2.5 stars (rounding to 3, you’re welcome Mr. Hughes)
It’s good at a glance for sure. There’s lots of little practical things in here to help us walk out our relationship with God. If you’re looking for a primer on disciplines (which here includes both spiritual disciplines and more generalized Christian disciplines) then grab yourself a copy! It’s truly not bad and certainly beneficial in places (and it’s recommended by Piper, so idk what else to say on that).
I’d say my major frustration is with what’s absent from the text. As we know, I love my Christian books with their first chapter about the gospel, and the first chapter here is … not. (To be fair, it’s about discipline, but still). Even though Hughes goes to great lengths to ensure we understand he’s not subscribing to legalism (doing things gets me merit/salvation from God), he lets us know our focus should be discipline (“I will do this because I love God and want to please Him”). And if discipline, as he then describes for *checks notes* 18 chapters, is the way to please God, then I think he’s still missing the point.
Even as I’m realizing I’m walking a thin line here, I want to emphasize that there’s more to pleasing God than just doing stuff that isn’t sin - and that’s what’s missing from this book. There’s no discussion of how God’s saving work in Jesus Christ was a work of reconciliation - relationship! God reconciled us to Himself and has called us to a great ministry of reconciliation! When we practice discipline, we are practicing reconciliation to God and others (Jesus would call these the first and second greatest commandments). Because of the cross, we can love God and walk in right relationship with Him, freely loving others out of an attitude of abundance. And it’s not that this book didn’t allude to that, but it certainly didn’t focus on it.
I think really my point is that it would be so easy to walk away from this book with a great list of action items to do to please God. And that’s not bad (hence, 2.5 stars, not 1). But we’ve lost the story if we forget that God has called us to love Him and to love His creations - other people. For what is discipline if not love manifested? Where this book makes it clear that these disciplines are what it is to love, it shines. That just wasn’t all that often.
Postscript
Ok sorry, thought of two more things.
(1) Man wrote about 18 disciplines but Sabbath wasn’t one of them? Bonkers!
(2) There wasn’t much of underlying connection between the disciplines. Like - some were spiritual, some were practical, some were communal, but that’s not how they were organized? Like it was all just kind of a hodge podge. Bleh, ok I’m done.
Postscript 2
Sorry sorry, one more thing:
A good portion of his illustrations came from movies, tv, and culture, which is definitely fine to do generally. Except(!) if we’re taking a lot of lessons about how to live like Christ from people that don’t, then we’ve missed the point for sure. Definitely a pet peeve of mine - like, don’t show me an example of how to live like Christ from a movie where that character or actor doesn’t actually believe the gospel.