Admittedly...this book is very, very funny. Yet I have a beef with it. For hilarity alone, 5 stars. For political views, even giving Kane the benefit of the doubt...2 and 1/2 stars.
The tone here is very dry, satirical humor, and Kane nails it. AVATCFUP is like The Office meets The Avengers. The heroes complain and whine; they bitch about their salaries and benefits. They have odd quirks and behave in ridiculous ways. The dialogue is quite funny, and the characters, while absurd, have enough foibles to seem human...ish.
The premise is that in a near future, superheroes are neither vigilantes nor government funded. Instead, they work for private corporations that then have contracts with local and state governments. They defend their territory for profit while minding the bottom line. And the superhero corporations also compete with each other for contracts and staff. In this particular instance, the Corporation for UltraHuman Protection (or CUP) manages to "steal" a contract from another corporation to protect the Bronx. And it just so happens that a giant egg spaceship that came through a rift in space is poised over Yankee stadium and possibly about to release a horde of aliens to take over the world. As part of their legally binding contract, will CUP be able to stop them with minimum loss of human life and property damage? Or will we all wake up dead tomorrow? You'll have to listen to find out, as this is an audiobook only release. The voiceover actress gives an outstanding performance...perfect comedic timing, great voices, very likable. She deserves 5 stars.
So, to my political beef. Andrea Vernon, the main character, is a very smart college grad who seems to be aimlessly drifting without focus or career plans. She's hired as the administrative assistant (right-hand woman, really) to the President of the company...a crotchety little old Asian woman from down South who runs the company with an iron hand, Southern wit and a mind to profitability. Andrea's brother works for the New York state government…I believe he is a state senator, and he believes that the corporations should not be trusted to run security and protection for society. Essentially, CUP is a private police force against supervillains. Or, like a private military contractor such as Triple Canopy today. Corporate mercenaries, basically. Andrea’s brother is portrayed as a pompous, somewhat naïve buffoon. And while CUP is satirized and Kane gets a lot of comedic mileage out of tongue-in-cheek efforts to save humanity while at the same time being mindful of administrative responsibilities (so you saved the school, but did you file the TPS report afterwards?), in the end CUP is portrayed as an effective and heroic team defending the country at the risk of their own lives.
In our day, with a President who wants to dismantle government in all its aspects and has blatant disregard for regulations and science, to make fun of government as an administrative morass versus the delusion of corporate “efficiency” is both inaccurate and morally indefensible. For a long time now, as right wing think tanks and funders like the Koch brothers have promoted, the Republican party has sought to discredit the capabilities of government to help the people. This can be found, for example, in the techniques they have used to discredit Social Security and portray it as collapsing with the goal in mind of converting all retirement funding to the stock market…and as a result a belief that government “won’t be there for you” has been instilled in people so the majority no longer demand it or think it’s even capable of it. We must turn to the “free market” for solutions to all of life’s problems. The shift has been made through both propaganda and specific efforts to weaken, defund and hobble government’s ability to oversee corporate malfeasance.
I’m willing to give Kane some benefit of the doubt in that there is always an ironic tone to the corporate humor. The playing off of cost/benefit analysis against human life and the secret, possibly alien or demonic corporate board behind CUP. But in the end, CUP agents do act selflessly and risk their lives to save humanity. So…the corporate way must be best after all? It rankled me at times. Perhaps Kane took this route simply as comedic expedient. Perhaps he’s not a political conservative. If so, I hope if he does another book in this series, he thinks a bit more about the real ramifications of privatization. Jennifer Government is a good example of a novel that addresses privatization of government services in a way that is actually considerate rather than glib. Swipe your credit card if you’d like help from the FBI to find your missing child. After all, won’t the search be more efficient if it’s for-profit?