Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Early American Places

Dividing the Faith: The Rise of Segregated Churches in the Early American North

Rate this book
Uncovers the often overlooked participation of African Americans and Native Americans in early Protestant churches

Phillis Wheatley was stolen from her family in Senegambia, and, in 1761, slave traders transported her to Boston, Massachusetts, to be sold. She was purchased by the Wheatley family who treated Phillis far better than most eighteenth-century slaves could hope, and she received a thorough education while still, of course, longing for her freedom. After four years, Wheatley began writing religious poetry. She was baptized and became a member of a predominantly white Congregational church in Boston. More than ten years after her enslavement began, some of her poetry was published in London, England, as a book titled Poems on Various Subjects, Religious and Moral. This book is evidence that her experience of enslavement was exceptional.

Wheatley remains the most famous black Christian of the colonial era. Though her experiences and accomplishments were unique, her religious affiliation with a predominantly white church was quite ordinary. Dividing the Faith argues that, contrary to the traditional scholarly consensus, a significant portion of northern Protestants worshipped in interracial contexts during the eighteenth century. Yet in another fifty years, such an affiliation would become increasingly rare as churches were by-and-large segregated.

Richard Boles draws from the records of over four hundred congregations to scrutinize the factors that made different Christian traditions either accessible or inaccessible to African American and American Indian peoples. By including Indians, Afro-Indians, and black people in the study of race and religion in the North, this research breaks new ground and uses patterns of church participation to illuminate broader social histories. Overall, it explains the dynamic history of racial integration and segregation in northern colonies and states.

344 pages, Hardcover

Published December 29, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Richard J. Boles

1 book2 followers
I am an Assistant Professor of History at Oklahoma State University (PhD from George Washington University and BA and MA from Boston College). I specialize in early American history, particularly African American and Native American history from the colonial era to the Civil War, and American religious history. Before moving to Oklahoma, I lived in California, Massachusetts, Washington DC, and New York. My first book focuses on race relations in northern Protestant churches from 1730 to 1850. This work examines the transition from racially diverse churches during the early eighteenth century to separate American Indian and African American congregations by the early nineteenth century in the Mid-Atlantic and New England regions. It shows that a significant portion of northern Protestants worshiped in interracial churches between 1730 and 1820. I have published articles in the Lutheran Quarterly, the Rhode Island History Journal, the New England Quarterly, and other publications.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
0 (0%)
4 stars
3 (100%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
Profile Image for Jeremy Canipe.
199 reviews7 followers
February 1, 2022
In this well-written and broadly researched book, Professor Richard J. Boles of Oklahoma State University has filled in a needed gap in the historical literature of the involvement of Native Americans and African Americans in white majority churches in colonial and early United States history in the middle Atlantic and northeastern colonies and states, and the rise of Indian and black churches.

Because his book draws on church records from a wide variety of denominations across this time period, Professor Boles may have corrected erroneous assumption by prior scholars.

Initially, Boles' book demonstrates that both Indians and black people (African and African Americans alike) were not an insignificant portion of churches of many denominations across the colonial northeast and middle Atlantic regions of British North America. While he correctly labels these churches as interracial rather than integrated, insofar as Indians and blacks (his terms) were not treated with full equality, Dr. Boles here is offering a significant corrective to prior historian's work.

Then, the book notes that Native American and African American participation in white-majority and white-led churches continued to rise even as Native Americans began forming Indian-led churches in the 1750s and 1760s. He also noted this trend continued through the First and Second Great Awakenings.

These arguments are important because they belie the assumptions of prior historians who assumed that the more energetic worship styles of Methodists and Baptists and the rise of initially anti-slavery theology in these two denominations explained an uptick in Native American and African Americans attendance and joining of these churches. In fact, both groups joined more liturgical worship style church denominations and churches which did not stand against slavery on biblical grounds.

However, in the 1820s, we began to see the rise of African American churches. Two reasons predominate. First, the fact of increasing white racism (in response to uncertainty in the wake of Gradual Emancipation about black Americans future in the free states) was a definite reason for the start of black churches. Second, in a new argument beyond what prior scholar have noted, Boles argues that some African American Christians concluded that non-believing African Americans would be more responsive to the gospel from churches without white involvement and leadership.

Lastly, Boles' book traces the rise of a Christian critique of white American Christianity and white-led churches by black American and Native American pastors and writers. In short, these writers wrote and argued that the fact of white racism (which was on the rise in the North and Middle Atlantic states) rendered proof that such white Americans were not actually Christians and that such organizations were not authentic Biblical churches).

While Richard Boles noted we lack clear evidence of the actual conversion and beliefs of most professed Indian and African American Christians for the entire period under study, his drawing out this gospel critique struck me, as both a Christian and as a historian. People of my faith must wrestle with what we do with and how we understand past Christians and their sins. One prominent example is, what about Jonathan Edwards, an esteemed colonial pastor and theologian who was also a slave owner? Must we conclude he was actually an unrepentant sinner?

I think the Bible ought to caution against such conclusions but suggest we look to the broader trends of such historical figures' lives. From Moses to David and beyond, all believers in the Bible were grave sinners, but they also were true believers. I don't think we can simply conclude all white slave owners were non Christians if the broader pattern of their lives were in keeping with their faith being real. But that's a question for a different forum and a different day.
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review