I'm a little baffled by the high reviews of this book and the fact that this woman has sold hundreds of millions of books. From the start, this book reminded me of a generic children's biography book from the old days in the writing style. Steel tells an 80 year story full of multiple characters like she's just listing history in a bland tone. Everything is told like a really long timeline. This fancy party happened and it was over the top luxurious, then this tragic thing happened, then 10 years passed and this happened, and then by the way this person died, and then this wonderful thing happened, and then this handsome, wonderful guy instantly fell in love with this female character because she was beautiful and interesting, and so on. Bad guys are rare and they are not terribly bad, just people with bad character flaws and they stop mattering soon.
The cliches are so over-the-top it was cringe-worthy. Every female main character was beautiful, slender and good, but in a very generic way. They had no flaws. At the start, they are obscenely rich, in an enormous mansion with a ballroom and the funds to spend a month in Paris to find the right coming out gown. The heroine is a sweet teenager and falls in love with a good looking, kind widower in his 30's who falls deeply in love with her, pretty much on sight. While it's basically a G-rated book, the wedding night sex is the cliche of she was afraid it would be painful and then he entered her and she arched her back and they both exploded together and then made love twice more. Any time sex is mentioned in this book, it's like that, but it's only mentioned a few times and without detail -- just the general "it was perfect and they did it constantly" kind of thing.
I am a notorious crier and I didn't cry over this book, which shows how much it is lacking in typical emotion. Main characters died (it covers 80 years so this is not really a spoiler) but it's practically mentioned in passing and then we move on to some trivial thing that is happening with another character. It just didn't do it for me. If I escape in a novel, I want to experience the characters' fears, joys, laughs, passion, rage and heartbreak, not to read it like a dry history book. I also really want three dimensional characters, not Disney princesses and noble heroes. I have realized now that Steel basically writes fairy tales for adults, and they read like the mass produced children's kind, for the good or bad.
Shrug. From the many 4 star reviews, I seem to be alone in this, but this book left me strangely blase. Two stars for "it was okay."
I read a digital ARC of this book for the purpose of review.