Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Society for Single Ladies #1

The Girl with the Pearl Pin

Rate this book
Founded by the wealthiest woman in London, an unconventional crime-solving club brings together single lords and overlooked ladies from every rung of society. It’s a perfectly scandalous match...

As London’s most sought-after bachelor, the Duke of Leomore stuns society when he announces his engagement to a woman who has just been branded a thief. Yet as his painfully shy “bride-to-be” understands, it is merely a ruse until The Society for Single Ladies apprehends the true culprit—and a ploy to further delay Leo’s obligation to wed. For him, marriage will be a purely practical affair. Still, why does a stolen kiss with his faux fiancée conjure such tempting visions of romance?

As if being falsely accused weren’t mortifying enough, Phoebe North is now the talk of the town. And while she knows Leo did the honorable thing to protect her reputation, she can’t help but long for more. It would be an impossible match given their unequal stations, and Leo has made his view of marriage quite clear. Yet his kiss and flirtatious ways say something else. If only she could persuade him of how delightful it would be to thumb their noses at convention—and become fools for love...

Kindle Edition

First published September 10, 2019

55 people are currently reading
652 people want to read

About the author

Lynne Connolly

132 books312 followers
I was born in Leicester, England, and lived in our cobbler’s shop with my parents and sister. It was an old house and most definitely haunted, but I didn’t find out until I left that my great uncle had hung himself in the living room! But I think our ghost might have been older than that. It was built on the site of the old Roman cemetery, and the land had been constantly inhabited, being in the centre of town. Then, when the council bought the house from us to build a road, my grandfather retired and my father went and worked for the Post Office. My mother was a sample machinist; that is, she worked with designers on the prototypes (models or samples) of garments. So I was very well dressed! We bought a relatively modern house in the country, and my mother was blissfully happy. It’s all very well living in a large old house, but it’s a dreadful task to keep it clean and warm!

My mother's side of the family are Romany gypsies, although sadly we haven't any of the old trailers that are so astonishingly beautiful. I was taught to read the Tarot cards, and I usually use two packs; the Rider pack for simple readings and the Crowley Thoth pack for the complex stuff.
I've always had an interest in the paranormal and it's been a delight to be able to put some of this into my novels.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
30 (19%)
4 stars
61 (40%)
3 stars
43 (28%)
2 stars
15 (9%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
Profile Image for Barbara Rogers.
1,754 reviews207 followers
August 26, 2019
Series: The Society for Single Ladies #1
Publication Date: 9/10/19
Number of Pages: 247

This book was a lovely start to a new series. We met future characters and learned the start of The Society for Single Ladies. I was particularly intrigued by the founder of the Society, Miss Angela Childers who may be featured in a book with Col, Duke of Colston Magna. That could definitely be an interesting match.

Leo, delightful, delicious Duke of Leomore, is all that is proper and appropriate. He’s handsome and rich – and according to his grandmother – he’s in need of a bride. He’ll look around this season, but silly debutants just don’t appeal. The only one who might hold his interest is Angela Childers who has staunchly declared that she will never marry. Leo decides to approach her for a dance, but she foists him off on her cousin, Phoebe North, who is visiting from the country.

Phoebe stutters when she’s stressed and she’s also sometimes a bit awkward. Leo is incensed when others ignore her during the dance and when she trips and begins to fall he sees her chagrin and rescues her. Uncharacteristically, he scoops her up and carries her outside to help repair the damage to her ruffle and to calm her. He feels the need to kiss her, but before he can, there is a commotion and she dashes out to see what is happening. A heavily cloaked man runs into her – and the rest of the people in attendance at the ball are running behind him. When the worst gossip in London, Lady Latimer, points her finger at Phoebe and accuses her of being the thief, Leo steps forward and says that can’t be so because she has just been accepting his proposal.

Phoebe definitely doesn’t think she’s duchess material – and Leo isn’t sure either, but the more time he spends with her, the more he is attracted. He’s sure it is a physical attraction, but he likes her as a friend too and that is all he needs in a wife – he has absolutely no desire for love in his marriage.

I absolutely adore the way this author handled a scurrilous, underhanded, sly kidnapper. It is one of the best ‘punishments’ I’ve seen. I loved it. I didn’t love the non-punishment that the theft mastermind got – and I wasn’t thoroughly clear on whether there was one or two masterminds. I’ll be interested to see what happens to Lucinda in the future – if we ever get to see that.

This was a fun read and a great introduction to the series. I hope you’ll enjoy it as much as I did.

I won this book in a Goodreads giveaway. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
3,111 reviews111 followers
October 26, 2019
Move over Ton elite, New Players are in town!

On the outside she's a demure young woman, always relegated to second place beside her younger, beautiful and vastly shallow sister Lucinda. Miss Phoebe North has removed to London ahead of her family to keep her friend Angela Childers company. Angela is a wealthy young woman, not interested in finding a husband, but in husbanding her business ventures and her latest brainchild, the Single Ladies Society.
Pheobe has a terrible stutter, a lively intelligence, a keen sense of the ridiculous and is convinced of her unworthiness to be special. She is! Unbeknownst to all, including Phoebe, inside hides a wanton woman the match for any strong man.
Enter the Duke of Leomore, “Call me Leo,” whom we meet at the beginning of the story just as enticement gives way to alarm! Phoebe and Leo are thrown into the midst of a jewel heist and Phoebe is accused of the theft. Our noble Duke saves Phoebe from that situation but even his best actions can't quieten the societal gossips and jealous remarks.
Phoebe, I think is worthy of our most stalwart Heyer like heroine. Leo certainly can lay claim to being a kindred spirit to many of Heyer's heroes.
I did feel that the story had no need to devote so many pages to the couple's lingering kisses and intimacies. In fact I found myself skipping through the bedroom antics. Although, I must say that for a shy spinster of the time (1750's), Pheobe displays a fervency I'd have more attributed to that of the Duke's ex mistress La Coccinelle. Still we have been told Phoebe has an inquiring mind. Her libido certainly hasn't been squashed by her years of being ignored. She and the Duke will have to ensure the servants wear ear muffs.
What I really wanted was more focus on the catching of the jewel thieves. That became a bit elusive. Both the mysterious jewel robbery and the doings of the Single Ladies Society are frequently lost in the romantic tendrils of the novel. Unfortunately, the SSL doesn't seem to have really found it's stride yet. I expect/hope that will happen as the series develops.
I must say too that Phoebe's sister Lucinda is a wonderful 'Piece of Work'. Connolly created a truly dreadful, willful sister, that was so easy to dislike. I kept wanting people to giver her the 'cut direct' or some such thing. Totally spoilt brat!
The opening is rather brilliant. That really hooked me in.
And yes, I will want to read further books in this Georgian romance/mystery series and follow the lives of some of the more interesting ladies met so far.

A Kensington ARC via NetGalley
Profile Image for Tracy Emro.
2,124 reviews64 followers
September 10, 2019
Phoebe North has come to London to help her cousin Angela Childers (the banking heiress we met in the Shaw series), Angela’s companion is ill and she has invited Phoebe to stay with her and attend events, she also introduces Phoebe to the Society of Single Ladies aka SSL.

Phoebe meets George “Leo” Cavendish, the Duke of Leomore at a ball Angela is hosting, he is there at his grandmother’s behest to being looking for a bride. He dances with Phoebe and immediately takes the role of her champion when a mishap rips her hem. He takes her out the garden and uses his pearl cravat pin to repair her gown, they talk a bit and he learns that Phoebe is shy and has a stammer, but she is intelligent and has a dry sense of humor that Leo finds incredibly attractive. They share a kiss and are preparing to return to the ball when a commotion breaks out and a man runs into Phoebe, she grabs at him but he gets away, but Phoebe did manage to hold on to something – a bracelet, but she also ended up with a cut to her hand. When guests begin to pour out, Lady Latimer sees what Phoebe is holding – her bracelet! She accuses Phoebe of stealing her jewels and Leo steps up and says that is not possible, he and Phoebe where in the garden the entire time and that he just proposed to her. Phoebe is shocked, but goes along with the ruse.

Phoebe is attracted to Leo, but feels that she is not suitable to be his bride, she agrees to go along with the deception until the end of the season and recruits the SSL to help find out who is behind the jewel theft. But things don’t go as planned and when Phoebe is kidnapped, Leo decides that suitable or not, Phoebe will be his bride.

I thought this was a good story, it has a little bit of everything, murder, mystery, multiple villains, petty relatives, steamy love scenes and a HEA, I personally, felt the Phoebe’s resistance and insistence that she was unworthy got a little tiresome after a while, but overall it was an enjoyable read and I would be happy to recommend it.

*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that was provided to me by NetGalley and the publisher.*
Profile Image for Elodie’s Reading Corner.
2,554 reviews152 followers
September 12, 2019
OMG, I’m in love!
I do adore Leo.

It’s been a while since I have read a book by Mrs Lynne Connelly and it is all my wrong doing, I purchased her last series but it went lost on my overloaded kindle shelves.
I can definitively say, even if the storyline is more then great, this book is a must-read because of Leo. Never he failed Phoebe, he might have his doubts but never he lost his composure and let distrust win the game.
He is a man whom never abuse from his position, he dislikes bullies and the like of them in the ton.
When he sees disparaging and belittling, he stands on the side of the victims.
Sure he is not flawless and makes a lot of mistakes but he does not hide behind his fault and accepts full responsibility when he does wrong.
A man after my own heart, ready to let the woman who came to count a lot for him find her inner strength, to help her find her own pace and to make peace with her past.
Phoebe has found in her cousin’s home a temporary respite. While her cousin is a very sought after heiress, she is a nobody, overlooked by everyone as a poor no one.
Until she crosses the path of one of the most eligible bachelor. A man whom in the span of few minutes will become her Champion.
For once, someone stands by her side, even if it is a temporary agreement.
Both know their only one finality to their fake engagement until the need of the other began to jostle their so ascertained understanding.
Each will cope differently, while Phoebe rushes straight into the lion’s den, then needs to steel herself to not give in despair, Leo asses his weapons and fights with everything he has.
Sure, at time I was upset at Phoebe inability to voice her thoughts and concerns, choosing often to bend instead of standing chin up but sometimes in the plot she found her say and expresses it despite her stammering. But it is her sweet and caring personality whom attracted Leo, so difficult to fault her for loving her family and forgiving their failing until their reach a no-return step.
Of course, Leo because of his past, has an issue with the emotion called love, he was a witness of what maddening love might cost. Why he is so afraid to open his heart but Phoebe without being noticed will creep slowly behind his defense walls.
A lovely and very entertaining read about love beyond reason.
As a first in a series, it was a great opening and I do wonder what will come next as there were aplenty of nice side protagonists.
A big 5 stars rate.

I was granted an advance copy by Netgalley and the publisher Kensington Books but I also purchased my own copy. Here is my true and unbiased opinion.
Profile Image for Nicole.
1,241 reviews99 followers
September 3, 2019
3.5 stars

When painfully shy Phoebe North finds herself accused of theft and facing potential ruin, she is shocked, along with the rest of London, when the Duke of Leomore, the ton's most eligible bachelor, claims she is his betrothed. Though the daughter of a simple country squire is overwhelmed by society, she's no fool; she fully understands that the engagement is a ruse only meant to last until she and her friends from the Society for Single Ladies apprehend the real thief. Leo is delighted to buy some time to put off marriage a bit longer. He wants no part of love after seeing how such passion destroyed his reckless parents and he simply wants friendship with his wife. Imagine his shock at the terrifyingly romantic bent of his feelings toward Phoebe.

For her part, though she is very attracted to Leo, Phoebe sees the impossibility of a true marriage with him due to the vast separation between their classes and her family's particular unconventional behavior. Soon Leo has set about to convince an ever reluctant Phoebe that a true marriage could work between them.

This was a different read and I enjoyed many aspects of it. I think this new series has potential and I'll follow it. This was a good read for me in the end, but I did get bogged down a bit in the repetition from both main characters of all the reasons they couldn't be together and Leo's constant insistence on not being in love. At times it felt like I was rereading sections of the book I'd already read, but in the end it was mostly satisfactory, though I would've liked to see Phoebe's family put in their place a bit more.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Joana.
377 reviews82 followers
September 26, 2019
Review originally published at Romancing Romances.

I received an eARC through NetGalley, and I am leaving a voluntary and honest review. Thank you.

2.75*


This was my first time reading a book by Lynne Connolly. To be honest, I don’t actually know what I was expecting.

This book is a bit slow, particularly in the beginning, but it gets better closer to the end.

The best thing about the book for me was the Society for Single Ladies, yet we saw so little of them… Hopefully they’ll get a bigger spotlight in the next books.

I liked Phoebe more than Leomore, he was a bit too possessive for my liking, but in the end he gets better. Phoebe is a clever young woman, and she deserves to be happy.

The mystery didn’t really work for me, I was pretty sure of the result right from the beginning.

Angela, Phoebe’s best friend, is one of the best characters of the book, and I think her story will be more interesting.

The romance wasn’t bad, but it could have been better… There just wasn’t enough chemistry for me between the main characters.

This is the kind of book that doesn’t really stick with you, it’s pleasant, but that’s just about it.
Profile Image for Lail.
267 reviews32 followers
September 23, 2019
4.5 Stars. The Girl With The Pearl Pin (The Society for Single Ladies Book 1) by Lynne Connolly is a delightful historical romance that warms the heart. This is a love story brought about by a mysterious theft and a fake proposal. This fast pace story has a bit of everything including action, suspense, mystery, heartache, a slow burn romance with a lot of sweet passionate kiss scenes and some steamy open bedroom door love scenes, towards the latter part of the book.
I did became distracted and thrown off with the abrupt backward change in Leo’s words and thoughts approx two thirds the way through. And, I expected and wanted to see more mention, action, and participation from the women’s crime solving club since it is the basis of the series. Overall I enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more by this author.
Happy Reading♥️
Profile Image for JoAn.
2,457 reviews1 follower
April 1, 2020
The Girl with the Pearl Pin by Lynne Connolly was a delightful historical mix of mystery and romance. As a fan of historical mysteries, I enjoyed visiting with the Society of Single Ladies as Phoebe tried to navigate the world of Society. "Leo" the Duke of Leomore was a captivating gentleman. I loved how he took his time with Phoebe and was her champion and protector throughout. The resolution of the mystery tied up all of the loose ends neatly. I look forward to more books set in this world.

I received this Kindle copy from my public library.
2,419 reviews21 followers
September 9, 2019
Loved the idea of the Society of Single Ladies. A little mystery a bit of love and a great romance. I know this is a romance and everything works out in the end but I have to say I wondered at times. If not for the loyalty of Leo, this could have gone all wrong. A feel good story that made me sigh. Loved this story.

I received a complimentary copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Profile Image for Lori D.
4,079 reviews130 followers
September 11, 2019
What an exciting start to this new series by Lynne Connolly! An unexpected encounter with the Duke of Leomore, led him asking Phoebe to dance! Of course she was attending the ball with her cousin Angela, who was much sought after and she had just declined to dance with him. He turned his attention to her and led her on the floor. I adored the interaction between Phoebe and Leo!
What happened next ( oh yes you will have to read and find out how it came about!), Leo announce they were engaged to try to get her out of a sticky situation!
Oh my, I loved Leo.. He came to her rescue and of course it was truly just a "pretend engagement" to save her from being accussed as a thief. But what could come of it anyone? He was a Duke and she really was not in his league.
Filled with humor, a mystery, murder, pretense, romance and of course the SSL Ladies, you will be carried away on a jouney until the last page. Cannot wait for more!!
Profile Image for Lail.
267 reviews32 followers
September 23, 2019
4.5 Stars. The Girl With The Pearl Pin (The Society for Single Ladies Book 1) by Lynne Connolly is a delightful historical romance that warms the heart. This is a love story brought about by a mysterious theft and a fake proposal. This fast pace story has a bit of everything including action, suspense, mystery, heartache, a slow burn romance with a lot of sweet passionate kiss scenes and some steamy open bedroom door love scenes, towards the latter part of the book.
I did became distracted and thrown off with the abrupt backward change in Leo’s words and thoughts approx two thirds the way through. And, I expected and wanted to see more mention, action, and participation from the women’s crime solving club since it is the basis of the series. Overall I enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more by this author.
Happy Reading♥️
Profile Image for Avril Hemingway.
994 reviews3 followers
April 10, 2021
disappointing didn't hold my attention and the mystery side was largely solved by accident
Profile Image for Dee Renee  Chesnut.
1,728 reviews40 followers
December 14, 2020
I downloaded this ebook in 2020 when I had difficulty downloading books from my library in the cloud on one of my Nooks. I expected a mystery with a romance which should have given it 4 stars. However I took away a star because this prude was unprepared for the descriptions of sexual activity--I mean there is not much skin revealed in the cover art--and I am reluctant to recommend it to my friends.
Profile Image for Janet.
5,171 reviews65 followers
September 5, 2019
Founded by the wealthiest woman in London, an unconventional crime-solving club brings together single lords and overlooked ladies from every rung of society. It’s a perfectly scandalous match.
The Duke of Leomore stuns society when he announces his engagement to a woman who has just been branded a thief. For him, marriage will be a purely practical affair after seeing how his parents nearly ruined the dukedom.
Phoebe tears a flounce & Leo offers to mend it or her unfortunately her pins are rusty so he uses his pearl pin. He then claims a kiss, shouts sound & Phoebe bumps into a fleeing man, the next thing she knows is that she’s branded a thief, Leo ever honourable, announces she was with him as they were celebrating their engagement. As if being falsely accused weren’t mortifying enough, Phoebe North is now the talk of the town. And while she knows Leo did the honourable thing to protect her reputation, she can’t help but long for more. It would be an impossible match given their unequal stations, and Leo has made his view of marriage quite clear.
A lovely page turning romance, I love the author’s attention to detail & the facts she always includes in her books. The characters are well portrayed, I loved Leo & Phoebe & how their relationship developed also how Phoebe’s confidence grew. Leo was absolutely gorgeous & how he helped her at every turn was a joy. The pace was very good & flowed effortlessly. The secondary characters also had depth & I felt there was a definite teaser about Angela! The villains mostly received their comeuppances & the ending was very satisfying although I would have liked an epiloue. This is the first in a new series & I look forward to more to come
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Profile Image for Ola Adamska.
2,881 reviews26 followers
September 9, 2019
It was a regent book when it comes to the style, form, and language used here Everything worked well for the plot and building the situation. So why would I take tej stars away from that book?
First, The heroine... eh... Phoebe is A really shy and uncertain girl. That was in the wrong place at the wrong time. No one could have suspected that. She was rescued by the Duke of Leomore. Sounds good, and he said that she's his wife to be! A dream come true! For most girls but not Phoebe. She was so doubting that nothing anyone said would work to convince her in the very last. She made this story slow the pace very much and add something that was not needed to that degree.
Second, this novel is not clean. The heroine in one chapter shy and virgin, the other one she changes out of character and that was really disturbing. Don't get me wrong I love my books on the steamier side, and some got scenes but only when it resonates with the rest of the book. Here not so much.
It was decent but those two facts made the read not great, but just ok.
Profile Image for TLynn.
1,467 reviews17 followers
September 11, 2019
This is the first book in the new series Society for Single Ladies, which is a group of ladies who work together to solve mysteries. The ladies are widows and spinster who attend Ton events and are overlooked by Society. One of the ladies belonging to the group is Phoebe North. She has come to London for the first time to be a companion for her cousin. She is overlooked by Society until her cousin introduces her to the Duke of Leomore “Leo”. While they are fixing her gown in the garden, a necklace was stolen and they were found together when people followed the thief out into the garden. Leo announces that they are betrothed to save her reputation. They agree to continue with the lie while they try to solve the mystery of who stole the necklace. A fake betrothal plot that included a mystery of stolen jewels was great. Leo’s character was interesting, he started off seeming aloft but as story continues we get to see his true emotions. I love the concept of a ladies club solving mysteries and can’t wait to see what the next book will have.
4,720 reviews39 followers
September 11, 2019
A scandalous match?
What an interesting group the Society for Single Ladies I can see where this idea will take the reader on many grand adventures. This was a different twist and it was so entertaining. Leo and Phoebe were great characters and with a pace that flowed so well, it was a read that was hard to put down. I highly recommend and I look forward to the next book in the series. I did receive a free copy of this book and voluntarily chose to review it.
Profile Image for Simo.
436 reviews3 followers
October 1, 2019
What crime-solving ladies club??? They haven't done a thing to even try solving the mystery, expect sitting around and saying that they need to solve it! This part of the plot is totally superfluous and forced. The only reason it is there, I assume, is to link the book in the series? I guess I'll never find out, because, even if this was an ok read, it wasn't interesting enough to motivate me to continue with the series.
2,120 reviews37 followers
July 11, 2019
Diamonds are girls best friend, maybe!

I won this book through a Goodreads giveaway. This is my honest review. What a delightful story. There is drama, suspense, romance and a little comedy, all in one book. Thoroughly enjoyed reading it. Looking forward to the next book in the series.
Profile Image for Melania Ramona.
613 reviews24 followers
Read
September 15, 2019
I wanted to like this book. All the reviews are praising it... But I just couldn't. The way it is written, the hero and the heroine... I just didn't "feel" the story or the romance and I didn't connect with the characters.
Profile Image for Ashley (A Stack Above The Rest Blogg).
59 reviews7 followers
September 28, 2019
This was a great historical romance with a twist. The characters are captivating and the spilt perspective was elegantly executed.

I would read more by this author and I would recommend it to fans of historical romance with some action and adventure thrown in.
284 reviews1 follower
September 17, 2019
This book absolutely, positively goes in my keeper file. A second chance romance that really puts this couple through heartbreaking emotional and physical pain.
6,155 reviews
October 7, 2019
The first installment from The Society for Single Ladies series, The Girl with the Pearl Pin, is a pretty good read. I recommend and give it four stars.
2,739 reviews127 followers
September 10, 2019
The Girl with the Pearl Pin is the first in Lynne Connolly's Society for Single Ladies series. It's a bit of an accidental betrothal story, and an ugly duckling story, as Phoebe North is hardly the toast of the town. While visiting her wealthy city cousin Angela Childers, she is accused of stealing a precious diamond necklace. The handsome and much pursued Duke of Leomore swoops in to save her by announcing their betrothal.

I definitely loved Phoebe and Leo's interactions, the way they are able to be the best versions of themselves with each other. I love how Leo admires foremost Phoebe's straight speaking and her heart, and finds his head turned to her kind of beauty. They get to know each other in part by exchanging correspondence, which is lovely too.

On the other hand, I deeply disliked most of Phoebe's family, especially her scheming younger sister, whom her parents apparently indulge, and her highhanded former suitor. I realize that these characters provide a foil to the heroine, but they are nevertheless very unpleasant to read about, and I found myself dreading their appearance on the page. Fortunately, Leo and Phoebe do ultimately prevail, and no one is left with any doubts as to Leo's feelings and priorities, from her family to the ton to Phoebe herself.

The missing necklace and the work of the Society for Single Ladies--a group of spinsters, "failed" debutantes, and others deemed "single" by society--organized by Ms Childers towards tracking it down also provide a lively backdrop to Phoebe and Leo's relationship.

This is an excellent start to this new series, and I look forward to the stories to come.
443 reviews1 follower
October 15, 2021
DNF 51%

I did not like the heroine. She started out great, she was sarcastic and sassy (although not shy at all even though we are constantly told how shy she is) I know that some introverts can be extremely outgoing with people they are comfortable with and have social anxiety around strangers, but she isn't really written that way. Her character was kind of all over the place. After being all sassy, out of nowhere she becomes extremely insecure. And reading her inner monologues where she keeps repeating the same talking points over and over ad nauseum despite all evidence to the contrary, got real old real fast. I also hated how snobby she got about her family. Earlier in the book, it seemed like she had a very fraught relationship with them and they treated her badly, but other than her sister, it seemed like a normal family. Basically, they embarrass her, that's it. All that anxiety over a slightly embarrassing family.

The hero was a little inconsistent as well. His philosophy is that love is bad and the worst reason to get married, but he is basically in instalove with the heroine. Halfway into the book and he isn't even struggling to reconcile his feelings with his philosophy. He's just like, shrug, what will be will be.

And on top of all that, I was bored. Nothing was happening. No rising stakes or conflicts.
Profile Image for Lauren.
2,516 reviews159 followers
January 6, 2023
The Girl with the Pearl Pin
4 Stars

In order to protect an innocent young woman accused of theft, London's most eligible bachelor, the Duke of Leomore, announces to one and all that she is his fianćee. While shy and sweet Phoebe North acknowledges and accepts that Leo's attentions are simply a ruse until the actual culprit is apprehended, she desperately wishes that the proposal were real - especially once his flirtation turns to passion.

The idea of an investigative organization comprised of women on the fringes of society beyond the attention of the ton, i.e., wallflowers, companions, governesses, spinsters and poor relations, has tremendous potential. Unfortunately, the Society for Single Ladies plays such a minor role in the story as to be non-existent, which is very disappointing.

Nevertheless, the rest of the book, focusing on Leo and Phoebe's romance, is delightful due to their obvious emotional connection and sizzling chemistry. Leo's affection for and protection of Phoebe are evident from the start and make him a particularly appealing hero. While my preference is usually for more forceful heroines, Phoebe grows in confidence throughout the story, and her strength and resilience in coping with her disability are admirable. That said, it would have been even better if she had .

While the mystery takes a back seat to the romance, it has its exciting moments and the resolution is exceedingly satisfying as the culprit gets their just desserts.

Overall, an excellent beginning to the series and I look forward to continuing.
Profile Image for Monique.
925 reviews69 followers
September 11, 2019
Review written: August 28, 2019
Star Rating: ★★★★☆
Heat Rating: ☀☀☀☼☼

An Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book was received free via Netgalley for an honest review.

The Girl with the Pearl Pin is the first book in a new series by Lynne Connolly, one of my favorite authors. Centering on mysteries and a group of “forgotten women” who have formed a club, The Society for Single Ladies series is looking like yet another winner by Connolly.

Of particular interest to me was the title which felt reminiscent of both The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and The Girl with the Pearl Earring. I especially liked the pearl pin itself and how it was used in the plot, giving it weight and import. I was less impressed with the “prom dress” cover because this publisher has been so good in the past with creating great covers for Connolly’s books. In the end, that is neither here nor there since Connolly’s writing is what’s really important to me.

The Girl with the Pearl Pin is significantly more lighthearted than either her Emperors of London or her The Shaws series, both of which dealt with particularly weighty matters like treason and possible death. I loved those series and I also love this foray into a more light and easy tone. After all, Connolly continues to explore interesting subjects in the past and illuminate the times through interesting and different people.

While this is set in Georgian England, Angela Childers is quite reminiscent of the Countess of Jersey who, in fact, ran a bank and was a patroness of Almack’s, one of the great arbiters of Society. I enjoyed that and the clear picture it presents of women in positions of power. There is no question that women were powerful and I enjoy reading books that portray that. But Angela is not the principal lead here, though I do wonder if she will get a book (I’m hoping yes.).

Her cousin Phoebe, who Angela neatly sets up, is in fact, the lead. Phoebe is a likeable character who is a bit of a doormat with her family but shows to great advantage when away from them. In London, and with Leomore, she is outspoken, interesting, thoughtful, and kind. I absolutely love how Leomore sees her and I also love how it is made clear that her intelligence, wit, and bearing are deeply appreciated not just by Leomore but by his grandmother as well. This is important because it clearly shows how substance over style is favored. After all, a bit of fluff cannot command an army of servants or take care of an estate and a great estate requires a mistress equal to the task. Only a foolish man would marry a bit of fluff. This is not just small subtext within the book but is writ large in the story of Leomore’s parents.

But back to Phoebe. She has mettle and strength when it is needed but never loses her tenderness and compassion. She is perfect as a duchess for exactly that reason. Connolly drew her so well that I could see her in a few years as a great lady with great polish and an arbiter of Society. This is a gift of Connolly’s. Her characterization is superb and she routinely writes people who are relatable, unique, and still utterly of their times.

Leomore (That would be Leo, or George but no one calls him that.) is an interesting character. He has both his parents’ terrible example and his grandmother’s exemplary example before him and has learned lessons from both. His desire for marriage is nothing more than affection (which is so in keeping with the times and comes from his grandmother) but he finds himself quite possessive and protective of a miss who has neither family nor fortune. I absolutely loved his thoughts on marriage to Phoebe – how he had doubts once meeting her family, how those were natural and just and how in the end, they didn’t matter. That worked so beautifully for me.

Phoebe’s family was horrible. Of all the book, their entrance and continued stays on the page felt melodramatic and off-kilter for me. Lucinda the sister, and their mother both felt like villains twirling their mustaches. They lacked any heft to their characters beyond their absurd scheming. I kept waiting for Leomore to lose it and tell Lucinda the only reason that Phoebe hadn’t made a great match was because her sister Lucinda was such a horrible person that it was hurting Phoebe. That’s how truly horrid Lucinda was. I’m not sure that Connolly will eventually give Lucinda a book, but she certainly has a great deal of growing up to do before she could be palatable to me. Her use of the pin and a horrible childhood friend against Phoebe was reprehensible and ties back to the mystery at hand, because this is also a mystery story.

Phoebe and Leomore become engaged when Lady Latimer accuses Phoebe of stealing her jewelry which is family heirlooms. This eventually is what leads the Society to try their hand at crime solving. As Leomore and Phoebe become further embroiled in the mystery, events continue to pile up leading to the idea of a grand conspiracy. I am hopeful that this conspiracy will continue to play a role in later books. There are plenty of characters who have opportunities for books so I look forward to that. Angela uses her power at her bank (in a way reminiscent of stories I have heard about Lady Jersey) to help with the case, and eventually the mystery is solved.

I did feel the ending was a little too easy and too pat, though. Everything got wrapped up in a big bow and the sense of walking off into the sunset was too strong. I would have preferred something a bit less perfect. That said, there was a potential coming book telegraphed though I doubt it will be next. I’m excited to read the next installment of The Society for Single Ladies and seeing yet another side of women’s life in the Georgian period. After all, at the moment, Connolly has another series The Daring Dersinghams which also explores the roles of women in Georgian England. The two series are not connected, but I do think they complement each other very well.

As always, I am eager to read the next Connolly book!

This review is ©August 2019 by Monique N. and has been posted to Netgalley.
Profile Image for Jamie Bee.
Author 1 book118 followers
September 11, 2019
Some Story Flaws but Good Characters

It is kind of funny. I have often thought to myself that authors do not explore the Georgian period often enough. Regency is certainly one of the most common types of historical romance. So I was intrigued by this story at the outset, knowing that it was of that earlier time period. I have to say, though, that this actually still just felt and read like a Regency. Other than the time frame, nothing really made it seem to stand out as Georgian. I also thought that the language didn't feel elevated enough to mimic those of that earlier time. I felt the author more often told rather than showed, and there was a rather prodigious dated dump in the first chapter. Actually, the author did seem to have a love of long descriptive passages not broken up by dialogue. Sometimes those became a little tedious. I liked the hero, Leo, as he is just such a thoroughly decent guy with more capacity for feeling than he gives himself credit for. He makes mistakes, to be sure, but I love how he is able to look beyond rank to see the value of another person, to see the content of their character rather than social class.

I received a free copy of this book, but that did not affect my review.

Read my other reviews at https://www.readingfanaticreviews.com
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
6,048 reviews113 followers
July 30, 2019
I won an advanced copy of The Girl with the Pearl Pin, but this isn't the first Lynne Connolly book I have enjoyed! This series takes place in the glitter of London, but Society for Single Ladies have been forced to make their own shine. The Society is made up of spinsters, widows, poor cousins, companions, and failed debutantes who have been relegated to the edges of the social swirl. Phoebe, while visiting her cousin Amelia, manages to snag a dance with the very eligible Duke Leo. Amelia has been using her considerable wealth and network of overlooked ladies to help solve crimes in relation to her work at her bank. When someone steals Lady Latimer's necklace and blames it on Phoebe, Amelia, Leo, and a whole cast of interested parties set out to clear Phoebe's name and retrieve the jewels.
I loved how the very human Phoebe finds the confidence to let her status and smarts define her instead of her stutter. Leo and Phoebe's romance and the intrigue of catching a thief made this a wonderful romp. I can't wait for the rest of the series!!
Profile Image for Sissy's Romance Book Review .
8,992 reviews16 followers
September 18, 2019
The Girl with the Pearl Pin by Lynne Connolly is book 0ne in The Society for Single Ladies Series. This is the story of Phoebe North and George “Leo” Cavendish, the Duke of Leomore.
Phoebe has come to town to stay with her cousin Angela whose companion has taken ill. Angela has promised to take her on events and introduce her to the Society for Single Ladies. Phoebe is very shy and when nervous has a stutters. When she attends one of the balls she meets Leo. Leo is there at his grandmother's request for him to find a bride. Leo and Phoebe dance but she ends up needing Leo's help which leads them to go outside where they end up talking and sharing a bond. But then someone comes running through that ends up leaving Phoebe being accused of a theft because that person left what he took with her. Of curse Leo steps forward claiming she is his bride to be which puts a protective coat on her reputation until they can clear this matter up. But both can't pretend long before there real feelings start to come through.
Enjoyed their story.


Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.