What do you think?
Rate this book
The Perfect Gentleman
Georgiana Darcy has gone missing. Lizzy Bennet knows just what to do to find her.
‘Tis no secret that Lizzy Bennet has dreams. The uniquely talented daughter of a woman with a dubious reputation, Lizzy knows she must make her own way in a world that shuns her.
Fitzwilliam Darcy carries the stains of his family’s dishonour upon his soul and only by holding himself to the strictest standards has he reclaimed his place in society.
If his fifteen-year-old sister cannot be found quickly, her scandal could destroy years of perfect behaviour. Lizzy is willing to join the pursuit to get what she wants but will Darcy be willing to trust her with his secrets? And what will they do when the search for Georgiana reveals what neither expected to find?
‘Tis no secret that Lizzy Bennet has dreams. The uniquely talented daughter of a woman with a dubious reputation, Lizzy knows she must make her own way in a world that shuns her.
Fitzwilliam Darcy carries the stains of his family’s dishonour upon his soul and only by holding himself to the strictest standards has he reclaimed his place in society.
If his fifteen-year-old sister cannot be found quickly, her scandal could destroy years of perfect behaviour. Lizzy is willing to join the pursuit to get what she wants but will Darcy be willing to trust her with his secrets? And what will they do when the search for Georgiana reveals what neither expected to find?
499 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 21, 2019
291 people are currently reading
274 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 94 reviews
October 16, 2019
This story has two volumes: A Not-so-Merry Chase and Love Wisely but Well. It quickly grabbed my attention and kept me turning pages. (I received an ARC with no strings attached.) It is a long story and does have many twists and turns but also that angst I so enjoy.
Elizabeth, her mother and Jane live in Ramsgate. The two girls have different fathers and while one's father supports her she is not his "legal" offspring. The other is the product of a marriage but her father abandoned them before she was born. Letters to him were never answered so as a young girl she soon gave up on any support much less contact.
Darcy's father also has a "situation" from which he struggled to recover. Tight reins and impeccable behavior for many years have restored the family to society but Darcy knows how costly that position was again won and is known for his strict adherence to all the rules of society. He is "the perfect gentleman".
We have a Mr. Bennet seemingly on his death bed...nursed by his sister, a widow, Margaret Bennet Bingley. She has a stepson, Charles, who is friends with (of course) Darcy. And so it is that when Margaret hears from this "dying" man that he has an abandoned family and that there might be a child, she asks Charles for advice and help. He knows that Darcy's sister is in Ramsgate where that abandoned family lived and writes (with his illegible script) asking Darcy to check up on the "child" there.
When Darcy goes to Ramsgate and calls at the residence he is shocked to find a grown woman, not an eight year old child. Their meeting is not a cordial one due to the circumstances...the history...of her mother and how she supports herself and her daughters. (There is so much going on here and I am skipping it all to allow you to enjoy finding out all these angles for yourself.) BUT one thing that comes out of the meeting is that Elizabeth learns that the name of his sister's companion is LYDIA YOUNGE. Elizabeth debates with herself whether to tell him what she knows about that "lady" and decides to let him know. Furthermore when it is realized that the lady and her charge are no longer in Ramsgate the two decide to track her down. However they don't agree on the possibilities and after a start find themselves going off in different directions.
I cannot possibly tell you, hint to you, all the events and situations in this tale. It is one I would mark as a "MUST" read.
The author keeps us in suspense as to what Darcy's family's disgrace was and even how his relations pressure him and his sister to bend to their demands.
Then there is the thread that this Elizabeth has a talent discovered by one of her mother's
"friends" while she was still very young. She is an artist with modeling clay. She sells her creations to help support the family. And her lifetime goal is to pursue that career...even go into sculpting. The man who gave her this spark with his noticing her talent is an H. Wickham!
This is a story that I highly recommend. There is so much more to the story than I mentioned here. Read it...I know you will enjoy it.
Elizabeth, her mother and Jane live in Ramsgate. The two girls have different fathers and while one's father supports her she is not his "legal" offspring. The other is the product of a marriage but her father abandoned them before she was born. Letters to him were never answered so as a young girl she soon gave up on any support much less contact.
Darcy's father also has a "situation" from which he struggled to recover. Tight reins and impeccable behavior for many years have restored the family to society but Darcy knows how costly that position was again won and is known for his strict adherence to all the rules of society. He is "the perfect gentleman".
We have a Mr. Bennet seemingly on his death bed...nursed by his sister, a widow, Margaret Bennet Bingley. She has a stepson, Charles, who is friends with (of course) Darcy. And so it is that when Margaret hears from this "dying" man that he has an abandoned family and that there might be a child, she asks Charles for advice and help. He knows that Darcy's sister is in Ramsgate where that abandoned family lived and writes (with his illegible script) asking Darcy to check up on the "child" there.
When Darcy goes to Ramsgate and calls at the residence he is shocked to find a grown woman, not an eight year old child. Their meeting is not a cordial one due to the circumstances...the history...of her mother and how she supports herself and her daughters. (There is so much going on here and I am skipping it all to allow you to enjoy finding out all these angles for yourself.) BUT one thing that comes out of the meeting is that Elizabeth learns that the name of his sister's companion is LYDIA YOUNGE. Elizabeth debates with herself whether to tell him what she knows about that "lady" and decides to let him know. Furthermore when it is realized that the lady and her charge are no longer in Ramsgate the two decide to track her down. However they don't agree on the possibilities and after a start find themselves going off in different directions.
I cannot possibly tell you, hint to you, all the events and situations in this tale. It is one I would mark as a "MUST" read.
The author keeps us in suspense as to what Darcy's family's disgrace was and even how his relations pressure him and his sister to bend to their demands.
Then there is the thread that this Elizabeth has a talent discovered by one of her mother's
"friends" while she was still very young. She is an artist with modeling clay. She sells her creations to help support the family. And her lifetime goal is to pursue that career...even go into sculpting. The man who gave her this spark with his noticing her talent is an H. Wickham!
This is a story that I highly recommend. There is so much more to the story than I mentioned here. Read it...I know you will enjoy it.
October 16, 2019
5+ stars
Be prepared to hang onto you seat when you read this book! It's a thrilling adventure for Darcy, Elizabeth and Georgiana in the first volume. The entire book is WAY off-canon, but the Pride and Prejudice characters remain more or less consistent with what we've come to expect from them, despite the completely different situations in which they have been placed.
Mr. and Mrs. Bennet have been estranged for many years; no one in his family or in Hertfordshire even know he is married. The two had met in Ramsgate, and Fanny did not disclose her scandalous past until after they'd wed - she had been a courtesan, and Jane was the natural child of a baronet, Sir Walter (nice little Persuasion nod there), who continued to provide limited support in the form of tutors and masters as well as nice clothing for his beautiful daughter. Believing Lizzy could be another man's child, Mr. Bennet immediately abandoned them. With no other means to support her family, Mrs. Bennet has reverted to entertaining one paramour after another. Having grown up in this world, Elizabeth and Jane have become quite resourceful and remain virgins. As the most intelligent and quick-witted of the three ladies, Elizabeth manages the entire household and guides her mother to make the most practical choices possible as her protectors.
But now Mr. Bennet is on his deathbed. He's guilt-ridden over the family he left behind so long ago, having saved letters penned by Lizzy when she was a child begging him to write back...which he never did. In this particular P&P universe, his sister is Mrs. Margaret Bingley, stepmother of Charles, Caroline and Louisa. Margaret must nurse her dying brother, who continues to cling to life, but she asks Charles to seek out one Elizabeth Bennet in Ramsgate. Charles has other obligations he can't break away from, but he knows his friend Darcy is going to Ramsgate to visit his sister Georgiana. This leads to Darcy and Elizabeth meeting each other.
It's at this point where things speed up and never slow down. Between some comments Mr. Darcy has made to Elizabeth and her intimate knowledge of Lydia Younge, she comes to the conclusion that Miss Darcy is in some danger. Elizabeth listens to her conscience and, reluctantly, she meets again with Mr. Darcy to enlighten him about the sketchy background of the woman he hired to be his sister's companion. Darcy's just found his sister and Mrs. Younge are not in Ramsgate, so his skepticism over information from "a harlot's daughter" fades. After strenuous arguments regarding how to proceed, the two of them embark together on a chase to save Georgiana.
I can't delve into much of the storyline in the second volume because it hinges on a major surprise waiting at Pemberley at the conclusion of the first volume. While there isn't as much adventure in the subsequent volume, it's still compelling reading with a lot of Darcy, Fitzwilliam and de Bourgh family drama going on. Elizabeth's artistic gift with clay, which was a plot point in the first volume, is expanded here. Darcy thoughtfully provides her with a master, assuming her interest will fade in a matter of weeks or, at most, months, but he doesn't recognize her passion or her genius as a sculptor.
This is one of those books that I needed to gulp up as quickly as I could turn pages. The writing is excellent, the characters are wonderful and feel real, and the plot grabs you by the throat and won't let go. It's quite appropriately broken into two volumes; each one has a specific primary plot, turning point and resolution. Although there are many subplots threading their way through both volumes, these are integrated into their respective primary plots very nicely. The sparks flying between Elizabeth and Darcy just crackle, with content that's suggestive but not graphic.
Highly recommend!
I received an ARC with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise.
Be prepared to hang onto you seat when you read this book! It's a thrilling adventure for Darcy, Elizabeth and Georgiana in the first volume. The entire book is WAY off-canon, but the Pride and Prejudice characters remain more or less consistent with what we've come to expect from them, despite the completely different situations in which they have been placed.
Mr. and Mrs. Bennet have been estranged for many years; no one in his family or in Hertfordshire even know he is married. The two had met in Ramsgate, and Fanny did not disclose her scandalous past until after they'd wed - she had been a courtesan, and Jane was the natural child of a baronet, Sir Walter (nice little Persuasion nod there), who continued to provide limited support in the form of tutors and masters as well as nice clothing for his beautiful daughter. Believing Lizzy could be another man's child, Mr. Bennet immediately abandoned them. With no other means to support her family, Mrs. Bennet has reverted to entertaining one paramour after another. Having grown up in this world, Elizabeth and Jane have become quite resourceful and remain virgins. As the most intelligent and quick-witted of the three ladies, Elizabeth manages the entire household and guides her mother to make the most practical choices possible as her protectors.
But now Mr. Bennet is on his deathbed. He's guilt-ridden over the family he left behind so long ago, having saved letters penned by Lizzy when she was a child begging him to write back...which he never did. In this particular P&P universe, his sister is Mrs. Margaret Bingley, stepmother of Charles, Caroline and Louisa. Margaret must nurse her dying brother, who continues to cling to life, but she asks Charles to seek out one Elizabeth Bennet in Ramsgate. Charles has other obligations he can't break away from, but he knows his friend Darcy is going to Ramsgate to visit his sister Georgiana. This leads to Darcy and Elizabeth meeting each other.
It's at this point where things speed up and never slow down. Between some comments Mr. Darcy has made to Elizabeth and her intimate knowledge of Lydia Younge, she comes to the conclusion that Miss Darcy is in some danger. Elizabeth listens to her conscience and, reluctantly, she meets again with Mr. Darcy to enlighten him about the sketchy background of the woman he hired to be his sister's companion. Darcy's just found his sister and Mrs. Younge are not in Ramsgate, so his skepticism over information from "a harlot's daughter" fades. After strenuous arguments regarding how to proceed, the two of them embark together on a chase to save Georgiana.
I can't delve into much of the storyline in the second volume because it hinges on a major surprise waiting at Pemberley at the conclusion of the first volume. While there isn't as much adventure in the subsequent volume, it's still compelling reading with a lot of Darcy, Fitzwilliam and de Bourgh family drama going on. Elizabeth's artistic gift with clay, which was a plot point in the first volume, is expanded here. Darcy thoughtfully provides her with a master, assuming her interest will fade in a matter of weeks or, at most, months, but he doesn't recognize her passion or her genius as a sculptor.
This is one of those books that I needed to gulp up as quickly as I could turn pages. The writing is excellent, the characters are wonderful and feel real, and the plot grabs you by the throat and won't let go. It's quite appropriately broken into two volumes; each one has a specific primary plot, turning point and resolution. Although there are many subplots threading their way through both volumes, these are integrated into their respective primary plots very nicely. The sparks flying between Elizabeth and Darcy just crackle, with content that's suggestive but not graphic.
Highly recommend!
I received an ARC with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise.
May 24, 2025
All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way. ~ Leo Tolstoy
Reduced to its basics, “The Perfect Gentleman” is a story about two unhappy families.
What a complicated affair life must have been before DNA testing – young Mrs. Bennet had no Maury Povich to say “Thomas Bennet, you are the father.”
That lack of “Paternity Court” is the basis of the unhappiness in Elizabeth Bennet’s family.
On a holiday at Ramsgate, Thomas Bennet married because his lover claimed he was the father of her unborn baby. Then Thomas learns his wife’s first child is the daughter of a Baron who had once been her protector. Is that man also the father of the unborn child? Or is the child Thomas’ as his wife claimed? Thomas abandons his wife and child. He never tells his family or friends that he was married. He never sends gifts to the child or support for her.
Mrs. Bennet must sell her favors to support herself and her daughters. Elizabeth eventually sees she is the one with the most sense in her family and she begins to choose her mother’s paramours on the basis of their ability and willingness to pay. And Elizabeth develops her talents with help from a man named Wickham.
The thing about family disasters is that you never have to wait long before the next one puts the previous one into perspective. ~ Robert Brault
On his deathbed, Thomas Bennet confesses his marriage and possible fatherhood to his sister who empathizes with the abandoned wife and child. She arranges for Darcy, who will soon be visiting his sister at Ramsgate, to also visit Elizabeth Bennet and report his findings. When it appears Darcy’s sister has left her home in Ramsgate, Elizabeth accompanies Darcy on a journey to find her and her companion, Lydia Younge.
The journey is the theme of the first book. Two words at the end of the first book set the stage for the second book.
Some forgive and forget, more forgive and remember, most forgive and remind. To truly forgive is to let the other person forget. ~ Robert Brault
Multiple hints are scattered through the earlier chapters, letting the reader know a scandal exists within the Darcy family as well as the Bennet family. We immediately learn that Fitzwilliam and Georgiana Darcy also have a parent they are unable to forgive.
Forgiveness is the theme of the second book.
What was the break in the Darcy family?
How did it affect a young Fitzwilliam Darcy?
How did it affect an even younger Georgiana Darcy?
These are two great stories – unique and unforgettable in a genre where so many plots are similar. Although the stories are very different, the second completes the first.
I received an early copy of this book with no promise made of a review, good or bad.
Life becomes easier when you learn to accept an apology you never got. ~ Robert Brault
Reduced to its basics, “The Perfect Gentleman” is a story about two unhappy families.
What a complicated affair life must have been before DNA testing – young Mrs. Bennet had no Maury Povich to say “Thomas Bennet, you are the father.”
That lack of “Paternity Court” is the basis of the unhappiness in Elizabeth Bennet’s family.
On a holiday at Ramsgate, Thomas Bennet married because his lover claimed he was the father of her unborn baby. Then Thomas learns his wife’s first child is the daughter of a Baron who had once been her protector. Is that man also the father of the unborn child? Or is the child Thomas’ as his wife claimed? Thomas abandons his wife and child. He never tells his family or friends that he was married. He never sends gifts to the child or support for her.
Mrs. Bennet must sell her favors to support herself and her daughters. Elizabeth eventually sees she is the one with the most sense in her family and she begins to choose her mother’s paramours on the basis of their ability and willingness to pay. And Elizabeth develops her talents with help from a man named Wickham.
The thing about family disasters is that you never have to wait long before the next one puts the previous one into perspective. ~ Robert Brault
On his deathbed, Thomas Bennet confesses his marriage and possible fatherhood to his sister who empathizes with the abandoned wife and child. She arranges for Darcy, who will soon be visiting his sister at Ramsgate, to also visit Elizabeth Bennet and report his findings. When it appears Darcy’s sister has left her home in Ramsgate, Elizabeth accompanies Darcy on a journey to find her and her companion, Lydia Younge.
The journey is the theme of the first book. Two words at the end of the first book set the stage for the second book.
Some forgive and forget, more forgive and remember, most forgive and remind. To truly forgive is to let the other person forget. ~ Robert Brault
Multiple hints are scattered through the earlier chapters, letting the reader know a scandal exists within the Darcy family as well as the Bennet family. We immediately learn that Fitzwilliam and Georgiana Darcy also have a parent they are unable to forgive.
Forgiveness is the theme of the second book.
What was the break in the Darcy family?
How did it affect a young Fitzwilliam Darcy?
How did it affect an even younger Georgiana Darcy?
These are two great stories – unique and unforgettable in a genre where so many plots are similar. Although the stories are very different, the second completes the first.
I received an early copy of this book with no promise made of a review, good or bad.
Life becomes easier when you learn to accept an apology you never got. ~ Robert Brault
October 23, 2019
WOW!!
This is a difficult book to succinctly classify. Yes it is a P&P variation, but is also a P&P Action adventure (in a good way). The author has skewed everything slightly so that the only things that are really consistent are Pemberley, Netherfield and Longbourn. Everything else is changed.
Before reading this book I didn't read a single review because I wanted to be surprised and before writing this review I still haven't. I will eventually but I guess my point is if you haven't read the story STOP: Turn Back NOW!
Well some people can't be deterred so I am going to spoiler everything plot related if you read it before the book you ONLY have YOURSELF to Blame
If you like your P&P variations to be really varying then you will love this book.
This is a difficult book to succinctly classify. Yes it is a P&P variation, but is also a P&P Action adventure (in a good way). The author has skewed everything slightly so that the only things that are really consistent are Pemberley, Netherfield and Longbourn. Everything else is changed.
Before reading this book I didn't read a single review because I wanted to be surprised and before writing this review I still haven't. I will eventually but I guess my point is if you haven't read the story STOP: Turn Back NOW!
Well some people can't be deterred so I am going to spoiler everything plot related if you read it before the book you ONLY have YOURSELF to Blame
If you like your P&P variations to be really varying then you will love this book.
May 12, 2020
What If Darcy and Elizabeth Both Had Scandalous Family Histories?
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: (Outside of Canon) Begins during Georgiana’s stay in Ramsgate
SYNOPSIS: In this alternate world of Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet is not recognized by her father, Mr. Bennet, and lives with her elder sister and mother in Ramsgate, where she helps support her family by making souvenir seaside sculptures. Elizabeth’s world is forever changed when a certain fastidious gentleman from Derbyshire turns up looking for her on behalf of her father’s family. But before Mr. Darcy can complete his mission, he learns that his sister, Georgiana, has abruptly departed Ramsgate with her companion. Knowing very well that Georgiana’s companion, Lydia Younge, is one bad egg, Elizabeth offers her discreet and valuable assistance to the stubborn and arrogant gentleman in hopes that she can help recover his sister but also receive some needed support in setting her life on a new course. Instead of balls, parties, and visits with family/friends, this adventurous Pride and Prejudice tale is filled with scandals, secrets, and troubled relationships.
WHAT I LOVED:
- Divergent Yet Connected: With only two Bennet daughters that are half-siblings, an estranged Mr. Bennet, and Lizzy aspiring to study art and become a sculptor this story has a lot of details that steer it a different direction. This premise is extremely inventive, and I think readers would be hard-pressed to find another book with similar twists. And yet, there are enough similarities in these characters’ personalities and the themes employed that this wholly divergent tale still feels connected to Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.
- Action-Packed Adventure: With seeking clues like a detective, playacting as a traveling couple, embarking on countless carriage rides across the country, and encountering dangerous ruffians on the road – this story is filled with exhilarating action! These events were thrilling to witness, and kept the pages turning fast.
- A Whirlwind Romance: Oftentimes I find fast-paced romances to be underdeveloped, based primarily on attraction, or too simple/easy. But I am happy to say that none of that is true for the whirlwind romance between Darcy and Elizabeth in this tale. I’m impressed with Julie Cooper’s talent for skillfully executing a romantic adventure that has a surplus of action at the same time as creating a relationship filled with developments, challenges, and a satisfying growth. Well done!!
- Multiple Threads: There are several relationships introduced and explored in this tale. I appreciated the sensitive and perceptive development of these relationships. I felt as immersed and invested in these relationships as I did Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s. Some developments were wonderfully surprising – like what happened with Mrs. Reynolds!
- Elizabeth Bennet: Lizzy is my hero in this story. She is full of energetic purpose, realistic optimism, and is prodigiously capable. I loved hearing about Lizzy’s precocious behaviors as a child – her wish for a father to make her life whole just broke my heart! I loved Lizzy’s talent and passion for sculpting and how she dreams of developing her talent to improve her life. And lastly, I loved witnessing Lizzy’s fearlessness and selflessness. She is faced with a lot of difficult situations and decisions and through them all she always puts others first and attempts to understand situations completely before letting pride, mistaken assumptions, and obstinacy creep in. She is a wonder and a delight!
- Lizzy and Mrs. Bennet: It is a rare occasion where I find myself enjoying the relationship between Elizabeth and her mother! It was lovely to see Lizzy be protective and understanding towards her mother – she is a protector in more ways than one. And even though Mrs. Bennet was still silly and a bit of a handful, I enjoyed seeing her respect and appreciate Lizzy instead of constantly criticize and insult her.
- Familiar Characters: I thought it was great fun to spot some familiar names and personalities in this story. These additions were very clever, and I loved the way some of the other Bennet sisters were still represented!
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
My only quibble would be that occasionally the second half felt a little long and slow, but at the same time there was a lot of storylines to continue and threads to weave in together.
CONCLUSION:
Extraordinary and enthralling – The Perfect Gentleman is a remarkably inventive Pride and Prejudice variation that not only splendidly entertains, but also sensitively explores the emotional impact of relationships and the importance of not letting yourself be defined by the actions and opinions of others. Congratulations on this spectacular debut, Julie Cooper!! I am so thrilled to hear there is another book of yours coming out later this year! 🤗🤩
Austenesque Reviews
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: (Outside of Canon) Begins during Georgiana’s stay in Ramsgate
SYNOPSIS: In this alternate world of Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet is not recognized by her father, Mr. Bennet, and lives with her elder sister and mother in Ramsgate, where she helps support her family by making souvenir seaside sculptures. Elizabeth’s world is forever changed when a certain fastidious gentleman from Derbyshire turns up looking for her on behalf of her father’s family. But before Mr. Darcy can complete his mission, he learns that his sister, Georgiana, has abruptly departed Ramsgate with her companion. Knowing very well that Georgiana’s companion, Lydia Younge, is one bad egg, Elizabeth offers her discreet and valuable assistance to the stubborn and arrogant gentleman in hopes that she can help recover his sister but also receive some needed support in setting her life on a new course. Instead of balls, parties, and visits with family/friends, this adventurous Pride and Prejudice tale is filled with scandals, secrets, and troubled relationships.
WHAT I LOVED:
- Divergent Yet Connected: With only two Bennet daughters that are half-siblings, an estranged Mr. Bennet, and Lizzy aspiring to study art and become a sculptor this story has a lot of details that steer it a different direction. This premise is extremely inventive, and I think readers would be hard-pressed to find another book with similar twists. And yet, there are enough similarities in these characters’ personalities and the themes employed that this wholly divergent tale still feels connected to Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.
- Action-Packed Adventure: With seeking clues like a detective, playacting as a traveling couple, embarking on countless carriage rides across the country, and encountering dangerous ruffians on the road – this story is filled with exhilarating action! These events were thrilling to witness, and kept the pages turning fast.
- A Whirlwind Romance: Oftentimes I find fast-paced romances to be underdeveloped, based primarily on attraction, or too simple/easy. But I am happy to say that none of that is true for the whirlwind romance between Darcy and Elizabeth in this tale. I’m impressed with Julie Cooper’s talent for skillfully executing a romantic adventure that has a surplus of action at the same time as creating a relationship filled with developments, challenges, and a satisfying growth. Well done!!
- Multiple Threads: There are several relationships introduced and explored in this tale. I appreciated the sensitive and perceptive development of these relationships. I felt as immersed and invested in these relationships as I did Darcy’s and Elizabeth’s. Some developments were wonderfully surprising – like what happened with Mrs. Reynolds!
- Elizabeth Bennet: Lizzy is my hero in this story. She is full of energetic purpose, realistic optimism, and is prodigiously capable. I loved hearing about Lizzy’s precocious behaviors as a child – her wish for a father to make her life whole just broke my heart! I loved Lizzy’s talent and passion for sculpting and how she dreams of developing her talent to improve her life. And lastly, I loved witnessing Lizzy’s fearlessness and selflessness. She is faced with a lot of difficult situations and decisions and through them all she always puts others first and attempts to understand situations completely before letting pride, mistaken assumptions, and obstinacy creep in. She is a wonder and a delight!
- Lizzy and Mrs. Bennet: It is a rare occasion where I find myself enjoying the relationship between Elizabeth and her mother! It was lovely to see Lizzy be protective and understanding towards her mother – she is a protector in more ways than one. And even though Mrs. Bennet was still silly and a bit of a handful, I enjoyed seeing her respect and appreciate Lizzy instead of constantly criticize and insult her.
- Familiar Characters: I thought it was great fun to spot some familiar names and personalities in this story. These additions were very clever, and I loved the way some of the other Bennet sisters were still represented!
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
My only quibble would be that occasionally the second half felt a little long and slow, but at the same time there was a lot of storylines to continue and threads to weave in together.
CONCLUSION:
Extraordinary and enthralling – The Perfect Gentleman is a remarkably inventive Pride and Prejudice variation that not only splendidly entertains, but also sensitively explores the emotional impact of relationships and the importance of not letting yourself be defined by the actions and opinions of others. Congratulations on this spectacular debut, Julie Cooper!! I am so thrilled to hear there is another book of yours coming out later this year! 🤗🤩
Austenesque Reviews
November 19, 2019
“A mother has far greater influence on her children than anyone else, and she must realize that every word she speaks, every act, every response, her attitude, even her appearance and manner of dress affect the lives of her children and the whole family. It is while the child is in the home that he gains from his mother the attitudes, hopes, and beliefs that will determine the kind of life he will live and the contribution he will make to society.”
― N. Eldon Tanner
Rating: MA: ->PG13 as mature/adult themes were discussed of a sexual nature.
A story in two parts: Volume 1 & Volume 2: Volume 1 established that this was an alternate universe for our P&P story. Thank goodness, we had a reduced number of characters and I am so glad the author did that. The stage did not need to be cluttered with all the P&P characters just because someone felt like they had to present EVERY person from the story. Whew! It was funny how our author was able to convey so much of those character traits and dialogue with the small cast as it was. The juxtaposition was pretty amazing.
This was a deep story and I didn’t expect that. I’m not sure I can fully convey what I felt as I read this. The story rides along on the surface and yet, in the depths, there bubbles an understanding of human nature and the common thread between people whether gentry or aristocracy. Although they may be separated by wealth, connections, interest and social status… people, especially women, are basically the same.
This was a story about restoration, forgiveness, redemption, reparation and coming to terms with one’s past. In the depths, the author dealt with the break-up of two families and the fallout and consequences that followed. We had the example of two fathers and two mothers and how each handled life’s hard realities and the resulting influence on their families, the children especially. We were presented with their sins or past behaviors, and the coming to terms with the guilt, shame, and consequences of those behaviors. We also had characters seeking forgiveness for past hurts and slights. The desire to restore that which was lost was especially strong and whether reparation could be accomplished was not always presented as a certainty. Two families, torn apart by past behavior of a similar nature. Both women painted with the same brush, branded with the same label, and similarly rejected by family and society. Then we have their children growing up without a parent and dealing with the aftermath of the scandal and social rejection.
The page-time between ODC was amazing. I can’t quite decide if Elizabeth was too modern or acted appropriately for a woman suffragette of the times. We watched as she struggled and strained against society and its expectations and restraints/restrictions on women. She did not take her choices lightly. She could marry Darcy, learn to run Pemberley as it should be, have a house full of children or she could fulfill her desire for a career and hone her artistic endeavors. Could she have it all… in other words?
I loved the way the story evolved but it could have been trimmed a few times when it went too far in a direction that wasn’t important. For example, deciding what Georgiana would or would not do in a situation. I didn’t care. Then we had a very modern Darcy vs Lizzy argument. He doesn’t understand what all the fuss is about and wants her to: quit playing with her art, assume her place as mistress of Pemberley, establish her social standing with the neighborhood [visits and social calls], and start a family. She wants to: pursue her art by studying under a master, put off having a family until later, and delegate the duties of Pemberley while she created in her studio. There were several scenes that made me think of the 2005 P&P movie where Lizzy was touring the statue gallery at Pemberley. I liked that.
What I didn’t like: there were several places where it dragged a bit... OK, quite a bit. In some respects, this felt like three or four novellas linked together to make one book. Vol 1 was one novella and then Vol 2 could have been divided again at least twice more. The tone kept changing with each section and there were several story threads running concurrently. At times I wanted to shake Darcy and then he’d do something that made me love him. Then, I wanted to shake Lizzy and she would do something that made me love her. My emotions were all over the place. And, lastly, it ended abruptly. I mean full stop and I have no idea what happened next. It just ran out of steam leaving several threads dangling and several unanswered questions. I don’t know if that was intentional [is there a sequel?] or that was just the end. There was no epilogue or even a follow-up.
I highly recommend this story for anyone who likes something completely different. This was so interesting. I did receive an ARC from the Quills & Quartos Publishing without any expectations of a review. The views expressed are my own.
― N. Eldon Tanner
Rating: MA: ->PG13 as mature/adult themes were discussed of a sexual nature.
A story in two parts: Volume 1 & Volume 2: Volume 1 established that this was an alternate universe for our P&P story. Thank goodness, we had a reduced number of characters and I am so glad the author did that. The stage did not need to be cluttered with all the P&P characters just because someone felt like they had to present EVERY person from the story. Whew! It was funny how our author was able to convey so much of those character traits and dialogue with the small cast as it was. The juxtaposition was pretty amazing.
This was a deep story and I didn’t expect that. I’m not sure I can fully convey what I felt as I read this. The story rides along on the surface and yet, in the depths, there bubbles an understanding of human nature and the common thread between people whether gentry or aristocracy. Although they may be separated by wealth, connections, interest and social status… people, especially women, are basically the same.
This was a story about restoration, forgiveness, redemption, reparation and coming to terms with one’s past. In the depths, the author dealt with the break-up of two families and the fallout and consequences that followed. We had the example of two fathers and two mothers and how each handled life’s hard realities and the resulting influence on their families, the children especially. We were presented with their sins or past behaviors, and the coming to terms with the guilt, shame, and consequences of those behaviors. We also had characters seeking forgiveness for past hurts and slights. The desire to restore that which was lost was especially strong and whether reparation could be accomplished was not always presented as a certainty. Two families, torn apart by past behavior of a similar nature. Both women painted with the same brush, branded with the same label, and similarly rejected by family and society. Then we have their children growing up without a parent and dealing with the aftermath of the scandal and social rejection.
The page-time between ODC was amazing. I can’t quite decide if Elizabeth was too modern or acted appropriately for a woman suffragette of the times. We watched as she struggled and strained against society and its expectations and restraints/restrictions on women. She did not take her choices lightly. She could marry Darcy, learn to run Pemberley as it should be, have a house full of children or she could fulfill her desire for a career and hone her artistic endeavors. Could she have it all… in other words?
I loved the way the story evolved but it could have been trimmed a few times when it went too far in a direction that wasn’t important. For example, deciding what Georgiana would or would not do in a situation. I didn’t care. Then we had a very modern Darcy vs Lizzy argument. He doesn’t understand what all the fuss is about and wants her to: quit playing with her art, assume her place as mistress of Pemberley, establish her social standing with the neighborhood [visits and social calls], and start a family. She wants to: pursue her art by studying under a master, put off having a family until later, and delegate the duties of Pemberley while she created in her studio. There were several scenes that made me think of the 2005 P&P movie where Lizzy was touring the statue gallery at Pemberley. I liked that.
What I didn’t like: there were several places where it dragged a bit... OK, quite a bit. In some respects, this felt like three or four novellas linked together to make one book. Vol 1 was one novella and then Vol 2 could have been divided again at least twice more. The tone kept changing with each section and there were several story threads running concurrently. At times I wanted to shake Darcy and then he’d do something that made me love him. Then, I wanted to shake Lizzy and she would do something that made me love her. My emotions were all over the place. And, lastly, it ended abruptly. I mean full stop and I have no idea what happened next. It just ran out of steam leaving several threads dangling and several unanswered questions. I don’t know if that was intentional [is there a sequel?] or that was just the end. There was no epilogue or even a follow-up.
I highly recommend this story for anyone who likes something completely different. This was so interesting. I did receive an ARC from the Quills & Quartos Publishing without any expectations of a review. The views expressed are my own.
March 11, 2020
My Rating: 4.5* rounded up to 5*
A satisfying and all encompassing read.
How can one not love an Elizabeth Bennet who completely upends Darcy's rigid world. Taking his soul and molding his mind into releasing all the anger, passion and hidden insecurities to give us the 'perfect gentleman'.
"But those eyes! They had weighed and measured his character and found him wanting." (quote from the book)
I was simply blown away by the complexities within this imaginative novel. We have scandal, heaps of it, and we have adventure. We have intrigue, compassion, laughter and tears. And, we have a Mr. Darcy that is rocked to his very core.
"You are trouble, Miss Bennet." (quote from the book)
This is an 'outside the box' Pride and Prejudice variation with lots of drama and over-the-top actions...a bit of 'suspend belief' in parts. But overall, it worked. I was gripped in its thrall as each character dealt with their past, their imperfections, and their fears. Would they or could they forgive those who harmed them the most.
"She had only to look at his mother, who in making the decision to fiercely protect her heart, found it broken instead by the walls she erected around it." (quote from the book)
This is a beautifully written debut novel that leaves me wanting more, for there are still some threads left dangling.
December 8, 2025
Excellent Read
Reviewed in Canada on October 22, 2019
This is a very well-written, non-canon story. Oh what to say without giving it all away. The character portrayals are surprising. The dialogue is good and not drowned in too much narrative. I did feel the ending unfinished between Lizzy and Bennet. I did miss an epilogue. Otherwise, very good and I highly recommend this book.
October 24, 2020—Enjoyed a second time reading along with the audiobook. Excellent narration and performance by Lillian Rachel.
August 19, 2023 - Audiobook re-listen.
Reviewed in Canada on October 22, 2019
This is a very well-written, non-canon story. Oh what to say without giving it all away. The character portrayals are surprising. The dialogue is good and not drowned in too much narrative. I did feel the ending unfinished between Lizzy and Bennet. I did miss an epilogue. Otherwise, very good and I highly recommend this book.
October 24, 2020—Enjoyed a second time reading along with the audiobook. Excellent narration and performance by Lillian Rachel.
August 19, 2023 - Audiobook re-listen.
November 4, 2019
First part - 5 stars
Second part - 3 stars
Overall - 4 stars
Second part - 3 stars
Overall - 4 stars
October 22, 2019
Book 1 was quite good, fast moving and mostly interesting, though the sheer amount of unfortunate occurrences did begin to get a bit silly.
Book 2 dragged. Tempted to DNF at 70%. Mrs R was really annoying. I don’t even think she’s realistic but either way I would have sacked her ASAP for trying to rule E and complaining to D. Didn’t feel on board with D & E’s relationship. E’s doubts were very realistic whereas their “devotion” (mostly lust) and desire for self sacrifice mixed with misunderstandings and lack of communication were immature, and felt like a teenage romance rather than a marriage. They didn’t really trust each other. Lizzy relied too much on other people’s opinion, not what Darcy told her. Darcy said whatever to get her to do what he wanted but he didn’t really understand or support her, or do things she likes with her, and was a bit of a prat about it. Decided to plough on as wanted to see if my concerns could be resolved, and I was wondering if the early mention of Wickham and the ring were going to be as important as they seemed in book 1. Their marriage got worse though, definitely not happy newlyweds. The ring was the plot device for their reconciliation, which was OTT dramatic (and E & Brimstone’s bit was just ridiculous). I did like the theme of reconciliation within both the Bennet & Darcy families.
Both books could do with editing. I found that there were strange word/phrase choices which distracted me from the novel - eg using plural instead of singular, some Americanisms, words that I think were spelling mistakes, mixed metaphors, and the overuse (imo) of ‘female’. There were definite mistakes such as describing something as legal in Scotland but illegal under British law. I assume the author is from the US and thinks British means English. Britain is an island including England, Scotland, and Wales. Scotland IS British. So the Scottish and English legal systems have differences, but British law would be followed by both (also true today). They also frequently mention Scotland as abroad, which I don’t think would be the term used by the English even then - Scotland and England are 2 geographical countries but one political country (the UK since 1707 Act of Union) which the English enforced by army occupation.
Book 2 dragged. Tempted to DNF at 70%. Mrs R was really annoying. I don’t even think she’s realistic but either way I would have sacked her ASAP for trying to rule E and complaining to D. Didn’t feel on board with D & E’s relationship. E’s doubts were very realistic whereas their “devotion” (mostly lust) and desire for self sacrifice mixed with misunderstandings and lack of communication were immature, and felt like a teenage romance rather than a marriage. They didn’t really trust each other. Lizzy relied too much on other people’s opinion, not what Darcy told her. Darcy said whatever to get her to do what he wanted but he didn’t really understand or support her, or do things she likes with her, and was a bit of a prat about it. Decided to plough on as wanted to see if my concerns could be resolved, and I was wondering if the early mention of Wickham and the ring were going to be as important as they seemed in book 1. Their marriage got worse though, definitely not happy newlyweds. The ring was the plot device for their reconciliation, which was OTT dramatic (and E & Brimstone’s bit was just ridiculous). I did like the theme of reconciliation within both the Bennet & Darcy families.
Both books could do with editing. I found that there were strange word/phrase choices which distracted me from the novel - eg using plural instead of singular, some Americanisms, words that I think were spelling mistakes, mixed metaphors, and the overuse (imo) of ‘female’. There were definite mistakes such as describing something as legal in Scotland but illegal under British law. I assume the author is from the US and thinks British means English. Britain is an island including England, Scotland, and Wales. Scotland IS British. So the Scottish and English legal systems have differences, but British law would be followed by both (also true today). They also frequently mention Scotland as abroad, which I don’t think would be the term used by the English even then - Scotland and England are 2 geographical countries but one political country (the UK since 1707 Act of Union) which the English enforced by army occupation.
May 28, 2020
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely wonderful. Highly recommended to those seeking an addictive and vastly entertaining tale!
Absolutely wonderful. Highly recommended to those seeking an addictive and vastly entertaining tale!
April 4, 2023
4,5 Stars
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
The Perfect Gentleman is a Pride & Prejudice regency variation, but it is so far of canon that it is even hard to explain its entire storyline, however, readers will like to know that this is an epic book that starts out with one plotline but ends up developing different plots, so it is perfect for people who love long stories where they can follow different dimensions of the characters they love.
The book starts out with Elizabeth and Darcy joining forces to search for Georgiana who has apparently eloped, but after their long chase throughout the country they end up getting married and we will see them overcome different obstacles as a solid couple. To me this book felt like two different books combined in one single story but I did enjoy both plotlines. The first part of the book is full of action and fast paced, we see the characters taking part of many different adventures while getting to know, respect and love each other. On the second part of the book we get a slow paced story focused on personal goals, life visions and relationships. Having these two different dimensions in the book made it a very complete, rich and interesting read in my opinion.
I believe this story could easily be a regency romance without any connection to Pride and Prejudice, and that allowed the book to have very interesting twists such as Elizabeth’s predicaments concerning her independence, her dreams and her priorities, Darcy’s struggle concerning his mother and his values etc. I found the topics approached very enticing and interesting, especially because some of them are not usually found in P&P variations. I particularly loved Elizabeth’s dilemma between following her artistic dreams and married life. Her character was interesting due to her intelligence and resourcefulness, but what I valued the most was seeing a woman whose goal in life was not simply to bear children for her husband and live a simple country life. There was much more than that to Elizabeth’s personality, and I enjoyed that very much.
I liked many different aspects of this book which was well thought of and well written. I liked the exploration of different types of relationships between so many different characters because it allowed me as a reader to explore the human nature in many different angles. I also enjoyed witnessing how so many different characters reacted differently to many situations, this book is a good description of human nature, and the reality of it all made it a great read.
Summing up, The Perfect Gentleman is an epic regency romance that has it all: adventure, romance, and character development. It is well written and explores the human nature in many different situations making the reader examine his own position in life. I highly recommend this book to those who love good novels
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
The Perfect Gentleman is a Pride & Prejudice regency variation, but it is so far of canon that it is even hard to explain its entire storyline, however, readers will like to know that this is an epic book that starts out with one plotline but ends up developing different plots, so it is perfect for people who love long stories where they can follow different dimensions of the characters they love.
The book starts out with Elizabeth and Darcy joining forces to search for Georgiana who has apparently eloped, but after their long chase throughout the country they end up getting married and we will see them overcome different obstacles as a solid couple. To me this book felt like two different books combined in one single story but I did enjoy both plotlines. The first part of the book is full of action and fast paced, we see the characters taking part of many different adventures while getting to know, respect and love each other. On the second part of the book we get a slow paced story focused on personal goals, life visions and relationships. Having these two different dimensions in the book made it a very complete, rich and interesting read in my opinion.
I believe this story could easily be a regency romance without any connection to Pride and Prejudice, and that allowed the book to have very interesting twists such as Elizabeth’s predicaments concerning her independence, her dreams and her priorities, Darcy’s struggle concerning his mother and his values etc. I found the topics approached very enticing and interesting, especially because some of them are not usually found in P&P variations. I particularly loved Elizabeth’s dilemma between following her artistic dreams and married life. Her character was interesting due to her intelligence and resourcefulness, but what I valued the most was seeing a woman whose goal in life was not simply to bear children for her husband and live a simple country life. There was much more than that to Elizabeth’s personality, and I enjoyed that very much.
I liked many different aspects of this book which was well thought of and well written. I liked the exploration of different types of relationships between so many different characters because it allowed me as a reader to explore the human nature in many different angles. I also enjoyed witnessing how so many different characters reacted differently to many situations, this book is a good description of human nature, and the reality of it all made it a great read.
Summing up, The Perfect Gentleman is an epic regency romance that has it all: adventure, romance, and character development. It is well written and explores the human nature in many different situations making the reader examine his own position in life. I highly recommend this book to those who love good novels
November 25, 2019
Pride and Prejudice Variation
An action-packed thriller with a dark ambiance.
What if Mr Bennet had left Mrs Bennet to fend for herself in Ramsgate after the second daughter was born?
The less than respectable Elizabeth (due to her mother's occupation) soon became a vital aid in the hunt to recover Miss Darcy which culminated in a genius plot-twist I have never seen before, at the end of the first volum. The second half picks up where the first left off with some intriguing happenings at Pemberley, plenty of romantic interludes with ODC and Mrs Reynolds(oh my, she was something...)
Heartily recommend this page turner of a book.
An action-packed thriller with a dark ambiance.
What if Mr Bennet had left Mrs Bennet to fend for herself in Ramsgate after the second daughter was born?
The less than respectable Elizabeth (due to her mother's occupation) soon became a vital aid in the hunt to recover Miss Darcy which culminated in a genius plot-twist I have never seen before, at the end of the first volum. The second half picks up where the first left off with some intriguing happenings at Pemberley, plenty of romantic interludes with ODC and Mrs Reynolds(oh my, she was something...)
Heartily recommend this page turner of a book.
February 4, 2020
Off canon
Darcy’s background and relatives are pretty much intact but Lizzy’s is way, way off canon. Much room for new story elements are made though so be prepared a wild story.
I enjoyed the first half and thought the second half suffered when compared the first half.
Given the story takes place in Regency England times, the HEA is a tad unlikely but I’m glad there was one.
Darcy’s background and relatives are pretty much intact but Lizzy’s is way, way off canon. Much room for new story elements are made though so be prepared a wild story.
I enjoyed the first half and thought the second half suffered when compared the first half.
Given the story takes place in Regency England times, the HEA is a tad unlikely but I’m glad there was one.
December 12, 2019
How ridiculous is this story? For starters, Mrs. Bennet is a hooker. Wickham is completely nuts. Jane is virtually nonexistent, and Mary, Kitty and Lydia never existed. “Lizzy” is a sculptor—not just any old sculptor, but a budding genius. Darcy is a virgin (well, I suppose Austen never said he wasn’t)! There’s no Mr. Collins or Charlotte, and Aunt Gardner has been replaced by—wait for it—Aunt Bingley. The story has a number of melodramatic twists and turns, someone having neglected to tell the author that P&P is a comedy of manners. The author has talent, but I would have accepted the whole thing more readily if she’d used original characters instead of naming them after Austen’s.
November 13, 2020
A feast
A rich feast of a book. Recommended! A refreshing and unusual viewpoint of our favorite characters in a unique story line.
A rich feast of a book. Recommended! A refreshing and unusual viewpoint of our favorite characters in a unique story line.
March 11, 2020
Audible review:
Julie Cooper has a wonderful debut story. And narrator Lillian Rachel does it justice as narrator. Easy to recommend.
Julie Cooper has a wonderful debut story. And narrator Lillian Rachel does it justice as narrator. Easy to recommend.
June 19, 2024
Status: Read January 1-4, 2023
via kindle & audible editions
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5)
Edition Read:
The Perfect Gentleman: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Julie Cooper
Kindle Edition, 408 pages
Published October 21, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing (first published October 16, 2019)
ASIN: B07Z2VHZMT
[ kindle unlimited ]
My Library Notes:
The Perfect Gentleman
by Julie Cooper
Paperback, First Edition, 399 pages
Published October 16, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing
ISBN13: 978-1951033125 / ISBN: 1951033124
Georgiana Darcy has gone missing. Lizzy Bennet knows just what to do to find her.
‘Tis no secret that Lizzy Bennet has dreams. The uniquely talented daughter of a woman with a dubious reputation, Lizzy knows she must make her own way in a world that shuns her.
Fitzwilliam Darcy carries the stains of his family’s dishonour upon his soul and only by holding himself to the strictest standards has he reclaimed his place in society.
If his fifteen-year-old sister cannot be found quickly, her scandal could destroy years of perfect behaviour. Lizzy is willing to join the pursuit to get what she wants but will Darcy be willing to trust her with his secrets? And what will they do when the search for Georgiana reveals what neither expected to find?
The Perfect Gentleman
by Julie Cooper, Lillian Rachel (Narrator)
Audible Audio, Unabridged, 17 pages
Published December 30, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing (first published October 16, 2019)
ASIN: B08392WZ48
Listening Length: 16 hours and 9 minutes
via kindle & audible editions
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.5)
Edition Read:
The Perfect Gentleman: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Julie Cooper
Kindle Edition, 408 pages
Published October 21, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing (first published October 16, 2019)
ASIN: B07Z2VHZMT
[ kindle unlimited ]
My Library Notes:
The Perfect Gentleman
by Julie Cooper
Paperback, First Edition, 399 pages
Published October 16, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing
ISBN13: 978-1951033125 / ISBN: 1951033124
Georgiana Darcy has gone missing. Lizzy Bennet knows just what to do to find her.
‘Tis no secret that Lizzy Bennet has dreams. The uniquely talented daughter of a woman with a dubious reputation, Lizzy knows she must make her own way in a world that shuns her.
Fitzwilliam Darcy carries the stains of his family’s dishonour upon his soul and only by holding himself to the strictest standards has he reclaimed his place in society.
If his fifteen-year-old sister cannot be found quickly, her scandal could destroy years of perfect behaviour. Lizzy is willing to join the pursuit to get what she wants but will Darcy be willing to trust her with his secrets? And what will they do when the search for Georgiana reveals what neither expected to find?
The Perfect Gentleman
by Julie Cooper, Lillian Rachel (Narrator)
Audible Audio, Unabridged, 17 pages
Published December 30, 2019 by Quills & Quartos Publishing (first published October 16, 2019)
ASIN: B08392WZ48
Listening Length: 16 hours and 9 minutes
February 17, 2020
This is a long story and circumstances so changed and varied, I'm not really sure how to start.... Lizzy and Darcy meet early on - her family and social situation is completely different but she helps Darcy look for his missing sister. This makes up the first part of the book. The second part is the return to Pemberley.
I liked this book - Darcy and Lizzy misunderstand each other a lot but essentially still very much like each other. The first part of the book is a real adventure - so much happens and the pace is pretty good. I didn't enjoy the second part so much when everyone returns to Pemberley. It focuses very much on Lizzy's interest in art - which I wasnt very interested in myself. There is some nice humour and, at its heart, this story is about relationships and families.... it's just so difficult trying to sum up the plot line!!
I love variations... but this one is a complete reimagining rather than variation- which might put some readers off. It's pretty creative which allows for all propriety to go out the window and allows the reader to spend the majority of time with Darcy and Lizzy. This is definately something different - an original idea well written and entertaining.
I liked this book - Darcy and Lizzy misunderstand each other a lot but essentially still very much like each other. The first part of the book is a real adventure - so much happens and the pace is pretty good. I didn't enjoy the second part so much when everyone returns to Pemberley. It focuses very much on Lizzy's interest in art - which I wasnt very interested in myself. There is some nice humour and, at its heart, this story is about relationships and families.... it's just so difficult trying to sum up the plot line!!
I love variations... but this one is a complete reimagining rather than variation- which might put some readers off. It's pretty creative which allows for all propriety to go out the window and allows the reader to spend the majority of time with Darcy and Lizzy. This is definately something different - an original idea well written and entertaining.
December 3, 2019
Very nice
For a first novel, this is pretty great: well written and an interesting premise. Elizabeth grows up with a courtesan mother and an asentee father, Mr. Bennett. She doesn't hear anything about him until she's 21 years old, and Darcy has been sent to find her, as a favor to his friend Bingley, where she lives with her mother and Jane in Ramsgate. Elizabeth gets involved in rescuing Georgiana from Wickham and Mrs. Younge when they convince her to elope. During the rescue efforts, Darcy falls in love with Elizabeth in spite of her rather scandalous upbringing.
This is one of those variations that changes almost everything, and seems to be only borrowing the names of the characters. The lives and circumstances of many of the main characters are completely different. The circumstances of the Bennetts and the Bingleys , however, does make sense and is believable. What doesn't make sense is some of the more dramatic portions of the story. The quest to rescue Georgiana,, initiated and engineered by Elizabeth, heads into some pretty far-fetched territory. Her ability to just drop everything, leave home, and traipse all over the countryside, finding clues and using investigators, pushes the boundaries of sense, and Darcy allowing it? Well, I don't know. I had to just shake my head and say "really!?" several times.
Still, the author is a talented storyteller. The book is well written and well edited. I enjoyed it very much , so I recommend it.
For a first novel, this is pretty great: well written and an interesting premise. Elizabeth grows up with a courtesan mother and an asentee father, Mr. Bennett. She doesn't hear anything about him until she's 21 years old, and Darcy has been sent to find her, as a favor to his friend Bingley, where she lives with her mother and Jane in Ramsgate. Elizabeth gets involved in rescuing Georgiana from Wickham and Mrs. Younge when they convince her to elope. During the rescue efforts, Darcy falls in love with Elizabeth in spite of her rather scandalous upbringing.
This is one of those variations that changes almost everything, and seems to be only borrowing the names of the characters. The lives and circumstances of many of the main characters are completely different. The circumstances of the Bennetts and the Bingleys , however, does make sense and is believable. What doesn't make sense is some of the more dramatic portions of the story. The quest to rescue Georgiana,, initiated and engineered by Elizabeth, heads into some pretty far-fetched territory. Her ability to just drop everything, leave home, and traipse all over the countryside, finding clues and using investigators, pushes the boundaries of sense, and Darcy allowing it? Well, I don't know. I had to just shake my head and say "really!?" several times.
Still, the author is a talented storyteller. The book is well written and well edited. I enjoyed it very much , so I recommend it.
October 23, 2019
Almost ...Perfect.
This is a great AU story utilizing JA's most memorable characters. This is beautifully written. This will capture the reader from the first and hold one's attention throughout. This is a tightly edited story. There are no serious grammatical or rampant Regency historical errors here to cause affront. It is like a plush, colorful, artistic and finely crafted carpet, thoroughly vacuumed. Despise me if you dare, and you very well may. Please, please, do not ... Tempt Me.
This is a great AU story utilizing JA's most memorable characters. This is beautifully written. This will capture the reader from the first and hold one's attention throughout. This is a tightly edited story. There are no serious grammatical or rampant Regency historical errors here to cause affront. It is like a plush, colorful, artistic and finely crafted carpet, thoroughly vacuumed. Despise me if you dare, and you very well may. Please, please, do not ... Tempt Me.
February 3, 2020
4.5 stars for me rounded up to 5. What a great book! It kept be reading all night long. I like stories where Lizzy Bennett is making her own way in the world like this one. Lizzy is her strongest and definitely some fabulous chemistry between her and Darcy. There’s still a first disastrous proposal and probably one of the best refusals I’ve seen. I reread that particular paragraph several times. 4.5 stars for me because I found the first half to be stronger than the second and it began to lose its intrigue.
April 3, 2022
What a perfect book! Darcy, Elizabeth and every single character was imperfectly perfect for the beautiful plot with so much events and emotions and romance and a heart-in-throat climax. What more can a reader ask for?
December 17, 2019
This book was in two parts. In my opinion, the first installment was much better than the second. Even though there were some things that my mind couldn't quite reconcile about it, there was a good plot and enough excitement and adventure that my enjoyment make those things easy to overlook. I found the premise of Mrs. Bennet's abandonment and forced lifestyle an interesting one and as a result, the Elizabeth here is very understandably different than the canon Elizabeth Bennet. It is a very unique variation that I was excited to explore.
The second installment, not so much. I found myself bored through much of it and it seemed to go on and on. Like some other reviewers, I found myself wanting to give up and not finish it. I did plow my way through to the end but I didn't really find the "romance" between D & E very compelling and didn't really understand or relate to them or the story much at all in this second book. I found that I wasn't even very fond of Elizabeth as written and felt guilty for feeling that way. The things that troubled me in the first part, but was able to overlook because I was enjoying it, still bothered me in the second and because I didn't feel much of a connection, I was unable to reconcile those things and it bothered me the whole time. The main that didn't sit well with me is that Elizabeth one day just up and leaves her family that she has basically been the head of according to the author, without a word and no one seems to notice or care. She finally writes one letter to her family from Pemberley at a much later time and again, no response for quite some time. Apparently it's no big deal or not noteworthy enough to catch the attention of her mother or sister that she is gone or that she marrying some rich man of consequence that they know nothing about. I also thought there great potential storylines waiting to spring up involving Bingley, Mrs. Margaret Bingley, Mr. Bennet, Jane, the Earl and his family etc. but it was not touched or developed at all. We spent way too much time at Pemberley being bored when we could have spent more time in Hertfordshire or London and gotten to know some of the other characters and seen things develop there. It was like everyone not at Pemberley barely existed or noticed the existence of Elizabeth or Darcy. I feel like there was so much wasted potential here.
The second installment, not so much. I found myself bored through much of it and it seemed to go on and on. Like some other reviewers, I found myself wanting to give up and not finish it. I did plow my way through to the end but I didn't really find the "romance" between D & E very compelling and didn't really understand or relate to them or the story much at all in this second book. I found that I wasn't even very fond of Elizabeth as written and felt guilty for feeling that way. The things that troubled me in the first part, but was able to overlook because I was enjoying it, still bothered me in the second and because I didn't feel much of a connection, I was unable to reconcile those things and it bothered me the whole time. The main that didn't sit well with me is that Elizabeth one day just up and leaves her family that she has basically been the head of according to the author, without a word and no one seems to notice or care. She finally writes one letter to her family from Pemberley at a much later time and again, no response for quite some time. Apparently it's no big deal or not noteworthy enough to catch the attention of her mother or sister that she is gone or that she marrying some rich man of consequence that they know nothing about. I also thought there great potential storylines waiting to spring up involving Bingley, Mrs. Margaret Bingley, Mr. Bennet, Jane, the Earl and his family etc. but it was not touched or developed at all. We spent way too much time at Pemberley being bored when we could have spent more time in Hertfordshire or London and gotten to know some of the other characters and seen things develop there. It was like everyone not at Pemberley barely existed or noticed the existence of Elizabeth or Darcy. I feel like there was so much wasted potential here.
October 19, 2023
Pride and Prejudice variation that is partly action adventure. 3.5 stars rounded up to 4. This is a reread in October 2023. I like so many of the author's books, I wanted to give this one a second chance. I read it back in December 2019 and rated it 3 stars at that time. I almost did the same on this reread, but there are definitely aspects of the story that I love. The main problem for me is that it could almost be two separate stories, except that there are strong links between those two stories that force it to be one. So maybe it's for the best that it's all one book. But be warned, there is a major turn in the focus of the story. With that known up front, this can be an incredibly fun story.
This is a romance that is partly action adventure, but with some class division problems that are even more pronounced than in the original P&P. It also deals with feminism, and one thoughtful theme that stands out, that of reconciliation with estranged family members. I wish the story had gotten to the point with one of the relations that it seems to with the other family. (I'm being cryptic here, but don't want to include spoilers.) But that's life. Sometimes our troubled relationships are never resolved.
There were some things that I found incredibly annoying but won't mention because they might not bother other readers at all, so there's no point calling attention to them.
This is a romance that is partly action adventure, but with some class division problems that are even more pronounced than in the original P&P. It also deals with feminism, and one thoughtful theme that stands out, that of reconciliation with estranged family members. I wish the story had gotten to the point with one of the relations that it seems to with the other family. (I'm being cryptic here, but don't want to include spoilers.) But that's life. Sometimes our troubled relationships are never resolved.
There were some things that I found incredibly annoying but won't mention because they might not bother other readers at all, so there's no point calling attention to them.
February 24, 2020
Improbable but enchanting
An adventure that develops into a love story. Thoroughly entertaining and enjoyable reading. A very fresh perspective of my favorite tale.
An adventure that develops into a love story. Thoroughly entertaining and enjoyable reading. A very fresh perspective of my favorite tale.
November 12, 2019
I love this book!
This story is an absolutely must read! While it is still a P&P variation and the characters’ personalities and names are known to us, it is so different and refreshing that becomes really original. Julie Cooper really did a wonderful job. In this story, Lizzy is still the witty and intelligent woman we know but she comes from a much more inferior position in society. Therefore she can do things in a freer way and her relationship with Darcy becomes much more open and straightforward. She doesn’t have to worry much about her reputation and what to say, since her world is very different from the one of a gentlewoman. Darcy, on the other hand, is much more worried about social conventions and reputation, because of his family history. When their worlds collide and he falls in love with this amazing Lizzy, he has to question everything he thought was right and fight to earn the love of the gem that is Lizzy. Both Darcy and Lizzy are really special in this book and it’s hard to pick my favorite. It’s a wonderful journey with lots of adventure, love and surprises along the way. I really recommend this book and know I will be rereading it many times in the future.
This story is an absolutely must read! While it is still a P&P variation and the characters’ personalities and names are known to us, it is so different and refreshing that becomes really original. Julie Cooper really did a wonderful job. In this story, Lizzy is still the witty and intelligent woman we know but she comes from a much more inferior position in society. Therefore she can do things in a freer way and her relationship with Darcy becomes much more open and straightforward. She doesn’t have to worry much about her reputation and what to say, since her world is very different from the one of a gentlewoman. Darcy, on the other hand, is much more worried about social conventions and reputation, because of his family history. When their worlds collide and he falls in love with this amazing Lizzy, he has to question everything he thought was right and fight to earn the love of the gem that is Lizzy. Both Darcy and Lizzy are really special in this book and it’s hard to pick my favorite. It’s a wonderful journey with lots of adventure, love and surprises along the way. I really recommend this book and know I will be rereading it many times in the future.
March 23, 2024
Quite Refreshing Storyline
The Perfect Gentleman is a very refreshing PNP variant. The storyline centers quite significantly around ODC and Georgiana instead of the whole Bennet family. Elizabeth's mother, father and older sister are introduced to the story instead of the whole cannon family. But they are more place holders to explain Elizabeth's circumstances. There's no real significant interaction with them in the storyline.
Darcy and Elizabeth have a brilliant meet-cute and the attraction is almost immediate on both ends but circumstances keep ODC apart for about half the book. I really enjoyed the their struggles and how they overcame them.
The Perfect Gentleman is a very refreshing PNP variant. The storyline centers quite significantly around ODC and Georgiana instead of the whole Bennet family. Elizabeth's mother, father and older sister are introduced to the story instead of the whole cannon family. But they are more place holders to explain Elizabeth's circumstances. There's no real significant interaction with them in the storyline.
Darcy and Elizabeth have a brilliant meet-cute and the attraction is almost immediate on both ends but circumstances keep ODC apart for about half the book. I really enjoyed the their struggles and how they overcame them.
October 22, 2019
Excellent new author
I thoroughly enjoyed everything about this book. New and different storyline, characters developed with extreme and interesting depth, and a nice long read. So looking forward to more!!!
I thoroughly enjoyed everything about this book. New and different storyline, characters developed with extreme and interesting depth, and a nice long read. So looking forward to more!!!
November 12, 2019
The perfect
This is the first book I have read by this author but it will not be the last. I am going to find another and hope she continues with the same blend of good characters, dialogue, humor, and plot.
This is the first book I have read by this author but it will not be the last. I am going to find another and hope she continues with the same blend of good characters, dialogue, humor, and plot.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 94 reviews