What do you think?
Rate this book
The Darkest Shore
The independent women of Scotland stand up to a witch hunt, male fury and the power of the Church in a battle for survival in this compelling historical novel based on true events in early eighteenth century Scotland.
1703: The wild east coast of Scotland.
Returning to her home town of Pittenweem, fishwife and widow Sorcha McIntyre knows she faces both censure and mistrust. After all, this is a country where myth and legend are woven into the fabric of the everyday, a time when those who defy custom like Sorcha has are called to account.
It is dangerous to be a clever woman who 'doesn't know her place' in Pittenweem - a town rife with superstition. So, when a young local falls victim to witchcraft, the Reverend Cowper and the townsfolk know who to blame. What follows for Sorcha and her friends is a terrifying battle, not only for their souls, but for their lives, as they are pitted against the villagers' fear, a malevolent man and the might of the church.
Based on the shocking true story of the witch hunt of Pittenweem, this multi-layered novel is a beautifully written historical tale of the strength of women united against a common foe, by one of Australia's finest writers.
PRAISE FOR KAREN BROOKS
'The Darkest Shore is meticulously researched, taking a real historical event, and [Karen Brooks'] academic experience and merging it with exceptional storytelling. The characters are complex and compelling ... a powerful novel, at times brutal, but always enthralling. The Darkest Shore is a major achievement for Karen Brooks.' Better Reading
'Meticulously researched and historically compelling... this fast-paced novel is a dramatic spy thriller that shines a spotlight on the inner workings of Elizabethan England.' - BOOKS+PUBLISHING on The Locksmith's Daughter
1703: The wild east coast of Scotland.
Returning to her home town of Pittenweem, fishwife and widow Sorcha McIntyre knows she faces both censure and mistrust. After all, this is a country where myth and legend are woven into the fabric of the everyday, a time when those who defy custom like Sorcha has are called to account.
It is dangerous to be a clever woman who 'doesn't know her place' in Pittenweem - a town rife with superstition. So, when a young local falls victim to witchcraft, the Reverend Cowper and the townsfolk know who to blame. What follows for Sorcha and her friends is a terrifying battle, not only for their souls, but for their lives, as they are pitted against the villagers' fear, a malevolent man and the might of the church.
Based on the shocking true story of the witch hunt of Pittenweem, this multi-layered novel is a beautifully written historical tale of the strength of women united against a common foe, by one of Australia's finest writers.
PRAISE FOR KAREN BROOKS
'The Darkest Shore is meticulously researched, taking a real historical event, and [Karen Brooks'] academic experience and merging it with exceptional storytelling. The characters are complex and compelling ... a powerful novel, at times brutal, but always enthralling. The Darkest Shore is a major achievement for Karen Brooks.' Better Reading
'Meticulously researched and historically compelling... this fast-paced novel is a dramatic spy thriller that shines a spotlight on the inner workings of Elizabethan England.' - BOOKS+PUBLISHING on The Locksmith's Daughter
528 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2020
92 people are currently reading
1916 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews
February 16, 2020
Sorcha McIntyre was unsure of her reception once she returned to her hometown of Pittenweem after an absence of years, but was pleasantly surprised at the welcome she received, at least from her women friends. The fishwives of Pittenweem were a strong, hardworking group of women who spent their days on the shore on the east coast of Scotland, mending the fishing nets and many other chores from dawn to dusk. Nettie, the good friend who had been living in Sorcha’s home while she was away, kept Sorcha close, filling her in on all that had happened in her absence.
The new incomer, Captain Aiden Ross was a fairer man than his predecessor and kept his soldiers in line, banishing them for any misdemeanors. But it was the Reverend Cowper who terrified her and many others. He’d always had a hatred of Sorcha – and she of him – but his fanatical beliefs had followers as well. Sorcha and her friends needed to remember not to ignite anything to cause the superstitions which were rife in the town in 1704. The innocent jest by one of the women started a terrifying and brutal time for Sorcha and the others as they were hounded for witches. Reverend Cowper was determined to see them all hang…
The Darkest Shore by Aussie author Karen Brooks is well researched, beautifully written but oh my goodness, it is brutal! Cruel, breathtaking, descriptive torture – I had to put the book down several times as I just couldn’t read any more. I ended up skimming a lot of the dark viciousness, while wishing the perpetrators much harm. Based on the true story of the witch hunt of Pittenweem back in 1704 and 1705, with many of the characters actual people, the Author’s Notes at the end are interesting – don’t read first as there are spoilers. Sorcha (a strong, independent woman, and my favourite character) and her family are fictional; and the ending was perfect. I feel sure Ms Brooks would have needed to do something light and entertaining after she finished this book. I know I need to read something light and entertaining now! Recommended.
With thanks to HarperCollins AU for my uncorrected proof ARC to read in exchange for an honest review.
The new incomer, Captain Aiden Ross was a fairer man than his predecessor and kept his soldiers in line, banishing them for any misdemeanors. But it was the Reverend Cowper who terrified her and many others. He’d always had a hatred of Sorcha – and she of him – but his fanatical beliefs had followers as well. Sorcha and her friends needed to remember not to ignite anything to cause the superstitions which were rife in the town in 1704. The innocent jest by one of the women started a terrifying and brutal time for Sorcha and the others as they were hounded for witches. Reverend Cowper was determined to see them all hang…
The Darkest Shore by Aussie author Karen Brooks is well researched, beautifully written but oh my goodness, it is brutal! Cruel, breathtaking, descriptive torture – I had to put the book down several times as I just couldn’t read any more. I ended up skimming a lot of the dark viciousness, while wishing the perpetrators much harm. Based on the true story of the witch hunt of Pittenweem back in 1704 and 1705, with many of the characters actual people, the Author’s Notes at the end are interesting – don’t read first as there are spoilers. Sorcha (a strong, independent woman, and my favourite character) and her family are fictional; and the ending was perfect. I feel sure Ms Brooks would have needed to do something light and entertaining after she finished this book. I know I need to read something light and entertaining now! Recommended.
With thanks to HarperCollins AU for my uncorrected proof ARC to read in exchange for an honest review.
March 3, 2020
History is rife with examples of humans doing their worst. When you read as much historical fiction as I do, you have occasion to come across this fairly regularly. Even so, I’m still pulled up at times by history that has been buried deep in the hopes that it may not ever be discovered and pulled out into the light. And so it is with the 1704 witch hunt of Pittenweem, the history that this incredible novel, The Darkest Shore, is based upon. This is a dark read, with human nature exposed at its most despicable, where torture and murder is vindicated as ‘the will of God’. It was at times a harrowing read, but such is the talent of Karen Brooks that this darkness did not equate to a depressing read. There are moments of such strength and love between friends and neighbours that you can’t help but feel as though this story is as uplifting as it is harrowing. As is the way with history, from the author’s notes at the end we learn that the very worst parts of this story were the ones that were entirely true.
‘Yet to Reverend Patrick Cowper, the fishwives represented everything he disapproved of: loud, godless women, women without men to control them, teach them how to behave and keep them tamed and quiet. That they were able to earn their keep and had means and property besides, only added to their sins.’
The Darkest Shore is a long novel, a touch over 500 pages, and it’s also a very involving novel. The story is epic in scope and immersive in its attention to detail. I absolutely loved the Scottish-ness of it, the language, the customs, and the way in which people interacted with each other; the ebb and flow of daily community life. This is where the more uplifting parts of the story were evident, particularly in the connections between the fishwives. There was a loyalty and affection between them that was empowering to witness. For all that these women endured, they drew strength from each other and I believe this was a big part of the reason why they survived all they were subjected to. Karen Brooks has brought the history of who these women were to life with honour and affection; this novel really is a beautiful tribute to who the fishwives were and the important role they played within Scottish fishing communities in the early 18th century.
‘In the telling, she owned the story. She took it from the men who inflicted the pain and suffering, the officials who allowed it to happen and kept records, and made it hers.’
Reverend Cowper was a villain and a half, let me tell you. There was no end to his evil, he just kept on stalking the women, hammering away at his congregation about ‘the witches’, whipping up hysteria and fear. He was a man obsessed, but what was more alarming was how the majority of Pittenweem locals fell for his fervour. Honestly, the man was transparent in his agenda and purely evil, yet he ruled that community like a puppet master. It’s a telling reminder of just how easy it is to manipulate the masses if the chips are all falling down in your favour. That he fashioned himself in the model of Pontius Pilate was beyond arrogant and entirely reprehensible. He deserved a reckoning that far surpassed what he had orchestrated and allowed to be done within his community. Karen Brooks gives us a more satisfying outcome with regards to Reverend Cowper than what history reports of his true fate.
‘Listening to the reverend, Sorcha marvelled that this man of God, who should be alleviating people’s fears, was exacerbating them. When he should be encouraging unity, he was fostering discord and suspicion.’
I really loved The Darkest Shore. The history of witches and witch hunting is of particular interest to me and I feel that Karen Brooks has handled such a dark history with care and empathy. I read The Chocolate Maker’s Wife last year and adored that and when considered alongside The Darkest Shore, I’d have to say that Karen Brooks is now one of my favourite authors. I’ll be reading everything she releases from now on and will be making a point of reading her historical fiction back list as well. I can’t recommend this one highly enough, it’s a brilliant read.
Thanks is extended to HarperCollins Publishers Australia for providing me with a copy of The Darkest Shore for review.
‘Yet to Reverend Patrick Cowper, the fishwives represented everything he disapproved of: loud, godless women, women without men to control them, teach them how to behave and keep them tamed and quiet. That they were able to earn their keep and had means and property besides, only added to their sins.’
The Darkest Shore is a long novel, a touch over 500 pages, and it’s also a very involving novel. The story is epic in scope and immersive in its attention to detail. I absolutely loved the Scottish-ness of it, the language, the customs, and the way in which people interacted with each other; the ebb and flow of daily community life. This is where the more uplifting parts of the story were evident, particularly in the connections between the fishwives. There was a loyalty and affection between them that was empowering to witness. For all that these women endured, they drew strength from each other and I believe this was a big part of the reason why they survived all they were subjected to. Karen Brooks has brought the history of who these women were to life with honour and affection; this novel really is a beautiful tribute to who the fishwives were and the important role they played within Scottish fishing communities in the early 18th century.
‘In the telling, she owned the story. She took it from the men who inflicted the pain and suffering, the officials who allowed it to happen and kept records, and made it hers.’
Reverend Cowper was a villain and a half, let me tell you. There was no end to his evil, he just kept on stalking the women, hammering away at his congregation about ‘the witches’, whipping up hysteria and fear. He was a man obsessed, but what was more alarming was how the majority of Pittenweem locals fell for his fervour. Honestly, the man was transparent in his agenda and purely evil, yet he ruled that community like a puppet master. It’s a telling reminder of just how easy it is to manipulate the masses if the chips are all falling down in your favour. That he fashioned himself in the model of Pontius Pilate was beyond arrogant and entirely reprehensible. He deserved a reckoning that far surpassed what he had orchestrated and allowed to be done within his community. Karen Brooks gives us a more satisfying outcome with regards to Reverend Cowper than what history reports of his true fate.
‘Listening to the reverend, Sorcha marvelled that this man of God, who should be alleviating people’s fears, was exacerbating them. When he should be encouraging unity, he was fostering discord and suspicion.’
I really loved The Darkest Shore. The history of witches and witch hunting is of particular interest to me and I feel that Karen Brooks has handled such a dark history with care and empathy. I read The Chocolate Maker’s Wife last year and adored that and when considered alongside The Darkest Shore, I’d have to say that Karen Brooks is now one of my favourite authors. I’ll be reading everything she releases from now on and will be making a point of reading her historical fiction back list as well. I can’t recommend this one highly enough, it’s a brilliant read.
Thanks is extended to HarperCollins Publishers Australia for providing me with a copy of The Darkest Shore for review.
February 1, 2020
‘Someone had to bear witness.’
In 1703, Sorcha McIntyre returns to her hometown of Pittenweem, on Scotland’s east coast. Pittenweem is a small fishing village, steeped in legend, tradition and superstition. Sorcha is a widow and a fishwife, whose defiance of custom will prove dangerous.
A young local lad falls ill. A victim of witchcraft, according to Reverend Cowper and some of the local villagers. In the ensuing hysteria, several women are named witches, imprisoned and tortured. The Reverend Cowper knows how to manipulate the situation, claiming to have right (and God) on his side.
What follows is an intense story, which is largely based on real events. Ms Brooks brings her characters to life: the circumstances and friendships of the fishwives are as much a part of the story as their fight for freedom. I kept reading, wanting the hysteria to abate. I kept reading, wanting to see justice for the accused women, wanting to see Reverend Cowper get his just deserts.
I read this novel twice. The first time, I read to find out how it would end. The second time, I paid more attention to the setting, to Ms Brooks’s depictions of character and place. I also appreciated the glossary and list of characters.
This is a compelling, dark work of historical fiction. Not comfortable, and a reminder of both the best and worst of human nature.
Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin HQ Fiction for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
In 1703, Sorcha McIntyre returns to her hometown of Pittenweem, on Scotland’s east coast. Pittenweem is a small fishing village, steeped in legend, tradition and superstition. Sorcha is a widow and a fishwife, whose defiance of custom will prove dangerous.
A young local lad falls ill. A victim of witchcraft, according to Reverend Cowper and some of the local villagers. In the ensuing hysteria, several women are named witches, imprisoned and tortured. The Reverend Cowper knows how to manipulate the situation, claiming to have right (and God) on his side.
What follows is an intense story, which is largely based on real events. Ms Brooks brings her characters to life: the circumstances and friendships of the fishwives are as much a part of the story as their fight for freedom. I kept reading, wanting the hysteria to abate. I kept reading, wanting to see justice for the accused women, wanting to see Reverend Cowper get his just deserts.
I read this novel twice. The first time, I read to find out how it would end. The second time, I paid more attention to the setting, to Ms Brooks’s depictions of character and place. I also appreciated the glossary and list of characters.
This is a compelling, dark work of historical fiction. Not comfortable, and a reminder of both the best and worst of human nature.
Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin HQ Fiction for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.
Jennifer Cameron-Smith
June 10, 2020
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
4.5 stars
'Wasn’t that what the fishwives were? Sisters of the sea.’Twas the sea and its siren call and the men whom they cleaved that made the sisters of all the fishwives, regardless of who their mothers were, where they hailed from, and whether their husbands, fathers or brothers were alive or dead. Once a fishwife, always a fishwife.’
Sometimes history turns dark corners. In The Darkest Shore, the latest novel from Karen Books, a group of women rebel against a harsh system and they pay a hefty price. Their story is moving, tragic, frustrating and inspiring. The Darkest Shore is yet another triumph from historical specialist Karen Brooks.
The Darkest Shore is a rich and multi layered story that takes the reader back in time to Scotland in the eighteenth century. In the coastal region of Pittenweem, we meet Sorcha McIntyre, a widow and a hardworking fishwife. Fighting for everyday survival and living independently, Sorcha is vulnerable to suspicion. With myths, legends and conspiracies dominating societal norms, it is an incredibly dangerous time to be a woman, especially a single woman. Sorcha knows she is different, some may consider her highly spirited, but this gets her into trouble. When rumors of witchcraft begin to circulate around the community of Pittenweem, victims are claimed. With a local reverend leading the charge, this tyrannical leader and his townsfolk rally together in their mission to stamp out any form of superstition brought about by witchcraft in their community. This is a harrowing and fearful time to be a fishwife and a member of the Pittenweem township. The Darkest Shore charts this fascinating, but grim time in our past.
A historically alluring and utterly engrossing read, The Darkest Shore plunges the reader in a well-heeled story of female independence, friendship, support networks, injustice and deep fear. Although it took me two attempts to read this novel from cover to cover (I wasn’t in the right mindset the first time I picked up the book), it definitely paid to persist. I was rewarded with a complex and convoluted story, which unfurled beautifully as I was immersed in the world of a common fishwife in eighteenth century Scotland. What a remarkable place and turning point in history!
Our guide for the breadth of The Darkest Shore is Sorcha McIntyre. We learn that Sorcha is a widow and a woman who works hard to make ends meet. Sorcha has the support of the other local fishwives in her community and she is an interesting soul. When one Pittenweem local is taken under suspicion for witchcraft by the local clergy, it sets in motion further suspicion, arrests and trials. These areas of the book are relayed by Brooks with vivid clarity. It proved to me that it was clearly a very dangerous time to be a woman, especially a woman with any kind of spirit. The sense of male power, the influence of religious beliefs, injustice and hardship is felt on all levels. This is an emotional sojourn and at times is hard to keep your feelings intact. However, the storytelling is simply marvelous, despite the sometimes bleak subject matter.
There are many resounding themes that gravitate around this set piece. From witchcraft, to life in 18th century Scotland, rules, norms, fables, myths, superstitions, economics, politics, religion, marriage and love practices are pulled apart by Brooks. The Darkest Shore proved to be an eye opening read. What struck me the most about this novel was the research base. Brooks’ Author’s Note, which extends over twelve pages, along with a glossary and a list of characters adds to the strong credibility of this novel. It also provides the reader with a sense of the sheer dedication the author has demonstrated to ensure that her book is historically precise. I found the Author’s Note almost as fascinating as the story itself, what a full and involving journey Karen Brooks has embarked upon to faithfully bring this story life. The helpful character list assists the reader in their journey through Pittenweem. While the glossary of terms, along with the Scottish vernacular inserted within the book contributes to the authenticity level of The Darkest Shore.
I studied witchcraft practices in Europe during my university studies and the opportunity to revisit this fascinating, but deadly time in our history books was a welcome experience. I feel I gleaned much more about the world of witchcraft, cultural norms and local superstition thanks to the excellent penmanship of Karen Brooks. With her innate ability to conjure up heartbreaking tales of the past, with a focus on the female experience, I wonder what Karen Brooks will be presenting her readers with next? I can’t wait!
*I wish to thank Harlequin Australia for providing me with a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Darkest Shore is book #66 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
4.5 stars
'Wasn’t that what the fishwives were? Sisters of the sea.’Twas the sea and its siren call and the men whom they cleaved that made the sisters of all the fishwives, regardless of who their mothers were, where they hailed from, and whether their husbands, fathers or brothers were alive or dead. Once a fishwife, always a fishwife.’
Sometimes history turns dark corners. In The Darkest Shore, the latest novel from Karen Books, a group of women rebel against a harsh system and they pay a hefty price. Their story is moving, tragic, frustrating and inspiring. The Darkest Shore is yet another triumph from historical specialist Karen Brooks.
The Darkest Shore is a rich and multi layered story that takes the reader back in time to Scotland in the eighteenth century. In the coastal region of Pittenweem, we meet Sorcha McIntyre, a widow and a hardworking fishwife. Fighting for everyday survival and living independently, Sorcha is vulnerable to suspicion. With myths, legends and conspiracies dominating societal norms, it is an incredibly dangerous time to be a woman, especially a single woman. Sorcha knows she is different, some may consider her highly spirited, but this gets her into trouble. When rumors of witchcraft begin to circulate around the community of Pittenweem, victims are claimed. With a local reverend leading the charge, this tyrannical leader and his townsfolk rally together in their mission to stamp out any form of superstition brought about by witchcraft in their community. This is a harrowing and fearful time to be a fishwife and a member of the Pittenweem township. The Darkest Shore charts this fascinating, but grim time in our past.
