A Weary World: Reflections for a Blue Christmas was a title that captured my attention in its publisher’s catalog (Westminster John Knox Press) because it didn’t seem to be a typical Advent devotional book. To be sure, A Weary World is a nice devotional resource but it is also useful for group study, too. The thesis, as should be obvious from the subtitle, is that A Weary World approaches this normally happy and festive season with a message for that larger than-realized minority who feels depression, anxiety, and grief during the holiday season.
Kathy Escobar knows whereof she writes because she lost her eldest son to suicide during this season. As a religious professional, Christmas suddenly became exponentially harder for her to navigate. So, she shares some of the insights that have helped her through the season in hopes that it will help others. The structure of the volume includes four weeks leading up to a Christmas Eve emphasis. However, instead of the usual Hope, Peace, Love, and Joy of Advent, her weeks follow the themes of: 1) Honoring Reality, 2) Practicing Honesty, 3) Embracing Paradox, 4) Borrowing Hope, and a more typical Christmas Eve theme of “God with Us.”
The first week largely recognizes that our usual ideas of Christmas sanitize the fact that “God with Us” means that God experiences the muck and mire of our complex realities. To those with inferiority complexes or feelings of unworthiness, Escobar points out how many of those involved with the first Christmas were unimportant people. She gives readers permission to admit that they are tired and to say, “I don’t know.” Then, she offers some suggestions on acknowledging this complicated reality.
The second week covered the vital area of practicing honesty. In “preparing the way” for experiencing Advent, she urges everyone to express their own voice in the wilderness. And, to be honest, she contends we have to be honest about our anger and express it as per Ephesians 4:26, to admit grief while being aware (as the Psalmist seems to be in Psalm 55:6 in the New Living Translation) “You have kept track of all my sorrows. You have collected all my tears in your bottle.”, facing fear by acknowledging it since four of the encounters in the Christmas story begin with “Don’t be afraid!”, confronting shame in a safe space, and seeking help in one’s disorientation.
The third week was the richest part of the volume. It was about embracing paradox, knowing that one doesn’t have to be defeated by the emotional whiplash of singing songs of joy while feeling the sting and pain of grief. I particularly liked her phrase: “The essence of the Jesus story is that we rise by descending.” (p. 58) She emphasizes paradox with the lines about the reversal of status from Mary’s Magnificat in Luke 1. She notes how we must navigate between Light and Dark, Beautiful and Ugly, Peace and Chaos, Hope and Despair, and Love and Hate without giving up when confronted by any of these extremes. The learning activity for this chapter has a fascinating approach. She offers lists of adjectives and challenges the reader to choose words from the lists to express the current paradox in which they find themselves (pp. 72-73). It’s simple, but eye-opening.
The fourth week was about “Borrowing Hope.” It sounds somewhat cliché, but it isn’t. As human beings, we have to learn how to depend upon each other. When we’re down, we need to borrow hope from God and borrow hope from those around us to be strengthened for the challenges we will face. Perhaps the best advice for those “loaning” hope to those in such dire situations is to “Be interested, not interesting.” (p. 89)
The final part of the book offers some interesting liturgical ideas for use with small groups or congregations with a sense that many are struggling during this holiday season. The book even offers some ideas for “Reflection Stations” with activities to express: grief and loss (collecting tears in a bottle and applying Psalm 55:6), fear (writing the things we fear on a mirror), anger (an ornament-smashing station (with protective gear)) and emotional pain (create your own wailing wall) among others (pp. 111-114).
For me, A Weary World: Reflections for a Blue Christmas was useful, but it felt more like a self-help book than a devotional tool. It has worthy quotations, interesting insights, and helpful suggestions, but it is light on scriptural reference and application. I’m glad the book was written and published, but I definitely feel like it could have stronger ties to scripture in general and the Christmas story in particular.