Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Sin Bravely: A Joyful Alternative to a Purpose-Driven Life

Rate this book
Mark Ellingsen dares you to go ahead and sin bravely! In this refreshing and unique read, he challenges the religious legalism pervasive throughout American evangelicalism today and encourages a new understanding of what it means to be both a Christian and a human being. Beginning with the first theological analysis of Rick Warren's brand of Christianity, this book exposes the burdens and narcissism that purpose-driven and duty-bound living encourages. Ellingsen criticizes the purveyors of the Prosperity Gospel, taught by such influential preachers like Joel Osteen, saying that this narcissistic inclination contributes to "Christianity light" a way of embracing faith without sacrificing too much. Ellingsen writes that brave sinners, aware of God's grace in their lives, instead say "no" to narcissism and "yes" to healthy risk-taking that gets beyond selfish desires to the desire to help one another. When people sin bravely, acknowledging that everything done is done in sin with God's saving grace acting upon them, people can learn to recognize God. Citing recent neurobiological findings, Ellingsen shows that when people forget themselves in order to focus on bigger projects, the pleasure centers of the brain are stimulated and people become happier and more content. It is this joyous risk-taking that he suggests brings people closer together, closer to God, and closer to a better understanding of themselves. This book demonstrates both how and why brave sinning leads to joy, and in so doing offers readers practical advice on living this way. Citing recent neurobiological findings, Ellingsen shows that when people forget themselves in order to focus on bigger projects, the pleasure centers of the brain are stimulated and people become happier and more content. It is this joyous risk-taking that he suggests brings people closer together, closer to God, and closer to a better understanding of themselves.

148 pages, Paperback

First published April 1, 2009

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Mark Ellingsen

42 books3 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2 (6%)
4 stars
11 (36%)
3 stars
6 (20%)
2 stars
11 (36%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
Profile Image for Nathan Napier.
10 reviews1 follower
August 7, 2013
As I prepared for seminary after finishing my bachelors degree, a well respected and articulate professor of mine said, "Go to seminary, study hard, but have fun. Theology is pointless if you're not having fun." I'd like to think what I have done since then has been a quest in having fun...and reading Sin Bravely has certainly been an extension, and affirmation, of all the fun being Christian is supposed to be, in case you didn't get the memo.

In a life plagued by interesting the mixture of classic American Liberalism and Puritan anthropological expressions of the Self, this small text goes to the heart of what happens when we turn our faith and our religion inward rather than outward: We become cowardly sinners who think our faith is FOR us and to support OUR worldviews as the INTENTION of God.

Funny how God always thinks like us isn't it?

The title is catchy, and is in fact why I picked it up, "Sin Bravely," but the text is not a book that promotes a life that is free from societal obligations or personal behavior that is founded in the Gospel of Jesus called the Christ. The text is, rather, a call to have fun in life, to have fun being a Christian, to have fun engaging our lives as brave sinners...because that is in fact all we are: Sinner saved by grace. Not that Paul does not use a past tense in the Greek there.

To those with holiness tradition sensibilities (i.e., most Wesleyan and American Holiness traditions) this may come as a surprise. At least it did for me, but Ellingsen was a trusty guide through those Augustinian/Lutheran forests. Historically, Augustine won the debate on defining sin, but in those traditions Pelagius has really taken center stage. Even the late Dr. Greathouse (a renowned theologian and leader in the Church of the Nazarene) quipped after a General Assembly to a colleague...as he was laughing "we're all just a bunch of Pelagians," and this comment after a debate on the floor following how the denomination was to define sin in its articles of faith.

Ellingson is trying to free us from that moral certitude, or overly humanistic perspective, that is touted by folks like Purpose Driven Life author Rick Warren or the similarly related prosperity preacher Joel Osteen (that which is the result of misapplying historical figures such as Jacob Arminius, John Wesley or even the Apostle Paul for that matter). These authors, along with strong currents of American ideology, promote a "do it yourself" Christianity that seems to equate purpose with a focus upon the self (even though they profess such is not the case). Jesus is to be followed because he enables you to be a better you...though I don't recall reading this in the Gospels. I digress. Warren, Osteen and their ilk, equate ones success with ones efforts...efforts that can overcome our humanity and align ourselves with God's "purpose" which somehow also looks like the vision of the world offered via the American Dream.

This is good, and commendable to a degree, but the problem arises when the "steps" are followed and the "purpose" discovered...and we continue to look more American in our materiality and philosophies and less Christian all the while. Its hard to be prophetic when your not really being prophetic...go figure. IN other words, the vision offered in the Purpose Driven model is one that looks like a success story within the American Dream...and the only thing that makes it different is that it is peppered with Jesus...not to mention all this talk of purpose is still talk directed upon ourselves, for ourselves. The goal becomes the self and its actualization. Christianity and Jesus are just the vehicles by which we actualize ourselves. This doesn't really sound a whole lot like the words of one who said, "unless you pick up your cross and follow me."

And this is where "Brave Sinning" takes center stage. Ellingsen is writing from a reformed perspective, Lutheran to be exact, and he is following Luther's Augustinian theology of concupiscent desire to discuss sin as not only those things that people do by omission or commission, but all our activities by which our self is the goal, the end, of the action. In other words, even being religious is something we do for the self...as as something that is self-ish...self-centered...so to it is sin. Even reading this review, or stopping to read this review, is an act of self decision for self-benefit...and hence marred in the sin of selfishness.

This is what Luther and Augustine mean by those bound by sin, Luther's idea of being simultaneously sinner and justified. It is not an idea hatched in Calvinist Hell as some would observe; it is, rather, the idea that at any point wherein the self is the driving force of the action the action is sinful. Thus, sin is ever present because our egos always play a role in our decisions. We cannot escape our condition...or as the writer of Ecclesiastes is apt to note, "there is not one righteous, no not one." Whether it be helping someone pray, writing a sermon, giving to the poor, asking God for forgiveness, mowing our yard, being kind to our spouses, being an awesome teacher to students etc., etc., all these actions have benefits for the self and were the self not benefited in some way than most of us would not do them. This is what separates us from Christ. Christ partook in action for the gain of nothing...as humans we do not know how to do that.

Even the act of confession is a sinful act whereby we are confessing our sins to save our "souls" from hell...and in the holiness traditions that speak of sanctification the goal is really a negation of the self in order to find the "real" spiritual self...its still an act of spiritual actualization that is not selfless...in fact it is totally centered on the self. And that is a profound theological trick: to convince people we are not interested in the self only to really preach a gospel that makes us better selves, feeling better about ourselves and creating a path whereby the self we hate becomes the self we can love.

Thus, Elingsen writes to inform us that once we realize we are all sinners to the core, selfish ego-centric beings, we can then be free to sin bravely...TO help the poor, to preach the Gospel, to petition for peace, to give to others, to bury the dead, to marry the happy, to help a child with their homework., etc., because we know that we do these things as people who are not pure in our intentions but who do them as sinners and do them so that God can turn our actions into something greater than our motives, no matter how pure we think them to be. In other words, we do them as sinners saved by grace in thought and practice, not as people who do them thinking we are worthy because of our holy intentions. Once we are released from the idea of purity in motive and act, we are then free to sin bravely, courageously, and to embody a Gospel that is authentic and honest...and one that is much more fun than a list of Puritan rules whereby we are the author and sustainer of our faith via our confession or our actions that "keep" us "right" with God.

Ellingsen reminds us of the words of Augustine, "love God and do what you will." A heart turned toward God will love God through its actions, yet it will do it lost in the space of Gods grace and not beholden to an ideal of purpose and prosperity that remains focused on the self rather than focused on the God wherein the self is to reside. A perpetual quest for self, whether secular or religious, leads to a fragmented society of fragmented people...that take themselves too seriously and get caught up in their own importance as they pursue themselves. But a life that is committed to brave sinning will face the world in hope and freedom. Hope in the Christ that has made us more than we could ever be and free to be ourselves as those that engage in the playful realities of life that we like to call business...a business that is just play to God (ala Augustine)...so I leave you with the words of Ellingsen

"So Sin Bravely! But believe and rejoice in Christ even more bravely...as long as we live here in this world we will have to sin, but no sin will separate us from Christ. Have fun, too!"

Highly recommend for its brevity and poignancy, clear articulation and ease of logic, and its daring to engage one of the most popular fads in American Christianity...and call it to the floor as wanting. Be a brave sinner...Read this book.
Profile Image for Leroy Seat.
Author 11 books18 followers
July 21, 2011
Except for the fifth chapter, which is on neurobiology, I thought this was a good and helpful book--mainly because it is so realistic. If it hadn't been for the fifth chapter, I definitely would have given the book four stars.

Even though the author is critical of Rick Warren, as expected from the subtitle, he is more critical of Joel Osteen and others who preach a "prosperity gospel."

This book reinforces what Ellingsen writes about so well in his book "Blessed are the Cynical." One such topic is that of the narcissistic ethos of contemporary American society.

Ellingsen is a Lutheran, and he evaluates the Lutheran theological outlook much more highly than what he calls the "Puritan Paradigm." The first section of the second chapter is "Narcissism, Our Economic Ethos, and the Puritan Paradigm."

The third chapter is also a theme from his earlier book: "An Augustinian Re-Education about Sin." The point:

"Because of our concupiscence, our innate propensity to use people and position for our own benefit, all our social interactions will always be flawed" (p. 63).

All this has practical (and realistic) implications. For example, Ellingsen avers,

"To believe in the fallen nature of humanity, our innate selfishness, entails that we cannot trust the free market to monitor itself. An awareness of our sin (especially among brave sinners) leads to a belief in the need to redistribute wealth and power" (p. 109).
331 reviews3 followers
February 9, 2011
Mark Ellingsen discusses the Christian concept of original sin vs. the new age message of "purpose" and "prosperity" as preached by Rick Warren and Joel Osteen which he says is too focused on self.

If we accept that we are born imperfect then, according to Ellingsen, we have to accept that everything we do, no matter how noble or virtuous it may seem, is motivated by our own "creepy motives" therefore we must rely on the grace of God and "sin bravely" as advised by Martin Luther in order to live life totally dependent on God and His grace.

I found this book to be a very refreshing throwback to the religion I was raised in and hope to read his "Blessed are the Cynical."
Profile Image for Michael.
Author 2 books18 followers
January 1, 2010
An excellent theological response to Rick Warren and the prosperity gospel folks. While I don't agree with its theology whole-heartedly, I do agree with its left-minded Christian politics. He is not afraid to confront the narcissism of the Republicans, who do not care for the poor and the disenfranchised in the U.S.
Profile Image for Laura Lee.
Author 556 books100 followers
March 10, 2012
I was disappointed in this little book. I enjoy books that take our conventional ways of thinking to task. I had some trouble with trying to put the pieces together in this one.

I agreed with the author on some of his criticisms of our culture of self-esteem and individualism at the expense of a focus on higher ideals and relationships. I felt that the author spent too much time detailing those cultural ills and focused too specifically on Rick Warren and Joel Orenstein. The concept that Christianity is not a religion of requirements and good deeds to perform in order to achieve a heavenly reward (What's in it for me?) is something I've been reflecting on lately. So there is a kernel of something there.

Yet Ellingsen's argument that we should focus on original sin and view ourselves as inherently sinful rather than as inherently good fails to break out of a false either/or mentality. Humans are neither inherently sinful nor inherently good. The reason that it is possible to use Biblical verses to make either argument is that both views are there because they represent the full picture of our human nature, with the capacity for compassion and loving and the capacity for hurtfulness, self-preoccupation and evil. Failing to acknowledge the areas in which we fall short of our ideals is unbalanced and unhealthy and leads to poor spirituality and a culture without depth or honesty, as the author argues. It is not an honest assessment of ourselves either. On the other hand, the notion that we are always by our nature sinful is equally unbalanced.