A historically alluring and utterly engrossing read, The Darkest Shore plunges the reader in a well-heeled story of female independence, friendship, support networks, injustice and deep fear. Although it took me two attempts to read this novel from cover to cover (I wasn’t in the right mindset the first time I picked up the book), it definitely paid to persist. I was rewarded with a complex and convoluted story, which unfurled beautifully as I was immersed in the world of a common fishwife in eighteenth century Scotland. What a remarkable place and turning point in history!
Our guide for the breadth of The Darkest Shore is Sorcha McIntyre. We learn that Sorcha is a widow and a woman who works hard to make ends meet. Sorcha has the support of the other local fishwives in her community and she is an interesting soul. When one Pittenweem local is taken under suspicion for witchcraft by the local clergy, it sets in motion further suspicion, arrests and trials. These areas of the book are relayed by Brooks with vivid clarity. It proved to me that it was clearly a very dangerous time to be a woman, especially a woman with any kind of spirit. The sense of male power, the influence of religious beliefs, injustice and hardship is felt on all levels. This is an emotional sojourn and at times is hard to keep your feelings intact. However, the storytelling is simply marvelous, despite the sometimes bleak subject matter.
There are many resounding themes that gravitate around this set piece. From witchcraft, to life in 18th century Scotland, rules, norms, fables, myths, superstitions, economics, politics, religion, marriage and love practices are pulled apart by Brooks. The Darkest Shore proved to be an eye opening read. What struck me the most about this novel was the research base. Brooks’ Author’s Note, which extends over twelve pages, along with a glossary and a list of characters adds to the strong credibility of this novel. It also provides the reader with a sense of the sheer dedication the author has demonstrated to ensure that her book is historically precise. I found the Author’s Note almost as fascinating as the story itself, what a full and involving journey Karen Brooks has embarked upon to faithfully bring this story life. The helpful character list assists the reader in their journey through Pittenweem. While the glossary of terms, along with the Scottish vernacular inserted within the book contributes to the authenticity level of The Darkest Shore.
I studied witchcraft practices in Europe during my university studies and the opportunity to revisit this fascinating, but deadly time in our history books was a welcome experience. I feel I gleaned much more about the world of witchcraft, cultural norms and local superstition thanks to the excellent penmanship of Karen Brooks. With her innate ability to conjure up heartbreaking tales of the past, with a focus on the female experience, I wonder what Karen Brooks will be presenting her readers with next? I can’t wait!
*I wish to thank Harlequin Australia for providing me with a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Darkest Shore is book #66 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
February 25, 2020
The Darkest Shore by Karen Brooks is a compelling, fascinating, and disturbing historical fiction novel inspired by true events.
“Twas the sea and its siren call and the men to whom they cleaved that made sisters of all the fishwives, regardless of who their mothers were, where they hailed from, and whether their husbands, fathers or brothers were alive or dead.”
The story begins on Hogmanay (New Years Eve) 1703 as Sorcha McIntyre returns home to Pittenweem, a small fishing village on the east coast of Scotland, after a fraught few months spent with her sister in St. Andrews. Despite a rude homecoming, Sorcha is happy to be back amongst her close friends, the fishwives of the ‘Weem, and quickly resettles into the rhythm of village life.
“He would put his mind to how to tame Sorcha McIntyre. Her and the rest of the fishwives.”
It’s not long however until the local minister, Patrick Cowper, who considers the independence of the fishwives and in particular Sorcha, an affront to God, takes advantage of an ill young man to turn the community against the women with accusations of witchcraft.
“All of them are wicked, wicked women, every last one of them.”
Drawing on a wide range of primary and secondary sources, (quotes from which chapter introductions are drawn), Brooks seamlessly blends historical detail with informed imagination to create a spellbinding story that explores the true events that occurred in Pittenweem, where seven women (and one man) were imprisoned and tortured after being accused of witchcraft.
While the true motives of the minister who led the persecution of the ‘Pittenweem Witches’ are unknown, Brooks offers an explanation that certainly seems plausible. Her portrayal of Cowper feels authentic (and frighteningly familiar) as he manipulates the Word of God to satisfy his lust for power and control, and to deflect his own personal shortcomings.
Sorcha is a young woman who has defied custom by circumstance. Both her parents are dead, her eldest brother is presumed to have been killed overseas while soldiering, and having been recently widowed, she is the sole owner of a large fishing vessel. The combination of her financial independence, her beauty, and her refusal to heed his demand that she remarry, are in part what infuriates Cowper and makes her a target of his rage.
Though Sorcha is a wholly fictional character, the other women (and one man) who also stand accused as witches in The Darkest Shore were once real people. Brooks breathes life into these tragic figures in a manner that I think honours the strength and dignity with which they seem to have faced Cowper’s vendetta in order to have survived it. The harrowing experiences of the accused, particularly at the hands of ‘The Pricker’ during their imprisonment, and the cruel fate that befell two of them, made for uncomfortable reading at times, more so when you are reminded that there is truth in their suffering.
Though there are many dark and troubling events depicted in the novel, there are also inspiring and heartening moments as the fishwives refuse to surrender hope, supporting and comforting one another as best they can through their prolonged ordeal. There is even a touch of romance when Sorcha finds a champion, and love, with an army Captain, and the ending (though Brooks admits it deviates from the official facts) is eminently satisfying.
Beautifully written, with authentic characterisation and vivid description, I found The Darkest Shore to be a captivating, even if sometimes confronting, read.
“Twas the sea and its siren call and the men to whom they cleaved that made sisters of all the fishwives, regardless of who their mothers were, where they hailed from, and whether their husbands, fathers or brothers were alive or dead.”
The story begins on Hogmanay (New Years Eve) 1703 as Sorcha McIntyre returns home to Pittenweem, a small fishing village on the east coast of Scotland, after a fraught few months spent with her sister in St. Andrews. Despite a rude homecoming, Sorcha is happy to be back amongst her close friends, the fishwives of the ‘Weem, and quickly resettles into the rhythm of village life.
“He would put his mind to how to tame Sorcha McIntyre. Her and the rest of the fishwives.”
It’s not long however until the local minister, Patrick Cowper, who considers the independence of the fishwives and in particular Sorcha, an affront to God, takes advantage of an ill young man to turn the community against the women with accusations of witchcraft.
“All of them are wicked, wicked women, every last one of them.”
Drawing on a wide range of primary and secondary sources, (quotes from which chapter introductions are drawn), Brooks seamlessly blends historical detail with informed imagination to create a spellbinding story that explores the true events that occurred in Pittenweem, where seven women (and one man) were imprisoned and tortured after being accused of witchcraft.
While the true motives of the minister who led the persecution of the ‘Pittenweem Witches’ are unknown, Brooks offers an explanation that certainly seems plausible. Her portrayal of Cowper feels authentic (and frighteningly familiar) as he manipulates the Word of God to satisfy his lust for power and control, and to deflect his own personal shortcomings.
Sorcha is a young woman who has defied custom by circumstance. Both her parents are dead, her eldest brother is presumed to have been killed overseas while soldiering, and having been recently widowed, she is the sole owner of a large fishing vessel. The combination of her financial independence, her beauty, and her refusal to heed his demand that she remarry, are in part what infuriates Cowper and makes her a target of his rage.
Though Sorcha is a wholly fictional character, the other women (and one man) who also stand accused as witches in The Darkest Shore were once real people. Brooks breathes life into these tragic figures in a manner that I think honours the strength and dignity with which they seem to have faced Cowper’s vendetta in order to have survived it. The harrowing experiences of the accused, particularly at the hands of ‘The Pricker’ during their imprisonment, and the cruel fate that befell two of them, made for uncomfortable reading at times, more so when you are reminded that there is truth in their suffering.
Though there are many dark and troubling events depicted in the novel, there are also inspiring and heartening moments as the fishwives refuse to surrender hope, supporting and comforting one another as best they can through their prolonged ordeal. There is even a touch of romance when Sorcha finds a champion, and love, with an army Captain, and the ending (though Brooks admits it deviates from the official facts) is eminently satisfying.
Beautifully written, with authentic characterisation and vivid description, I found The Darkest Shore to be a captivating, even if sometimes confronting, read.
April 2, 2020
Set in early 18th century Scotland this evocative tale retells an infamous and dark incident of history. The persecution of people but mainly women by men in authority who used superstition and mob mentality to exercise their own power. A slow moving story in parts however the reader will also feel a real sense of indignation and contempt for these supposed Godly men whose accusations of witchcraft will decimate the lives of these women and leave an lasting stain on a whole community.
The author's note at the end proves interesting reading on the differences between the actual events and how she chose to end the story on a more upbeat feeling.
3.5 stars
The author's note at the end proves interesting reading on the differences between the actual events and how she chose to end the story on a more upbeat feeling.
3.5 stars
April 21, 2020
- thanks to @harlequin for sending the book my way💕
I have always been super interested in reading about historical witch trials, especially novels inspired by real events. On this account, The Darkest Shore was a wise choice as the author has undoubtedly done an extensive research to write this book. There is an author's note at the end that thoroughly explains how certain characters were based on some of the people who were involved in the Pittenween witch trials of 1705.
Although historically, this book is a gem, I found myself struggling with it more often than not. The writing was atmospherically on point, but the narration itself was moving at such slow pace that I had to force myself to push through until the end. There were several scenes which did not contribute to anything in particular; nor any of the character's or the plot's development. I understand it is necessary to rely on descriptions to set the imagery. Still, I felt there were too many moments when nothing substantial was happening, that provoked my interest to waver constantly.
This story relies heavily on the female characters, but unfortunately, I wasn't able to connect with any of them. I was horrified by all the unspeakable things these women go through, but I was only horrified by these events because I wouldn't wish anyone anything like this, more than because I was worried about these characters in particular. Sorcha, the protagonist, was the only character easily identifiable, as all the other women are just a mish-mash in my head who I could never distinguish from each other due to the general shallowness of their personalities.
I also struggled with the Scottish dialect, which made my reading experience quite disruptive. However, I have to remark that, at the end of the day, this book is about friendship, courage, bravery and the unbelievable injustices women have had to endure from the beginning of times.
Overall, The Darkest Shore recounts the Pittenween witch trials in a profound, meticulous way. Personally, I would have loved a faster pace with a more in-depth characterisation, but I would recommend this book to any patient historical fiction lover.
I have always been super interested in reading about historical witch trials, especially novels inspired by real events. On this account, The Darkest Shore was a wise choice as the author has undoubtedly done an extensive research to write this book. There is an author's note at the end that thoroughly explains how certain characters were based on some of the people who were involved in the Pittenween witch trials of 1705.
Although historically, this book is a gem, I found myself struggling with it more often than not. The writing was atmospherically on point, but the narration itself was moving at such slow pace that I had to force myself to push through until the end. There were several scenes which did not contribute to anything in particular; nor any of the character's or the plot's development. I understand it is necessary to rely on descriptions to set the imagery. Still, I felt there were too many moments when nothing substantial was happening, that provoked my interest to waver constantly.
This story relies heavily on the female characters, but unfortunately, I wasn't able to connect with any of them. I was horrified by all the unspeakable things these women go through, but I was only horrified by these events because I wouldn't wish anyone anything like this, more than because I was worried about these characters in particular. Sorcha, the protagonist, was the only character easily identifiable, as all the other women are just a mish-mash in my head who I could never distinguish from each other due to the general shallowness of their personalities.
I also struggled with the Scottish dialect, which made my reading experience quite disruptive. However, I have to remark that, at the end of the day, this book is about friendship, courage, bravery and the unbelievable injustices women have had to endure from the beginning of times.
Overall, The Darkest Shore recounts the Pittenween witch trials in a profound, meticulous way. Personally, I would have loved a faster pace with a more in-depth characterisation, but I would recommend this book to any patient historical fiction lover.
April 30, 2020
“Above all, THE DARKEST SHORE is a love-letter to the fishwives and all other ‘wicked women’ out there, a tribute to strong, resourceful women whose boldness and courage, and that of their families and the men who stand by them, is cause for wonder, celebration and commemoration.” Karen Brooks about her book THE DARKEST SHORE
If you like books featuring courageous and strong female characters, then look no further. Karen Brooks’ love-letter to the fishwives, who feature prominently in this story – some based on real life characters and some who have sprung from the author’s own imagination – tells of a frightening and yet compelling episode in Scottish history: the Pittenweem witch trials. Set in the small fishing village of Pittenweem on the east coast of Scotland, the story centres around real life events that took part there in 1704, when five local women were accused of witchcraft, and another two women and a man named as accomplices as the result of a story told by a teenage boy. The events that follow will chill you to the core. It is a sign of Brooks’ talent as a writer that she was able to take dry facts gleamed from history books and spun them into a rich tale of courage and solidarity, as her brave fishwives face their accusers and battle to stay alive.
THE DARKEST SHORE brims with richly drawn, well-rounded characters that instantly transported me into 18th century Scotland. I love nothing better than an atmospheric setting, and the books delivered this in spades. As soon as I met the group of fishwives, those brave, fearless women who are as resourceful as they are resilient in the absence of their men at sea, and who look out for one another even if it puts their own lives in danger, I was fully invested in their fates. It is no surprise then that I also took an instant dislike to the minister at the heart of the crisis, a narcissistic fanatic, who unfortunately wields a great deal of power in the village. Let one of the fishwife’s own words speak for themselves:
They are not easily cowered, those fishwives, so it is easy to see how they posed a threat to the social order at the time, especially to the men of the cloth, the religious leaders who imposed strict rules on villages and exerted a massive amount of power. If Brooks thinks of the fishwives as “life-affirming and bold” (in her own words), then she really managed to let these qualities shine through in her characters.
In summary, THE DARKEST SHORE is a story that not only tells of a dark but fascinating chapter in Scottish history, but also offers us a glimpse into the lives of Scottish fishwives, a bunch of strong, courageous and independent women who are true role models for women everywhere. With such a rich cast of strong and intriguing characters and an atmospheric Scottish setting that made the perfect backdrop for a thrilling and chilling read, the book was a pleasure to read from beginning to end. One of the most intriguing and well researched historical fiction books I have read. Highly recommended!
Thank you to HQ Fiction for the free copy of this novel and for giving me the opportunity to provide an honest review.
If you like books featuring courageous and strong female characters, then look no further. Karen Brooks’ love-letter to the fishwives, who feature prominently in this story – some based on real life characters and some who have sprung from the author’s own imagination – tells of a frightening and yet compelling episode in Scottish history: the Pittenweem witch trials. Set in the small fishing village of Pittenweem on the east coast of Scotland, the story centres around real life events that took part there in 1704, when five local women were accused of witchcraft, and another two women and a man named as accomplices as the result of a story told by a teenage boy. The events that follow will chill you to the core. It is a sign of Brooks’ talent as a writer that she was able to take dry facts gleamed from history books and spun them into a rich tale of courage and solidarity, as her brave fishwives face their accusers and battle to stay alive.
THE DARKEST SHORE brims with richly drawn, well-rounded characters that instantly transported me into 18th century Scotland. I love nothing better than an atmospheric setting, and the books delivered this in spades. As soon as I met the group of fishwives, those brave, fearless women who are as resourceful as they are resilient in the absence of their men at sea, and who look out for one another even if it puts their own lives in danger, I was fully invested in their fates. It is no surprise then that I also took an instant dislike to the minister at the heart of the crisis, a narcissistic fanatic, who unfortunately wields a great deal of power in the village. Let one of the fishwife’s own words speak for themselves:
“Do you hear that, God? You have chosen poorly, Sir, and need to rethink whom you allow to speak on your behalf. They’re letting you down, these men. They pretend a consideration they don’t feel; they lie and cheat and call it your will.”
They are not easily cowered, those fishwives, so it is easy to see how they posed a threat to the social order at the time, especially to the men of the cloth, the religious leaders who imposed strict rules on villages and exerted a massive amount of power. If Brooks thinks of the fishwives as “life-affirming and bold” (in her own words), then she really managed to let these qualities shine through in her characters.
In summary, THE DARKEST SHORE is a story that not only tells of a dark but fascinating chapter in Scottish history, but also offers us a glimpse into the lives of Scottish fishwives, a bunch of strong, courageous and independent women who are true role models for women everywhere. With such a rich cast of strong and intriguing characters and an atmospheric Scottish setting that made the perfect backdrop for a thrilling and chilling read, the book was a pleasure to read from beginning to end. One of the most intriguing and well researched historical fiction books I have read. Highly recommended!
Thank you to HQ Fiction for the free copy of this novel and for giving me the opportunity to provide an honest review.
July 22, 2020
The Darkest Shore by Karen Brooks is a story set in the town of Pittenweem in Scotland named for its witches and witchcraft.
It's historical fiction based on true events some of which may disturb you as it's a dark and brooding tale.
It's set in a fishing village by the sea where fish abound.
The location is the perfect setting for this witches and fishwives tale.
Isle of May in the distance with a light that shines and twirls brightly over the moonlit ocean.
You'll ride on stormy seas and enjoy the setting of the Scottish coast where seals and puffins play.
Make sure you pour yourself a little Drambuie as you venture into this stormy, dark and brewing witches tale!
Another great story and tale by writer, Karen Brooks.
It's historical fiction based on true events some of which may disturb you as it's a dark and brooding tale.
It's set in a fishing village by the sea where fish abound.
The location is the perfect setting for this witches and fishwives tale.
Isle of May in the distance with a light that shines and twirls brightly over the moonlit ocean.
You'll ride on stormy seas and enjoy the setting of the Scottish coast where seals and puffins play.
Make sure you pour yourself a little Drambuie as you venture into this stormy, dark and brewing witches tale!
Another great story and tale by writer, Karen Brooks.
March 19, 2021
Much time and dedicated research here for which Karen Brooks must be lauded, and on a topic which I enjoy. Yet I couldn’t help but feel that the book was as drawn out as the inclement Scottish weather. I was disappointed to remain relatively unmoved throughout the majority of the book. The character of the priest was all black, with not a glimmer of gold in his heart. More believable had we been shown at least a zephyr of goodness if only in passing. Nor did the beguiling ‘Sea Witch’ draw me to her as she should. I was gratified with an ending that moistened the eyes, but I would not tramp through those pages for a second time.
March 19, 2022
I won this book in a contest and I am very pleased that I did.
I loved 'The Darkest Shore' it's a keeper on my bookshelf. Karen Brooks is that magical person, a born storyteller, and with her very detailed research she brings to life the history of witches when 'the independent women of eighteenth-century Scotland fight a witch hunt and male fury in a battle for survival and freedom in a story based on true events'. Karen Brooks is both historian and novelist but her research rests lightly in the novel and she brings to life the wild east coast of Scotland, 1703.
I've read two books by Karen Brooks. I'll search out her backlist and I look forward to her next novel. I highly recommend 'The Darkest Shore.
I loved 'The Darkest Shore' it's a keeper on my bookshelf. Karen Brooks is that magical person, a born storyteller, and with her very detailed research she brings to life the history of witches when 'the independent women of eighteenth-century Scotland fight a witch hunt and male fury in a battle for survival and freedom in a story based on true events'. Karen Brooks is both historian and novelist but her research rests lightly in the novel and she brings to life the wild east coast of Scotland, 1703.
I've read two books by Karen Brooks. I'll search out her backlist and I look forward to her next novel. I highly recommend 'The Darkest Shore.
April 16, 2020
This book had my name written all over it! A historical novel set in my fav time period of 1704/05 and in Scotland as well, which is one of my fav settings!!! Yay! I couldn’t wait to dive right in. Australian author Karen Brooks has presented an amazingly well researched, captivating book. Based on true events, this book is about a lot of things, friendship, family, loyalty but so much more as well, imprisonment, injustice and brutal torture! I will admit sometimes I just found it hard to pick the book up worrying about what else could happen to these women accused of witchery. All in all though Karen has created a very atmospheric book (you can virtually feel the sea spray coming off the coast!) this book will stay with me for a long time to come!
July 2, 2020
This is quite dark with the imprisonment and torture of the supposed witches but the character of the reverend really takes the cake.
I'd had given it 5 stars but it ended too sweetly for me with all the characters getting their happily ever after
I'd had given it 5 stars but it ended too sweetly for me with all the characters getting their happily ever after
May 3, 2020
3.5*
I have read and enjoyed two Karen Brooks novels before and they have been exceptional. I was therefore eager to try her latest - a tale of witch hunts in eighteenth century Scotland.
This gripping and confrontational tale revolves around a group of women - fishwives - who are accused of being witches. There is a great deal of research that has gone into this fictional adaptation. Based on a true story this is a shocking truth and extremely cruel occurrence. In a world dominated by men and religion, these women come together and exemplify everything that embodies the word ‘friendship’. Add into the mix superstition and a clergy out for revenge and it is hard to believe that much of this story is true! These women fight to save their lives and the torture they endured can only be described as horrific.
‘Listening to the reverend, Sorcha marvelled that this man of God, who should be alleviating people’s fears, was exacerbating them. When he should be encouraging unity, he was fostering discord and suspicion. How was this helping the town? It wasn’t. It was destroying it.’
Karen has done an incredible job of not only researching the trials themselves but capturing the time and place of Scotland during this period. The best part I believe, however, is her detailed characterisations. As she states, “I hope that this book, while dark and harrowing in parts, is understood as I intend it—not only to showcase female friendship, the great bonds and love that can exist between good and decent men and women, even when all about them is unravelling, but also to honour the community of Pittenweem and especially those who fell during these bleak and terrible times.”. The author’s note at the conclusion is most insightful after such a read.
‘... slowly, carefully, she embraced the woman. She smelled of musty old caves, fear and hunger. Of nightmares and endless days of loneliness. She smelled of defiance.’
Despite all of this, I did struggle at times. There were parts of the book that seem overly drawn out and the reader needs to be patient and persevere to learn of this desperate time in history for women. This tale is so dark and difficult to read at times simply because of the material - it really is confrontational. Although uncomfortable and challenging, it shines a light on both the good and bad to be found in human natures.
‘There was something not quite right about someone who could inflict that level of pain on another human being, divest a woman of her robes without blinking a cold eye nor show any emotion as he pawed her flesh, pulled and searched… Searched, my arse. It was as if his soul had been dislodged or evaporated altogether. And they called her a witch.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
I have read and enjoyed two Karen Brooks novels before and they have been exceptional. I was therefore eager to try her latest - a tale of witch hunts in eighteenth century Scotland.
This gripping and confrontational tale revolves around a group of women - fishwives - who are accused of being witches. There is a great deal of research that has gone into this fictional adaptation. Based on a true story this is a shocking truth and extremely cruel occurrence. In a world dominated by men and religion, these women come together and exemplify everything that embodies the word ‘friendship’. Add into the mix superstition and a clergy out for revenge and it is hard to believe that much of this story is true! These women fight to save their lives and the torture they endured can only be described as horrific.
‘Listening to the reverend, Sorcha marvelled that this man of God, who should be alleviating people’s fears, was exacerbating them. When he should be encouraging unity, he was fostering discord and suspicion. How was this helping the town? It wasn’t. It was destroying it.’
Karen has done an incredible job of not only researching the trials themselves but capturing the time and place of Scotland during this period. The best part I believe, however, is her detailed characterisations. As she states, “I hope that this book, while dark and harrowing in parts, is understood as I intend it—not only to showcase female friendship, the great bonds and love that can exist between good and decent men and women, even when all about them is unravelling, but also to honour the community of Pittenweem and especially those who fell during these bleak and terrible times.”. The author’s note at the conclusion is most insightful after such a read.
‘... slowly, carefully, she embraced the woman. She smelled of musty old caves, fear and hunger. Of nightmares and endless days of loneliness. She smelled of defiance.’
Despite all of this, I did struggle at times. There were parts of the book that seem overly drawn out and the reader needs to be patient and persevere to learn of this desperate time in history for women. This tale is so dark and difficult to read at times simply because of the material - it really is confrontational. Although uncomfortable and challenging, it shines a light on both the good and bad to be found in human natures.
‘There was something not quite right about someone who could inflict that level of pain on another human being, divest a woman of her robes without blinking a cold eye nor show any emotion as he pawed her flesh, pulled and searched… Searched, my arse. It was as if his soul had been dislodged or evaporated altogether. And they called her a witch.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
April 3, 2020
Great historical fiction based on true events of how women were treated long ago. So well researched and compelling reading! I read in 4D these days! Whilst reading this book, I listened to Celtic music & ocean sounds, googled everything and used Google maps to 'walk' around Pittenweem's harbour, streets, church, cemetary, Tolbooth and actually go inside St Fillan's Cave where the witches were imprisoned 300 years ago. Full immersion! LOL I think I was there in a past life! Well done, Karen! Great story telling!!!
March 29, 2025
The Darkest Shore by Karen Brooks messed with my head—and my heart—in the best kind of way. Set in this tiny, wind-battered Scottish town in 1703, the story follows Sorcha McIntyre, a tough, no-nonsense widow who comes home hoping for peace but ends up smack in the middle of a nightmare: a full-blown witch hunt. And not the metaphorical kind—the real, horrifying kind where women are tortured because someone decided they looked at a fish the wrong way. What really hit me was the sisterhood. The fishwives? Absolute legends. You can feel their grit, their loyalty, their heartbreak. Brooks paints this eerie, claustrophobic world so well that you can almost hear the waves crashing and the whispers turning to accusations. That said, the book’s a slow burn—sometimes too slow—and Reverend Cowper? The man reads like a cartoon villain in human skin. Still, even with its flaws, the story grabs you by the collar and makes you feel things. It made me angry, sad, hopeful, and kind of in awe. Not perfect, but man, it sticks with you. A gritty, emotional 3.5 out of 5.
March 4, 2020
1703 Scotland:- Sorcha McIntyre returns to her cottage in Pittenweem after spending time away at the home of her sister. She left Pittenweem originally to mourn the death of her husband and young son.
On her return Sorcha is reminded of the small mindedness of the locals and suspicions regarding fish wives such as herself being the source of witchcraft, and when a young lad appears to have been cursed, the Reverend Cowper, a thorn in Sorcha’s side from way back, is determined to bring about the ridding the town of all the fish wives ie witches, including Sorcha.
Cowper is a despicable character (reminding me somewhat of a Sheriff of Nottingham-type character) . Manipulative and calculating whilst totally self-serving.
This book is based in a true story in history, although Sorcha’s character is fictional. She is a fierce, independent young woman, loyal and honest to a fault. Its a tale of the strength of the human spirit, of friendship and love throughout the most horrific set of circumstances. It is brutal and honest but written with such historical detail, the issues seem current and the characters are close to your heart. Superstition, the church, a zealot with a thirst for power, and a true gentleman all feature in what is an exceptional historical novel.
Upon starting this 500+ pages I did wonder how long it was going to take me to read. The answer, not long when it’s such a fantastic read. I can’t recommend this book highly enough.
Props to Australian author Karen Brooks for this wonderful book. Thank you to Harper Collins Australia and Harlequin Books Australia for providing me with a copy of the book to review. My opinions are genuine and my own.
This review has been posted to my Instagram page @aplace_inthesun.
On her return Sorcha is reminded of the small mindedness of the locals and suspicions regarding fish wives such as herself being the source of witchcraft, and when a young lad appears to have been cursed, the Reverend Cowper, a thorn in Sorcha’s side from way back, is determined to bring about the ridding the town of all the fish wives ie witches, including Sorcha.
Cowper is a despicable character (reminding me somewhat of a Sheriff of Nottingham-type character) . Manipulative and calculating whilst totally self-serving.
This book is based in a true story in history, although Sorcha’s character is fictional. She is a fierce, independent young woman, loyal and honest to a fault. Its a tale of the strength of the human spirit, of friendship and love throughout the most horrific set of circumstances. It is brutal and honest but written with such historical detail, the issues seem current and the characters are close to your heart. Superstition, the church, a zealot with a thirst for power, and a true gentleman all feature in what is an exceptional historical novel.
Upon starting this 500+ pages I did wonder how long it was going to take me to read. The answer, not long when it’s such a fantastic read. I can’t recommend this book highly enough.
Props to Australian author Karen Brooks for this wonderful book. Thank you to Harper Collins Australia and Harlequin Books Australia for providing me with a copy of the book to review. My opinions are genuine and my own.
This review has been posted to my Instagram page @aplace_inthesun.
March 23, 2023
Wow, where do I start with this terrible book?
So many times whilst reading I stopped and thought: ‘I can’t do this.’ Nevertheless, I persisted, to my detriment.
I listened to the audiobook, which was 16 hours long, and I have to ask: WHY? Aside from a couple of moments of ‘drama’, NOTHING happened.
I’ve seen a lot of people say the writing is atmospheric. I’d argue it’s clumsy purple prose. Anyone who earnestly describes eyes as ‘limpid’ or a voice as ‘dulcet’ is a lazy writer.
I honestly didn’t give a toss about any of the characters. Sorcha is a Disney princess. Aidan Ross is a thinly veiled Poldark insert. Reverend Couper is an irredeemable villain, and everyone else is filler.
Now let’s discuss the RIDICULOUS finale. Spoilers ahead, if you care.
Reverend Couper finally takes Sorcha unawares (as she’s standing on the end of the crumbling pier, in the middle of a violent storm, arms raised and singing in Norwegian - for someone with the reputation of a ‘Sea Witch’ she’s painfully lacking in self-awareness) and knocks her out. He ties her up on the deck of a nearby wrecked ship and ‘dunks’ her in the sea multiple times by way of a rope around her waist. Horrific, right? I mean, it should have been, but I was too busy stopping my eyes rolling right out of my skull.
Sorcha is dunked into the sea for minutes at a time, each time for longer. This woman should be half-drowned after the first couple of dunkings, but not only does she manage to sass the Reverend every time he hoists her out, she cuts her bonds on some convenient barnacles and swims to a nearby boat, where she hauls herself out, nimbly leaps back onto the deck of the shipwreck, and finds a convenient iron bar to hit the Rev with. At this point I was waiting for the old bait and switch - is she ACTUALLY a witch? If I were the author, that’s the direction I would have gone in. But no, she’s just that perfect, she doesn’t need air, or for her blood to stay in her body, apparently.
There’s the final inevitable showdown where Revvy Coups falls into the sea and Sorcha tries nobly to save him, but alas he dies. But it’s ok because the rest of the town saw her heroic efforts and decides she’s their new fave person and no one wants to kill her for being a witch anymore. YAY! All her friends are immediately pardoned too, of course.
Aidan returns from the war completely unscathed, and miraculously, he has Sorcha’s missing-presumed-dead brother in tow, who is now conveniently a man of the cloth and can immediately step into the recently vacated shoes of the Reverend. Perfect! Sorcha and Aidan get married and they have a baby on the way, how lovely! Everyone is so happy and nothing is bad anymore, which is definitely how things really happened for women accused of witchcraft in the 1700s. There’s a literal rainbow. The end!
Honestly I can’t remember the last time I read a book so bad.
P.S. Sorcha is almost raped multiple times, of course, because what’s a novel with a female protagonist without a little SA for spice?
So many times whilst reading I stopped and thought: ‘I can’t do this.’ Nevertheless, I persisted, to my detriment.
I listened to the audiobook, which was 16 hours long, and I have to ask: WHY? Aside from a couple of moments of ‘drama’, NOTHING happened.
I’ve seen a lot of people say the writing is atmospheric. I’d argue it’s clumsy purple prose. Anyone who earnestly describes eyes as ‘limpid’ or a voice as ‘dulcet’ is a lazy writer.
I honestly didn’t give a toss about any of the characters. Sorcha is a Disney princess. Aidan Ross is a thinly veiled Poldark insert. Reverend Couper is an irredeemable villain, and everyone else is filler.
Now let’s discuss the RIDICULOUS finale. Spoilers ahead, if you care.
Reverend Couper finally takes Sorcha unawares (as she’s standing on the end of the crumbling pier, in the middle of a violent storm, arms raised and singing in Norwegian - for someone with the reputation of a ‘Sea Witch’ she’s painfully lacking in self-awareness) and knocks her out. He ties her up on the deck of a nearby wrecked ship and ‘dunks’ her in the sea multiple times by way of a rope around her waist. Horrific, right? I mean, it should have been, but I was too busy stopping my eyes rolling right out of my skull.
Sorcha is dunked into the sea for minutes at a time, each time for longer. This woman should be half-drowned after the first couple of dunkings, but not only does she manage to sass the Reverend every time he hoists her out, she cuts her bonds on some convenient barnacles and swims to a nearby boat, where she hauls herself out, nimbly leaps back onto the deck of the shipwreck, and finds a convenient iron bar to hit the Rev with. At this point I was waiting for the old bait and switch - is she ACTUALLY a witch? If I were the author, that’s the direction I would have gone in. But no, she’s just that perfect, she doesn’t need air, or for her blood to stay in her body, apparently.
There’s the final inevitable showdown where Revvy Coups falls into the sea and Sorcha tries nobly to save him, but alas he dies. But it’s ok because the rest of the town saw her heroic efforts and decides she’s their new fave person and no one wants to kill her for being a witch anymore. YAY! All her friends are immediately pardoned too, of course.
Aidan returns from the war completely unscathed, and miraculously, he has Sorcha’s missing-presumed-dead brother in tow, who is now conveniently a man of the cloth and can immediately step into the recently vacated shoes of the Reverend. Perfect! Sorcha and Aidan get married and they have a baby on the way, how lovely! Everyone is so happy and nothing is bad anymore, which is definitely how things really happened for women accused of witchcraft in the 1700s. There’s a literal rainbow. The end!
Honestly I can’t remember the last time I read a book so bad.
P.S. Sorcha is almost raped multiple times, of course, because what’s a novel with a female protagonist without a little SA for spice?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 24, 2020
4.5/5
This is a story based on true events. It is essentially about the imprisonment and torture of a group of women falsely accused of witchcraft.
This story is very dark but also intensely riveting. I couldn’t put it down! I binge read the last 70% in a day. The author has done a fantastic job in creating an authentic and tense atmosphere. The setting is richly detailed without being belabored and feels like it’s own character.
The author has done an exceptional job at creating interesting and well rounded characters. I particularly enjoyed the friendships between the women. It was lovely to see strong female characters with equally strong friendships. And there is also a ‘Joffrey-esq’ character that you just want to repeatedly punch in the face - in a really good way though. It’s a testament to good story telling when you want a character to get their comeuppance so forking badly.
There is also a love interest for the main character but it’s firmly in the background to the rest of the story. The only reason this didn’t get 5 stars was because the relationship felt a bit insta lovey in the beginning and there is a sex scene that could have been toned down. It just felt a little out of place in the overall story. That being said I came to really love Sorcha and Aidan’s relationship by the end.
Thank you to Harlequin Australia and NetGalley for providing me a copy of this title to review!
This is a story based on true events. It is essentially about the imprisonment and torture of a group of women falsely accused of witchcraft.
This story is very dark but also intensely riveting. I couldn’t put it down! I binge read the last 70% in a day. The author has done a fantastic job in creating an authentic and tense atmosphere. The setting is richly detailed without being belabored and feels like it’s own character.
The author has done an exceptional job at creating interesting and well rounded characters. I particularly enjoyed the friendships between the women. It was lovely to see strong female characters with equally strong friendships. And there is also a ‘Joffrey-esq’ character that you just want to repeatedly punch in the face - in a really good way though. It’s a testament to good story telling when you want a character to get their comeuppance so forking badly.
There is also a love interest for the main character but it’s firmly in the background to the rest of the story. The only reason this didn’t get 5 stars was because the relationship felt a bit insta lovey in the beginning and there is a sex scene that could have been toned down. It just felt a little out of place in the overall story. That being said I came to really love Sorcha and Aidan’s relationship by the end.
Thank you to Harlequin Australia and NetGalley for providing me a copy of this title to review!
June 8, 2024
“In no other place in Scotland were witches hunted with such fervour as in Pittenweem”.
The Darkest Shore is a historical fiction based on the true events of the witch trials in Pittenweem, Scotland in the 18th Century. Like all Karen Brooks novels, this was very well researched and very detailed. Given that Brooks is a historian as well as novelist, this comes as no surprise. It’s quite a large book that did tend to read at a slow pace but was packed with intrigue and atmosphere (always love a Scottish setting).
The characters are a mix of real people in history and fiction, but the bonds and friendships that Karen Brooks has written felt so genuine and heartfelt. You really feel for these characters and all they endure over the course of this story.
If you’re a fan of dark historical fiction, exceptional storytelling and lovely Scottish seaside settings then you definitely need to pick up The Darkest Shore.
Thank you HarperCollins/Harlequin for providing me with a copy to review.
The Darkest Shore is a historical fiction based on the true events of the witch trials in Pittenweem, Scotland in the 18th Century. Like all Karen Brooks novels, this was very well researched and very detailed. Given that Brooks is a historian as well as novelist, this comes as no surprise. It’s quite a large book that did tend to read at a slow pace but was packed with intrigue and atmosphere (always love a Scottish setting).
The characters are a mix of real people in history and fiction, but the bonds and friendships that Karen Brooks has written felt so genuine and heartfelt. You really feel for these characters and all they endure over the course of this story.
If you’re a fan of dark historical fiction, exceptional storytelling and lovely Scottish seaside settings then you definitely need to pick up The Darkest Shore.
Thank you HarperCollins/Harlequin for providing me with a copy to review.
May 21, 2020
Absolutely loved this beautiful story of women’s strength and friendship set in the early 18th century. Full RTC but I will definitely be reading Karen’s next book!
May 18, 2020
For me this was a book that I found hard to get into at the beginning, but when I did I didn’t want to put it down, the research that went into this book to tell the story of witch hunts in Pittenween back in the 1700’s was amazing and it is based on a true happening with extra characters added that made this one a story that had me getting emotionally involved and so many emotions, sadness, anger and the ending had me smiling.
It is 1703 in the village of Pittenween on the coast of Scotland and Sorcha McIntyre has just returned to her home she is one of the fishwives and widowed and her and her friends Nettie, Nicholas, Janet, Isobel and Beatrix work hard to earn money to put food on the table, they are strong woman and honest and would do anything for each other.
When one of the young men in the village falls ill and witchcraft is suspected Reverend Cowper starts a witch hunt that will change the lives of the fishwives, it will push them to the limits but together no matter what cruel punishment is doled out to them they stay strong.
Captain Aiden Ross is in charge of the soldiers billeted in the village he is a caring man and finds himself drawn to Sorcha and when the fishwives are captured and tortured as witches Aiden does what he can to help and this puts the Reverend off side, the Reverend’ sermons incite the villagers and the incomers that have come to be there while the witches are supposedly put to trial, this caused even more hurt and pain for the women and man accused of being witches.
This story is heart-wrenching and beautiful at the same time and I am sure that MS Brooks would have been emotionally exhausted after the research and then writing this story, that she has done so well, I do highly recommend this book but yes there are very cruel and violent moments throughout but the strength that these woman show lifted the spirits of myself and then the ending was beautiful the joy and happiness. I honestly went through many emotions reading this one, thank you MS Brooks.
It is 1703 in the village of Pittenween on the coast of Scotland and Sorcha McIntyre has just returned to her home she is one of the fishwives and widowed and her and her friends Nettie, Nicholas, Janet, Isobel and Beatrix work hard to earn money to put food on the table, they are strong woman and honest and would do anything for each other.
When one of the young men in the village falls ill and witchcraft is suspected Reverend Cowper starts a witch hunt that will change the lives of the fishwives, it will push them to the limits but together no matter what cruel punishment is doled out to them they stay strong.
Captain Aiden Ross is in charge of the soldiers billeted in the village he is a caring man and finds himself drawn to Sorcha and when the fishwives are captured and tortured as witches Aiden does what he can to help and this puts the Reverend off side, the Reverend’ sermons incite the villagers and the incomers that have come to be there while the witches are supposedly put to trial, this caused even more hurt and pain for the women and man accused of being witches.
This story is heart-wrenching and beautiful at the same time and I am sure that MS Brooks would have been emotionally exhausted after the research and then writing this story, that she has done so well, I do highly recommend this book but yes there are very cruel and violent moments throughout but the strength that these woman show lifted the spirits of myself and then the ending was beautiful the joy and happiness. I honestly went through many emotions reading this one, thank you MS Brooks.
April 28, 2020
This book made me want to visit Pittenweem. The intense and dramatic Fife coast, in my mind, was as bewitching as any of the characters in the book; I find this often happens in novels with a Scottish setting- the sense of place eclipses, yet enhances, the rest of the story. By the end of this novel, I felt a real affection for ‘The Weem’ …it feels like a home I’ve never visited.
The Darkest Shore is a celebration of female friendship and resilience. A study of superstition, religion, and gossip in an insular town. It is based on real historical events taking place in Scotland between 1703 &1705- one of which is particularly awful. There are some pretty detailed descriptions of torture in the novel, which can be hard to stomach- it was hard to be a woman in the 18th Century, that’s for sure!!
The author’s note succeeding the story is a delight to read, separating fact from fiction and sharing some of the resources she used to research and create the story. I’ll certainly be using some of the resources to learn more about the fishwives/herring lasses in my spare time.
I’m not a fan of romantic storylines, and this book has one, but it’s used well enough- as a device to explore the characters and the lives of women in this time. I do love that this novel gives a new voice and experience to women lost long ago in some very unfair circumstances.
“Waves that matched the oorlich palette of the sky thundered against the crescent-shaped shore and it’s stone-walled harbour, sending curtains of wash over the ruined pier, drenching the men who scrambled along it in their hob-nailed boots. As she’d suspected, not even the lure of Hogamanay kept them from work. Errant beams of afternoon sunlight pierced the thick canopy of clouds, spears of defiance that cast a holy light upon the scene. Sorcha could almost believe that God himself was welcoming her back”
The Darkest Shore is a celebration of female friendship and resilience. A study of superstition, religion, and gossip in an insular town. It is based on real historical events taking place in Scotland between 1703 &1705- one of which is particularly awful. There are some pretty detailed descriptions of torture in the novel, which can be hard to stomach- it was hard to be a woman in the 18th Century, that’s for sure!!
The author’s note succeeding the story is a delight to read, separating fact from fiction and sharing some of the resources she used to research and create the story. I’ll certainly be using some of the resources to learn more about the fishwives/herring lasses in my spare time.
I’m not a fan of romantic storylines, and this book has one, but it’s used well enough- as a device to explore the characters and the lives of women in this time. I do love that this novel gives a new voice and experience to women lost long ago in some very unfair circumstances.
“Waves that matched the oorlich palette of the sky thundered against the crescent-shaped shore and it’s stone-walled harbour, sending curtains of wash over the ruined pier, drenching the men who scrambled along it in their hob-nailed boots. As she’d suspected, not even the lure of Hogamanay kept them from work. Errant beams of afternoon sunlight pierced the thick canopy of clouds, spears of defiance that cast a holy light upon the scene. Sorcha could almost believe that God himself was welcoming her back”
April 25, 2021
3.75 ⭐️
Sorcha McIntyre is not in a good place. Her husband and baby are dead and her sister has just kicked her out. With no choice but to return to her hometown of Pittenweem on the east Coast of Scotland, this fishwife knows that life won’t be easy and that very few will be happy to see her back, for in 1703 independent women who don’t know their place breed superstition and accusations of witchcraft.
No one is more displeased about Sorcha’s return than Reverend Cowper. She knows his darkest secret and he will stop at nothing to see her gone. When Peter Morton’s medical condition cannot be diagnosed, the Reverend declares it an act of witchcraft and now has the perfect excuse to charge and imprison Sorcha and her fishwife friends. As he eagerly awaits the opportunity to try them for witchcraft away from Edinburgh; it becomes clear that the Reverend will stop at nothing to see them burn. Can Captain Ross ensure the fishwives receive a fair trial or will the wrath of the Reverend as ‘God’s servant’ see evil triumph over good?
The Darkest Shore by Karen Brooks is a work of fiction that is based on true events of the real Pittenweem fishwives who were accused of witchcraft, which makes for a compelling read in the historical fiction genre. Whilst the real life events made for an excellent fictional plot, it was on occasion let down by verbose chunks of writing that added nothing but were obviously included to refer to an event that Brooks had come across in the research that she’s clearly undertaken; which is a pet hate of mine. Having said that; apart from these instances of verbose content, the plot was otherwise interesting and informative and the writing engaging.
The characters made the book for me. There are plenty to both love and that you will love to hate; but they are all well crafted, interesting and typical of the early 1700s. Brooks wrote them so well that they were easy to visualise as they went about their business, which is always appreciated by me.
Fans of historical fiction, Scottish history, witches and witchcraft will no doubt enjoy The Darkest Shore. It’s not a quick read but one worth adding to your TBR pile.
To play along with my book bingo and to see what else I’m reading, go to #ktbookbingo and @kt_elder on Instagram.
Sorcha McIntyre is not in a good place. Her husband and baby are dead and her sister has just kicked her out. With no choice but to return to her hometown of Pittenweem on the east Coast of Scotland, this fishwife knows that life won’t be easy and that very few will be happy to see her back, for in 1703 independent women who don’t know their place breed superstition and accusations of witchcraft.
No one is more displeased about Sorcha’s return than Reverend Cowper. She knows his darkest secret and he will stop at nothing to see her gone. When Peter Morton’s medical condition cannot be diagnosed, the Reverend declares it an act of witchcraft and now has the perfect excuse to charge and imprison Sorcha and her fishwife friends. As he eagerly awaits the opportunity to try them for witchcraft away from Edinburgh; it becomes clear that the Reverend will stop at nothing to see them burn. Can Captain Ross ensure the fishwives receive a fair trial or will the wrath of the Reverend as ‘God’s servant’ see evil triumph over good?
The Darkest Shore by Karen Brooks is a work of fiction that is based on true events of the real Pittenweem fishwives who were accused of witchcraft, which makes for a compelling read in the historical fiction genre. Whilst the real life events made for an excellent fictional plot, it was on occasion let down by verbose chunks of writing that added nothing but were obviously included to refer to an event that Brooks had come across in the research that she’s clearly undertaken; which is a pet hate of mine. Having said that; apart from these instances of verbose content, the plot was otherwise interesting and informative and the writing engaging.
The characters made the book for me. There are plenty to both love and that you will love to hate; but they are all well crafted, interesting and typical of the early 1700s. Brooks wrote them so well that they were easy to visualise as they went about their business, which is always appreciated by me.
Fans of historical fiction, Scottish history, witches and witchcraft will no doubt enjoy The Darkest Shore. It’s not a quick read but one worth adding to your TBR pile.
To play along with my book bingo and to see what else I’m reading, go to #ktbookbingo and @kt_elder on Instagram.
December 1, 2023
Interesting yet distressing to read, it is far too long with too much detail; slow paced for half of plot, at least.
Like author, Fiona McIntosh, every researched aspect of their historical stories are included; in mixing fact with fiction. Further editing is required; some punctuation and dialogue was annoying at times. Some scenes were not necessary and there were far too many characters.
All of the above detracts somewhat and one can easily become disengaged. However, the idea and era, setting and atmospheric imagery was well described.
Thus, this dark, passionate, treacherous and torturous (emotional, physical, spiritual etc), early 18th century tale of witchcraft woes in a Scottish fishing village, the 'Weem', holds the reader from the start. But it plodded along in Part One, up until the Tollbooth tortures began.....and kept going, and going, which took far too much effort to stay focussed. Gruesome!
Indeed, with accusations and superstition put upon the independent and strong-knitted female workers, the fishwives, and it's consequential divisiveness, imprisonment and death thereafter, the plot unfolds, exploring the culture and beliefs of the day. Not the least that of the local Church.
Reverend Couper is the greatest distorter of truth, the power-hungry antagonist within this plot. He yields this in his weekly sermons, planting seeds of doubt, rumour and manipulation amidst the parishioners. Nothing new. It reminded me of the book, Chocolat, which also had a likewise priest who preached against the sins of eating the delicacy in the French town. He succumbed eventually but his presence manipulated the parishioners throughout. Maybe Karen Brooks has used this too, in her other book, The Chocolate Maker's Wife; I'm yet to read.
However, the course of injustice in The Darkest Shore, is the plot's strongest thread, the scaffolding holding it together in a Church versus women theme. It's undoing, though, is the women's commitment and support of each other, and their town; their focus being more Christian than the Church itself. This aspect is impressive in the plot.
A forward thinking group of females for the day, these fishwives bring a sense of liberation to the plot with their consistent strength, honesty and independence for their cause. They show sheer grit and determination throughout, none more so than during the hideous prison torture.
But also when one of their own is viciously killed, hoisted and dunked in the sea then trampled upon on a road, with a large door over her, one rallies towards the fishwives cause. Yet the townspeople, by this stage, were engorged with hatred toward these supposed witches.
Detail is graphic, perhaps too much so. It's quite disturbing. It's what causes war and with coercive leaders, like the Reverend, in the name of God, there have been many. Europe chased witches, burnt and expelled the devil and this, in historical terms, was also seen in Scotland and printed in the annals of the day.
This is what attracted Brooks to the tale she created around the facts; beginning each chapter with real quotes. She discusses at the end, again, in far too much detail as if it was another book, though of interest, that she included realistic settings and characters and events.
But her tale's ending is different...it's too sickly sweet and perfect...it seemed rather hastened after the bulk of the plot was slow paced, and gave one the impression, that the torture was all worth it. I was disappointed. However, the decision to dunk and kill the Reverend was ‘just desserts’ yet a pricking for this prick would not have gone astray either! Then suddenly after his death, villagers stopped the harassment of the fishwives. Just too neat. There would have been Church members who still believed that these witches should burn.
Some of the characters seemed flimsy at times as the focus was on the authorial license of her fictional protagonist, the beautiful sorceress (of course!), Scorcha McIntyre. Too beautiful and too intelligent a character.
She conveniently, finds her handsome Captain, Aiden Ross, and rather promptly, following her own terrifying imprisonment (Part 1), their lustful desire and love is supposed to transcend this, in a stark contrast.
From torture to wanting sexual passion when Scorcha is all but limp, cut, weeping pus from her torturous wounds, it’s hard to comprehend. Thus to find energy for such
an astounding, yet quite a moving and sensual scene, seemed out of place; it was too soon in the plot…hence overdone and unnecessary in its intent. There was no other scene like this thereafter.
What would have worked, instead, after Aiden bathed Scorcha’s wrecked body, (since they were not yet physically intimate), was to tend to her wounds, very carefully, then placing her on the bed to sleep (much needed), and gently stroking her hair and laying beside her for the night; calming her when nightmares occurred or cried from pain with her terrible ‘pricking’ prison injuries etc.
The author could have kept the ‘carrot dangling’ with their relationship and ultimate consummation; by slowly adding to their intimacy, over the weeks (and chapters), as Scorcha slowly healed, both physically and emotionally. A kiss, a hug, a cradling in arms, asleep, sharing food, histories etc before a well enough woman falls into her lover’s arms.
Overall 2.5-3*, occasionally lower and higher.
It’s a fascinating history but Brooks had a tendency to overwrite, almost to the point that we hear her voice throughout; all that research crammed into her head thrust itself into the plot making it rather drawn out.
Post note:
Many have reviewed the book in detail, and comments varied yet I agree with those of lower * . I'll read another of her books and hope it won't be too long winded.
Like author, Fiona McIntosh, every researched aspect of their historical stories are included; in mixing fact with fiction. Further editing is required; some punctuation and dialogue was annoying at times. Some scenes were not necessary and there were far too many characters.
All of the above detracts somewhat and one can easily become disengaged. However, the idea and era, setting and atmospheric imagery was well described.
Thus, this dark, passionate, treacherous and torturous (emotional, physical, spiritual etc), early 18th century tale of witchcraft woes in a Scottish fishing village, the 'Weem', holds the reader from the start. But it plodded along in Part One, up until the Tollbooth tortures began.....and kept going, and going, which took far too much effort to stay focussed. Gruesome!
Indeed, with accusations and superstition put upon the independent and strong-knitted female workers, the fishwives, and it's consequential divisiveness, imprisonment and death thereafter, the plot unfolds, exploring the culture and beliefs of the day. Not the least that of the local Church.
Reverend Couper is the greatest distorter of truth, the power-hungry antagonist within this plot. He yields this in his weekly sermons, planting seeds of doubt, rumour and manipulation amidst the parishioners. Nothing new. It reminded me of the book, Chocolat, which also had a likewise priest who preached against the sins of eating the delicacy in the French town. He succumbed eventually but his presence manipulated the parishioners throughout. Maybe Karen Brooks has used this too, in her other book, The Chocolate Maker's Wife; I'm yet to read.
However, the course of injustice in The Darkest Shore, is the plot's strongest thread, the scaffolding holding it together in a Church versus women theme. It's undoing, though, is the women's commitment and support of each other, and their town; their focus being more Christian than the Church itself. This aspect is impressive in the plot.
A forward thinking group of females for the day, these fishwives bring a sense of liberation to the plot with their consistent strength, honesty and independence for their cause. They show sheer grit and determination throughout, none more so than during the hideous prison torture.
But also when one of their own is viciously killed, hoisted and dunked in the sea then trampled upon on a road, with a large door over her, one rallies towards the fishwives cause. Yet the townspeople, by this stage, were engorged with hatred toward these supposed witches.
Detail is graphic, perhaps too much so. It's quite disturbing. It's what causes war and with coercive leaders, like the Reverend, in the name of God, there have been many. Europe chased witches, burnt and expelled the devil and this, in historical terms, was also seen in Scotland and printed in the annals of the day.
This is what attracted Brooks to the tale she created around the facts; beginning each chapter with real quotes. She discusses at the end, again, in far too much detail as if it was another book, though of interest, that she included realistic settings and characters and events.
But her tale's ending is different...it's too sickly sweet and perfect...it seemed rather hastened after the bulk of the plot was slow paced, and gave one the impression, that the torture was all worth it. I was disappointed. However, the decision to dunk and kill the Reverend was ‘just desserts’ yet a pricking for this prick would not have gone astray either! Then suddenly after his death, villagers stopped the harassment of the fishwives. Just too neat. There would have been Church members who still believed that these witches should burn.
Some of the characters seemed flimsy at times as the focus was on the authorial license of her fictional protagonist, the beautiful sorceress (of course!), Scorcha McIntyre. Too beautiful and too intelligent a character.
She conveniently, finds her handsome Captain, Aiden Ross, and rather promptly, following her own terrifying imprisonment (Part 1), their lustful desire and love is supposed to transcend this, in a stark contrast.
From torture to wanting sexual passion when Scorcha is all but limp, cut, weeping pus from her torturous wounds, it’s hard to comprehend. Thus to find energy for such
an astounding, yet quite a moving and sensual scene, seemed out of place; it was too soon in the plot…hence overdone and unnecessary in its intent. There was no other scene like this thereafter.
What would have worked, instead, after Aiden bathed Scorcha’s wrecked body, (since they were not yet physically intimate), was to tend to her wounds, very carefully, then placing her on the bed to sleep (much needed), and gently stroking her hair and laying beside her for the night; calming her when nightmares occurred or cried from pain with her terrible ‘pricking’ prison injuries etc.
The author could have kept the ‘carrot dangling’ with their relationship and ultimate consummation; by slowly adding to their intimacy, over the weeks (and chapters), as Scorcha slowly healed, both physically and emotionally. A kiss, a hug, a cradling in arms, asleep, sharing food, histories etc before a well enough woman falls into her lover’s arms.
Overall 2.5-3*, occasionally lower and higher.
It’s a fascinating history but Brooks had a tendency to overwrite, almost to the point that we hear her voice throughout; all that research crammed into her head thrust itself into the plot making it rather drawn out.
Post note:
Many have reviewed the book in detail, and comments varied yet I agree with those of lower * . I'll read another of her books and hope it won't be too long winded.
September 16, 2023
Very interesting historical fiction detailing some of the tragic events of witch hunts in Scotland. Good to read historical fiction that doesn’t feel like it is trying to be a history lesson; yet it was obvious that this topic was well- researched. The audio version was very well narrated and the accents sounded authentic to my (non Scottish) ears! Recommended.
July 20, 2020
A little bit drawn out for me , and skimmed some parts. Good historical fiction ..
December 12, 2021
Brilliant! Another enjoyable read from Karen Brooks. This book will at various stages make you laugh and cry and feel outraged at the treatment of these amazing women.
May 10, 2022
An interesting & distressing read,that for me was drawn out & too long.
Meticulously researched & atmospherically written. Gruesome & very dark until the very end.
Meticulously researched & atmospherically written. Gruesome & very dark until the very end.
October 22, 2024
I’ll take a story based in Scotland during the 1700’s anytime. But this story of the witches of the Weem has been one I’ll remember. I’ve been so moved by the fierce loyalty and sisterhood among these women, their unshakable bonds even in the darkest of times. Their endurance in the face of persecution has been inspiring, and demonstrates once again the power and fear women can inflict on those lead by total ignorance.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews