The Misanthrope by Moliere
A misanthrope seems to be a negative character, someone who can teach us only what to avoid, whose flaws are to be displayed so that the audience would not take a similar path, a role model with a minus in front.
Indeed, positive psychology studies have revealed that isolation – which goes hand in hand with misanthropy – is Twice as Dangerous as smoking and therefore we should soon have messages on television that speak about this peril, just as the public was informed about smoking.
A happy person is one that socializes – the opposite of the main character in this play – and there is research in the same domain of psychology that suggests that the size of the human brain is due to the need to cope with the community and the use of tools as had been thought.
The challenges of being able to deal with the multitude of issues posed by a variety of individuals in society is daunting and leads to the “social animal’s” large brain size, capable to simultaneously satisfy this child, that woman and this man, all the same time.
The Misanthrope is a complex, dynamic hero who has the handicap of cynicism, skepticism, reclusiveness and hatred of human beings, but at the same time, he has some very valuable traits.
He is honest in the extreme and although this sounds like a positive trait, there is more to say about it, as an interlocutor, Celimene, highlights when talking about the various shortcomings of people that we surely could not speak of in their face…
That woman, he says, you cannot say to her that she is no longer young and under the paint on her face, it is evident that age has taken its toll and she no longer fools anyone in that regard – this is not a quote, but it is the message of the friend.
How to Win Friends and Influence People, the archetypal, quintessential classic that has sold hundreds of millions of copies, being one of the best sold books in history, by Dale Carnegie argues that we all like to be appreciated and complimented, therefore one of the rules has it that we should use praise to win friends…
This is not what the Misanthrope does; he is so honest as to antagonize even professed admirers, one of them coming to express his awe, only to find he is soon repudiated, granted, after he annoys his audience with his poem.
This amateur, awful poet takes ages before he starts with his bad creation, explaining it only took him minutes, it is dedicated to someone he loves and the Misanthrope aka Alceste keeps telling him to get on with it, while the boring performer repeats himself ad nauseam.
In favor of the hero, one must highlight that he did not respond to the flattery, in fact he says nothing with this proclaimed fan makes a laudatory speech, kisses Alceste, asking for his true opinion…in other words, the victim is the one who called upon himself the brutal, vigorous, acid but sincere evaluation of his failed poetry.
One can argue that the Misanthrope has a point- taking it to the present, let us look at what people elect, in the United States, Russia, Italy and so many other countries, individuals like Trump and Putin.
If this is the choice of so many human beings, we could say that being a Recluse, a Hermit is the right choice, if humanity opts for these inverted, perverted values proclaimed by the likes of the Orange Donald, then there is no reason to interact, converse, mingle with such creatures…
What is more, Alceste is quick to emphasize that he does not view his own shortcomings as tolerable or his persona as above the rest – in such flagrant contrast with Trump, extreme narcissist that he is – when challenged by the flawed poet.
The Misanthrope exaggerates when he says that the poem is “rubbish, nauseating and later on, that the poet must have his throat cut” – but when asked to present his own work, so that it can be evaluated, the hero says plainly that his is not any better.
However, he does not feel the need to overwhelm others with his creations, aware that they are not worthwhile.
The French have a saying – "les extrêmes se touchent” aka opposites attract, Alceste is strangely attracted to Celimene, a woman with the opposite views, flattering where the protagonist criticizes, limiting herself to irony, rejection of various characters only when they are not around.
There are some personages that show the merits of the Misanthrope by contrast, Alceste is so self-indulgent, arrogant, pretentious and vain in his statements about his value, the manner in which his pronouncements are followed and the people of Paris depend on his opinions.
When placing the two on the same stage, one cannot help but see the superiority of the Hermit, when the company, community is formed of such brutes and ignoramuses
Jean-Jacques Rousseau wrote in a letter that The Misanthrope is the best work written by Moliere – on the other hand, we learn from the brilliant The Intellectuals by the wonderful Paul Johnson that the philosopher has abandoned all his many children at the door of the orphanage, in an age when nine out of orphans left in such a place died…
“Mankind has grown so base, / I mean to break with the whole human race".