Lori Shepherd has been busy as an overprotective new mom to twin boys and going crazy in the process. Bill confers with Aunt Dimity and it is decided Lori needs help! Aunt Dimity sends the Pym sisters with Francesca Schiparelli to help with housework and twin duty. Francesca's help frees Lori to assist the vicar with a little problem. There's a civil war brewing in the village between the domineering Peggy Kitchen who plans to hold a harvest festival come hell or high water and some outsiders; archeologists come to dig up Scragg's End in search of Roman ruins. Half the village hopes the search for Roman artifacts will bring tourists to the village. The other half thinks the village is fine as is and doesn't need an influx of outsiders. The only person who has evidence the archeological site is a hoax is ... someone unknown. The vicar claims to have had an obscure Victorian era pamphlet explaining the hoax but someone stole it from his desk. He wants Lori to use her rare books expertise to discreetly ask around and find the pamphlet to put a stop to the tension. Lori's search introduces her to an eclectic bunch of villagers from a domineering old lady planning to revive Finch's historic traditions to a lonely little girl in need of a friend. Aunt Dimity helps things along by playing matchmaker again, this time for Francesca. Francesca, not knowing about AD, seems resistant to the plan and Lori isn't going to force the issue. Could AD be wrong for a change?
I loved this story! It's my favorite of the series so far. I'm a sucker for a cozy English village story. This one doesn't feature a murder, just a search for a missing pamphlet, but it's a real mystery. I thought I knew who took the pamphlet but I was totally wrong. I was completely surprised by the identity of the thief. They were not on my radar. The story made me laugh out loud in spots but it was also poignant and sad. Since it's set in the ;ate 1980s/early 1990s, WWII is still very much present in people's memories and the shadows loom large over Finch. The historical story broke my heart. The technology details date this story and made me chuckle a bit. I studied abroad in London back then and almost no one had home internet back then. I know Emma is a tech person so it makes sense for her but it would still be dial up using the phone line and very slow! (My host dad had it for his business so I think Bill should have it too).
I adored the secondary characters but not so much Lori. I'm kind of lukewarm on her. I'm not a mother so I can't relate to her struggles but I haven't clicked with her before. She says she loves Bill but she doesn't really seem to love him as much as he loves her. Of course he had a head start, falling in love with her as a child. They're still getting to know each other and learning to be parents now. Bill is a sweet, caring husband and father. He's a good egg to cave in and do Morris dancing and it was lovely of him to consult Dimity on his own with how to help Lori. I don't know many fathers who would recognize their wife was struggling let alone ask a ghostly "aunt" for help. Aunt Dimity has less of a role in this book. She pops up here and there but Lori is trying to keep the journal a secret from Francesca and so Aunt Dimity is kept on the down low. The twins are babies and totally uninteresting. Reginald appears in a few scenes and plays a role in the matchmaking. Emma Harris is around but doesn't move the story forward. She's far more appealing than Lori though. Nell and Peter are both away. Lori's old mentor, Stan, appears in two scenes via phone call. He's crude, crass and rude. If he has children, his ex-wife took them far, far away! He knows his books but to him, they're something to be bought and sold. I don't think he has any reverence for them.
The vicar is a dear. He's an absentminded sort with a messy desk and unlocked doors. Is it possible the pamphlet just got lost or blew away? He'll never find it in the jungle outside but maybe Emma will. His wife is lovely and intelligent. She keeps her husband in order the best she can and helps interpret his confusing backwards stories. They're a nice couple. Francesca, in spite of her name, was born and raised on a farm outside the village. She's like a genie- able to care for small children and cook, clean and sew! It's like she was heaven sent! (Was she?) She's very, very stubborn and proud. Sometimes she lets her pride get in the way and she doesn't want to listen. Her communication skills need work. Her father sounds like he was a loving Papa who taught his children to respect their culture and their ancestors, to love the land and to be industrious workers. He went above and beyond to turn the other cheek when people were mean and let bygones be bygones. He sounds like a saint! Their family story was a big shock and really tragic.
The one thing I hate about village and small town books is how gossippy and small minded everyone is. Peggy Kitchen is the village bully. She is loud and in charge and wants Lori on her side. Who would dare cross Peggy Kitchen? She's terrifying. She has singlehandedly made Finch into the very model of Ye Olde English Village with revived old traditions. Now she is determined to get her harvest festival come hell or high water and no one better stand in her way OR ELSE! Yikes! Her minion, Jasper Taxman, seems to be so besotted with her that he'll do anything for her. He doesn't talk much but he's very kind. I guess opposites attract? Dimity knows something about Peggy that makes her more realistic and Dimity's story serves as a reminder not to judge people until you've heard their story, to have compassion for people who may be hurting underneath the fierce exterior.
Peggy's rival is Sally Pyne who runs a tea room. Sally is busy renovating her tea room, dealing with an active, energetic granddaughter and whatever fad diet she decides to take on next. Sally is pro-archeology and hopes to make money off tourists. This puts her at direct odds with Peggy. I do not envy Sally. Sally is the village's biggest gossip and if she gets ahold of information, it spreads through the village in 5 minutes. She has a big motivation to steal that pamphlet! Sally's granddaughter, Raine, is a preocious, energetic 9 year-old in need of a friend. She's staying with her grandmother because Mummy has a new baby. No one really knows how to deal with Raine, except maybe Emma. While Raine is the opposite of Nell and Emma lacks maternal instict, Emma's passion for gardening fills Raine with enthusiasm and occupies the child. Then Raine decides archeology is her passion. Both outdoor activities keep her busy, active and outdoors where she likes to be. She's not a bad kid, but as usual with ADHD kids, no one really knows what to do with them.
Dr. Culver, a young archeology professor, is leading the expedition in Finch. He falls in love with Francesca at first sight and becomes a dithering idiot. He seems way too sweet and naive to be the evil villain Peggy Kitchen makes him out to be. He brings along some students, Simon and Kristina. Simon is kind of bland and boring but Kristina is tough. She worships Adrian and certainly has a crush on him. She's crazy intense and making up theories as she goes along just to prove her ideas are right and continue the project. She's too tough and singleminded for me. I'm not sure she'd break into the vicar's study but I suspect she knows about the pamphlet and if she didn't take it, she knows who did.
Christine Peacock is my favorite of the villagers. Her description of what she saw Sunday night made me laugh out loud. I love her plans for the pub - it will never go down there though. However, her constant longing for her son was sad and made me hate the man for not connecting with his parents too often. I'm sure his military career keeps him busy but he could come home once in awhile more often than 20 years! Christine reminded of of Miriam Brindsley in the 1940s period drama Home Fires. Her husband seems sensible and nice but he can't stop his wife's crazy plan. Their hound is a hoot.
I also liked Mr. Weatherhead, one of the newcomers to Finch and an eyewitness to the robbery. He doesn't know what he say and his explanation is hilarious. His secret is not so shameful. His hobby is shared by lots of men and Lori's suggestion is a good one. It's sweet of her to help him get out more and make new friends, to become a part of village life. Mrs. Morrow, another newcomer, is a hoot. She's unashamed, unabashed and totally kooky. She's also an eyewitness to the robbery, maybe, and her explanation made me laugh out loud.
Annie Hodge is the vicarage cleaning lady. She seems unpleasant and uninterested in anything but herself and her job. She sounds anti-archeologist but doesn't get involved in the civil war. I don't think she took the pamphlet because she could have done it at any time but what about her husband? Did he steal the pamphlet? He doesn't seem in favor of the archeologists but he's always watching them from afar? Is he secretly hoping they'll stay, find something cool on his farm and make him a fortune?
This book features a recipe for lemon bars. I do not like lemon so I have not tried them.
Trigger warnings:
Fat shaming/slightly rude adjectives to describe a big boned person
wartime traumatic experiences in the past
prejudice against "the enemy" from WWII based solely on ethnicity.