3.5 🌟
Before we begin, a little disclaimer: I am part of the Spellhacker Launch Crew and I was provided with an e-ARC of the book via Edelweiss+, but I want to make sure that you know that neither of these two circumstances have affected my rating nor will influence my review in any way.
Usually, when I start writing a book review I know what I am going to say, more or less, and I already know what rating I gave to the book on Goodreads. This time is different, because ever since I have finished the book I have been thinking about it, without really knowing my feelings about it. It was a quite pleasant but somewhat weird journey. I have settled on a 3.5 out of 5 stars by now, but it took me forever to decide.
Let’s start by saying that I don’t think I have ever read anything similar to Spellhacker, genre wise. It is a blend of sci-fi and fantasy and I knew that before diving into the book, but I didn’t know what to expect.
The first thing I can say about the book is that in the beginning, the main character Diz is unsufferable. She is exactly what an angsty teenager is like in my mind. Not that I am that much older than her, but sometimes her reasoning was so childish I felt like I could be her grandmother. She is a very needy and angry person, who snaps at everyone if things don’t go as she wants them to go.
The problem is: she gets angry when people do things she doesn’t want them to do, even though she does not tell them not to do said things. For example, the main thing she is pissed about is the fact that her friends are moving to another city without her. Diz could go with them, but doesn’t want to and she wants her friends to stay, but she never tells them. One of the characters actually asks Diz to tell them to stay and Diz doesn’t say a single word. I mean, I get that. I really do, I am the first one who does not tell other people what bothers me, but you can’t stay angry at them if they don’t read your mind.
In the first part, this trait of Diz’s personality was overdone, in my opinion. If it had been a little less stressed, I would have enjoyed this book a lot more, because it is actually one of the few complaints I have about it.
I think it is also because I had loved Nax (the main character from M.K. England’s other novel The Disasters) so so so so so much. He was one of my favourite characters from the book and I was expecting to love Diz just as much. It is probably my fault, because you should not compare characters from two different books, but sadly that is what happened.
During the course of the book, anyway, Diz has grown up and softened a little bit and that I very much appreciate.
On the other hand, I have loved all Diz’s friends. My favourite was definitely Remi, the love interest in the story. They are non binary and, obviously, since the author themself is non binary, it was perfectly written. It is very well woven into the story, without making a big deal out of it, and I always appreciate that in a YA novel or in a novel in general.
There were also many other LGBT+ characters and it was never shown as something strange or out of the ordinary, as so many times happens in literature. It should always be this easy and I want to give the biggest shout out to M.K. England for always knowing how to amazingly insert LGBT+ characters, without making their queerness the focus of the plot. Thank you so much, it is so beautiful to witness.
I also love how the main cast was so diverse in every sense of the word and how they were all different in attitude and personality and yet they were a perfect portrait of friendship. The only thing that bothered me was how many times it was underlined that one of them was rich and the other three were not. Diz spends an enormous amount of time at being bitter because Ania is a rich girl, even though Ania never does anything to make her friends feel like they are not worth her time or whatever Diz thinks. Diz should just calm down a little bit and aknowledge that everyone is different and that not all the world is against her.
Just the biggest corporation in her futuristic world, that is.
The world builing was a little bit difficult for me to get into, but when I got used to it I could recognise it was really well thought out and I loved the science and magic blend, even though at the beginning I was really confused on how magic worked. After a while I got really invested in it and I have also created a tag on the different kinds of magic.
The plot was very interesting, but I have predicted almost all the plot twists. That is not uncommon for me, I tend to guess from the beginning how some things are going to end up happening, but probably in this case some of them were really predictable for everyone. If you read the book and you don’t guess, let me know so that I can update my review.
All in all, I would still recommend this book to people who are looking for an entertaining read, but The Disasters will forever be in my heart. I would also recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a genre-crossing novel and to people who love reading diverse books. If you love heists, very YA plots and creative world buildings, I am sure you will enjoy this book more than I did.