It seems to me that in recent years I became a bit allergic to the classical american self help philosophy. It could somehow affect my reception of this book.
What I didn't like:
- Definition of success. Money, fame, leadership, legacy. Although there are moments where Proctor softly tries to point out that there are other applications of his principles than just to make money, I couldn't shake the feeling that it was a bit artificial. My reception was - it's actually all about making money! If you're an average person that has a normal life, hobby and family then basically you're a looser. It doesn't matter if you're happy or not. Your potential is hidden and unused. Your destiny has not been fulfilled. The life battle has been lost.
- Spirituality. Well, to be honest, I had to put the book down quite often. The reason was always the same - references to God, soul, universe and our destiny. Tough reading for atheists...
- Absolute lack of an outside American perspective. Everyone has equal opportunities, everyone can succeed. Well, I think that genes, upbringing, culture or place of birth in the world may have some importance here...
What I liked:
- If you have a particular and concrete goal (in business, health, sport etc.) AND you're looking for a large dose of motivation AND you're not afraid of abstractions and indirect language AND you put away all of those God / spirituality / universe / destiny aspects THEN this is actually a really valuable book! Most of the conclusions and messages are fine, healthy and helpful.
- Chapter about creativity. I believe this is the only place where author gave a practical advice - how to awake our creativity in different areas on multiple layers. I truly enjoyed it.
To sum it up, if you treat this book just as a tool to accomplish the goals you have (but not as a life philosophy) then I can recommend it. Otherwise, IMO there are better sources on being happy and successful in your life.