Beyond the usual everyday annoyances and exasperations we all experience in the workplace, pettiness limits careers and opportunities on a broad scale and sometimes crosses the line into undeniably criminal behavior.
Based on recent research conducted by SHRM, this groundbreaking book examines the seemingly limitless depths of workplace pettiness–as well as the remarkable heights of creativity it seems to inspire in people–and delivers proven tools for anyone to spot pettiness and deal with it directly.
In addition to revealing the root cause of pettiness and what can be done to eliminate it, Dr. Alonso also offers insights into the personal and organizational costs associated with petty behavior and shows how HR can be its most fierce adversary. But perhaps best of all, he shares some of the most incredible true stories about petty behavior in the workplace you’ll ever read!
I reserved this at the library as it qualifies for SHRM recertification credit if I read it and pass a 10 question test. That's my favorite way to get recertification credits! Thankfully this book was short because it was a somewhat painful read. Here is a general outline of the book:
Chapter 1. Defining pettiness. Easy enough.
Chapter 2: A bunch of stories HR professionals sent in to the author that were classified as "trivial" pettiness. At this point some of the stories were entertaining such as how one admin assigned herself as the "post its police" and she would only give out one pad of post its at a time and she had them under lock and key. Everyone started buying their own pads of post its rather than have to make a case to the admin as to why they needed another pad.
Chapter 3: A bunch of stories HR professionals sent in that were classified as "Minor". I am not sure there was much of a difference between the two categories if you ask me. I am starting to get impatient - enough of the stories and teach me something!
Chapter 4: A bunch of stories HR professionals sent in that were classified by the author as "Major". Some of the stories were not edited and the random folks submitting them embellished the stories for entertainment purposes but by this time, color me bored.
Chapter 5: More stories - classified as "Significant". 100% skimmed (ok skipped) this chapter. There is not going to be anything from any of these stories on the quiz (I was right).
Chapter 6: NOW we have stories that are considered pettiness that was CRIMINAL. At this point, though, I really don't care. I like a good HR story as much as the next person, but for how long? It's just feeling like drama now and I really just want to learn how to identify it and stop it.
Chapter 7. The piece de resistance....except not really. The part where I expected to learn something was 6 pages...two of which was a self-quiz where we are to self-assess our own level of pettiness based on a random quiz that the author invented complete with his self-invented scoring system. The solution to "STOMPing" out pettiness (every good book has its acronyms, right?) is to tell yourself that you will assess yourself every 6 months and make a commitment to stop. THAT'S IT.
BTW, the tool "STOMP" stands for Stomp Out Most Pettiness. Total eye roll. I really don't like being so harsh in my review but I feel very frustrated and let down by this book and whereas I try to look for redeeming factors....I just didn't have it in me for this book.
I was expecting this book to have tangible recommendations for how to address acts of pettiness in the workplace. It is more of a series of 1-2 page true stories of what HR professionals have personally experienced or had to untangle as HR.
This would be a good book for professors of HR, leadership, or I/O psych to pull stories from for examples in class. I don’t think this book is helpful for practitioners (aside from thinking - oh, something similar happened to me. Now I fee not so alone).
There is a model that the author attempts to categorize the severity of petty events into, but I found it to be overly academic and not useful.
Recommend for professors to design small group discussions or written reflections around, but not for any other audience.
It’s difficult to adjust to business systems built on systemic racism... The ultimate pettiness is making a wrong out of being Black no matter education or experience. Most Black Women are faced daily with every level of pettiness simultaneously. This accounts for none of these base issues.