What do you think?
Rate this book
Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge
Seven years after Jacob Marley and the three ghosts of Christmas changed Ebenezer’s life, Scrooge has a problem. He’s given away most of his money and brightened many lives, restored churches, and made London workhouses better for those living and working inside. If only all of that made him feel better about his life…
Ebenezer is plagued with doubt. Even with all of his philanthropy, he still has questions he can’t answer. Are the scales balanced? Did he do enough good in his life to avoid Jacob Marley’s fate? And when a very special person dies, he adds another question: Why did God let it happen?
When he falls ill himself, Ebenezer’s questions take on a new desperation.
From the Cratchits to the workhouse fundraisers to nephew Fred, you’ll be reintroduced to several old friends, as well as a few new ones. With each visitor, Ebenezer tries to get closer to the answers to his questions. As the clock starts to run out, Ebenezer will need the words from an old friend to tip the scales in his favor.
Saving Ebenezer picks up on a story started by Charles Dickens in 1843 with A Christmas Carol. Christians will appreciate a heartwarming story of God's love shown in tragedy while all readers will enjoy the common points between Saving Ebenezer and the original work.
Ebenezer is plagued with doubt. Even with all of his philanthropy, he still has questions he can’t answer. Are the scales balanced? Did he do enough good in his life to avoid Jacob Marley’s fate? And when a very special person dies, he adds another question: Why did God let it happen?
When he falls ill himself, Ebenezer’s questions take on a new desperation.
From the Cratchits to the workhouse fundraisers to nephew Fred, you’ll be reintroduced to several old friends, as well as a few new ones. With each visitor, Ebenezer tries to get closer to the answers to his questions. As the clock starts to run out, Ebenezer will need the words from an old friend to tip the scales in his favor.
Saving Ebenezer picks up on a story started by Charles Dickens in 1843 with A Christmas Carol. Christians will appreciate a heartwarming story of God's love shown in tragedy while all readers will enjoy the common points between Saving Ebenezer and the original work.
92 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 12, 2019
21 people are currently reading
46 people want to read
About the author
S. Daniel Smith
9 books2 followersDan Smith is a Christian, a husband, a father, a career US Navy sailor, and freelance writer living in San Diego, CA with his family. His publishing history goes back 18 years.
He has dreamed of being a novelist since he was a boy, growing up in a small town in Southeast Kansas (Girard). That dream has become a drive that led to his recent novelette, The Dirty Campaign, and upcoming novella, Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge.
Dan can be reached by emailing him at: dan[at]navychristian.org.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
October 17, 2021
Christmas novella set seven years after The Christmas Carol.
Ebenezer Scrooge has spent seven years caring for others. Is that enough?
"I'm afraid that I've spent so much time giving out my money that I forgot about my soul."
The premise of the novella is fabulous and the author's message is beautiful. There are moments of comedy to enjoy and profound statements included. However, this Christmas tale didn't fully capture my interest.
My gratitude to the CelebrateLit for a complimentary e-copy of the novella. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Ebenezer Scrooge has spent seven years caring for others. Is that enough?
"I'm afraid that I've spent so much time giving out my money that I forgot about my soul."
The premise of the novella is fabulous and the author's message is beautiful. There are moments of comedy to enjoy and profound statements included. However, this Christmas tale didn't fully capture my interest.
My gratitude to the CelebrateLit for a complimentary e-copy of the novella. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
December 11, 2021
Although I’ve only read A Christmas Carol maybe twice in book form, I have plenty of delightful memories with this heartwarming classic, from the school play in third grade to listening to Patrick Stewart’s one-man show recording. I’ve also enjoyed various film adaptations, over the years.
When I came across Saving Ebenezer, by S. Daniel Smith, I was immediately intrigued by the synopsis. The sweet novella takes place seven years after the conclusion of the Dickens classic and includes many of the original characters, but with a twist.
Scriptural Connection
And He said to him, “Truly I say to you, today you will be with Me in Paradise.”
Luke 23:43
While this verse isn’t specifically quoted, the event is referenced, in the novella, in a significant way.
Spiritual Themes
S. Daniel Smith explores the question of the meaning of life, as Scrooge grapples with the feeling of meaninglessness, even after all of his acts of philanthropy. The author also includes an end note explaining that being a “good person” simply isn’t enough. It is clear that Jesus is the One who saves our souls.
I appreciate that, while the topic is broached in the context of mortality, the emphasis is not the fear of hell. The novella definitely discusses the afterlife, but it is also about finding meaning in this life.
What I Liked
It was such a cozy experience to step back into Scrooge’s world at Christmastime. I had a lot of fun reengaging with the familiar characters, but through a different story.
