Holy canoli, the need for the next book is real! This was even better than its predecessor. My rave's already begun and I haven't gotten to the pros and cons. Here we go:
Pros
-Separation from inspiration and source material
*The Goodreads blurb from Red Rider admits this is Red Riding Hood+The Handmaid's Tale, and while there are similar elements (stripping the girls-the Chosen-of their identities by giving them numbers and nondescript white gowns and masks, conglomerating them into one for a single purpose, Red's hunt for her red cloak), but unlike many dystopian works, the society is run by a female Alpha, and they're are instructed to fight (however weakly) during the pre-wedding ceremony, and are promised the chance to decline their mate and choose their own if defeat the Sworn soldier
-Notion of Red's village restricted library/book usage to scholars spilling over into Sworn Society: reading is dangerous in the hands of the lower classes because if they truly understood, they'd rebel
-Animal comparison
*Mother Shade's invasive examination into Red's nooks and crannies brings to mind a perspective horse rider searching out the purebred, as well as the tracking device implanted in each of the Chosen resembles a dog's microchip
-Red's plan to blend in with the other girls/hide her rebellious nature resembles how women feel they must act the "right" way in order to succeed in life/the workplace, as well as the system of rewarding those who exude beauty, submissiveness, and fertility is a scary metaphor for how we as a society determine who's good enough
-Hesitate to call this a pro... Violent imagery
*I'm not a fan of violence for shock value, but in dystopias, it has its place. Once Red is captured, she is whipped for her defiance, starved in solitary confinement, and one unlucky Chosen is forced to eat the pages of contraband book. Jesus, it was downright disturbing, but necessary to show just how dire their straits.
-The Alpha likening herself to "a big bad wolf"
-Bribing the Chosen with food/security for their families only after submitting to a mate explains why so many intentionally lose the fight
-Conflict
*Red knows Kassian (Vixon) is both gone and still around; and while Vixon is kind, feeds/shelters Red, he still serves a society that punishes her.
-Vixon's reason for wearing silver armor
*True to werewolf legend, silver stings the Sworn. But pain is the only thing that reminds Vixon of his vulnerability, his humanity. And for him, that sensation is worth feeling.
-Red wielding a knitting needle as a weapon
*One, that's a big middle finger to those who consider crafting to be women's work and promotes docile nature, and second, it took me back to The Marvelous Land of Oz.
-Streamlined story telling
* So much happens in less than 300 pages and there are many settings, but they all get their due
-The end
* Red wins the sword fight against a Sworn set on having her as a mate, and chooses Vixon as her own. Makes me happy she's decided to follow her heart in being with him, and not taking the easy way out, instead taking down the system from the inside.
Cons
-Repetition of certain internal lamentations: "my stomach was tied in knots" is said one too many times.
Would you look at that? One measly con. You know I'm carrying on!