Williams-Broad. Where Sir Albert is leading, Bingley is following and the path is not straight and narrow.

This is NSNB (not-so-nice-Bingley) and in his efforts to extricate himself from an unpleasant alliance, he is willing to implicate his friend Darcy.

The story wanders to Pemberley where the Gardiners and their two oldest nieces have been invited. Bingley is also invited but will he arrive?

In Ms. D’Orazio’s profile, she mentions her Jack Russell Terriers and confides she sometimes patterns human characters with the personality traits of her JRTs. As a fellow terrier-lover, that statement caught my attention. Who in this book could be named Jack Russell? Viscount Saye, of course! The Viscount appears in other stories by this author and he is always enjoyable. When the older brother of our favorite Colonel appears in JAFF, he is often a drunken gambler, sometimes afflicted with the French disease. But not Viscount Saye. A bit of a playboy (OK, a lot of a playboy); determined; out to do-good but not get caught at it. What could be more Terrierish? Absolutely loved his comeuppance for the Bingley shrew! Punishment to fit the crime!

The story is well-written, edited and proofread (proofreaders, my secret heroes). I would recommend it to everyone.

I received an ARC of this book with no promise of a review, good or bad.

A man cannot be comfortable without his own approval. ~ Mark Twain
Profile Image for Debbie.
1,680 reviews79 followers
May 25, 2016
This is another wonderful unpublished story by Amy, a.k.a. Alex9903. Even though it's long, it definitely keeps your interest throughout. I would describe it as having two distinct storylines, but the one involving Darcy's relationship with Bingley affects Darcy's relationship with Elizabeth; consequently, the two plotlines have rising action, turning point, and falling action that interweave.

The first half of the book focuses more on the unfortunate chain of events that spreads the news of Darcy's engagement to Miss Elizabeth Bennet before he's even proposed to her. Naturally, he's embarrassed about it, but he's convinced that she's going to accept anyway, so it shouldn't matter, should it? HAH! Her refusal is a rude awakening for him, especially since she'd rather deal with her ruined reputation that will encompass her entire family than marry him.

There are a number of memorable scenes in this section, including those with Darcy's family members pleading his case and pointing out the benefits of marriage to such a worthy gentleman. I really love Colonel Fitzwilliam's older brother Saye, although every character is nicely developed. No matter how many times Darcy's advances are rebuffed, though, he just falls back, regroups, and brainstorms to come up with another approach to win Elizabeth. Eventually, he convinces her to come to Pemberley with Jane along with the Gardiners, and he promises that Bingley will be there, which will fix the relationship that Elizabeth holds him responsible for breaking. The romance in this story comes to the forefront at Pemberley, and she gradually starts to soften as she sees what kind of man Darcy truly is.

Throughout all the above, Bingley's character demonstrates the author's brilliant takeaway from Jane Austen's description of him as "easily persuadable." In his despair over believing he made a fool of himself in Hertfordshire when Jane didn't even love him, he starts drinking more and eventually falls in with a dissolute group of friends, distancing himself more and more from Darcy. In the second part of this book, he goes from distancing himself, to resisting every effort to pull him from his downward spiral, to actively betraying Darcy. His actions create even more obstacles for Darcy and Elizabeth to overcome. Her solution is just perfect!

You'll find here a perfect mixture of romance, passion, angst, humor, and character study. Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Sheila Majczan.
2,687 reviews201 followers
May 16, 2016
I loved this story…another variation of my favorite couple’s working through misunderstandings and gossip and manipulations on the part of some who would have claimed friendship in canon. Beware: if you love or have any fondness for Charles Bingley, this story is not one you will like. But we also meet or get to know much better others who are working to bring about a happy ending.

As the story description tells us Darcy wants to propose at Hunsford but when Colonel Fitzwilliam realizes he plans it do it during a visit by occupants of the parsonage and in the presence of Lady Catherine the colonel has a serious talk with Darcy about possible consequences what with society, much less family possibly shunning them and bringing about the death of Darcy’s admiration for the lady with cold shoulders and the ostracizing by one and all.

So Darcy is off to town to talk to his uncle, who is not at all receptive. But as Lord Matlock talks to his lady and then conversations are overheard and despite demands not to tell anyone as it is not fait accompli we read of “whisper-down-the-lane” and soon everyone is talking of some version of an engagement for Fitzwilliam Darcy. Caroline Bingley is incredulous and is off to Darcy’s townhouse to ascertain, hopefully, a denial of this rumor. Georgiana happens to just get an inkling of what Caroline is ranting about and so plays along that “yes, it is true and she knew about it”…as she so wishes for a sister and has heard kind remarks from her brother about Elizabeth Bennet.

The final straw is that Mrs. Bennet cannot resist (with the prompting from Mrs. Philips - one of the biggest gossips in Meryton) opening a letter in which Mr. Darcy states he is requesting some time during which to talk to Mr. Bennet. That can only mean one thing to Mrs. Bennet. Thus Meryton is now full of the news. Elizabeth is still in Kent but is soon accosted by Mr. Collins at the behest of Lady Catherine and immediately sent packing to her aunt’s and uncle’s in London as she has "betrayed all hospitality extended to her".

Yes, Darcy’s has not even proposed so there is no letter explaining his influence on Bingley in regards to Jane nor is there any explanation about Wickham’s story. Elizabeth continues to hold harsh feelings concerning those acts.

When Darcy realizes what has happened and is confronted by an outraged Elizabeth he has a lot of not only explaining to do but some backtracking and then supplicating. How to save the reputation of the lady (and thus also her sisters) when it is not at all her fault? So an agreement is negotiated and reached to have the couple chaperoned at Pemberley for a limited amount of time by M/M Gardiner, who have planned a trip along with Jane to the north during a visit at Pemberley. They can get to know each other better and, if not suited, hope time will have allowed gossip to die and then go their separate ways.

The Viscount, Saye, the heir to the Earl of Matlock, and the colonel’s older brother, is a favorite in this story. Having to endure a long engagement of his own he is much in company in London and at Pemberley and is just so cunningly manipulative. In Darcy’s words, “Never be misled by Saye,” ... “When he appears the most languid, the most disinterested, then may be assured you are likely in trouble. He sees through closed eyelids, and his hearing is beyond anyone’s I have ever known. He has, also, a tendency to be appear when and where he is least expected.” Readers, you must love how he has an ear to the door and with a turn of a phrase here or a dropped hint there, he unravels the most complicated of webs with this and that being said of our dear couple.

Jane’s prospects are part of the bargain with Darcy but will he be able to now bring about a reunion between Miss Bennet and his “friend” Bingley? This parallel story is overshadowed by surprising behaviors and threats and even blackmail. Lady Catherine with Anne seek not only revenge for Anne bring “jilted” by Darcy but also a solution to the need for a Rosings’ heir. I found this additional part of the tale amusing and justified!

The reputation of more than one individual is tainted herein. I am sure you will enjoy this longer novel and a reckoning about the deeds regarding that. Amusing and creative and perfectly romantic.
Profile Image for Debbie.
1,680 reviews79 followers
August 3, 2019
5+ stars!

This is a wonderful, clever, funny, romantic, beautifully-written book. So much of the plot is constructed around the consequences that uncontrolled (and, occasionally, controlled) gossip have for Our Dear Couple.

It all begins at Rosings, where Mr. Darcy confides to Colonel Fitzwilliam of his intention to propose marriage to Miss Elizabeth Bennet. Their discussion brings Darcy to conclude he should take steps beforehand in order to ward off unwanted talk about the intended Mrs. Darcy. Neither gentleman considers the possibility that the lady may wish to refuse him.

His actions have exactly the opposite effect. Step by step, we see how this little spark of gossip turns into a conflagration as confidantes gleefully share the surprising news. You can imagine the impact it has on Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine, and Mrs. Bennet.

That's only the first wave. Titillating news of Mr. Darcy and his unknown betrothed will dominate the rumor grapevine several times throughout the book, including a final tweak in part of the Epilogue.

Woven through these are Darcy's desperate attempts to make amends with the understandably furious Elizabeth. Once he sets his mind to wooing her, their romance gets swoony, including a middle-of-the-night picnic on the rooftop of Pemberley.

Another major plot point is Mr. Bingley. His tendency to be "easily persuaded" is exploited by Ms. d'Orazio. He drifts away from Darcy, seeking distraction with a new set of more entertaining friends. Perhaps Darcy can return him to better company with Jane Bennet.

Be sure you pay attention to Lord Saye, eldest son of the Earl of Matlock. He's a scene stealer and one of my very favorite characters added to the regulars in an Austen variation.

The tone of this author's writing shifts smoothly to match the story - sometimes humorous, sometimes angsty, and sometimes beautifully romantic. I was fully invested in these characters and their problems.

I love when it appears all has spiraled so far out of control that an HEA seems impossible, as it does here. The excellent resolutions are that much more satisfying. I felt like cheering at the fates for Darcy and Elizabeth as well as other characters. They're brilliant!

Content is clean.

Received an ARC with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise
Profile Image for Claudine DiMuzio / Just Jane 1813.
182 reviews9 followers
February 19, 2017
I loved this book from beginning to end... Maybe my second favorite by Amy D'Orazio... But the problem truly is she writes too many stories that I love, LOL! Oh, I love bookish problems!!

I hope this is published sooner rather than later... So many good surprises throughout this story and one moment where I almost threw my kindle and stopped reading this story... that's how good the angst was for me. Reminiscent of Abigail Reynold's "Mr. Darcy's Noble Connections" where my poor Kindle nearly suffered the same disastrous fate... LOL!!
Profile Image for Sam H..
1,224 reviews60 followers
February 22, 2024
2022: Very enjoyable audiobook.

Darcy, so overcome with his love for Elizabeth, yet apprehensive on what his family and the ton would say, he accepts advice from Col. F and speaks with Lord Matlock first.
However, he didn't take in to account the gossips and before long everyone is talking about D&E's betrothal.
Except, Elizabeth doesn't know, in fact she doesn't even like Darcy. Darcy has to leap through loops to try and win Elizabeth's regard, let alone her love.

The time at Pemberley gives ODC that time to learn one another and reach a better understanding. However, trials always show up to put a spoke in the wheel.

Saye is adorbs of course (the Saye fan-club will be pleased) All the other characters make up a great supportive team, balancing out the whole story.

I forgot how blegh Blingley was in this one, which is nice when you reread (listen) to stories again.
Profile Image for J. W. Garrett.
1,736 reviews133 followers
August 20, 2019
When you are rich and powerful, no one will challenge you to your face or give you a chance to explain yourself. All the whispers are behind your back. You are left with no means of clearing your own name. And after a while you realize there is no point in even attempting to do so. No one wants the truth. All anyone wants is the chance to add more fuel to the fires of gossip. The whispers become so loud that sometimes you think you will drown in them.” ― Amanda Quick, Ravished

Rating: MA: adult themes: Nothing explicit, but discussions of those in society that lean toward licentious living and debauchery. ODC became a bit steamy in their progressing courtship.

I first read this as a WIP [work-in-progress] on a fanfiction site and then gratefully received an ARC prior to publication. It is my wish to also purchase a copy for my library. I must say, I loved this story and the deeper I got into it the better I liked it. OMG! I loved the interactions between Jane and Lizzy. They were so cute in their sisterly bond. Man… that was good. It seemed that Lizzy was more stubborn and angry than even in canon. She lambasted Darcy from morning until dark and Darcy was a bit more controlling and unthinking that usual. Everything he put his hands to fell apart and there was nothing he could say or do that would assuage his mistakes in the eyes of Miss Elizabeth Bennet. To her, he was the worst of men.

Darcy: “A true gentleman is one that apologizes anyways, even though he has not offended a lady intentionally. He is in a class all of his own because he knows the value of a woman’s heart.” Shannon L. Adler

Our author was so creative and just when I wanted to shake our dear girl, things changed. That, for me, was when the story really picked up. Because then… we had Lizzy and Darcy working together toward a goal. Oh, that was delicious. I love them together and it became a bit steamy and sensual as their relationship progressed.

“Always remember… Rumours are carried by haters, spread by fools, and accepted by idiots.” Ziad K. Abdelnour, Economic Warfare: Secrets of Wealth Creation in the Age of Welfare Politics

I loved Lord & Lady Matlock and Darcy’s two cousins… the Fitzwilliam brothers, Lord Saye and our dear Colonel. I simply adored these guys. Their banter reminded me so much of my own brothers. I loved their camaraderie and their love and concern for Darcy. They simply made this story happen. Lord Saye was also a big influence in quelling the rampant gossip that was circulating in London. He was such a scream. I would not want him on my bad side. I loved him as much as I did our dear Colonel. Didn’t expect that to happen. However, in the end, only he could get away with some of the things he did. I mean… seriously… he was magnificent. Don’t let him hear that. He is a vane one, our Lord Saye.

Caroline Bingley: “Gossip is just a tool to distract people who have nothing better to do from feeling jealous of those few of us still remaining with noble hearts.” Anna Godbersen, Splendor

Nothing new in her department… same old same old; however, I would like to know for sure what happened to her.

“You will never do anything in this world without courage. It is the greatest quality of the mind next to honor.” Aristotle

Bingley: OMG! You know… this was so believable that it actually rang true. I mean… seriously, this spineless twit was such a jerk. He did whatever he jolly well pleased, with whom he pleased, whenever and where ever he pleased. When Darcy tried to talk some sense into him, Bingley talked smack to Darcy and, in his own way, told him to mind his own business. Then when things went horribly wrong and fell in the dirt [as Darcy predicted], Bingley turned and betrayed his dearest friend in a way that still has me reeling from the shock and disappointment. He totally threw Darcy under the bus [carriage if you will] and didn’t give it a second thought. Well, maybe a moment of regret but it soon faded.

IMHO [in-my-honest-opinion], what Bingley did was unforgivable and more importantly… ungentlemanly. But then Bingley wasn’t a gentleman… now was he? He was acting as the tradesman’s son that he always was. He didn’t even consider that Darcy had a gentleman’s code of honor to uphold. To Bingley, an inconvenience or a bit of trouble could always be taken care of by throwing money at it. And he figured that Darcy had a boatload of money and a family with a lot of influence that could quell any gossip/scandal. He just knew that Darcy could afford to silence the wolf at the door. Our author brought out several thoughts regarding Bingley that I had not thought of or considered before. I was really amazed at the psychological makeup of Bingley.

Later, Bingley wanted to act like nothing had happened and asked Darcy what he should do regarding his future. Really?? Are you freaking serious? I would be more than happy to tell that back-stabbing-twit just what he could do with his future. But he didn’t ask me. He then attempted to go back to Longbourn, find his angel and make nice. If I had been Jane, I would have kicked him from here all the way back to London. However, Jane is nicer than I am and she had her own way of dealing with Mr. Bingley. Jane, you go girl!! She was magnificent. What a conclusion for her. I approve completely.

At 32-chapters, there were still a few questions left dangling. I was glad to hear about what happened with Anne de Bourgh… that was a hoot. I certainly didn’t see that coming. Who knew??? I did wonder about the future of the other Bennet sisters. Nor was anything mentioned about our dear Colonel, or Georgiana and I was left bereft for knowledge regarding their futures. What about Caroline? I sort of have an idea about her, but still, it would have been nice to know for sure. Thanks to the author for the ARC. The views expressed are my own. This is one I plan to purchase and add to my personal library. It is worthy of rereading. I loved this story and can highly recommend it.

1st read 1-21-18 ~ 1-22-18 [unpub on fanfiction site]
2nd read 7-29-19 ~ 8-19-19
Profile Image for Meredith (Austenesque Reviews).
997 reviews345 followers
January 9, 2020
What If Loose Lips Had Half of London and Meryton Believing Darcy and Elizabeth were Engaged?


TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation

TIME FRAME: Begins just before Mr. Darcy’s Hunsford Proposal

SYNOPSIS: Behaving quite responsibly and pragmatically, Mr. Darcy departs Rosings briefly to prepare his relations (and garner their support) for his impending engagement to Elizabeth Bennet, in addition to visiting Longbourn and seeking Mr. Bennet’s blessing. And both of the Fitzilliam and Bennet relations are “very industrious in setting the news abroad” not knowing that Mr. Darcy is “the last man in the world [Elizabeth] could ever be prevailed on to marry!” Elizabeth is worked on by Mr. Darcy’s well-intentioned relations to no avail, but it looks like the answer Mr. Darcy seeks lies with Mr. Bingley and his anticipated trip to Pemberley… Will bringing Elizabeth and Jane to Pemberley change her unfavorable opinion of him? Will Mr. Bingley forgive Darcy for his mistaken advice about Jane and join him in Pemberley?

WHAT I LOVED:

- An Honorable Mr. Darcy: While he had good intentions, Mr. Darcy handled things quite badly and officiously, and ran the risk of ruining Elizabeth’s reputation in the process. But it is easy to forgive Mr. Darcy his sins when you see all he does to try and make it right – all the plans he makes and the unthinkable things he is willing to put himself through to take care of Elizabeth and others. I loved seeing the ardency of Mr. Darcy’s love for Elizabeth in this story. And I was quite ready to swoon when he made comments that left no question of his devotion and desire for her…

- Elizabeth’s Evolution: I love it when we get to witness Elizabeth gradually falling in love with Mr. Darcy – especially when it takes place at Pemberley! *sigh* I really appreciated the depiction of Elizabeth’s journey to love in this story – how she first grew to understand Mr. Darcy better and found pleasure in his stimulating and surprisingly pleasant conversation, and then eventually grew to admire him and wish to spend more time with him. I especially loved the turn of events that prompted Elizabeth to be unapologetic and demonstrative about her love and wishes. Elizabeth Bennet, you are my hero.

- Thoughtful Character Deviations: One unique twist to this premise was that it had a bad, or troublesome, Mr. Bingley! And while I am a fan of Bingleys 💕, I do recognize the plausibility of this character deviation – Mr. Bingley is impressionable and easily swayed in Pride and Prejudice. This is the road Mr. Bingley could travel down if he was more influenced by less reputable friends than the mature and responsible Mr. Darcy. His actions and inactions felt very believable and I applaud Ms. D’Orazio for realizing and exploring this unique character deviation! (Side Note: I really loved Jane Bennet and her character development in this story!)

- Romantic Moments: Two words. The. Roof. *swoon* Gah!! Such a heart-stopping and exquisitely romantic scene! I absolutely adored every minute of it. But that wasn’t all – there were plenty of adorable, devoted, funny, and stirring scenes between Darcy and Elizabeth that brought on smiles, sighs, and heart flutters. Ms. D’Orazio has quite the talent for creating memorable and moving scenes between Darcy and Elizabeth filled with palpable emotion.

- Viscount Saye and the Fitzwilliams: A favorite original character of many, Viscount Saye (Colonel Fitzwilliam’s older brother) is absolutely a riot – deliciously irreverent and meddlesome, with no filter and a penchant for mischief. I loved every one of his scenes and enjoyed his interactions, silent observations, and oh-so-helpful tips! (I think Saye might need his own story one day!) And I loved this portrayal of the rest of the Fitzwilliam clan – it was fun to see their well-meaning attempts to help Darcy win Elizabeth over.

WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:

Not. A. Thing. 😉

CONCLUSION:

Rumors and reputations, mistaken assumptions and atoning for past mistakes, interfering family members and false friends – A Lady’s Reputation is a compelling and cleverly crafted Pride and Prejudice variation that traverses a unique set of obstacles for Darcy and Elizabeth. Definitely one I highly recommend!

Note: For those who may not have read Ms. D’Orazio’s previous works – The Best Part of Love and A Short Period of Exquisite Felicity – because of their reputation for high angst, 😩😭 A Lady’s Reputation might be a great story for you to try as it is doesn’t have the same measure of anguish and turbulence that these others do. It is more on the moderate-angst side. 😨

Austenesque Reviews
Profile Image for J. W. Garrett.
1,736 reviews133 followers
January 22, 2018
http://meryton.com/aha/index.php?show...

When you are rich and powerful, no one will challenge you to your face or give you a chance to explain yourself. All the whispers are behind your back. You are left with no means of clearing your own name. And after a while you realize there is no point in even attempting to do so. No one wants the truth. All anyone wants is the chance to add more fuel to the fires of gossip. The whispers become so loud that sometimes you think you will drown in them.”
― Amanda Quick, Ravished

Rating: MA: adult themes: Nothing explicit, but discussions of those in society that lean toward licentious living and debauchery.

I have just finished this WIP and I must say… I don’t know what to say. I loved this story and the further I got into the story the better I liked it. OMG! I loved the interactions between Jane and Lizzy. They were so cute in their sisterly bond. Man… that was good. It seemed that Lizzy was more stubborn and angry then even in canon. She lambasted Darcy from morning until dark and to all his relations as well as hers. Darcy was more controlling and unthinking that usual. Everything he put his hands to fell apart and there was nothing he could say or do that would assuage his mistakes in the eyes of Miss Elizabeth Bennet. To her he was the worst of men.

Darcy: “A true gentleman is one that apologizes anyways, even though he has not offended a lady intentionally. He is in a class all of his own because he knows the value of a woman’s heart.” Shannon L. Adler

Our author was so creative and just when I wanted to slit my own throat as well as Elizabeth’s… things changed. That, for me, was when the story really picked up. Because then… we had Lizzy and Darcy working together toward a goal. Oh, that was delicious. I love them together and it became a bit steamy and sensual as their relationship progressed.

“Always remember… Rumours are carried by haters, spread by fools, and accepted by idiots.” Ziad K. Abdelnour, Economic Warfare: Secrets of Wealth Creation in the Age of Welfare Politics

I loved Lord and Lady Matlock and Darcy’s two cousins… the Fitzwilliam brothers, Lord Saye and our dear Colonel. I simply adored these guys. Their banter reminded me so much of my own brothers. I loved their camaraderie and their love and concern for Darcy. They simply made this story happen. Lord Saye was also a big influence in quelling the rampant gossip that was circulating in London. He was such a scream. I would not want him on my bad side. I loved him as much as I did our dear Colonel. Didn’t expect that to happen. However, in the end, only he could get away with some of the things that he did. I mean… seriously… he was magnificent. Don’t let him hear that… he is quite vane, our dear Lord Saye.

Caroline Bingley: “Gossip is just a tool to distract people who have nothing better to do from feeling jealous of those few of us still remaining with noble hearts.” Anna Godbersen, Splendor

Nothing new in her department… same old same old; however, I would like to know for sure what happened to her.

“You will never do anything in this world without courage. It is the greatest quality of the mind next to honor.” Aristotle

Bingley: OMG! You know… this was so believable that it rang true. I mean… this spineless twit was such a jerk. He did whatever he jolly well pleased, with whom he pleased, and whenever he pleased. When Darcy tried to talk some sense into him, Bingley talked smack with Darcy, then when things went horribly wrong and fell in the dirt [as Darcy predicted], Bingley turned and betrayed his dearest friend. Later he wanted to act like nothing had happened and asked Darcy what he should do regarding his future. Really??? He then attempted to go and find his angel and make nice. I would have kicked him from here to London. Jane, you go girl!! She was magnificent. What a conclusion for her. I approve completely.

At over 30 chapters, plus an epilogue… there were a few questions left dangling. I was glad to hear about what happened with Anne de Bourgh… that was a hoot. I was curious and certainly didn’t see that coming. Who knew??? I did wonder about the future of the other Bennet sisters. Nor was anything mentioned about our dear Colonel, or Georgiana and I was left bereft for knowledge regarding their futures. What about Caroline? I sort of have an idea about her, but still, it would have been nice to know for sure. Altogether, I loved this.
Profile Image for Tandie.
1,563 reviews249 followers
September 22, 2022
This was just excellent! So good, that I have a smile on my face still. I’m definitely going to look at this author’s other books. The witty repartee was fabulous! I had a very tiny quibble with the way Bingley was done; his villainy and disreputability were a bit over the top. I was expecting an opium addiction or raging alcoholism to explain his behavior, but he was merely influenced by a bad lot of friends. Overall, still a 5 star read. The audiobook was nicely narrated, and I’m sure I’ll revisit this story soon.
Profile Image for Nicole Barton Sasser.
563 reviews2 followers
March 22, 2023
Status: Read August 21-25, 2019

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Review: Fun read, I ❤ Lord Saye!

Edition Read:

A Lady's Reputation
by A. D'Orazio
Kindle Edition, First Edition, 472 pages
Published July 29, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing
ASIN: B07VF31C8M
[ kindle unlimited ]

Reputation is everything...

“Mr. Darcy, I am eager to hear your explanation for the fact that quite a few people believe we are engaged.”

IT STARTS WITH a bit of well-meant advice. Colonel Fitzwilliam suggests to his cousin Darcy that, before he proposes to Elizabeth Bennet in Kent, perhaps he ought to discuss his plans with their families first.

WHAT NEITHER MAN could have predicted however was that Lord Matlock would write the news to his sister, or that Viscount Saye would overhear and tell his friends, or that his friends might slip a little and let their friends know as well. The news spreads just as quickly through Hertfordshire once Mrs Bennet opens the express Mr Bennet receives from Mr Darcy, and in a matter of days, it seems like everyone knows that Mr Darcy has proposed marriage to Elizabeth Bennet.

Everyone, that is, except Elizabeth herself.

HER REFUSAL IS quick and definite—until matters of reputation, hers as well as Jane’s, are considered. Then Mr Darcy makes another offer: summer at Pemberley so that Jane can be reunited with Mr Bingley and so that he can prove to Elizabeth he is not what she thinks of him. Falling in love with him is naturally impossible…but once she knows the man he truly is, will she be able to help herself?
Profile Image for Ree.
1,333 reviews78 followers
June 2, 2025
Thoroughly Entertaining!
Oh my! I haven’t had such fun reading a book in a while. The story, the humour, the fun, and ohhh, Mr. Bingley! What a surprise variation for him! Even better, Lord Saye! His character is one of the best I’ve encountered in JAFF. He needs his own social media page. The banter among the Fitzwilliam brothers and Darcy is hilarious. I laughed out loud multiple times. The dialogue in general was wonderful as well. Of course, we cannot forget ODC! I loved how their love story developed through to their HEA! Beautiful touch of romance on the roof. Love the way Ms. D’Orazio writes. The love of humour and the ridiculous that comes through is delightful. Nicely edited, her attention to ensuring an absence of glaring proofreading and grammar errors is well appreciated. I can’t wait for her next book. Highly recommend this one. I wish there were 10 stars to give.

This was my favorite book of 2019 and one of my top 10 P&P variations.

Just as wonderful the second time around.—September 7, 2020

The third time read is still delightful, especially while following along with the audiobook. Lillian Rachel is fabulous. Something not mentioned previously that I so enjoy in this book is the fact that Saye and his brother the Colonel are close. Often in variations Colonel Fitzwilliam and his Viscount brother are at odds with one another. I much prefer this loving relationship. —October 10-11, 2020

February 12, 2022 - Second audiobook listen
Gosh, I love this book. It remains in my top five favourite JAFF ever. Lord Saye is laugh-out-loud funny.
Profile Image for Jan Ashton.
Author 24 books105 followers
July 29, 2019
So excited to have one of Amy D'Orazio's finest stories available to all, on Kindle, and with a gorgeous (and intriguing) cover. The book is just out today, and there's so much to say about the story, but read the blurb and tell me what you think:

“Mr. Darcy, I am eager to hear your explanation for the fact that quite a few people believe we are engaged.”

It starts with a bit of well-meant advice. Colonel Fitzwilliam suggests to his cousin Darcy that, before he proposes to Elizabeth Bennet in Kent, perhaps he ought to discuss his plans with their families first.

What neither man could have predicted however was that Lord Matlock would write the news to his sister, or that Viscount Saye would overhear and tell his friends, or that his friends might slip a little and let their friends know as well. The news spreads just as quickly through Hertfordshire once Mrs Bennet opens the express Mr Bennet receives from Mr Darcy, and in a matter of days, it seems like everyone knows that Mr Darcy has proposed marriage to Elizabeth Bennet.

Everyone, that is, except Elizabeth herself.

Her refusal is quick and definite—until matters of reputation, hers as well as Jane’s, are considered. Then Mr Darcy makes another offer: summer at Pemberley so that Jane can be reunited with Mr Bingley and so that he can prove to Elizabeth he is not what she thinks of him. Falling in love with him is naturally impossible…but once she knows the man he truly is, will she be able to help herself?
Profile Image for James S.
1,432 reviews
October 30, 2020
Beautiful love story

I particularly like how the love match was made between Lizzy and Darcy. After the bad proposal Darcy realizes what an arrogant being he has been and begins changing himself. But he doesn’t do in the privacy of his life. He is thrown into much contact with Lizzy caused by his unwarranted belief Lizzy will accept him and accidentally starts rumors of being betrothed.

So as in many variations he begins his metamorphosis. At the same time though he is trying to court Lizzy who doesn’t like him at all.

Lizzy also has changing to accomplish for herself. As she comes to know she also suffers from pride and prejudice , changes happen to her also. But she isn’t in 100% change mode because she doesn’t have love to spur her on.

It is a nice, logical emotional ride ODC are on and it not something that can be rushed. There are some new characters that are fun to learn about for we readers. Some of them are bumps in the road but most are friends or relatives that want the best ODC.

Great story, very well written. I loved the entirety of it. I recommend this book highly.
Profile Image for Talia.
970 reviews4 followers
July 31, 2019
I read this one first and could hardly put it down. Many times, I needed to stop to inform my family of what was happening. Mr Bingley is presented in the most unique way I have seen him. I like it when author's flush out our faves in different directions, positive or negatives. It was very interesting. I hope this will make it into paperback form one day so I can add it to my shelves. Loved it.
Profile Image for ana darcy.
314 reviews8 followers
October 10, 2019
5 🌟

Everybody knew of her engagement but her! XD

https://myvicesandweaknesses.wordpres...

Lately I am finding quite difficult to write reviews without spoilers. It could be because lately I am not writing many reviews on the blog as I barely have time, or maybe it is the author’s fault! Yes, you read it, the author’s fault for writing such a good book that you just want to tell people everything that is going on!

However, I will try to stop myself and just tease you with the review. I hope you like it.

Once upon a time, there was a proud gentleman who was in love with a lady who refused him… Apparently he did not get it the first time and then he decided that he would propose again but checking with his family first, and then with hers. Tiny problem: he forgot to check with her.

Elizabeth was determined to reject him (again) but she then considered her reputation and her sisters’ and gave him an opportunity to “court” her… in Pemberley!! Elizabeth did it also for Jane’s sake as she was supposed to be reunited with Mr. Bingley (thankfully it did not happened… I leave it there! You will have to read the book to know more).

Elizabeth followed her sisters words “Offer your friendship to him, and I think you will be surprised where it leads you”. Elizabeth did and even if it was a bit annoying that her sister, after everything Mr. Darcy did to separate her from Mr. Bingley, recommended her to be nice to Mr. Darcy.

You can imagine what Mr. Darcy is feeling during the book: remorse, regret, guilt. Everything that he could feel, he will feel it because he is soooooo maddening in this book! but we love him anyways. You will read how much he puts on his shoulders, he blames himself or takes responsibility about anything and anyone. Jane Austen was really nice to him compared to Amy D’Orazio! Even the weather may be his fault xD However, Elizabeth and the other characters are there to make him realise that it is not his fault.

Talking about other characters in A Lady’s Reputation, I have a favourite, apart from our main protagonists, and that is Viscount Saye. He is hilarious but he is loyal. He is Darcy’s cousin, the eldest brother of Colonel Fitzwilliam who also appears in the novel and is as usual, very charming. He jokes, he teases, he is somehow a bit liberal, he is engaged to be married to a nice lady, she is a minor character but important enough to appear. Even when she does not talk, the mention of her is important as Saye is all over the place.

Let me give you another “tiny” interesting detail: in this book, Darcy never gave Elizabeth a letter defending himself of the two accusations she gave him on her rejection. She does not know about Wickham, yet.

I was not able to put the book down (in this case my kindle) until I finished the most spread engagement-not-engagement on the history of JAFF! I highly recommend the book, it may be that you want the HEA to happen quicker than it does but everything is worth it.
Profile Image for Barbara K..
757 reviews21 followers
September 29, 2023
September 27, 2023 reread.

October 5, 2019 review:

I enjoyed this immensely. It's yet another JAFF, a Pride and Prejudice variation, but funny, intensely romantic, unique, entertaining, and a satisfying read. I loved how the characters were portrayed, especially the Earl of Matlock and both his sons. Lord Saye is a crack-up. I think the portrayal of Bingley here is interesting as well, though I wanted to shake him or strangle him through most of the story. I've always seen him as somewhat spineless and too easily swayed. I mean, even in the original P&P, I could never help thinking, if you're in love, you're in love. You don't care what your friends or family think. He was rather sad in this variation, when not infuriating, but not in a way that was easy to forgive. Poetic justice in the end. Very interesting variation on this beloved story. Highly, highly recommended.

The first third or half of this one had me laughing a lot!
Profile Image for Joana Starnes.
Author 21 books247 followers
September 26, 2019
I fell in love with Amy D’Orazio’s writing style after ‘The Best Part of Love’ that had me on tenterhooks and played havoc with every feeling. ‘A Lady’s Reputation’ is in a very different vein. It’s light-hearted and highly entertaining, and answers my love of scenarios that compel Elizabeth and Mr Darcy to spend time together and learn to go beyond their misunderstandings. It was such fun to see Mr Darcy being put through the paces thanks to his own family and friends, who turn out to be even more gabby and frustrating than Mrs Phillips and Mrs Bennet (no mean feat, that). Lord Saye was an absolute delight and even more of a scene-stealer than Colonel Fitzwilliam (which was no mean feat either). A great read and a great premise. Loved it!
Profile Image for Shifra ♕.
244 reviews74 followers
December 27, 2020
A very logical and sound plan to ease Lizzy’s acceptance into his family and society before he proposes has Darcy enlisting the aide of the Fitzwilliams towards bringing Lizzy into the higher circles and Darcy asking for Lizzy’s hand from her father to show due respect, however only two may keep a secret if one of them is dead.
Neither the Bennets nor the Fitzwilliams have the precedent of being discreet and this is no exception!

The word of Mr Darcy offering for an unknown country upstart with a paltry 1000 pound dowry, Miss Elizabeth Bennet, and them being engaged is the kind of cannon fodder that is ideal to London ton gossip and soon it is common knowledge, and we get to watch how quickly the London gossip mill turns! Lizzy is the last to know!

I was laughing with, though mostly at, poor Mr. Darcy as all his best laid plans went astray to comedic proportions. He is trying so hard , the poor dear, during the whole story trying to right things in impossible circumstances, bless his soul! He bears it remarkably!
description
Now her reputation irrevocably engaged, Lizzy comes to a difficult realization that her acceptance or refusal could potentially affect not only her future prospects, but that of her sisters and even her beloved Gardiners.
description

With Darcy out to prove himself worthy of a women worthy of being pleased, and the comical aide of JAFF’s favorite plot device, the Fitzwilliams, wacky hijinks will ensue, surprising villains will arise, and heartfelt romance will be had.

Bingley is the baddie in this, well kind of! His faults are exploited in his weakness and tendency to be influenced by his companions! He stil comes off as a puppy who was just kicked to much!
description
The poor dear is heartbroken over Jane and due to it pushes Darcy away and takes up shop with a real rake and emulates that scoundrels behavior!
description

What I enjoyed:
-It draws you in right away, I was instantly hooked! It is a very plausible deviation, no suspense of disbelief required! A rare feat in JAFF indeed!
-Darcy is besotted;
“Mr Bennet is one of the principal landowners in that area. His was not
the finest estate,” Darcy forced another smile, “but inarguably, he had the
most beautiful daughters.”

witty;
“Mrs Reynolds was rather unreserved in her commendation of you, sir.
In the words of my aunt, the good lady gave you something of a flaming
character.”
Seriously, he replied, “It is good to know she performed well. I shall
have to remember to supplement her wages accordingly.”

It took a moment for Elizabeth to recognize the unexpected jest for what
it was, and she laughed.”

and constant.

-Viscount Saye just steals the scene every time ! I wish he existed in all JAFF works! I console myself with visitation rights anytime I read Amy D'Orazio.
“FITZWILLIAM FAMILY FRACAS!”
description
-Lord Henry of Matlock is akin to the male Lady Catherine, but instead of trying to get Lizzy to stay away from Darcy, confronts her almost as harshly but to marry him! I loved the flip of that.

What Displeased Me:
Drawing a blank! It was very good, though I will say it is missing something in its air and manner as Miss Bingley would say.
Perhaps a bit of that compelling angst and substance. I would group it as comparing a great romantic comedy like ‘When Harry Met Sally’ to an epic like ‘Gone with the Wind’.
Both accomplished what it meant to, but they cant be appreciated as equals, as one makes you feel the lows and highs to incredible depth and the other makes you laugh and aww and not particularly move you beyond that.
Thus I respectfully withhold the full 5, but bestow with my compliments a 4.


Conclusion:
One of my favorite JAFF's, and I just finished reading it for the second time, still great!

Author is well known in JAFF for being a reliable source of genuine good JAFF. Her work is always pleasing and light, but this is my favorite of hers!

I measure the quality of a JAFF by three factors, as follows;

1. Did I feel the characters acted true to Austen's character framework (allowing for changed circumstance and scenario to offer some leeway)? Yes
2. Was I engaged during the reading and not bored? Yes
3. Was the writing compelling/ intelligent and was there sufficient interaction/dialogue between the main characters?
Yes
Profile Image for Kim.
832 reviews1 follower
April 27, 2022
This was a fun story overall. Darcy and Elizabeth have their happily ever after once she agrees to go to Pemberley and sees Darcy in a better light. Wickham is absent once the militia leaves Meryton, so no Lydia/Wickham storyline. Darcy’s cousin Viscount Saye has an active role in just about everything and his character is mischievous but fun. I was surprised at Bingley’s actions and the outcome. Though Lady Catherine’s plan was not as diabolical as she thought it was.
Profile Image for Christina.
Author 14 books326 followers
August 11, 2019
What happens when a smitten Darcy considers his future with the delightful Miss Elizabeth Bennet—and thinks that before he asks her for her hand, it might be beneficial to address any objections to her lack of fortune or connection with his illustrious relations...? And then when that obstacle is overcome, decides he should ask her father for his blessing as well? With so many informed of Darcy’s intentions, loose lips are sure to sink ships, and before even Elizabeth knows of his desires, half the ton is buzzing about Darcy’s betrothal. Of course when Elizabeth hears she is attached to the last man in the world she would ever want to marry, she assumes there must be some misunderstanding that can be easily remedied. After more such intelligence reaches her, she realizes that if she denies the betrothal, not only her reputation would be jeopardized but also Darcy’s. When Darcy finally realizes his clumsy mistake, and they are thrown together more, might she begin to see him as the gentleman he truly is?
“A Lady’s Reputation”, Amy D’Orazio’s third novel, is as delicious as we expect with characters from canon who we know and love as well as a few new faces. D’Orazio’s invention of Darcy’s cousin, the handsome and charming Viscount Saye, reappears, playfully poking and prodding as Darcy discovers how to woo Elizabeth as she deserves. Saye, an unrepentant gossip, though one of Darcy’s closest confidantes, must be vigorously warned to not add to the London gossips’ verve but Saye will do as he likes—and is always quick with a witty response, no matter Darcy’s mien: “If you do not lean back in the next four seconds,” said Saye calmly, “I am going to kiss you, and then you will be plagued by the sorrowful realization that the last lips on your own were not hers but mine.”
Fortunately Darcy does learn how to properly woo the woman he loves with beautiful, even madcap, moments at Pemberley. “Every day, I fall in love with you, and every night, I sleep, certain that my attachment to you cannot grow further—until a new day dawns, and I am love’s Fool once more.” How could Elizabeth resist such a man? #Swoon

If you are looking for an engaging book that will leave you with a happy heart, make sure to add “A Lady’s Reputation” to your summer reading. Romantic, inventive, and amusing—everything an Austenesque novel should be!
899 reviews70 followers
August 27, 2019

"Where do I begin - To tell the story of how great a love can be..."(Love Story by Andy Williams)

Oh my goodness, where do I begin to describe the feelings that coursed through me while reading this angst-filled, laugh-out-load, want to smack someone up the side of the head (or take them out at the knees), absolutely heart melting starry-eyed novel? I don't think I will be able to do it justice, but I will try.

First, cue the music. You know the kind that slowly builds the tension when you know it is not going to end well. But then a sliver of light and laughter appears to break that tension...Lord Saye. Have I mentioned how much I love this man? But I digress.

"Fitzwilliam Family Furore...I challenge you to say it twenty times fast." (quote from the book)

Darcy, as we know from the book description, has taken advice from Colonel Fitzwilliam to first discuss his plan to propose to Elizabeth Bennet with his family. However, in doing so, a snowball rolling downhill is the end result, especially when it hits a roadblock...Elizabeth Bennet herself! Now, I had to keep putting the book down after each chapter as this was all happening...like a suspenseful movie, I was peeking through my fingers. Once I got past the disaster, I could not put the book down. Have I mentioned how much I love the book cover?

Second, how much I loved Mr. Darcy and his road to redemption. Oh, the poignancy of those scenes! His willingness to improve and humble himself along with his absolute determination to make things right for Elizabeth, Jane and Bingley. Don't get me started on Bingley though.

"I cannot deny that I have lost my heart, my mind, and my soul to her, and deuced if it is not the most splendid thing I have ever done." (quote from the book)

But Mr. Darcy is not the only one who must look deep inside himself. Elizabeth, and to some degree Jane, both have their own journeys to go through. Elizabeth has much to learn, not only about Darcy, but herself.

"His opinion of her suddenly mattered a great deal." (quote from the book)

Needless to say, but I will anyway, I loved this story! The twists and turns sprinkled throughout added a whole new perspective as Elizabeth and Darcy climb to new heights!
Profile Image for Elin Eriksen.
Author 24 books158 followers
August 9, 2019
Pride and Prejudice variation

Well written story with a unique plot.

Circumstances made the betrothal of Mr Darcy and Miss Elizabeth widely known, before the blessed event had taken place, which in Elizabeth's preference, would be never...
Loved the development of ODC's relationship, slow-paced, believable and romantic. It felt like it was Elizabeth's imperfections that was expounded and she learned a few lessons, the hard way.
Another one that had his character traits expounded was Bingley. He was not so much the villain but the author created a plausible scenario of what could have been the outcome of the weaknesses in his character. It was an intriguing and creative twist to this story.
Lord Saye was the highlight of all the characters and had me laughing out loud on several occasions, even once in coalition with Mrs Bennet.

I have a couple of reservations though and I struggled to decide if it was 4 or 5 star read, to me...
I got a little impatient at times, it moved a little slow.
I am generally not fond of the major setback when things are settling in and it feels like it is time to wrap up. It has to be 100% believable for me to swallow it raw and in this book there was an incident that was a tad weak. I decided to be generous though. When in doubt, I usually round up and therefore chose to be generous rather than stingy.

Recommend!
Profile Image for Madenna U.
2,147 reviews1 follower
October 12, 2021
This book is what happens if everyone knows that Darcy is to propose to Elizabeth before he actually does it plus what if Bingley was an arse. I really enjoyed this tale of how our happy couple comes together even though Elizabeth protests much louder than usual, if not to much.

As always, the secondary characters in this author's stories are the same. At this point I think the Viscount deserves his own story. I absolutely love him.
Profile Image for Gail Frisby.
471 reviews13 followers
January 26, 2022
Loved it

Great story,I had read it on a f2f site don't remember which but I had to read it again. The plot was great I was so glad to see The Bingleys get their just rewards, especially Charles. I loved Says who could not love him he was the joy of this story.
Profile Image for Talia.
970 reviews4 followers
September 12, 2021
One of my new favorite JAFF books. Bingley! I love it. Well-written, clever, and fun. I think most people will love it as much as I do.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 149 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.