There were some clear nods to the original. For example, the novella begins with a line about someone who is definitively dead, which is the same way A Christmas Carol begins. There are also some lines, throughout, that are references to or rewording of sentences from the original. Smith also borrows some of the language (including English spellings) of the original. While it is definitely clear that Saving Ebenezer is written by a different author, there are definitely connecting threads between the two.
Thematically, S. Daniel Smith raises a very important point: doing “good” things isn’t enough to satisfy a person’s soul.
The cover is so pretty and imaginative, and really captures the feeling of the Scrooge saga.
I felt that the plotline was believable and, overall, consistent with the original.
Critique
Based on the synopsis, I had hoped to see Scrooge meet Jesus, in the sense of getting to know Him and fall in love with Him. For me, the book was a bit more intellectual, as in “Here are the facts of what Jesus did.” With that said, the book does point to the truth that we are all, ultimately, empty without Jesus. Upon reflection, I can also really see why the author wanted to emphasize what would come next for Scrooge, given that the whole “Marley and his shackles” thing is so important to the original.
Even so, the language used felt a bit “preachy” to me, by which I mean that it sounded more like I was reading a tract or sitting in church, rather than being introduced to the personal Jesus I know. While I very much enjoyed the story, it didn’t really minister you me, in particular.
Recommendation Status
Recommended with discretion for fans of the classic who already know Jesus. I would not recommend the book as an evangelistic title for nonbelievers. However, this was definitely a delightful cozy and nostalgic read.
I received a complimentary copy of the book. Opinions expressed are my own.
When I came across Saving Ebenezer, by S. Daniel Smith, I was immediately intrigued by the synopsis. The sweet novella takes place seven years after the conclusion of the Dickens classic and includes many of the original characters, but with a twist.
Scriptural Connection
And He said to him, “Truly I say to you, today you will be with Me in Paradise.”
Luke 23:43
While this verse isn’t specifically quoted, the event is referenced, in the novella, in a significant way.
Spiritual Themes
S. Daniel Smith explores the question of the meaning of life, as Scrooge grapples with the feeling of meaninglessness, even after all of his acts of philanthropy. The author also includes an end note explaining that being a “good person” simply isn’t enough. It is clear that Jesus is the One who saves our souls.
I appreciate that, while the topic is broached in the context of mortality, the emphasis is not the fear of hell. The novella definitely discusses the afterlife, but it is also about finding meaning in this life.
What I Liked
It was such a cozy experience to step back into Scrooge’s world at Christmastime. I had a lot of fun reengaging with the familiar characters, but through a different story.
There were some clear nods to the original. For example, the novella begins with a line about someone who is definitively dead, which is the same way A Christmas Carol begins. There are also some lines, throughout, that are references to or rewording of sentences from the original. Smith also borrows some of the language (including English spellings) of the original. While it is definitely clear that Saving Ebenezer is written by a different author, there are definitely connecting threads between the two.
Thematically, S. Daniel Smith raises a very important point: doing “good” things isn’t enough to satisfy a person’s soul.
The cover is so pretty and imaginative, and really captures the feeling of the Scrooge saga.
I felt that the plotline was believable and, overall, consistent with the original.
Critique
Based on the synopsis, I had hoped to see Scrooge meet Jesus, in the sense of getting to know Him and fall in love with Him. For me, the book was a bit more intellectual, as in “Here are the facts of what Jesus did.” With that said, the book does point to the truth that we are all, ultimately, empty without Jesus. Upon reflection, I can also really see why the author wanted to emphasize what would come next for Scrooge, given that the whole “Marley and his shackles” thing is so important to the original.
Even so, the language used felt a bit “preachy” to me, by which I mean that it sounded more like I was reading a tract or sitting in church, rather than being introduced to the personal Jesus I know. While I very much enjoyed the story, it didn’t really minister you me, in particular.
Recommendation Status
Recommended with discretion for fans of the classic who already know Jesus. I would not recommend the book as an evangelistic title for nonbelievers. However, this was definitely a delightful cozy and nostalgic read.
I received a complimentary copy of the book. Opinions expressed are my own.
October 12, 2019
"Tiny Tim was dead, to begin with. There was no doubt about that."
With this first line S. Daniel Smith grabbed my attention in his fan sequel to the Dickens classic 'A Christmas Carol.' Scrooge, Tiny Tim and the Spirits are a Christmas season tradition for my family. We ALWAYS watch the Muppet's adaptation of the story together, and sometimes read aloud the book itself. So, I felt compelled to read on and learn what caused Tiny Tim to die and how his death affected the rest of the family, especially Scrooge.
Smith brings out a theme from the original story that I had never considered -- that Scrooge's change from a selfish miser to a giving benefactor is motivated by a desire to earn the love of others and, more importantly, the approval of God. We all know love isn't supposed to be earned, but is it possible to earn our way to heaven? To "balance the scales" of our selfishness with acts of kindness and service?
In this age of random acts of kindness and charitable concerns, the questions Smith raises through Scrooge are valid and worth discussing. I highly recommend you read this book to see how Ebenezer answers them.
With this first line S. Daniel Smith grabbed my attention in his fan sequel to the Dickens classic 'A Christmas Carol.' Scrooge, Tiny Tim and the Spirits are a Christmas season tradition for my family. We ALWAYS watch the Muppet's adaptation of the story together, and sometimes read aloud the book itself. So, I felt compelled to read on and learn what caused Tiny Tim to die and how his death affected the rest of the family, especially Scrooge.
Smith brings out a theme from the original story that I had never considered -- that Scrooge's change from a selfish miser to a giving benefactor is motivated by a desire to earn the love of others and, more importantly, the approval of God. We all know love isn't supposed to be earned, but is it possible to earn our way to heaven? To "balance the scales" of our selfishness with acts of kindness and service?
In this age of random acts of kindness and charitable concerns, the questions Smith raises through Scrooge are valid and worth discussing. I highly recommend you read this book to see how Ebenezer answers them.
December 2, 2019
From the time of being a very little girl, "A Christmas Carol" has been my favorite Christmas story, movie and everything else. My Mother would say every year "Are you going to watch that again?" I would always reply yes, every time they show it, I will watch it. Now that I am much older (72) I still wait for it to be put on television, and have several actors that have played old Scrooge to be broadcast each year. The one thing I always questioned was his outcome. Yes the spirits managed to change an old heartless man, bitter and alone, money grubbing skinflint into someone that cared about his fellow man and made the change to help those in need and thereby melt his heart of stone. Mr. Dickens stopped there, and did not truly give old Scrooge the real key to his redemption, only his reclamation................Now to the presentation of the stories conclusion, Mr. Scrooge finds himself in another dilemma and visitation....................Finally, without spoiling the tale for others to read, I have read the whole story and the ending I truly desired. Our Mr. Scrooge gets the answer he has missed all along............20**************, He is truly born anew. Loved this Novella. Thank you for the long awaited perfect ending.
October 12, 2019
This is definitely one to buy for Christmas! Truly a lovely read.A tale full of hope and a incredible follow up to the much loved ‘A Christmas Carol’ It carries on the story perfectly as though Charles Dickens had picked up where he had just left off.It’s full of warmth,compassion and meaning.Highly recommend.Well done Dan xx
October 27, 2019
Great book
I liked the book. I recommend this book to anyone who loves this Christmas story. Familiar characters that we have come to love.
I liked the book. I recommend this book to anyone who loves this Christmas story. Familiar characters that we have come to love.
December 23, 2023
#BookReviewFriday
#2023readingchallenge
#19holidaynovella
Book Review ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
# 19 Holiday Novella
Book: Saving Ebenezer
Author: S. Daniel Smith
It’s always tricky to review a book written by someone you know, especially for me, because I will always give an honest review! Boy am I glad I enjoyed this book!! I gave it four and a half stars, and as always I round up!
This book was written by a colleague; I expressed to him that my review would be an honest one, all of my views on this story are my own.
This story is an unofficial continuation of the Charles Dickens' classic "A Christmas Carol". I didn't have time to reread the original, so I watched the 1999 version of the movie starring Patrick Stewart, which is widely considered one of the most faithful adaptations of the original book before reading this story.
I loved the concept of this book. It explored the fact that although Scrooge made significant changes to become a good person, he wouldn't ultimately be truly changed until he made the ultimate change of accepting Jesus Christ as his Lord and savior.
The book was charming, cute and a quick and easy read. In his author's note, he points out that he intended to keep the true essence of the characters and the time period and for the most part I believe he accomplished this.
I took the half star for two reasons. 1) because the charm of A Christmas Carol revolved around the three spirits and what they revealed to Scrooge, personally I didn't feel the device used in its place was as interesting or charming. 2) the point of his conversion was belabored just a tad to long in my opinion. I started to get a little antsy. Setting the scene is one thing, no need to continue to point out the same plot elements. Readers will get it.
The really good part about the book was the faith message, I'm happy to say I have so many little gems highlighted in such a tiny book! Also, I found the final messenger of his deliverance to be a significant and impactful little Easter egg.
Overall, I highly recommend this book and this author.
📸 Look at this post on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/share/fmHCDE...
#2023readingchallenge
#19holidaynovella
Book Review ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
# 19 Holiday Novella
Book: Saving Ebenezer
Author: S. Daniel Smith
It’s always tricky to review a book written by someone you know, especially for me, because I will always give an honest review! Boy am I glad I enjoyed this book!! I gave it four and a half stars, and as always I round up!
This book was written by a colleague; I expressed to him that my review would be an honest one, all of my views on this story are my own.
This story is an unofficial continuation of the Charles Dickens' classic "A Christmas Carol". I didn't have time to reread the original, so I watched the 1999 version of the movie starring Patrick Stewart, which is widely considered one of the most faithful adaptations of the original book before reading this story.
I loved the concept of this book. It explored the fact that although Scrooge made significant changes to become a good person, he wouldn't ultimately be truly changed until he made the ultimate change of accepting Jesus Christ as his Lord and savior.
The book was charming, cute and a quick and easy read. In his author's note, he points out that he intended to keep the true essence of the characters and the time period and for the most part I believe he accomplished this.
I took the half star for two reasons. 1) because the charm of A Christmas Carol revolved around the three spirits and what they revealed to Scrooge, personally I didn't feel the device used in its place was as interesting or charming. 2) the point of his conversion was belabored just a tad to long in my opinion. I started to get a little antsy. Setting the scene is one thing, no need to continue to point out the same plot elements. Readers will get it.
The really good part about the book was the faith message, I'm happy to say I have so many little gems highlighted in such a tiny book! Also, I found the final messenger of his deliverance to be a significant and impactful little Easter egg.
Overall, I highly recommend this book and this author.
📸 Look at this post on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/share/fmHCDE...
Read
October 12, 2021Why Saving Ebenezer Was My #1 Christmas Recommendation Last Year
Saving Ebenezer is one of the best novel continuations I’ve seen. While staying faithful to the original story, he gives us more and shows us where Dickens fell just a bit short of the true goal of Marley’s warning. He even brings in one tiny element of It’s a Wonderful Life, which, of course, makes perfect sense. After all, It’s a Wonderful Life is a retelling of Dickens’ A Christmas Carol.
Saving Ebenezer begins seven years after the events of A Christmas Carol. It explores giving everything away without faith behind your actions.
After an opening line that ripped out my heart, Dan then really made the whole Cratchit family come alive. He wrote with a flair and style very similar to Dickens without the excessive wordiness that Dickens employed. The characters stayed who Dickens made them to be, but they grew because that’s what people do.
Dan spoke to how the original manuscript for this went to a much darker place than he finally ended with in his final draft. Instead of that dark place, he and his editors and beta readers worked together to make sure the book ends on hope. As we discussed in the podcast, Dickens focused on hope and love, but Dan brought the element of faith in here and created a perfect trifecta right there.
Saving Ebenezer is one of the best novel continuations I’ve seen. While staying faithful to the original story, he gives us more and shows us where Dickens fell just a bit short of the true goal of Marley’s warning. He even brings in one tiny element of It’s a Wonderful Life, which, of course, makes perfect sense. After all, It’s a Wonderful Life is a retelling of Dickens’ A Christmas Carol.
Saving Ebenezer begins seven years after the events of A Christmas Carol. It explores giving everything away without faith behind your actions.
After an opening line that ripped out my heart, Dan then really made the whole Cratchit family come alive. He wrote with a flair and style very similar to Dickens without the excessive wordiness that Dickens employed. The characters stayed who Dickens made them to be, but they grew because that’s what people do.
Dan spoke to how the original manuscript for this went to a much darker place than he finally ended with in his final draft. Instead of that dark place, he and his editors and beta readers worked together to make sure the book ends on hope. As we discussed in the podcast, Dickens focused on hope and love, but Dan brought the element of faith in here and created a perfect trifecta right there.
October 17, 2021
Seven years ago Scrooge had three nightly visitors that showed him the past, present and future, and since Scrooge has worked hard to make up for his past wrongs. But despite the best doctors that money can buy and Scrooge's change of heart, Tiny Tim is dead. Could it be possible that Scrooge missed something those seven years ago?
A well done novella realistically revisits the world of Dicken's most well loved Christmas story. I liked how the author authentically imitates Dicken's style, but also makes the language more accessible for modern readers. I liked that this story brings back many of the familiar faces from the original classic.
Overall, a well written sequel to a beloved classic, it does an excellent job of staying true to the original while also daring to dive deeper and ask questions of faith and mortality. Inspiring and full of hope, this was the perfect twist on a classic. Definitely recommend, this Christmas Carol revisited!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A well done novella realistically revisits the world of Dicken's most well loved Christmas story. I liked how the author authentically imitates Dicken's style, but also makes the language more accessible for modern readers. I liked that this story brings back many of the familiar faces from the original classic.
Overall, a well written sequel to a beloved classic, it does an excellent job of staying true to the original while also daring to dive deeper and ask questions of faith and mortality. Inspiring and full of hope, this was the perfect twist on a classic. Definitely recommend, this Christmas Carol revisited!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
December 7, 2024
Okay, this was an enjoyable and believable sequel. However, I will say it was not anywhere close to Dickens-level writing and I don't feel like enough effort was made to keep the wording and feel of the original language.
I enjoyed this. I enjoyed Scrooge finally finding true hope and redemption.
I enjoyed this. I enjoyed Scrooge finally finding true hope and redemption.
November 6, 2021
I would suggest skipping Saving Ebenezer.
Read A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens.
Beyond reading the original wonderful story, do watch some of the great movie adaptations also.
Read A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens.
Beyond reading the original wonderful story, do watch some of the great movie adaptations also.
December 4, 2020
Dickens' "Christmas Carol" has always been a favorite book of mine and have read it many times over. When I came across "Saving Ebenezer" I was pleasantly surprised and I thought it only fitting that there would be a true ending to the story that Dickens had written. Needless to say I devoured this book and found it much in keeping with the original Dickens work. Ebenezer's final saving was indeed a surprise I was not expecting. I know many of you who have loved the original "Christmas Carol" will also enjoy this next installment.
October 20, 2021
Good heaven’s Scrooge. The world isn’t about you and your hurt feelings.
Scrooge is very sad that Tiny Tim has died, and questions what good it did to change from who he was. After seven years of doing all he could to make sure he will be acceptable, he still has a few things he needs to learn about God. Visited by some old friends and some new ones, will he finally begin to understand that peace comes when you give it to God?
What a lovely way to draw a very satisfying conclusion to a story that can teach us all so much! This copy was received through CelebrateLit. My thoughts and impressions were in no way solicited.
Scrooge is very sad that Tiny Tim has died, and questions what good it did to change from who he was. After seven years of doing all he could to make sure he will be acceptable, he still has a few things he needs to learn about God. Visited by some old friends and some new ones, will he finally begin to understand that peace comes when you give it to God?
What a lovely way to draw a very satisfying conclusion to a story that can teach us all so much! This copy was received through CelebrateLit. My thoughts and impressions were in no way solicited.
October 22, 2019
Have you ever wondered what became of Ebenezer Scrooge? Well, the classic story has come to life again through the words of author S. Daniel Smith. You will find yourself immersed in the lives of Scrooge and the Cratchit Family. The author weaved heartache, hope, and love into the story--a gripping combination that will have you wanting to finish the book in one sitting. I highly recommend this novella!
December 8, 2019
Ever wonder what happened to Scrooge after the story was said and done? Did you ever ask yourself "now what"? Well, I happen to think this is a wonderful way to explore both of these answers!
We get a glimpse of life seven years after the three spirits visited Scrooge and how life changed for him and the Cratchits. I loved how his answers and doubts were answered in an unexpected but pleasant way. A satisfying tie-in to an old classic!
We get a glimpse of life seven years after the three spirits visited Scrooge and how life changed for him and the Cratchits. I loved how his answers and doubts were answered in an unexpected but pleasant way. A satisfying tie-in to an old classic!
December 10, 2020
Perfect timing for the holiday season! Beautifully written with era-respected diction. Great continuation of perspective and narrative to follow the original work. A quick, fun read that kept me smiling throughout!
October 22, 2019
💕
Loved this book. I'm glad the author is a Christian, and also resolved another matter that I had wondered about.
Loved this book. I'm glad the author is a Christian, and also resolved another matter that I had wondered about.
December 6, 2023
Good Works Are Not Enough
I purchased this novella the day it was published in 2019. For whatever reason, one I'm not entirely sure of, I forgot to review the story back then. Today, modern day 2023, I decided it needed a review. In order to give it a proper one, I needed to freshen up my memory of the complete story. So... I read it again.
As I began reading, and the story started coming back to me, a smile grew on my face. That nostalgic feeling of being somewhere you've been before, but not quite remembering everything, every moment, or scent, until you feel it again. I was there.
A little side information about me, the reader: I didn't grow up loving Dickens. GASP! I know, I know. But I didn't. In truth, I loved the Bill Murray and Mary Lou Retton film version of the story the most because I was entertained. All the Old English words, and spellings... Ugh. Not my cup of tea. However, I did eventually grow up. I now love those things about Old English literature. I can't say I love Dickens, but I can agree he's grown on me.
Saving Ebenezer has shed a new, and shinier, light on the characters for me. Truthfully, I appreciate them more in S. Daniel Smith's version. I'm not sure, but possibly I'm a sequel before the original type of reader? Probably not, but in this case we will say yes. It's also possible I loved this version taking place 7 years after the original more because it examines the three spirits in a superior light. I always felt there was something missing in the original with the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future. Now I know there undeniably was.
If you are wishing to read something uplifting this Christmas, or any time of year, I suggest Saving Ebenezer. You won't regret spending time with this novella. It's also the perfect gift for someone in your life who needs uplifting literature, (or that reader friend asking what book is on your reading list; we all have them) especially during the holiday season.
I purchased this novella the day it was published in 2019. For whatever reason, one I'm not entirely sure of, I forgot to review the story back then. Today, modern day 2023, I decided it needed a review. In order to give it a proper one, I needed to freshen up my memory of the complete story. So... I read it again.
As I began reading, and the story started coming back to me, a smile grew on my face. That nostalgic feeling of being somewhere you've been before, but not quite remembering everything, every moment, or scent, until you feel it again. I was there.
A little side information about me, the reader: I didn't grow up loving Dickens. GASP! I know, I know. But I didn't. In truth, I loved the Bill Murray and Mary Lou Retton film version of the story the most because I was entertained. All the Old English words, and spellings... Ugh. Not my cup of tea. However, I did eventually grow up. I now love those things about Old English literature. I can't say I love Dickens, but I can agree he's grown on me.
Saving Ebenezer has shed a new, and shinier, light on the characters for me. Truthfully, I appreciate them more in S. Daniel Smith's version. I'm not sure, but possibly I'm a sequel before the original type of reader? Probably not, but in this case we will say yes. It's also possible I loved this version taking place 7 years after the original more because it examines the three spirits in a superior light. I always felt there was something missing in the original with the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future. Now I know there undeniably was.
If you are wishing to read something uplifting this Christmas, or any time of year, I suggest Saving Ebenezer. You won't regret spending time with this novella. It's also the perfect gift for someone in your life who needs uplifting literature, (or that reader friend asking what book is on your reading list; we all have them) especially during the holiday season.
October 17, 2021
Bah! Humbug! Yes those were my first thoughts upon seeing this book. If there ever was a mean old man who took the meaning out of Christmas, it was Ebenezer Scrooge. The mere thought of him makes me sad. Such an unhappy person he was. I couldn’t hold back my excitement to see what the author would do with this character. Is it possible for someone to change? Of course it is if they choose to. Awe there lies the big question doesn’t it? Would Ebenezer want to be happy and spend his days helping others? Would be utter the words to ask Jesus into his heart? Well let’s see what happens in this adventure.
I sensed the theme of the book right away. Scrooge was having a pity party and wanted others to feel sorry for him. He had changed his ways, given money to those in need but still Tiny Tim wasn’t saved. What more did God want from him? How silly he was to think that good deeds is what God was looking for.
The story is a look at a man who needed to surrender his life to God. Ebenezer knew who God was but he didn’t have a relationship with him. I enjoyed the journey of watching Ebenezer learn about forgiveness and being set free from sin. He finds hope when he felt there was none. As his heart softened and he began to understand he found Christ. I loved reading how his faith grew stronger and you could feel that he wanted to shout from the rooftops, “I am saved.”
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
I sensed the theme of the book right away. Scrooge was having a pity party and wanted others to feel sorry for him. He had changed his ways, given money to those in need but still Tiny Tim wasn’t saved. What more did God want from him? How silly he was to think that good deeds is what God was looking for.
The story is a look at a man who needed to surrender his life to God. Ebenezer knew who God was but he didn’t have a relationship with him. I enjoyed the journey of watching Ebenezer learn about forgiveness and being set free from sin. He finds hope when he felt there was none. As his heart softened and he began to understand he found Christ. I loved reading how his faith grew stronger and you could feel that he wanted to shout from the rooftops, “I am saved.”
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
September 30, 2021
From the time I was a little girl, I have always love Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol. I certainly am not alone in that... I am certain that most of us have fond memories of the story, rather it be from reading the actual story in it's original telling or seeing one of it's MANY modern re-tellings. It is a story that we all love and know so well. But did you ever wonder what happened after those famous words by Tiny Tim? In this short novella, author Dan Smith expands the classic seven years after the classic ends, following the death of Tim.
Taking on such a classic as this is quite the undertaking because again... so many of us absolutely adore this story. While I certainly don't think anything could come close to the original, I must admit I was pleasantly surprised with this story. Admittedly, it's been some time since I've actually read A Christmas Carol, but the tone of this story felt very familiar to my memory of it...it definitely had that classic feel to it, while still being a story uniquely it's own as well. I feel like the author did a great job of taking what we loved about the classic, and making this continuation feel authentic to the original. It was fast paced and a very quick read with a great message of faith for the holiday season.
**I received a complimentary copy for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
Taking on such a classic as this is quite the undertaking because again... so many of us absolutely adore this story. While I certainly don't think anything could come close to the original, I must admit I was pleasantly surprised with this story. Admittedly, it's been some time since I've actually read A Christmas Carol, but the tone of this story felt very familiar to my memory of it...it definitely had that classic feel to it, while still being a story uniquely it's own as well. I feel like the author did a great job of taking what we loved about the classic, and making this continuation feel authentic to the original. It was fast paced and a very quick read with a great message of faith for the holiday season.
**I received a complimentary copy for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
November 2, 2021
Saving Ebenezer is the perfect continuation of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. Dan Smith did an incredible job fixing the one glaring hole in Dickens’ tale.
What’s that, you ask?
The lack of Christ.
A Christmas Carol is a good example of behavior change, but doesn’t demonstrate the true change of heart that comes with salvation. Yes, Scrooge was no longer the mean miserly old man he once was, but what good are works without salvation? I absolutely love that the author delves into this and shows how Ebenezer changes in the same way Dickens did.
Just this time with Jesus.
I think He’s pretty important, don’t you?
You get to know the Cratchit family a little better, and you get to see them grow too. You might see some other familiar faces, and even some new ones too!
This truly was a beautiful story of redemption and repentance.
If you loved A Christmas Carol, then you’ll love this book too! I give this book 4 out of 5 stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Celebrate Lit, this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
What’s that, you ask?
The lack of Christ.
A Christmas Carol is a good example of behavior change, but doesn’t demonstrate the true change of heart that comes with salvation. Yes, Scrooge was no longer the mean miserly old man he once was, but what good are works without salvation? I absolutely love that the author delves into this and shows how Ebenezer changes in the same way Dickens did.
Just this time with Jesus.
I think He’s pretty important, don’t you?
You get to know the Cratchit family a little better, and you get to see them grow too. You might see some other familiar faces, and even some new ones too!
This truly was a beautiful story of redemption and repentance.
If you loved A Christmas Carol, then you’ll love this book too! I give this book 4 out of 5 stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Celebrate Lit, this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
October 15, 2021
I really liked "Saving Ebenezer" by S. Daniel Smith. I really like how the author continues the story but points out that just being a good person and giving away money isn't enough. This is a good story for all fans of "The Christmas Carol" to read. It is also a good story for all Christians to read because it does reminder us that none of us can save ourselves, it is only Jesus who can save us and we have to follow Him.
Yes, this book is a Christian read but I believed even unbelievers would like this novel continuation.
The opening to this story really made my heart cry, but the book ended on a happy note.
At the end of the book the author invites the reader to his blog where he shares more info on how to be saved.
I absolutely love how the book ends with "God bless us, every one!"
I received a complimentary copy from the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.
Yes, this book is a Christian read but I believed even unbelievers would like this novel continuation.
The opening to this story really made my heart cry, but the book ended on a happy note.
At the end of the book the author invites the reader to his blog where he shares more info on how to be saved.
I absolutely love how the book ends with "God bless us, every one!"
I received a complimentary copy from the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.
October 22, 2021
This short book has depth that belies its length. Similar in style to A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens, this continues the tale of Ebenezer Scrooge and what happened later in his life and with the family of his employee, Bob Cratchit, with particular focus on Tiny Tim. The novella brings these characters to life, and they seem authentic in their actions and responses. Although the drama unfolds a sad story, it also offers one in which realistic hope also rises before the satisfying conclusion. This also includes a supernatural element, which illustrates God’s loving care for every person He’s created. This brief book could also be dramatized like the original Christmas fictional account and would make a nice read-aloud for the holiday season. You may wish to read the Dickens classic before adding this epilogue to his work. I received a copy from Celebrate Lit. All opinions are my own.
October 23, 2021
Saving Ebenezer is an enjoyable sequel to the classic A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. I didn’t quite know what to expect and I was a little bit apprehensive. But, Dan Smith did a great job at creating an imaginative sequel, but he also captured the writing stuyle of the original work and sounded like Mr. Dickens himself!
I appreciated that the novel examines what is necessary for a person to truly be changed – salvation. And how all the money and good works account for nothing apart from salvation. I thought this was an interesting theme to explore, especially with such a well-beloved, classic character.
I also enjoyed getting reacquainted with these beloved characters, as well as meeting some new ones too.
Overall, this was a great follow-up to A Christmas Carol, and I highly recommend it if you are looking for a Christmas story told in a similar vein. 4/5 Stars.
*I received a copy of this book from the author and Celebrate Lit in exchange for my honest review.
I appreciated that the novel examines what is necessary for a person to truly be changed – salvation. And how all the money and good works account for nothing apart from salvation. I thought this was an interesting theme to explore, especially with such a well-beloved, classic character.
I also enjoyed getting reacquainted with these beloved characters, as well as meeting some new ones too.
Overall, this was a great follow-up to A Christmas Carol, and I highly recommend it if you are looking for a Christmas story told in a similar vein. 4/5 Stars.
*I received a copy of this book from the author and Celebrate Lit in exchange for my honest review.
October 27, 2021
Saving Ebenezer takes up the story of Ebenezer Scrooge and the Cratchit family seven years into the future after the three ghosts visited him. Despite all the money Scrooge spent trying to save Tiny Tim, the little boy died. Scrooge finds himself in a dark and hurting place. Scrooge seeks answers about faith when he discovers his own health is failing.
Just like the original story, Scrooge receives visitors to help guide him along his path. An angel appears as the first visitor. Then, he receives a visit from others, including Bob Cratchit’s wife, the men from the workhouse, and his own nephew. Discovering faith in God and the love He has for His people, this book captured my attention from the very beginning. So if you enjoy stories that pick up where other stories leave off, or if you enjoy Christmas stories, check out this book for yourself.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
Just like the original story, Scrooge receives visitors to help guide him along his path. An angel appears as the first visitor. Then, he receives a visit from others, including Bob Cratchit’s wife, the men from the workhouse, and his own nephew. Discovering faith in God and the love He has for His people, this book captured my attention from the very beginning. So if you enjoy stories that pick up where other stories leave off, or if you enjoy Christmas stories, check out this book for yourself.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
November 26, 2020
“'Mr. Scrooge, are you angry with God?' Ebenezer looked down at his shoes. 'Yes,'he muttered. 'I believe so. Does that make me a bad person?'"
Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol to pay his bills when his life took a turn downward. I have been a fan of Dickens for decades and have read every "sequel" to see how we ,a century and more later, see how things have changed...or not. As a retired minister, I read this after I received a review by another author because I respect her opinions. It's a bit over the top in it's evangelism but it's a sound story and author S. Daniel Smith writes well. As much as I liked the story however, in my opinion the theological premise is a bit shallow. I guess I need to remember that new believers take baby steps. I do recommend this small addendum to the well loved lessons of Scrooge and hope to see author Smith's name on future projects. 4/5
Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol to pay his bills when his life took a turn downward. I have been a fan of Dickens for decades and have read every "sequel" to see how we ,a century and more later, see how things have changed...or not. As a retired minister, I read this after I received a review by another author because I respect her opinions. It's a bit over the top in it's evangelism but it's a sound story and author S. Daniel Smith writes well. As much as I liked the story however, in my opinion the theological premise is a bit shallow. I guess I need to remember that new believers take baby steps. I do recommend this small addendum to the well loved lessons of Scrooge and hope to see author Smith's name on future projects. 4/5
September 12, 2021
Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge is my first introduction to the talented writer S Daniel Smith. I loved this rendition of the classic A Christmas Carol. I enjoyed seeing of the author’s imagination of what became of Scrooge after that story ended. It was a very quick read and it was a very well spent a couple of hours reading it.
I am giving Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge a very well deserved five plus stars. I highly recommend it for readers who enjoy reading Holiday Historical Fiction. I would love to read more like this in the future by S Daniel Smith.
I received a digital copy of Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
I am giving Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge a very well deserved five plus stars. I highly recommend it for readers who enjoy reading Holiday Historical Fiction. I would love to read more like this in the future by S Daniel Smith.
I received a digital copy of Saving Ebenezer: The Continuing Saga of a man named Scrooge from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
October 21, 2021
I think we have all enjoyed watching the story of Scrooge during Christmas time. Wether it's the classic version or the beloved Disney animated one we all enjoy seeing the redeeming aspect of the story. This was a great little novella. Here we find ourselves seven years later and see how Scrooge life changes and how he begins to truly see that just giving monetary things does not make you a good person in God's eyes but truly surrendering to Him and doing what He asks you to do is where the real relationship with Christ comes to fruition.
If you enjoy remakes of stories, especially classics, and you are in the mood for a Christmas story I definitely recommend this one!
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate Lit. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
If you enjoy remakes of stories, especially classics, and you are in the mood for a Christmas story I definitely recommend this one!
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate Lit. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
November 4, 2021
Oh my! This is a side of the Christmas Carol that I’d never even thought of before. I loved it! Who would have thought to take it further than just Scrooge having a change of heart? I will say my favorite Christmas movie is The Muppets Christmas Carol. So I’m very familiar with the story, plus having read the book to my kids myself. But this is definitely a new favorite as well.
Of course, I didn’t approve of Tiny Tim dying! Why couldn’t he live? But then of course this book would not be the book it is. Definitely, one to keep on the shelves.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
Of course, I didn’t approve of Tiny Tim dying! Why couldn’t he live? But then of course this book would not be the book it is. Definitely, one to keep on the shelves.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews