3.5 Stars
***Spoilers***
The (second chance) romance was nothing to write home about, but the history shared among the Three Amigos (Duncan (H), Imogen (h), and Corey) was most fascinating. It involved an unusual friendship, a love triangle, secrets & lies & betrayals, a suicide (note), and a reunion of soulmates who had been forcibly separated for almost THIRTY years.
Corey was an interesting, complex character. He was very peculiar, and I couldn’t tell if he was a sociopath or not. I wanted to begrudge him for ruining the friendship and breaking Duncan & Imogen apart, but he made it hard to hate him because—despite his flaws & mistakes—he was also the kind of person who went above & beyond to take care of the people he loved. He was the cause of Duncan & Imogen’s break up, but he was also the one who brought them back together. Not to mention, during the years while they were separated, both Duncan and Imogen had led a good life (marriage/family & career wise). The same can’t be said about Corey. He was a successful businessman but a lonely, tortured individual. My heart breaks for him.
Duncan & Imogen went their separate ways when they were in their early 20s, and they were reunited in their 50s. Aside from Corey and his meddling, their reunion also wouldn’t have been possible if Imogen’s marriage hadn’t ended. Duncan had been divorced for two years and Imogen two months (I think) when they had their second chance. In my opinion, it was way too soon for Imogen to be in a new relationship considering how much she’d loved Tom, her ex husband (though not as much as she did Duncan obviously). I mean, to come to terms with Tom’s indiscretion (he cheated), their 25+ year marriage ending, and all the revelations from Corey... there was so much to unpack. It seemed far-fetched that she could do it while falling (back) in love with Duncan.
Their romance just felt contrived and convenient, and the way it unfolded was simply through Duncan & Imogen having a lot of sharing and catching up, and a lot of exchanged introductions among the children from their previous marriages. There wasn’t (enough) sparks or chemistry even though their love was supposed to be epic. It was like they just agreed to be in love again cause now they were both single (and old) and there were no more obstacles. The way Duncan & Imogen were with each other felt like they loved each other but they weren’t really in love? Idk, on the one hand: the romance was nothing special; the love & fondness was there, but the passion felt dimmed; and their reunion felt rushed. On the other hand: their relationship was heartwarming and just... made sense.
I’ve noticed that this is how KA tend to write her romance books when they’re about older couples. It’s like the importance is not just on the love story between the couple, but she put more emphasis on the family dynamics. She’s not just bringing two people together but also merging two families—which was what happened here. They also tend to be less steamy. I enjoyed reading about the kids, and I’m excited to read their books. Sully & Gage (Duncan’s) were hilarious. Chloe (Imogen’s) was a little annoying, but I also kinda liked her. And Sasha (Imogen’s) I feel like I could resonate with her. I’m most intrigued by Hale (Corey’s). Tom & Duncan developed a friendship, which was weird but whatever.
When it comes down to it, this prequel was... good, but meh? It felt more... familial than anything you’d expect in a romance, which was fine. It could’ve had a more emotional impact, but it didn’t carry. Anyway, if you plan to read this, make sure to get the extended edition because I listened to the audiobook and it didn’t include Corey’s chapters.
(Read as an Audiobook)