Resources running low, the population exploding, the planet is in danger: are we masters of our own destruction, or have we been invaded by aliens bent on mass extinction? Is this a pattern across the entire universe, or just our small sector of cosmic life?
This new title in our successful Gothic & Fantasy Short Stories series explores the theme of a dying planet, written by a fabulous mix of classic, ancient and brand new writing, with contemporary authors from all over the world. For the first time we’ve made a conscious effort to reach beyond our usual submissions seeking a broader voices. This book offers a glorious mix of American, British, Canadian, Italian, Indian, Spanish and Chinese writers with contributions from Elizabeth Rubio, John B. Rosenman, Francesco Verso, Marian Womack, Zach Shephard, E.E. King, Raymond Little, Ken Liu, Shikhandin, Alex Shvartsman and many more.
In these pages too, first-time contributions jostle with the work of Camille Flammarion, Clark Ashton Smith, Stanley G. Weinbaum, Jack London, William Hope Hodgson, H.G. Wells and, stretching back much further, to the Norse Eddas and Sagas, and an Ancient Egyptian Myth on the death of humankind.
This series of books from Flame Tree Publishing are the only ones I buy for looks first, content second. I try to choose ones that will interest me but I've also purchased my top contenders so I have to branch out. Stories with the theme of a dying planet felt appropriate for the dumpster fire we're currently living in.
This is a collection of 34 stories, some new (this is their first publication) and some old (the oldest was an ancient Egyptian myth from around 1350 bc). As always, I'll include a little something on each individual story below. Overall, the collection was not my favorite. I rated it 2 stars because the stories weren't all duds but I had to force myself to buckle down and just finish the book.
Another ding on the book: there was a story that continued online but wasn't actually available on their website. The first few books I read from this series had some stories that continued online (which I don't like as a feature; the stories should stand alone plus if the story is too long to be printed it shouldn't be included in a book of short stories) so then I started checking ahead of time to skip the stories that weren't complete in the book. Then the next few books I read didn't have any stories that weren't self-contained so I thought it was something they tried and didn't continue. So I was tricked. I don't like stories that continue online but it's worse to have it say it continues online and then not be available.
The Destruction of Mankind This is an ancient Egyptian myth written in hieroglyphics. I don't have anything to say about it because it wasn't really a story.
How to Reclaim Water It was very ironic to read a story about rationing and reclaiming water while the sounds of a thunderstorm play in my headphones to cancel out noise. The letters back and forth was a good way to tell the story and keep it moving, and I like that there wasn't a meeting or final ending.
The Hollow Journal "I want to say that the world ended all at once on a perfect Saturday, but we all knew the end was coming for a long time." Oof, what a line. This was a lovely story and found pockets of humanity in the little that remained.
Power Grid I could feel the stifling isolation.
Rainclouds It's amazing how the shift from assuming they were on Earth to finding out they're not can happen with just a few subtle words. A lot of death for just a few pages but an optimistic ending.
A Quiet, Lonely Planet That was lovely. I didn't realize how invested I was until I found myself rooting for her to back to her "home" and friends instead of leaving for somewhere new.
The Arrow of Time That had an emotional arc I wasn't expecting in such a short story. I think about time travel a lot.
Acrylics for a Wasteland I wanted more of an ending. The character had a lot of emotion and depth that I wasn't expecting from a survival story.
Milking Time That was a tough (in a good way) read. Very visceral and too close to the edge of believability, especially with the world we currently live in.
The Air Trust Dangit, I let my guard down and was tricked! The first few books I read from this series had some stories that continued online which I didn't like so then I started checking ahead of time to skip the stories that weren't complete in the book. Then the next few books I read didn't have any stories that weren't self-contained so I thought it was something they tried and didn't continue. Unfortunately, this story continued online. Worse, it said it continued online and then wasn't actually available on their website. So I read a "short story" that was 42 pages in the book and wasn't the whole story but now I don't know the end. That's a bummer of my investment. And now I have to start checking for incomplete stories again.
The Last Day on Earth Very short. I read with trepidation, afraid there would be a twist like "The Mist" or something, and I'm glad that wasn't the case.
Omega: The Last Days of the World This was an absolute stinker that may weigh the whole book down. 52 pages long, I gave up and skimmed just to see what the comet would actually do. Too analytical and unemotional to get into.
The House on the Borderland Too long. I don't think the story fit the theme of the book, it felt like more of a monster/ghost story. I know I was skimming but I didn't see the connection to a dying planet at all.
The Rediscovery of Plants Bleak yet beautiful.
The Sun Takers Very creative and surprisingly emotional. I was glad things seemed to level out at the end.
Scream and I'll Come to You There was a lot packed into this short story and I was fully absorbed.
Mono no aware My palms were sweaty reading the ending. It was oddly comforting to read a calm, orderly reaction to chaos. I loved the line, "It is in the face of disasters that we show our strength as a people."
The Dream of Debs It's amazing the story was written in 1909. With a few communication changes I can see the same thing playing out today; people's greed and class warfare hasn't changed.
And Fade Out Again Typically I would feel more claustrophobic reading a story that takes place underwater but the character's calmness made me comfortable as well. Unexpected ending.
The End of the World An interlude of mythology before continuing the book.
Free Air That read like something from a Twilight Zone episode (or maybe the newer reference would be Black Mirror but I haven't seen it). A sense of apprehension throughout the whole thing with an extra twist at the end.
A Line Cutting Canvas An interesting concept. Even if it's not the assignments they want, I'm glad this society appears to take care of all its members.
What Treasures We Store on Earth It's sad that the most outlandish part of this story is the great treatment parents get. Sterilization? I hope it doesn't happen but I can see it. Benefits such as housing, food, money, and appreciation for new parents? Unbelievable.
The Final Chapter of Marathon Mandy Even with the title giving it away I had hoped her ending would be different.
Communal I felt like this was a long setup for half a page of explanation at the end. The increasing paranoia and isolation felt realistic.
Ambassador to the Meek It felt short but had a good arc.
The Empire of the Necromancers It's ambitious to write a sci-fi short story because throwing a reader into a completely unfamiliar setting with unusual names can feel very overwhelming. This story wasn't successful to me because I felt lost the entire time and then it was over.
The Isle of the Torturers I didn't realize until I finished it that the same author wrote this as the one above but it makes sense because I had the same issues with this one.
Decimate That had the unsettling feeling I expect from doomsday-type stories. The randomness of the selection would be the hardest part to live with as you wait your turn.
Whose Waters Never Fail Strangely uplifting. It was nice to see little pockets of humanity and love amid very tough conditions.
Two Worlds It was fine. These stories are in alphabetical order by author and I may have liked this more at the beginning of the book. I'm bogged down and ready to be done with this book.
A Martian Odyssey Other than the constant use of 'queer' as a descriptor for strange things, I wouldn't have known this wasn't written by a contemporary author.
The Time Machine I'd read this story by H.G. Wells before. Long but fine.
Black Isle I wish I had a better understanding of what happened to the animals.
The cover of this book has "Gothic Fantasy" on it. Evidently I don't know what "Gothic Fantasy" is because the stories went everywhere from notes on Norse mythology to Wells' The Time Machine (always a favorite), to some Clark Ashton Smith to Egyptian myth to authors brand new to me and recently (past five or so years) published. As with any anthology, I wonder what the qualifying elements were. "This story made it in because...?" A rough count shows a third of the stories in the public domain. Some of the stories were story-wise uncomfortable reads. Good job. Some of the stories were craft-wise poorly written. See my question re qualifying elements above. Three authors new to me with standout stories were E.E. King's The Rediscovery of Plants, Ken Liu's Mono no aware, and Francesco Verso's Two Worlds. Incredible craft and wonderful reads, these. I'll be looking for other work by these authors.
For the most part, this was an excellent collection of short stories exploring what it means to face the end of your world. Most (although not all despite the foreword) focus on a lack of hope, a lack of a possibility of something continue. What is important when nothing is really important. Unfortunately, there is a lack of clear organization. There are beautifully poignant and gripping short stories and then everything will come to a standstill for fifty pages of Le fin Du Monde which reads entirely differently and feels like it is dragging in comparison. There isn't even a substantial attempt to stay to the dying world vs. apocalypse dichotomy the foreword sets up. Some of the best stories: Mono no aware, The rediscovery of plants, Communal, How to Reclaim Water.
I had such high hopes for this book, but they didn't pan out. While some of the short stories in this collection are amazing, the majority were bland and stereotypical for the apocalypse genre. Sometimes the world ended, sometimes it didn't, sometimes it was in danger but then it turned out okay. This collection felt all over the place and didn't hold true to its premise. Also, one of the short stories ends on a cliff-hanger with a link to the author's website so you can read more, which feels like bad form. All in all, it's not a book worth reading for the few gems it contains.