What do you think?
Rate this book
No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency #20
In the Land of Long Lost Friends
In the latest book in the widely beloved No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, Precious Ramotswe takes on a case for a childhood acquaintance and finds that family relationships are always a tricky proposition--even for Botswana's premier female detective.
Mma Ramotswe has reconnected with an old friend who has been having problems with her daughter. Though Precious feels compelled to lend a hand, she discovers that getting involved in family affairs is always a delicate affair. The young woman appears to be involved with a charismatic preacher. But are his ministrations entirely of a godly nature?
Elsewhere, Charlie is also struggling with a tricky matter of the heart. He wishes to propose to his girlfriend, Queenie-Queenie, but he's struggling to come up with a bride price that will impress her father. When Queenie-Queenie's brother offers to help by giving him a job, the offer may not be quite what Charlie expected.
As always, Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni will offer wise counsel, Mma Makutsi will weigh in with her opinions, and Mma Potokwane will be there with her welcome fruit cake. But in the end it will be up to Mma Ramotswe to reflect on love, family, and the nature of men and women in order to resolve family dramas and remind everyone about all the good things they have in life--so many, in fact, that it would take far too long to count them.oral sense to get to the heart of the matter.
Mma Ramotswe has reconnected with an old friend who has been having problems with her daughter. Though Precious feels compelled to lend a hand, she discovers that getting involved in family affairs is always a delicate affair. The young woman appears to be involved with a charismatic preacher. But are his ministrations entirely of a godly nature?
Elsewhere, Charlie is also struggling with a tricky matter of the heart. He wishes to propose to his girlfriend, Queenie-Queenie, but he's struggling to come up with a bride price that will impress her father. When Queenie-Queenie's brother offers to help by giving him a job, the offer may not be quite what Charlie expected.
As always, Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni will offer wise counsel, Mma Makutsi will weigh in with her opinions, and Mma Potokwane will be there with her welcome fruit cake. But in the end it will be up to Mma Ramotswe to reflect on love, family, and the nature of men and women in order to resolve family dramas and remind everyone about all the good things they have in life--so many, in fact, that it would take far too long to count them.oral sense to get to the heart of the matter.
240 pages, Hardcover
First published September 5, 2019
1331 people are currently reading
3660 people want to read
About the author
Alexander McCall Smith
673 books12.7k followersAlexander McCall Smith is the author of the international phenomenon The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, the Isabel Dalhousie Series, the Portuguese Irregular Verbs series, and the 44 Scotland Street series. He is professor emeritus of medical law at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland and has served on many national and international bodies concerned with bioethics. He was born in what is now known as Zimbabwe and he was a law professor at the University of Botswana. He lives in Scotland. Visit him online at www.alexandermccallsmith.com, on Facebook, and on Twitter.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,167 reviews
August 25, 2019
Same old, same old
My dear Mma Ramotswe
In 2004, you found a wonderful man, Alexander McCall Smith to write your story. I will never forget the year and my excitement of meeting you for the first time. You restored my African soul and made me fall in love with you, Mr JLB Makatoni, Charlie and Fanwell. I tolerated Mma Makutsi and grew to respect her, but never to truly love her. Maybe, it’s her shoes, that answer back all the time.
Each year since then, I’ve waited in anticipation for the latest instalment from Botswana. Each year I’ve marvelled at your generosity and kindness while finding solutions for your clients.
All this has changed this year. I’m not sure how to tell you this news. It’s bad news Mma. I found that Rra McCall Smith did not do you any service this year. He must have forgotten all the notes he’d written down after visiting you and so all he did was repeat some of the stories we’ve heard before – over and over again.
I did love the story of the baby coming to live with you and Charlie getting married (please send him my best wishes). But Mma, that was just a few lines. No Mma this is not good. Not good at all. How could so little have happened in one year?
Mma, please speak to Rra McCall Smith and tell him he must please not repeat stories. He must not forget his notes with you. I want to hear more about you solving the puzzles your clients bring you. Not repeat, repeat, repeat stories from long ago. My memory does not need reminding.
Please Mma, tell him. Tell him we want all your stories and clients’ puzzles back.
With my very best wishes
Mma Imbali
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review.
My dear Mma Ramotswe
In 2004, you found a wonderful man, Alexander McCall Smith to write your story. I will never forget the year and my excitement of meeting you for the first time. You restored my African soul and made me fall in love with you, Mr JLB Makatoni, Charlie and Fanwell. I tolerated Mma Makutsi and grew to respect her, but never to truly love her. Maybe, it’s her shoes, that answer back all the time.
Each year since then, I’ve waited in anticipation for the latest instalment from Botswana. Each year I’ve marvelled at your generosity and kindness while finding solutions for your clients.
All this has changed this year. I’m not sure how to tell you this news. It’s bad news Mma. I found that Rra McCall Smith did not do you any service this year. He must have forgotten all the notes he’d written down after visiting you and so all he did was repeat some of the stories we’ve heard before – over and over again.
I did love the story of the baby coming to live with you and Charlie getting married (please send him my best wishes). But Mma, that was just a few lines. No Mma this is not good. Not good at all. How could so little have happened in one year?
Mma, please speak to Rra McCall Smith and tell him he must please not repeat stories. He must not forget his notes with you. I want to hear more about you solving the puzzles your clients bring you. Not repeat, repeat, repeat stories from long ago. My memory does not need reminding.
Please Mma, tell him. Tell him we want all your stories and clients’ puzzles back.
With my very best wishes
Mma Imbali
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review.
December 20, 2019
I am so glad that Alexander McCall Smith is such a prolific writer. It means he writes books faster than I can find time to read them so I never run out. Of course when it comes to the latest No.1 Ladies Detective Agency book I make the time to read it.
As is expected Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi drink lots of Rooibos tea, discuss the failings of mankind, and still solve a few mysterious cases along the way. The little white van is amazingly still more or less road worthy, Charlie is showing signs of maturing (a little anyway) and Mma Ramotswe is as soft hearted as ever. It seems there may be room for another child in the Maketoni household.
I enjoyed this book as much as I have the previous nineteen. I hope they continue coming for a long time yet.
As is expected Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi drink lots of Rooibos tea, discuss the failings of mankind, and still solve a few mysterious cases along the way. The little white van is amazingly still more or less road worthy, Charlie is showing signs of maturing (a little anyway) and Mma Ramotswe is as soft hearted as ever. It seems there may be room for another child in the Maketoni household.
I enjoyed this book as much as I have the previous nineteen. I hope they continue coming for a long time yet.
November 13, 2019
Oh, how exciting, a new “No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency” book. Number 20 in the series to be exact.
Mma Ramotswe meets a friend at a wedding that the newspaper said died in a car accident. From this, master story teller Alexander McCall Smith weaves another interesting tale.
The book is well written. The story meanders in the AMS style. It is so good to be visiting with my friends, Precious Ramotswe and Grace Makati. AMS weaves humor, a moral dilemma and some action into a delightful tale. I just have to sit down with some bush tea and visit with my friends. I cannot wait for book number 21.
I read this as an audiobook downloaded from Audible. The book is nine hours and five minutes. Lisette Lecat does an excellent job narrating the book. Lecat is an actress from South Africa and has narrated all the “No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency” books. She does a great job with all the various accents.
Mma Ramotswe meets a friend at a wedding that the newspaper said died in a car accident. From this, master story teller Alexander McCall Smith weaves another interesting tale.
The book is well written. The story meanders in the AMS style. It is so good to be visiting with my friends, Precious Ramotswe and Grace Makati. AMS weaves humor, a moral dilemma and some action into a delightful tale. I just have to sit down with some bush tea and visit with my friends. I cannot wait for book number 21.
I read this as an audiobook downloaded from Audible. The book is nine hours and five minutes. Lisette Lecat does an excellent job narrating the book. Lecat is an actress from South Africa and has narrated all the “No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency” books. She does a great job with all the various accents.
October 25, 2019
I always look forward to a new book in The Ladies’ No.1 Detective Agency. This is the 20th book in this enjoyable series and have read them all with pleasure. If one is unfamiliar with these books, and looking for a fast-paced and complicated mystery involving brutality and murder, this may not be for you. These lovely stories contain much wit and wisdom and a gentle philosophy of life. This is a relaxing read where I feel I am welcoming back old friends.
In Precious Ramotswe’s thoughts:
“ The bad behaviour with which No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency was concerned was not really all that bad. They saw selfishness and greed; they saw vanity, and its cousin, insecurity. They did not see major cruelties, nor great frauds and dishonesties. “
Most of the narrative consists of amusing but thought-provoking dialogue.
Precious Ramotswe, a woman of high moral values, is the owner and manager of the detective agency. Helping her in the office and investigations is her assistant Mma Makutsi. This proud, prickly, and argumentative lady has promoted herself from secretary to detective. She has now given herself some sort of management title. The impoverished Charlie worked as an apprentice mechanic but never made it as a full-fledged mechanic. He now is an office assistant for Mma Ramotswe,
Charlie longs for the title of assistant detective but has to put up with insults from Mma Maktusi who impedes his progress. In helping with their detective investigations, he is confused about the need for subterfuge in questioning witnesses. However, he learns that being completely honest in his personal relationships may be remarkably rewarded.
Precious becomes reacquainted with an old friend and finds her unhappy due to an estrangement from her adult daughter. The cause is unknown. She learns that the daughter works in a diamond sorting facility and now drives a very expensive car and lives in an upscale apartment. This looks suspicious to Precious and her team. She also learns that an old acquaintance who was enjoying great wealth was now broke and had given away her Mercedes Benz. Precious is determined to restore kindness, happiness to these women, and she hopes for a feeling of equality throughout her Botswana community. They take on these cases free of charge. There is another investigation requested by a woman who suspects her husband is being unfaithful. He claims his frequent visit with a woman is to learn mathematics from her. The truth turns out to be very complicated.
If you are a fan of The Ladies’ No. 1 Detective Agency, don’t miss this enjoyable addition to the series.
In Precious Ramotswe’s thoughts:
“ The bad behaviour with which No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency was concerned was not really all that bad. They saw selfishness and greed; they saw vanity, and its cousin, insecurity. They did not see major cruelties, nor great frauds and dishonesties. “
Most of the narrative consists of amusing but thought-provoking dialogue.
Precious Ramotswe, a woman of high moral values, is the owner and manager of the detective agency. Helping her in the office and investigations is her assistant Mma Makutsi. This proud, prickly, and argumentative lady has promoted herself from secretary to detective. She has now given herself some sort of management title. The impoverished Charlie worked as an apprentice mechanic but never made it as a full-fledged mechanic. He now is an office assistant for Mma Ramotswe,
Charlie longs for the title of assistant detective but has to put up with insults from Mma Maktusi who impedes his progress. In helping with their detective investigations, he is confused about the need for subterfuge in questioning witnesses. However, he learns that being completely honest in his personal relationships may be remarkably rewarded.
Precious becomes reacquainted with an old friend and finds her unhappy due to an estrangement from her adult daughter. The cause is unknown. She learns that the daughter works in a diamond sorting facility and now drives a very expensive car and lives in an upscale apartment. This looks suspicious to Precious and her team. She also learns that an old acquaintance who was enjoying great wealth was now broke and had given away her Mercedes Benz. Precious is determined to restore kindness, happiness to these women, and she hopes for a feeling of equality throughout her Botswana community. They take on these cases free of charge. There is another investigation requested by a woman who suspects her husband is being unfaithful. He claims his frequent visit with a woman is to learn mathematics from her. The truth turns out to be very complicated.
If you are a fan of The Ladies’ No. 1 Detective Agency, don’t miss this enjoyable addition to the series.
September 23, 2019
I cannot "not like" any of these stories, I just love the characters and the Botswana setting too much. Still, this one was - sadly - a little lacking. I missed the usual slow build-up of the one central case, where we are on a journey of discovery together with Mma Ramotswe and her helpers. Also the other developments, Charlie's engagement and baby Daisy, are treated a little too fleetingly for my taste.
I love Mr McCall Smith's writing, but could it be that he is working on too many projects?
I love Mr McCall Smith's writing, but could it be that he is working on too many projects?
October 5, 2021
1.5 Stars
If you read and loved this story, you may not want to read this review. Looking at the Goodreads overall rating, it appears that I’m a definite outlier! I’m offering this unpopular opinion as a fan of the series...I’ve read them all.. however, this recent installment is a huge disappointment. Fans of the series may want to read it and may enjoy it (I suggest that this is one to borrow and not buy)....but if you decide to skip it, you won’t have missed much. One pet peeve is that the love triangle between Charlie, Queenie-Queenie, and Fanwell that is noted in the book’s description never occurs in the story. In fact, it appears as if the person who wrote the summary never read the book. Another frustration is the amount of time the author devotes to philosophizing.....it hijacks the story and almost seems like the main reason he writes it. I am left with the impression that it was written as a filler to meet contract obligations (speculation!) If you want to read a good story in this series, I suggest reading House of Unexpected Sisters from two years ago.
I usually don’t write these types of negative reviews .... I simply give it a star rating and move on ..... but as a fan of the series and of Maa Ramotswe, I am deeply disappointed and decided to speak up. I encourage you to check out other more positive reviews to gain a more balanced perspective! If you read it and loved it, I’d love to hear what I may have missed!
Even though this was a disappointing read, I did note a few quotes because The author has a lovely way of expressing thoughts:
“Kindness, after all, did not distinguish between those who merited it and those who did not. It was like rain, she thought. It fell everywhere and made everything green and new and alive once more. That is what it did.”
“That nurturing of plants, that desire to cultivate, to sow and reap, lay at the heart of the culture, along with the deep-seated desire to tend cattle.
according to the rules of the old Botswana morality, as an older relative she had at least some responsibility for him. That was how it was: nobody was left alone, unrelated, and uncared for—somewhere, in the vast tangle of human relationships, everybody could say to at least someone: I am one of your people.”
“The world was not like that, she knew; we had to fit in with the world rather than the world fit in with us, but every so often it was nice to imagine that it was the other way round. And there was no doubt, she thought, that Botswana fitted her to perfection. It was the right size; it was the right shape on the map; the people who lived in it and the cattle they kept were just as she would want them to be; it was so perfect that she imagined that God himself had thought: I shall invent a country that is just right for Mma Ramotswe when she comes along, and I shall call it Botswana, and it will be a good place.”
For more reviews visit my blog www.readingladies.com
If you read and loved this story, you may not want to read this review. Looking at the Goodreads overall rating, it appears that I’m a definite outlier! I’m offering this unpopular opinion as a fan of the series...I’ve read them all.. however, this recent installment is a huge disappointment. Fans of the series may want to read it and may enjoy it (I suggest that this is one to borrow and not buy)....but if you decide to skip it, you won’t have missed much. One pet peeve is that the love triangle between Charlie, Queenie-Queenie, and Fanwell that is noted in the book’s description never occurs in the story. In fact, it appears as if the person who wrote the summary never read the book. Another frustration is the amount of time the author devotes to philosophizing.....it hijacks the story and almost seems like the main reason he writes it. I am left with the impression that it was written as a filler to meet contract obligations (speculation!) If you want to read a good story in this series, I suggest reading House of Unexpected Sisters from two years ago.
I usually don’t write these types of negative reviews .... I simply give it a star rating and move on ..... but as a fan of the series and of Maa Ramotswe, I am deeply disappointed and decided to speak up. I encourage you to check out other more positive reviews to gain a more balanced perspective! If you read it and loved it, I’d love to hear what I may have missed!
Even though this was a disappointing read, I did note a few quotes because The author has a lovely way of expressing thoughts:
“Kindness, after all, did not distinguish between those who merited it and those who did not. It was like rain, she thought. It fell everywhere and made everything green and new and alive once more. That is what it did.”
“That nurturing of plants, that desire to cultivate, to sow and reap, lay at the heart of the culture, along with the deep-seated desire to tend cattle.
according to the rules of the old Botswana morality, as an older relative she had at least some responsibility for him. That was how it was: nobody was left alone, unrelated, and uncared for—somewhere, in the vast tangle of human relationships, everybody could say to at least someone: I am one of your people.”
“The world was not like that, she knew; we had to fit in with the world rather than the world fit in with us, but every so often it was nice to imagine that it was the other way round. And there was no doubt, she thought, that Botswana fitted her to perfection. It was the right size; it was the right shape on the map; the people who lived in it and the cattle they kept were just as she would want them to be; it was so perfect that she imagined that God himself had thought: I shall invent a country that is just right for Mma Ramotswe when she comes along, and I shall call it Botswana, and it will be a good place.”
For more reviews visit my blog www.readingladies.com
June 15, 2022
This book provided me with several pleasant interludes while cycling my stationary recumbent bicycle. I find I will exercise longer if I am sufficiently distracted! There were the usual references to cups of tea and teatime, which provided several of my favorite quotes:
"A cup of tea usually restored perspective on things.."
"Tea was served and the cake was wordlessly taken from its tin, given admiring looks by Mma Ramotswe, and served on Mma Potokwane's best plates..." This stirred fond memories of teatimes past. How I love to share the soothing ritual of afternoon tea with a dear friend. There is nothing quite like it.
"It was the tea that had made her say what she said. It was the tea. But she never once regretted what she had done under the influence of tea.."
Finally, a quote about kindness, which makes life so much more pleasant and lifts our spirits: "Kindness, after all, did not distinguish between those who merited it and those who did not." I remind myself regularly that I will never regret being kind.
"A cup of tea usually restored perspective on things.."
"Tea was served and the cake was wordlessly taken from its tin, given admiring looks by Mma Ramotswe, and served on Mma Potokwane's best plates..." This stirred fond memories of teatimes past. How I love to share the soothing ritual of afternoon tea with a dear friend. There is nothing quite like it.
"It was the tea that had made her say what she said. It was the tea. But she never once regretted what she had done under the influence of tea.."
Finally, a quote about kindness, which makes life so much more pleasant and lifts our spirits: "Kindness, after all, did not distinguish between those who merited it and those who did not." I remind myself regularly that I will never regret being kind.
October 28, 2019
"Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni had been uncertain what to say. He wondered if he should ask Mma Ramotswe why she had not consulted him, but decided against it. If husbands started to question their wive's decisions, then where would it end, and what purpose would it serve?"
And that's why I love this series, and will continue reading each installment as long as Smith keeps writing them.
And that's why I love this series, and will continue reading each installment as long as Smith keeps writing them.
September 4, 2019
There is just something so refreshing about reading another Precious Ramotswe book in this long running series. I just love how much she loves Botswana and her life. I like how her kindness finds unique solutions to her investigations. This is so apparent in her case of a man whose wife suspects him of cheating with his math tutor. I love the solution to that case.
Precious also discovers a friend that she had long thought was dead and her renewed friendship leads her into an investigation of a church established by a lay person with the name Mechanic in the title. I like this church as it's held outside by a river with a barbecue going the entire time. Now that's my idea of church. Of course, there's more going on.
Old favorites are also featured including Charlie who finally has something wonderful happen to him. And what book would be complete without Mma Makutsi and her shoes? And there is wonderful news from the orphanage that adds joy to Precious and her family.
You don't read these books necessarily for the story but for how good they make you feel and this one made me feel excellent. I had a big smile on my face when I was done. Now that's a satisfactory ending.
Precious also discovers a friend that she had long thought was dead and her renewed friendship leads her into an investigation of a church established by a lay person with the name Mechanic in the title. I like this church as it's held outside by a river with a barbecue going the entire time. Now that's my idea of church. Of course, there's more going on.
Old favorites are also featured including Charlie who finally has something wonderful happen to him. And what book would be complete without Mma Makutsi and her shoes? And there is wonderful news from the orphanage that adds joy to Precious and her family.
You don't read these books necessarily for the story but for how good they make you feel and this one made me feel excellent. I had a big smile on my face when I was done. Now that's a satisfactory ending.
July 31, 2022
Second read:
I love this series. Medicine for the soul. ❤️
first read:
The latest Mma Ramotswe novel is out, and yes. The magic is still there. I love the wisdom and the kindness (but without any type of feeling of sickening-sweetness) in these books. There is humor that is genuinely funny, sometimes laugh out loud funny, because as you get to know these characters, you can't help but love them, even for their faults. They are real and I love spending time with them.
AMS loves Botswana, and it shows. He loves and appreciates trees, the sky, gardens, birds, etc. He has a sensitive soul, as do I, and this is obvious when you read him. I just love him and his wonderful characters, that's all there is to it. He is a man after my heart, and may God continue to bless his keyboard, pen, hands, paper, all of it. The world needs civility times a thousand, and every time I read his books, I get a refill.
In addition, the wonderful Lisette Lecat narrates every audiobook in this series. I listen to close to a hundred audiobooks each year. She is in my top three all-time narrators. There is no way the audio performance could be improved; it would be impossible. I encourage you to listen to this series and drink it in, particularly if, like me, you're troubled by all the animosity in the world today. This series (and this author) will revive you, like an oasis in the desert.
Thank you, Alexander McCall Smith.
I love this series. Medicine for the soul. ❤️
first read:
The latest Mma Ramotswe novel is out, and yes. The magic is still there. I love the wisdom and the kindness (but without any type of feeling of sickening-sweetness) in these books. There is humor that is genuinely funny, sometimes laugh out loud funny, because as you get to know these characters, you can't help but love them, even for their faults. They are real and I love spending time with them.
AMS loves Botswana, and it shows. He loves and appreciates trees, the sky, gardens, birds, etc. He has a sensitive soul, as do I, and this is obvious when you read him. I just love him and his wonderful characters, that's all there is to it. He is a man after my heart, and may God continue to bless his keyboard, pen, hands, paper, all of it. The world needs civility times a thousand, and every time I read his books, I get a refill.
In addition, the wonderful Lisette Lecat narrates every audiobook in this series. I listen to close to a hundred audiobooks each year. She is in my top three all-time narrators. There is no way the audio performance could be improved; it would be impossible. I encourage you to listen to this series and drink it in, particularly if, like me, you're troubled by all the animosity in the world today. This series (and this author) will revive you, like an oasis in the desert.
Thank you, Alexander McCall Smith.
November 22, 2024
3.5 stars
In this 20th book in the 'No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency' series, Mma Ramotswe - who owns the agency - gets involved in various disparate situations.
The book can be read as a standalone, but familiarity with the series is a plus.
*****
Mma Ramotswe is at a wedding celebration when she spots an old friend, Calviniah Ramoroka, whom she hasn't seen in years. Later, when the women are lunching together, Calviniah confides that her daughter Nametso has become distant, and Calviniah doesn't know why.
Mma Ramotswe intuits that Calviniah wants her help, and the detectives at the 'No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency' proceed to follow and investigate Nametso. One scene where Mma Ramotswe, her detective partner Mma Makutsi, and assistant detective Charlie are all stuffed into the front seat of Mma Ramotswe's tiny white van is hilarious.
Mma Ramotswe also learns that another old friend named Poppy, who had accumulated a substantial nest egg, is now almost broke. It seems Poppy has given her new preacher a VERY expensive Mercedes Benz.
Mma Ramotswe is distressed by Poppy's plight and would like to help.
Meanwhile, Mma Ramotswe has been hired by a woman called Mma Mogorosi, who wants to know if her husband is cheating on her. Mma Ramotswe finds that the hubby isn't unfaithful but is secretly taking math lessons. This isn't the end of the story though.....
On a day off, Mma Ramotswe visits her friend, orphanage director Mma Potokwane, who always serves bush tea and delicious fruit cake.
At the orphanage, Mma Ramotswe meets one of the house mothers, and a surprise follows.
Lastly, assistant detective Charlie, a young man who works as an assistant to Mma Ramotswe and a part-time mechanic for Mma Ramotswe's husband - Mr. JLB Matekoni at Tlokweng Road Speedy Motors - says he wants to marry his girlfriend Queenie Queenie.
There's a big problem though. Charlie is very poor, Queenie Queenie's family is very rich, and Botswana customs require a substantial bride price. A possible solution presents itself, but Charlie is ambivalent about jumping in.
In the end, a series of (unlikely) coinidences help resolve many of the above situations.
The books in this series are never really about solving mysteries, but rather about Mma Ramotswe's kind heart, desire to think the best of people, and philosophy of life. As always, Mma Ramotswe has entertaining conversations with her husband and staff, and Mma Makutsi's shoes - which like to chime in with opnions - make some fun comments as well.
The novel is just the ticket for an afternoon's light reading.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot.com
November 19, 2019
An upbeat, easygoing book, perfect for the holidays. This is latest in the series from an author who is Botswana's best travel agent--(meant in the nicest way.) While Precious grapples with real problems and find ways to solve them, readers get to understand and enjoy her very humane world-view.
This series is 180-degrees from a hard-charging thriller; still, mystery and cozy readers will like this gentle book that nonetheless deals with weighty topics.
Highly recommended.
This series is 180-degrees from a hard-charging thriller; still, mystery and cozy readers will like this gentle book that nonetheless deals with weighty topics.
Highly recommended.
October 29, 2019
Maybe not quite as good
I love Mma Ramotswe and J.L.B Matekoni. I adore Mma Makutse and Charlie and Mma Potekwane. And even though I have never seen Botswana, I love it as well.
But I did not love this novel as I have so many of the others. I have noticed a tendency in recent novels for the author to tie things together very quickly in just a few pages, as if he suddenly realized he was nearing a page limit and had to finish things up in the pages that were left. This installment has a similar problem.
I do not even know where to begin with this one, but will say this, without, I hope, giving too much away. The original case that begins this novel involves a woman who believes her husband is cheating on her. Nothing really happens with that story line except for one other scene and two letters. It is almost as if the author forgot all about that case and just let it float away.
Disappointing. And I was so excited for another Precious Ramotswe book.
I love Mma Ramotswe and J.L.B Matekoni. I adore Mma Makutse and Charlie and Mma Potekwane. And even though I have never seen Botswana, I love it as well.
But I did not love this novel as I have so many of the others. I have noticed a tendency in recent novels for the author to tie things together very quickly in just a few pages, as if he suddenly realized he was nearing a page limit and had to finish things up in the pages that were left. This installment has a similar problem.
I do not even know where to begin with this one, but will say this, without, I hope, giving too much away. The original case that begins this novel involves a woman who believes her husband is cheating on her. Nothing really happens with that story line except for one other scene and two letters. It is almost as if the author forgot all about that case and just let it float away.
Disappointing. And I was so excited for another Precious Ramotswe book.
October 30, 2019
Disappointing. I've read all previous, but probably won't read any more in the series. It reads like it was written quickly, to a publisher's timetable. There is a fair bit of filler here. And the repeated comments on the (supposed) behaviours of men is really getting on my nerves, it's repetitive and wrong and sexist in my opinion, and occurs in almost every chapter. I know he is writing for his feminist audience and they (probably) lap it up, but even then, these biting criticisms come across as the most condescending of writings. They may have been meant as funny, but it's not, it's just juvenile. Men (and women) deserve a better commentary. And readers deserve a better writing and plot and storylines. Poor old Alexander has hit rock bottom here.
January 11, 2020
“She had already had a cup of tea at home before she left for the office, but that was no reason not to have one now. A cup of tea usually restored perspective on things, and that was what she needed now, rather than to sit and think about the ways in which the modern world was ordered. And she was right: a steaming cup of redbush tea was sufficient to banish thoughts of change and decay and to restore the spirits. This was going to be a good day - she was determined to make that so – and she was going to work steadily and efficiently through the list of tasks she had written out for herself.”
To The Land Of Long Lost Friends is the twentieth book in the popular No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series by Scottish author, Alexander McCall Smith. Attending a traditional Botswana wedding, Precious Ramotswe sees a ghost. Mr JLB Matekoni worries about heat stroke, but the explanation is far simpler, and Precious decides to help her long lost friend with a family problem. An intriguing case results, with theories and advice offered by Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie as well as Mma Makutsi.
A case of possible adultery which Mma Ramotswe believes to be concluded is taken up by Mma Makutsi, who feels there is more to learn. A puzzling letter is subsequently received and Charlie gives a male perspective. And a charismatic preacher who is very skilled at divesting wealthy ladies of their money is shown the error of his ways.
In a jaw-dropping development, given his meagre resources, Charlie becomes engaged. Mma Makutsi dares to entertain critical thoughts about Mma Ramotswe’s reverence of Seretse Khama. Both Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie are upbraided for sexist attitudes, although Mma Makutsi does admit her expectations of Charlie might be unreasonably high.
It seems that Mma Makutsi’s pronouncements about excessive meat consumption have had an insidious effect on Mma Ramotswe’s cooking: Mr JLB Matekoni subtly voices mild criticism of the dearth of meat in his meal.
Mma Ramotswe muses on obligation to love your brothers and sisters, even if they “were difficult people, dirty in some cases, selfish and calculating in others, even smelly” and the real difficulty of loving your enemies (Violet Sepotho?). Mma Potokwani enlightens Mr JLB Matekoni on the existence of “deserved calories”.
The story includes a shady scheme, a guilty daughter, a religious charlatan and a certain silver Mercedes Benz. And there is an unexpected addition to the household of Mma Ramotswe and Mr JLB Matekoni, Motholeli and Puso. As always, McCall Smith gives the reader a novel that has humour and wisdom, insightful observations and heartfelt emotion. Delightfully entertaining.
Adjoa Andoh’s narration of the audio version is a joy to listen to.
To The Land Of Long Lost Friends is the twentieth book in the popular No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series by Scottish author, Alexander McCall Smith. Attending a traditional Botswana wedding, Precious Ramotswe sees a ghost. Mr JLB Matekoni worries about heat stroke, but the explanation is far simpler, and Precious decides to help her long lost friend with a family problem. An intriguing case results, with theories and advice offered by Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie as well as Mma Makutsi.
A case of possible adultery which Mma Ramotswe believes to be concluded is taken up by Mma Makutsi, who feels there is more to learn. A puzzling letter is subsequently received and Charlie gives a male perspective. And a charismatic preacher who is very skilled at divesting wealthy ladies of their money is shown the error of his ways.
In a jaw-dropping development, given his meagre resources, Charlie becomes engaged. Mma Makutsi dares to entertain critical thoughts about Mma Ramotswe’s reverence of Seretse Khama. Both Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie are upbraided for sexist attitudes, although Mma Makutsi does admit her expectations of Charlie might be unreasonably high.
It seems that Mma Makutsi’s pronouncements about excessive meat consumption have had an insidious effect on Mma Ramotswe’s cooking: Mr JLB Matekoni subtly voices mild criticism of the dearth of meat in his meal.
Mma Ramotswe muses on obligation to love your brothers and sisters, even if they “were difficult people, dirty in some cases, selfish and calculating in others, even smelly” and the real difficulty of loving your enemies (Violet Sepotho?). Mma Potokwani enlightens Mr JLB Matekoni on the existence of “deserved calories”.
The story includes a shady scheme, a guilty daughter, a religious charlatan and a certain silver Mercedes Benz. And there is an unexpected addition to the household of Mma Ramotswe and Mr JLB Matekoni, Motholeli and Puso. As always, McCall Smith gives the reader a novel that has humour and wisdom, insightful observations and heartfelt emotion. Delightfully entertaining.
Adjoa Andoh’s narration of the audio version is a joy to listen to.
March 30, 2021
Prolific author Alexander McCall Smith writes ‘gentle’ novels that remark on the foibles we human beings fall prey to. His characters in the No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency have become my old friends. There is Precious Ramotswe, the owner of the Agency who is determined to respect the hearts and feelings of everyone around her. That is not the case with her acerbic assistant, Mma Makutsi. She is quick to share her opinion regardless of whom it might offend. Mma Potokwane must make some awesome fruitcake as it seems to dependably cajole others to volunteer their time/energy on behalf of the orphanage. Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni is the perfect husband for Precious—always supportive, always willing to listen, and occasionally offers a wise observation.
As the title suggests, this offering has Mma Ramotswe seeking to help an old friend. In addition, Charlie is in a quandry—in love with Queenie-Queenie, a young woman from a much wealthier family. How can he ever expect to raise enough money to meet her families’ bride price. Enjoy!
As the title suggests, this offering has Mma Ramotswe seeking to help an old friend. In addition, Charlie is in a quandry—in love with Queenie-Queenie, a young woman from a much wealthier family. How can he ever expect to raise enough money to meet her families’ bride price. Enjoy!
November 4, 2024
I am not sure why I disliked this book when I read it in 2019 as a review copy. But though it has too many silly Mma Makutsi argues with Mma Ramotswe (or Charlie) sequences, I enjoyed it a lot more this time around.
September 2, 2019
Copy received from Hachette Australia for an honest review
I have read the No 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series on and off over the years and have enjoyed them.
However, this one was a miss for me. It was lacking that something that makes these books great.
This installment just felt like it was earlier books on repeat, and it really did not do Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi justice (though I have not really been a fan of Mms Makutsi in the past either)
I did like that Charlie got married (highlight of the book for me, though we didn't get enough of it).
I hope Mr McCall Smith can bring back the great in later books.
I have read the No 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series on and off over the years and have enjoyed them.
However, this one was a miss for me. It was lacking that something that makes these books great.
This installment just felt like it was earlier books on repeat, and it really did not do Mma Ramotswe and Mma Makutsi justice (though I have not really been a fan of Mms Makutsi in the past either)
I did like that Charlie got married (highlight of the book for me, though we didn't get enough of it).
I hope Mr McCall Smith can bring back the great in later books.
August 15, 2019
I am amazed that Alexander McCall Smith, one of the most prolific of contemporary authors, has managed to write another wonderful story about Precious Ramotswe and her fellow residents of Botswana. Mma Ramotswe meets an old friend who is estranged from her daughter, and her investigation dovetails in a surprising way with another problem handled by the indomitable Mma. Potokwame. Precious treats everyone with kindness, because “kindness, after all, did not distinguish between those who merited it, and those who did not. It was like rain, she thought. It fell everywhere and made everything green and alive once more. That is what it did.” This might sound trite in less skilled hands, but McCall Smith has delineated the character of Precious Ramotswe so carefully that it sounds perfect. Highly recommended.
December 1, 2020
Mma Potokwane comes through in the clutch in this lovely, relaxing adventure. The ladies—and Charlie—each took a turn reminding me why these books are my happy place.
Botswana Botswana Botswana
Botswana Botswana Botswana
February 6, 2020
I'm a long time fan of this series, but this one seems to have out-gentled all the others I can remember. There is a sweetness to it, with families wrapping themselves around those who need it, and secular mini-homilies about forgiveness, refraining from assumption, generosity of spirit and loyalty. For me this book was less mystery than it was observation on human relationships.
But there is a little dark streak of women v men, rich v poor, religion v tradition, the in people and the out people. I'm not exactly sure where the author lands on those topics other than to wave them in the air, and that Precious R will have her way, while Mr. J L B Matekoni will do what she says, but think what he thinks. Not sure that is the takeaway meant, but I believe it 97%, at least.
100% I believe in talking shoes. Wan-hon-dred pour-scent! Looking forward to the next edition in this delightful series.
But there is a little dark streak of women v men, rich v poor, religion v tradition, the in people and the out people. I'm not exactly sure where the author lands on those topics other than to wave them in the air, and that Precious R will have her way, while Mr. J L B Matekoni will do what she says, but think what he thinks. Not sure that is the takeaway meant, but I believe it 97%, at least.
100% I believe in talking shoes. Wan-hon-dred pour-scent! Looking forward to the next edition in this delightful series.
November 26, 2019
Book #20 in my favorite series yay! There's just something about these books. It's the people, the descriptions of the land itself, and the positive depictions of almost everyone and everything including traditionally built ladies. Just look at some of the titles: The Good Husband of Zebra Drive, Blue Shoes and Happiness, The Full Cupboard of Life, The Woman Who Walked in Sunshine and some other titles like The Art of Gratitude and The Careful Use of Compliments. I've watched a lot of interviews with the author and it's obvious that this is who he himself is as a person...someone who holds traditional values in high regard. He's a person who, through his writing, reminds us to be grateful even through hard times because every day truly is a gift. His books helped me through some pretty dark times honestly. They also made me want to travel one day and travel first to his beloved Botswana. The author did grow up, live, and teach in Africa. During interviews people ask him why he never mentions the high amount of persons living with the HIV virus in Africa to which he replies something like "I like to focus on the loving kindness of the people rather than their medical problems and everyone knows it's there but no one really talks about how much goodness there is within the hearts of the people of that beautiful country." I've read every single one and here's to starting number 20.
July 4, 2020
I passed on the last couple of books in this series, largely because I’ve only ever wanted to listen to them on audible and suddenly the formerly delightful narration was overrun by unpleasant, distracting mouth noise.
The quality of these stories has always been variable, with odd and sometimes important narrative inconsistencies running throughout, and I had grown weary of both. I thought I was finished with the series.
But I found myself missing my escapes to Botswana through the eyes of these mild yet remarkably believable and interesting characters. Botswana—the land, culture, and people, for me, is the main and most interesting character.
In the 2020 that I need escapes from, these light reads beckoned. I listened to a sample of the latest story and found the narration quality of this one much better than recent books in the series.
The featured mystery is the weakest of the series, the most uninteresting and irrelevant to the book. It was also almost comically, though not amusingly, predictable. The only plot thread of any interest was, oddly enough, regular character Charlie’s love life.
The read is largely an experience of following the characters and conversations around in their meandering fashion for a few days.
Disappointing as the plot was, it didn’t matter much to me since I wasn’t expecting a lot and I got what I came for, pleasant enough time in a fascinating faraway place. Armchair travel is what we have these days.
I did find myself slipping unexpectedly into 2020 worry for both the real Botswana, and in the silly way of fictive belief, for the characters of this book who I’m convinced are actually walking around in the real Botswana. I had to clamp down that thought train and keep it at down. I came for escape, yet brought our troubles right into the story place with me. Reading vigilance for a fictional world is an unexpected and sad fallout of our time.
The quality of these stories has always been variable, with odd and sometimes important narrative inconsistencies running throughout, and I had grown weary of both. I thought I was finished with the series.
But I found myself missing my escapes to Botswana through the eyes of these mild yet remarkably believable and interesting characters. Botswana—the land, culture, and people, for me, is the main and most interesting character.
In the 2020 that I need escapes from, these light reads beckoned. I listened to a sample of the latest story and found the narration quality of this one much better than recent books in the series.
The featured mystery is the weakest of the series, the most uninteresting and irrelevant to the book. It was also almost comically, though not amusingly, predictable. The only plot thread of any interest was, oddly enough, regular character Charlie’s love life.
The read is largely an experience of following the characters and conversations around in their meandering fashion for a few days.
Disappointing as the plot was, it didn’t matter much to me since I wasn’t expecting a lot and I got what I came for, pleasant enough time in a fascinating faraway place. Armchair travel is what we have these days.
I did find myself slipping unexpectedly into 2020 worry for both the real Botswana, and in the silly way of fictive belief, for the characters of this book who I’m convinced are actually walking around in the real Botswana. I had to clamp down that thought train and keep it at down. I came for escape, yet brought our troubles right into the story place with me. Reading vigilance for a fictional world is an unexpected and sad fallout of our time.
March 15, 2024
Listened to as an audiobook. It’s been 3 or 4 years since I have read one of the Ladies #1 Detective Agency books. There is a bit more sadness in the stories this time around, especially as we learn more about the long poverty of apprentice detective, Charlie. But as always, things end well.
April 10, 2024
Setting: Botswana, Africa; modern day.
This is the 20th book in the saga of the No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency, featuring Precious Ramotswe and her sidekick, Mma Makutsi. No particular 'cases' in this one for the pair to investigate, apart from the man being investigated for an affair who turns out to be having maths lessons, yet still the pair manage to get involved in trying to right wrongs perpetrated on friends of theirs. The theme of this book was very much the 'battle of the sexes', or at least the rights and wrongs of some men's feelings towards women and some women's feelings towards men. In many ways, the book seemed to be attempting to correct misconceptions on the side of both men and women about the opposite sex, which perhaps became a bit laboured as the book continued. Hence, although still enjoyable overall and still a 4-star read for me, not quite as high a rating as previous books in the series - 8/10.
This is the 20th book in the saga of the No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency, featuring Precious Ramotswe and her sidekick, Mma Makutsi. No particular 'cases' in this one for the pair to investigate, apart from the man being investigated for an affair who turns out to be having maths lessons, yet still the pair manage to get involved in trying to right wrongs perpetrated on friends of theirs. The theme of this book was very much the 'battle of the sexes', or at least the rights and wrongs of some men's feelings towards women and some women's feelings towards men. In many ways, the book seemed to be attempting to correct misconceptions on the side of both men and women about the opposite sex, which perhaps became a bit laboured as the book continued. Hence, although still enjoyable overall and still a 4-star read for me, not quite as high a rating as previous books in the series - 8/10.
September 17, 2019
The 20th instalment in this series features all the familiar characters and follows the faithful formula, but it's not the best of the bunch. There are three central storylines but as usual they take a backseat to the characters sitting around drinking tea and discussing life. For whatever reason I found their conversations less interesting than usual and at least one of the storylines gets wrapped up so abruptly in the final two pages that I didn't fully understand how it had come together. Nevertheless this is a warm hearted and easy read.
November 17, 2020
Yet another enjoyable entry in the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series. The characters are moving on in life, even though Mma Ramotswe is still driving her tiny white van, much to the displeasure of Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni. Mma Ramotswe agrees to investigate why an old friend's daughter doesn't want anything to do with her mother anymore. Mma Makutsi and Charlie look further into a case that seemed to have been solved. The Ramotswe/Matekoni family gains a new member, and Charlie's and Queenie-Queenie's relationship moves forward.
January 11, 2020
“She had already had a cup of tea at home before she left for the office, but that was no reason not to have one now. A cup of tea usually restored perspective on things, and that was what she needed now, rather than to sit and think about the ways in which the modern world was ordered. And she was right: a steaming cup of redbush tea was sufficient to banish thoughts of change and decay and to restore the spirits. This was going to be a good day - she was determined to make that so – and she was going to work steadily and efficiently through the list of tasks she had written out for herself.”
To The Land Of Long Lost Friends is the twentieth book in the popular No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series by Scottish author, Alexander McCall Smith. Attending a traditional Botswana wedding, Precious Ramotswe sees a ghost. Mr JLB Matekoni worries about heat stroke, but the explanation is far simpler, and Precious decides to help her long lost friend with a family problem. An intriguing case results, with theories and advice offered by Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie as well as Mma Makutsi.
A case of possible adultery which Mma Ramotswe believes to be concluded is taken up by Mma Makutsi, who feels there is more to learn. A puzzling letter is subsequently received and Charlie gives a male perspective. And a charismatic preacher who is very skilled at divesting wealthy ladies of their money is shown the error of his ways.
In a jaw-dropping development, given his meagre resources, Charlie becomes engaged. Mma Makutsi dares to entertain critical thoughts about Mma Ramotswe’s reverence of Seretse Khama. Both Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie are upbraided for sexist attitudes, although Mma Makutsi does admit her expectations of Charlie might be unreasonably high.
It seems that Mma Makutsi’s pronouncements about excessive meat consumption have had an insidious effect on Mma Ramotswe’s cooking: Mr JLB Matekoni subtly voices mild criticism of the dearth of meat in his meal.
Mma Ramotswe muses on obligation to love your brothers and sisters, even if they “were difficult people, dirty in some cases, selfish and calculating in others, even smelly” and the real difficulty of loving your enemies (Violet Sepotho?). Mma Potokwani enlightens Mr JLB Matekoni on the existence of “deserved calories”.
The story includes a shady scheme, a guilty daughter, a religious charlatan and a certain silver Mercedes Benz. And there is an unexpected addition to the household of Mma Ramotswe and Mr JLB Matekoni, Motholeli and Puso. As always, McCall Smith gives the reader a novel that has humour and wisdom, insightful observations and heartfelt emotion. Delightfully entertaining.
Adjoa Andoh’s narration of the audio version is a joy to listen to.
To The Land Of Long Lost Friends is the twentieth book in the popular No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series by Scottish author, Alexander McCall Smith. Attending a traditional Botswana wedding, Precious Ramotswe sees a ghost. Mr JLB Matekoni worries about heat stroke, but the explanation is far simpler, and Precious decides to help her long lost friend with a family problem. An intriguing case results, with theories and advice offered by Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie as well as Mma Makutsi.
A case of possible adultery which Mma Ramotswe believes to be concluded is taken up by Mma Makutsi, who feels there is more to learn. A puzzling letter is subsequently received and Charlie gives a male perspective. And a charismatic preacher who is very skilled at divesting wealthy ladies of their money is shown the error of his ways.
In a jaw-dropping development, given his meagre resources, Charlie becomes engaged. Mma Makutsi dares to entertain critical thoughts about Mma Ramotswe’s reverence of Seretse Khama. Both Mr JLB Matekoni and Charlie are upbraided for sexist attitudes, although Mma Makutsi does admit her expectations of Charlie might be unreasonably high.
It seems that Mma Makutsi’s pronouncements about excessive meat consumption have had an insidious effect on Mma Ramotswe’s cooking: Mr JLB Matekoni subtly voices mild criticism of the dearth of meat in his meal.
Mma Ramotswe muses on obligation to love your brothers and sisters, even if they “were difficult people, dirty in some cases, selfish and calculating in others, even smelly” and the real difficulty of loving your enemies (Violet Sepotho?). Mma Potokwani enlightens Mr JLB Matekoni on the existence of “deserved calories”.
The story includes a shady scheme, a guilty daughter, a religious charlatan and a certain silver Mercedes Benz. And there is an unexpected addition to the household of Mma Ramotswe and Mr JLB Matekoni, Motholeli and Puso. As always, McCall Smith gives the reader a novel that has humour and wisdom, insightful observations and heartfelt emotion. Delightfully entertaining.
Adjoa Andoh’s narration of the audio version is a joy to listen to.
November 24, 2019
I look forward to each of these books as I would to visiting with old, dear friends. There is gentle humor, delightful dialogue, warmhearted scenes, interesting mysteries, and just the feeling of kindness and of people relating to each other in different ways. There's an unhurried atmosphere throughout each book, which I especially like, since during too much of life we seem to want rush through it in a matter of minutes. I very much like each of the regular characters, and as the series has progressed I am glad to see the development and maturation of Charlie, from a lazy, sexist young man to a useful, thoughtful, considerate person who is getting along with Grace Makutski better and better. They have reached a level of comfort and sympathy for each other that is very attractive. In this story I felt for Charlie, as he tries to navigate through the highs and lows of his romantic life, and of his sense of being a more useful part of the detective agency. This my favorite series of books, and this title reinforced my belief. A joy to read from beginning to end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,167 reviews