That said, there is a kernel of something here that I think was fleshed out better in the book The Spirituality of Imperfection. That is that recognizing our inherent imperfection we are freed up to focus on the game of life rather than trying to whip ourselves for the ways in which we fail to be perfect. Put another way, it is the idea that our imperfection is not a failing but a matter of intelligent design.
It's not a bug, it's a feature. His views of viewing life as play seem to be better articulated in James P. Carse's Finite and Infinite Games.

One of the things I found odd about this book was that after taking down Rick Warren's purpose driven life because, the author argues, it leads to pre-occupation with the self, he goes on to argue that the benefit of what he calls "brave sinning" is that those who do it are more joyful. He fails to break out of the "what's in it for me" thereputic mindset he criticizes.
Profile Image for Theodore Zachariades.
Author 16 books17 followers
June 14, 2013
In a world of pop psychology where therapy rules and i the contemporary Christian sub-culture where prosperity peddlers and purpose driven models abound, Ellingsen provides hope of authentic Christianity taking his cue from sixteenth century reformer, Martin Luther. Sin Bravely is not about reckless abandon or a life of licentiousness, so those who think you can have your heavenly cake and eat it too, or a fool's paradise of wasteful exuberance in this world, Ellingsen will disappoint. No, he is clear that what we ought to be doing is less doing that focuses on ourselves and believing in real grace that frees us we can live genuine lives that focus on others, especially the poor and disenfranchised. Though he sets his sights on Osteen and Warren in the popular evangelical/prosperity school, he also chastises the entire puritan paradigm that Ellingsen claims is co-conspirator in the dealy game of right wing politics and profiteering capitalism, which have led to the ethos that fosters such preying preachers. Readers will find some of Ellingsen's ideas a bit hard to accept, and other ideas hard to follow,especially when he delves into neuroscience and brain-talk. However, if one will zero in on his specific goal of getting you to seriously engage your own sinfulness in its overwhelming reality of tarnishing your entire life and hence getting you to genuinely accept and appreciate God's grace, then you can join the ranks of brave sinners and dream big and serve God and love people in the game of life, and you may be surprised that this is a high that nothing else will provide.
Profile Image for Stuart.
72 reviews12 followers
September 2, 2013
I'm not done with this book just yet, but I don't think my impressions will change. The book is pretty hard to read. Maybe I've just not hung out with enough Lutherans, but I don't quite understand the theology and ideas presented here. I want to, but I'm just not getting it.

I would also rate this book as being poorly written. It's not bad, but could be a lot better. At times the author seems to constantly remind us he is basically taking Warren and Osteen to task, and frequent mentions of "The Reformer" puts his Lutheranism up front.

With such a clever title, I expected more. I still think there is some great wisdom to be found in the idea to "sin boldly", but I'd need someone else to explain it to me better.
Profile Image for Dean.
192 reviews
April 22, 2010
Mark Ellingsen has written a unique book. This is not your traditional religious book. It is certainly not a devotional at all. The author, has, however written a scholarly academic work that compares the Prosperity Gospel of Joel Osteen and Rick Warren’s Purpose Driven Life with the traditional protestant view of Christianity. He roots his arguments in writings from two thousand years of faith. He does, however, base most of arguments in the work of Martin Luther. I do not have a strong background in the history of Luther’s work, and so, this was an eye opener.
Profile Image for Thom.
1,921 reviews81 followers
April 23, 2010
Some interesting thoughts and historical basis are scattered through this not unjustified attack on Rick Warren and contemporary Puritanical Christianity. The misuse of science to justify some of these ideas rubbed me the wrong way, detracting from his overall position. The author does make several good points on the origins of American Christianity, and the ease with which the people flock to this plusher path. I value this slim volume as much for its bibliography as its main points, and that is a shame.
8 reviews1 follower
June 6, 2011
Definately gave me a chance to really consider how to give back to the world and the people in it without worry and fear.
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews