I Have a Lot to Say About This Book!
So, I've read the first three books in this series and haven't been too terribly impressed. After finishing this one, I just HAD to write a review and get everything off my chest.
I'll start out by saying this will not only be the last book in this series that I'll read, but it's going to be the last Charlotte Byrd book I'll ever read, and here's why. Firstly, something that's majorly irritated me from book one was all the inconsistencies. The sheer amount of things that Charlotte seems to forget she's written (unless she's purposely trying to make her characters look forgetful to the point of being amnesiacs, or just like they're really stupid) is staggering. Here are a few of the many instances.
During one scene, Nicholas gives Olive her first "paycheck" of $38,000. She holds the check and thinks to herself that this is the most money she's ever held. Um, did Charlotte forget what she'd written in her previous books? This whole thing started out with Olive receiving a check for roughly $176,000, which was what she needed to payoff her student loans. Then later, she asks Nicholas for $50,000 to pay off a debt her mother owed to a loan shark because she thought they'd kidnapped and were going to kill her mom if she didn't pay it. These were pretty big plot points. How do you forget them?
MAYBE the argument could be made that the time In-between writing the books in this series caused her to forget. But you'd have to go years in-between books for that to really be plausible unless Charlotte suffers from short-term memory loss. The next example is onlyna few pages apart, so that excuse won't fly.
There's a point in the book where Olive's brother Owen goes missing. She calls Nicholas in a panic, and he goes and picks her up. She tells him that Owen didn't come home last night and that she even called the teacher he had been having a relationship with while incarcerated, but that woman never responded to her calls.
A few pages later, which was mere minutes for the characters, they're in Olive's apartment going through Owen's belongings, and Nicholas asks Olive if she knows the teacher's name. She says no, Owen never told her. Nicholas proceeds to look through a bunch of notebooks from one of Owen's bags and comes across a phone number and email written in the margins. The email is issued by a local college, so he pulls up the college's website, and they start looking through the listings from the English department since that's what the teacher taught. Olive suddenly points to a woman at the bottom of the list and says, "That's her. That's Gabby." Just minutes before she claimed to not have been told the woman's name, so...WTF?
Secondly, are the things which plain old don't make sense. For example, *SPOILER ALERT* Olive's mom tells her she's adopted. How'd she afford to adopt a kid when we're told Olive's mom has only ever worked minimum wage jobs? How'd she get approved for adoption when she was an alcoholic druggie whose husband would disappear for weeks and even months at a time? Nobody would give her a kid!
The last reason really rubbed me the wrong way, and is why I won't be reading anymore of Charlotte's books. I'm reading along and come to a scene where Olive is trying to get her mind off of some fights she's been having with her brother and Nicholas. She tries watching TV and it doesn't help so she decides to read. What follows is four pages of absolutely unnecassary info because it doesn't further the plot or reveal any important information about the characters. Being unnecassary isn't what caused me to be so off put. It's that the entire four pages were, essentially, jumping up on the soap box, extolling the virtues of indie writers (of which the author is one), and how much better their writing and especially sex scenes are. Her character's inner monologue reveals that she's re-reading (for like the tenth time) Charlotte Byrd's 'Lavish Lies.' Then Charlotte panders for fan engagement by having her character think, 'if you find a favorite author, make sure to write to her and look her up on social media...she will likely even have a Facebook group for you to join.'
Then she has her character go on to think, 'Charlotte Byrd is probably one of my favorite authors, not just indie but of all time.' Then Charlotte uses her character to brag about what a good writer she is (a whole paragraph was dedicated to this), and then actually has the character quote her (the author's) actual fricking blog! "The point of language is to convey exactly what you mean to keep the story going, and that's exactly what I aim to do with each of my sentences."
Oh, the irony! How is it "keeping the story going" when you spend four pages proseltyzing about how great indie writers, especially yourself, are through your character? It was an embarrassing, narcissistic, self agrandizing speed bump! The time would've been better spent editing out the misspelled and misused words her books are riddled with!