What do you think?
Rate this book
White Poison: A Tale of the Gold Rush
"White Poison," like "Little Big Man," is a history of the American West as told by an old man who has lived through it all and thinks he knows everything about the good and evil of the civilization he has helped create in far Northern California -- until two events in 1911 change his mind and prompt him to write his memoirs. First, he learns he has a brain tumor and will soon lose his mental capacity and probably die. Second, Ishi, "the last wild Indian in California," wanders out of the woods, possibly knowing the answer to a mystery Wells has pondered ever since Tyee Bob, a Shasta Indian who used to work on Wells' ranch, told him about it on his deathbed in 1908. According to Bob, as many as 3,000 members of his tribe were fed poisoned beef and bread at a treaty-signing feast in 1851 -- a death toll 10 times that of Wounded Knee, which everyone knows about. But nobody seems to know about this greater massacre -- not Wells, who arrived in Siskiyou County a year later, nor other white people, who have left no written record of it. Until now....
378 pages, Paperback
Published March 31, 2020
7 people are currently reading
2781 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
June 17, 2020
You who are about to read “White Poison” must be prepared to make mental room for a whole different world in the place that now holds your grade-school conditioning and education.
Yes, this story is about cowboys, prospectors, ranchers, vigilantes, militias, and Indians. But, daring reader, be warned, there is little or no romance involved. There is none of that old and misleading white-hats, black-hats movie rigmarole. Don’t come back at me for recommending this terrible book, which I do. Know that there are no Tontos or Kemosabes waiting in the literary bushes. Also, there is no Pocahontas.
And I say “terrible” not in the sense that it is a bad book, but in the sense that it is a fine book that will terrorize your old complacency, and I recommend it for that and for its style.
Fortunately, most of us have not, nor will ever face, the choice of committing murder or mayhem, or somehow avoiding it, but it is a question that resided at the heart of “Manifest Destiny,” a convenient term that European-Americans have employed when history noticed that they were taking over someone else’s territory. “We couldn’t avoid it, it was destiny!”
But Harris’s characters are up against it nonstop during their whole lives, and it brings about the emotional and philosophical conflicts that Harris takes up.
The “white poison” of the title is based on a report that in 1851 a group of Indian fighters had used strychnine-laced raw beef to kill hundreds of California’s Shasta Indians. Also, the title engenders a double accusation. From the Indians’ point of view, whites were poisonous just in their existence, since their existence involved the loss of the natives’ way of living.
The author’s protagonist is dying at the start of the book, which is a tricky, dangerous and fascinating way to start a story. “Dangerous” because if one is not careful one could get the cart before the horse, as in the movie “Sunset Boulevard,” wherein the hero is dead before the story starts, yet he’s telling the story.
But never mind that, there is no such problem here. Harris’s protagonist has to be near death before he can develop the fortitude and the heart it takes to tell a story that includes his own moral breakdown. His own pain began with his murder of several Indians in revenge for the slaying of his parents.
Meetings by white pioneers with Indians in the 1850s were usually hit or miss, and the “hit” included arrows, bullets, whippings and beatings, both sides doing it. But the thing known as a massacre was not invented by Indians, but by European whites. A fracas between Indians often ended with just physically touching a dangerous enemy. That was a coup, and that was it. Whites took another approach. They considered a kind of “final solution,” a well-known example of which occurred in Europe in the 20th century.
Harris does a remarkable job of presenting the psychological impact of a man carrying in his memory what he eventually considered to be a crime, perpetrated by himself. As an impromptu Indian fighter, he and his cohorts were considered heroes by white village dwellers, ranchers and prospectors. But the images of what his own hands caused, as he became acquainted with Indians who were not yet killed, actually ruin his life. How this happens, and what form his eventual punishment takes on, make for a page-turner book. Be warned, sleep might become difficult.
Yes, this story is about cowboys, prospectors, ranchers, vigilantes, militias, and Indians. But, daring reader, be warned, there is little or no romance involved. There is none of that old and misleading white-hats, black-hats movie rigmarole. Don’t come back at me for recommending this terrible book, which I do. Know that there are no Tontos or Kemosabes waiting in the literary bushes. Also, there is no Pocahontas.
And I say “terrible” not in the sense that it is a bad book, but in the sense that it is a fine book that will terrorize your old complacency, and I recommend it for that and for its style.
Fortunately, most of us have not, nor will ever face, the choice of committing murder or mayhem, or somehow avoiding it, but it is a question that resided at the heart of “Manifest Destiny,” a convenient term that European-Americans have employed when history noticed that they were taking over someone else’s territory. “We couldn’t avoid it, it was destiny!”
But Harris’s characters are up against it nonstop during their whole lives, and it brings about the emotional and philosophical conflicts that Harris takes up.
The “white poison” of the title is based on a report that in 1851 a group of Indian fighters had used strychnine-laced raw beef to kill hundreds of California’s Shasta Indians. Also, the title engenders a double accusation. From the Indians’ point of view, whites were poisonous just in their existence, since their existence involved the loss of the natives’ way of living.
The author’s protagonist is dying at the start of the book, which is a tricky, dangerous and fascinating way to start a story. “Dangerous” because if one is not careful one could get the cart before the horse, as in the movie “Sunset Boulevard,” wherein the hero is dead before the story starts, yet he’s telling the story.
But never mind that, there is no such problem here. Harris’s protagonist has to be near death before he can develop the fortitude and the heart it takes to tell a story that includes his own moral breakdown. His own pain began with his murder of several Indians in revenge for the slaying of his parents.
Meetings by white pioneers with Indians in the 1850s were usually hit or miss, and the “hit” included arrows, bullets, whippings and beatings, both sides doing it. But the thing known as a massacre was not invented by Indians, but by European whites. A fracas between Indians often ended with just physically touching a dangerous enemy. That was a coup, and that was it. Whites took another approach. They considered a kind of “final solution,” a well-known example of which occurred in Europe in the 20th century.
Harris does a remarkable job of presenting the psychological impact of a man carrying in his memory what he eventually considered to be a crime, perpetrated by himself. As an impromptu Indian fighter, he and his cohorts were considered heroes by white village dwellers, ranchers and prospectors. But the images of what his own hands caused, as he became acquainted with Indians who were not yet killed, actually ruin his life. How this happens, and what form his eventual punishment takes on, make for a page-turner book. Be warned, sleep might become difficult.
May 10, 2020
This is a great historical tale, set in far northern California in the late 1800s. I rank it right up with novels by Wallace Stegner and Ivan Doig as capturing life in the West in this formative period. The writing is clear, graceful and understated. The characters are nuanced and complex. Harris is a master of the craft who deserves a wide audience.
May 2, 2025
Scalping the archive
In White Poison: A Tale of the Gold Rush, Michael Harris reconstructs a morally fraught history of settler colonialism in Northern California through the fictional memoir of Alexander Wells, a settler-turned-lawyer whose personal evolution is intimately entangled with the region’s violent transformation. Structured as a retrospective confession written in 1911, Wells’s narrative is catalysed by the dual shock of an impending death from a brain tumour and the unexpected appearance of Ishi, a Yahi man thought to be the last of his tribe. These events reopen an old mystery: the claim, relayed by a dying Shasta man in 1908, that thousands of his people were deliberately poisoned during a treaty feast in 1851. The novel thus pivots on the unsettling silence of official archives and the erasure of atrocity, driving Wells to confront not only the historical record but also his own complicity. Harris crafts a deeply layered historical fiction that draws on archival voids and moral uncertainty, placing collective amnesia and personal guilt at the center of a literary excavation of settler violence.
Harris’ tale unfolds through a dialectic of memory and trauma, as Wells recounts his transformation from orphaned boy on a wagon train to militia member, landowner, drunkard, and eventually penitent lawyer. The text spans decades of conquest and internal contradiction, with episodes such as the massacre at Lost River, a vengeful scalping of women and children, and the later reversal of power in Wells’s brutal beating by Tyee Bob, haunting the arc of the protagonist’s life. Harris, attentive to period idioms and emotional restraint, constructs a narrator whose retrospective voice is credible not because it seeks redemption, but because it bears the weight of irredeemable actions. The character’s moral evolution does not undo his past; rather, it underscores the deep psychological sedimentation of frontier violence. As the 20th century encroaches—via labour disputes, aggressive capitalism, and the unresolved legacies of indigenous dispossession—Harris suggests that the foundational violence of the American West is not merely a historical phase, but an enduring structure of power and silence.
Ultimately, White Poison rises as both a novel of remembrance and a meta-historical inquiry into the ethics of narrative itself. Harris resists melodrama in favour of a slow-burning reckoning, positioning Wells not as a hero but as a flawed witness to a history whitewashed by myth and omission. Drawing on the conventions of the historical novel, Harris uses Wells’s individual trajectory to trace larger social processes, rendering the colonial frontier not as a site of triumphant expansion but as a crucible of unacknowledged horror. The result is a meditation on history’s absences—both in the archives and in the conscience—and on the limits of reparative justice when the past has been so thoroughly buried.
In White Poison: A Tale of the Gold Rush, Michael Harris reconstructs a morally fraught history of settler colonialism in Northern California through the fictional memoir of Alexander Wells, a settler-turned-lawyer whose personal evolution is intimately entangled with the region’s violent transformation. Structured as a retrospective confession written in 1911, Wells’s narrative is catalysed by the dual shock of an impending death from a brain tumour and the unexpected appearance of Ishi, a Yahi man thought to be the last of his tribe. These events reopen an old mystery: the claim, relayed by a dying Shasta man in 1908, that thousands of his people were deliberately poisoned during a treaty feast in 1851. The novel thus pivots on the unsettling silence of official archives and the erasure of atrocity, driving Wells to confront not only the historical record but also his own complicity. Harris crafts a deeply layered historical fiction that draws on archival voids and moral uncertainty, placing collective amnesia and personal guilt at the center of a literary excavation of settler violence.
Harris’ tale unfolds through a dialectic of memory and trauma, as Wells recounts his transformation from orphaned boy on a wagon train to militia member, landowner, drunkard, and eventually penitent lawyer. The text spans decades of conquest and internal contradiction, with episodes such as the massacre at Lost River, a vengeful scalping of women and children, and the later reversal of power in Wells’s brutal beating by Tyee Bob, haunting the arc of the protagonist’s life. Harris, attentive to period idioms and emotional restraint, constructs a narrator whose retrospective voice is credible not because it seeks redemption, but because it bears the weight of irredeemable actions. The character’s moral evolution does not undo his past; rather, it underscores the deep psychological sedimentation of frontier violence. As the 20th century encroaches—via labour disputes, aggressive capitalism, and the unresolved legacies of indigenous dispossession—Harris suggests that the foundational violence of the American West is not merely a historical phase, but an enduring structure of power and silence.
Ultimately, White Poison rises as both a novel of remembrance and a meta-historical inquiry into the ethics of narrative itself. Harris resists melodrama in favour of a slow-burning reckoning, positioning Wells not as a hero but as a flawed witness to a history whitewashed by myth and omission. Drawing on the conventions of the historical novel, Harris uses Wells’s individual trajectory to trace larger social processes, rendering the colonial frontier not as a site of triumphant expansion but as a crucible of unacknowledged horror. The result is a meditation on history’s absences—both in the archives and in the conscience—and on the limits of reparative justice when the past has been so thoroughly buried.
April 30, 2025
The White Poison by Michael Harris tells the story of Alexander Wells, a dying lawyer looking back on a lifetime shaped by violence. Set in Northern California in 1911, the novel dives into the hidden brutality of America's expansion into Native lands. After finding out he has a brain tumor and after meeting Ishi, the last "wild" Native American, Wells decides to write down the truth of what he has seen and done.
Harris mixes real historical events, like the little-known poisoning of the Shasta Indians, with fictional lives. The novel strips away the glamor often tied to Western history, exposing murder, racism, and betrayal. Wells's journey is grim but gripping. Readers watch him wrestle with shame and guilt that grows heavier with time. The book doesn't end with redemption but with a broken man trying to make peace with his memories. White Poison is strong, hard-hitting historical fiction. It doesn't flatter the past. It demands that readers sit with the discomfort it brings.
Michael Harris deserves credit for creating a realistic and brutal world without resorting to clichés. The setting — Northern California during and after the Gold Rush — feels raw and authentic. Harris draws from real history but wisely leaves space for the unknowns and contradictions that real history holds. The use of actual historical touchpoints, such as the poisoning at Scott Valley and the later arrival of Ishi, lends weight to the story. Some passages, particularly those surrounding court cases and land disputes, slow the pace, but overall, the setting pulls you in and keeps you engaged.
The characters are another strength. Alexander Wells is complicated and often unpleasant, but he feels real. His journey from rage to shame is believable and sad. Harris shows Wells as a man trying and failing to find peace. Secondary characters like Dr. Baxter and Tyee Bob are solid, but Amelia, Wells's daughter, deserves more focus. Her relationship with Wells could have added a deeper emotional layer, especially during their ride into the mountains late in the book. The plot moves with strong momentum at first. Wells's early years, the Modoc massacres, and the mystery of the Shasta poisoning are gripping. However, the middle of the novel drags when the focus shifts to Wells's law career. The urgency fades until Ishi appears. After that, the story regains speed. Still, readers will notice the dip and may struggle through a few slower chapters.
Harris's writing is clear and sharp. His sentences have muscle. He writes violence and guilt with a cold honesty that fits the story. At times, though, the style feels almost too flat. Some emotional scenes could have had a greater impact with a bit more color or depth. Despite this, Harris's refusal to offer easy answers gives the novel its power. The White Poison is a hard book to read — and it should be. It demands that readers face ugly truths about history and human nature. It stumbles in parts, but its brutal honesty makes it unforgettable.
Readers who like historical fiction that faces hard truths head-on — and fans of authors like Wallace Stegner or Cormac McCarthy — will find this novel rewarding.
Harris mixes real historical events, like the little-known poisoning of the Shasta Indians, with fictional lives. The novel strips away the glamor often tied to Western history, exposing murder, racism, and betrayal. Wells's journey is grim but gripping. Readers watch him wrestle with shame and guilt that grows heavier with time. The book doesn't end with redemption but with a broken man trying to make peace with his memories. White Poison is strong, hard-hitting historical fiction. It doesn't flatter the past. It demands that readers sit with the discomfort it brings.
Michael Harris deserves credit for creating a realistic and brutal world without resorting to clichés. The setting — Northern California during and after the Gold Rush — feels raw and authentic. Harris draws from real history but wisely leaves space for the unknowns and contradictions that real history holds. The use of actual historical touchpoints, such as the poisoning at Scott Valley and the later arrival of Ishi, lends weight to the story. Some passages, particularly those surrounding court cases and land disputes, slow the pace, but overall, the setting pulls you in and keeps you engaged.
The characters are another strength. Alexander Wells is complicated and often unpleasant, but he feels real. His journey from rage to shame is believable and sad. Harris shows Wells as a man trying and failing to find peace. Secondary characters like Dr. Baxter and Tyee Bob are solid, but Amelia, Wells's daughter, deserves more focus. Her relationship with Wells could have added a deeper emotional layer, especially during their ride into the mountains late in the book. The plot moves with strong momentum at first. Wells's early years, the Modoc massacres, and the mystery of the Shasta poisoning are gripping. However, the middle of the novel drags when the focus shifts to Wells's law career. The urgency fades until Ishi appears. After that, the story regains speed. Still, readers will notice the dip and may struggle through a few slower chapters.
Harris's writing is clear and sharp. His sentences have muscle. He writes violence and guilt with a cold honesty that fits the story. At times, though, the style feels almost too flat. Some emotional scenes could have had a greater impact with a bit more color or depth. Despite this, Harris's refusal to offer easy answers gives the novel its power. The White Poison is a hard book to read — and it should be. It demands that readers face ugly truths about history and human nature. It stumbles in parts, but its brutal honesty makes it unforgettable.
Readers who like historical fiction that faces hard truths head-on — and fans of authors like Wallace Stegner or Cormac McCarthy — will find this novel rewarding.
April 26, 2025
Michael Harris’s White Poison is not just a novel—it’s a reckoning. At once a sweeping historical epic and a deeply intimate confession, this haunting tale unspools through the memoirs of Alexander Wells, an aging lawyer in 1911 Northern California, staring down both a terminal brain tumor and the ghosts of his past. As Wells looks back on his life, Harris drags the reader through the brutal underbelly of America’s westward expansion, refusing to let us look away from the truth.
Wells, once a teenage orphan who joined a militia to avenge his parents’ deaths at the hands of the Modoc, is a man shaped by blood and loss. He fights in massacres, builds a life on land once soaked in violence, and later spirals into guilt and alcoholism. The novel pivots around a mystery revealed to him on a deathbed: a long-silenced genocide, in which as many as 3,000 Shasta Indians were deliberately poisoned in 1851—an atrocity ten times the scale of Wounded Knee, yet almost entirely erased from public memory. The arrival of Ishi, “the last wild Indian in California,” years later forces Wells to confront this hidden horror and question everything he thought he knew about his past, his people, and the country they claimed.
Harris’s prose is as sharp as it is poetic, weaving historical fact with fictional depth. But unlike many Westerns, there is no glory here. The American frontier is stripped of its romance, laid bare as a landscape carved by greed, racism, and cultural erasure. Through Wells’s eyes, we see not only the physical devastation of Native lands and lives, but the internal rot such violence brings to those who perpetuate it. Every massacre, every betrayal, every moment of cowardice and complicity festers within him, and by the novel’s end, the weight is nearly unbearable.
What makes White Poison so devastatingly effective is its emotional honesty. Wells is no saint. He is selfish, flawed, and often blind to his own privilege. But he is also brutally self-aware, particularly in his later years, as he seeks meaning in study, in law, and in caring for his disabled son. The supporting cast are not mere side characters, but embodiments of the moral tension that permeates the narrative.
This is a novel about buried truths—those written out of history books and those we try to bury inside ourselves. It is also about the high cost of silence. The massacre of the Shasta, if true, represents not just a historical crime, but a moral blind spot so vast it threatens to consume Wells’s soul. His belated search for answers, and his hope that understanding the past might stop future violence, gives the novel its fragile heartbeat.
In White Poison, Harris has given us a story that refuses to flinch. It’s not comfortable. It’s not clean. But it is necessary. For anyone willing to sit with the difficult truths of America’s past—and to examine how those truths echo into our present. It reminds us that history is not just what happened, but what we choose to remember. And sometimes, remembering is the most radical act of all.
Wells, once a teenage orphan who joined a militia to avenge his parents’ deaths at the hands of the Modoc, is a man shaped by blood and loss. He fights in massacres, builds a life on land once soaked in violence, and later spirals into guilt and alcoholism. The novel pivots around a mystery revealed to him on a deathbed: a long-silenced genocide, in which as many as 3,000 Shasta Indians were deliberately poisoned in 1851—an atrocity ten times the scale of Wounded Knee, yet almost entirely erased from public memory. The arrival of Ishi, “the last wild Indian in California,” years later forces Wells to confront this hidden horror and question everything he thought he knew about his past, his people, and the country they claimed.
Harris’s prose is as sharp as it is poetic, weaving historical fact with fictional depth. But unlike many Westerns, there is no glory here. The American frontier is stripped of its romance, laid bare as a landscape carved by greed, racism, and cultural erasure. Through Wells’s eyes, we see not only the physical devastation of Native lands and lives, but the internal rot such violence brings to those who perpetuate it. Every massacre, every betrayal, every moment of cowardice and complicity festers within him, and by the novel’s end, the weight is nearly unbearable.
What makes White Poison so devastatingly effective is its emotional honesty. Wells is no saint. He is selfish, flawed, and often blind to his own privilege. But he is also brutally self-aware, particularly in his later years, as he seeks meaning in study, in law, and in caring for his disabled son. The supporting cast are not mere side characters, but embodiments of the moral tension that permeates the narrative.
This is a novel about buried truths—those written out of history books and those we try to bury inside ourselves. It is also about the high cost of silence. The massacre of the Shasta, if true, represents not just a historical crime, but a moral blind spot so vast it threatens to consume Wells’s soul. His belated search for answers, and his hope that understanding the past might stop future violence, gives the novel its fragile heartbeat.
In White Poison, Harris has given us a story that refuses to flinch. It’s not comfortable. It’s not clean. But it is necessary. For anyone willing to sit with the difficult truths of America’s past—and to examine how those truths echo into our present. It reminds us that history is not just what happened, but what we choose to remember. And sometimes, remembering is the most radical act of all.
April 29, 2025
Gripping, Raw US-versus-them Narrative
White Poison is a March 2020 book by Michael Harris. The book is divided into 12 sections whose timespan ranges from 1852 to post-1911. As its subtitle shows, it especially chronicles unacknowledged intrigues associated with the California gold rush.
A physician’s note, dated April 1912 and signed by dr. Frederick C. Baxter, kickstarts the first-person narrative. The note tells of a forwarded memoirish manuscript detailing long-time lawyer and old-timer Alexander Wells’ reminisces of the American frontier many years prior.
The preliminary historical and journalistic excerpts hint at the book’s dark secrets, particularly the extrajudicial theme. There are two plot conflicts. The internal plot conflict: Dr. Baxter diagnoses the 76-year-old Wells with a potentially terminal illness. External plot conflict: Ishi, a malnourished middle-aged man—a wild California Indian who is the last surviving Mill Creek tribesperson—ultimately surrenders to civilization, attracting the attention of university-affiliated anthropologists.
Before his tumor devours his mind, Wells writes about his ranch farmhand Tyee Bob’s 1908 deathbed confession that if “true, everything I thought I knew about this place is a lie…our capacity for evil…everything we have struggled for…rests on a foundation even more treacherous…rests on blood...more blood that I had ever imagined.”
The intricacies of this hushed up confession—the title-inspiring part and plot’s watershed moment—mentions an 1851 feast of beef, witnessed by the then young Bob; “too young for the ceremony”, Bob survived the poisoned feast, overseen by one of the appointed commissioners, Colonel McKee, “at Sharp’s Gulch for the treaty signing”, where “so many died; three thousand of us, some say.”
So, “what could Ishi tell me about Sharp’s Gulch that…others in this very country could not, if only they were willing to break their silence to me?” Wells mulls. Innocent yet plagued by collective guilt amid personal tragedies, Wells turns a blind eye to his disappointments and must promise and compromise.
White Poison is a gripping, raw US versus them narrative whose valiant chronicler looks under the homeland’s carpet.
White Poison is a March 2020 book by Michael Harris. The book is divided into 12 sections whose timespan ranges from 1852 to post-1911. As its subtitle shows, it especially chronicles unacknowledged intrigues associated with the California gold rush.
A physician’s note, dated April 1912 and signed by dr. Frederick C. Baxter, kickstarts the first-person narrative. The note tells of a forwarded memoirish manuscript detailing long-time lawyer and old-timer Alexander Wells’ reminisces of the American frontier many years prior.
The preliminary historical and journalistic excerpts hint at the book’s dark secrets, particularly the extrajudicial theme. There are two plot conflicts. The internal plot conflict: Dr. Baxter diagnoses the 76-year-old Wells with a potentially terminal illness. External plot conflict: Ishi, a malnourished middle-aged man—a wild California Indian who is the last surviving Mill Creek tribesperson—ultimately surrenders to civilization, attracting the attention of university-affiliated anthropologists.
Before his tumor devours his mind, Wells writes about his ranch farmhand Tyee Bob’s 1908 deathbed confession that if “true, everything I thought I knew about this place is a lie…our capacity for evil…everything we have struggled for…rests on a foundation even more treacherous…rests on blood...more blood that I had ever imagined.”
The intricacies of this hushed up confession—the title-inspiring part and plot’s watershed moment—mentions an 1851 feast of beef, witnessed by the then young Bob; “too young for the ceremony”, Bob survived the poisoned feast, overseen by one of the appointed commissioners, Colonel McKee, “at Sharp’s Gulch for the treaty signing”, where “so many died; three thousand of us, some say.”
So, “what could Ishi tell me about Sharp’s Gulch that…others in this very country could not, if only they were willing to break their silence to me?” Wells mulls. Innocent yet plagued by collective guilt amid personal tragedies, Wells turns a blind eye to his disappointments and must promise and compromise.
White Poison is a gripping, raw US versus them narrative whose valiant chronicler looks under the homeland’s carpet.
April 27, 2025
It is rightly said that heaven and hell exist within us. Your wrongdoings weigh on your conscience, creating inner turmoil and misery—a hell of your own making. Conversely, your righteous actions bring peace and fulfillment, creating a heaven in your heart. What's remarkable is that none of us enters this world inherently good or evil. We begin as blank canvases, neither saints nor sinners. Yet our experiences shape us profoundly, molding our character and shifting our moral compass in ways we might never have anticipated.
The same happens with protagonist Alexander Wells, a 76-year-old lawyer in 1911 reflecting on his life in Northern California since the Gold Rush. He found out from Dr. Baxter that he had a brain tumor, which made him feel like he didn't have much time left. Around the same time, Ishi, who people called the "last wild Indian in California," showed up. Because of these two things, he felt he needed to write his life story. The narrative delves into his life, starting in 1852 when, as a 17-year-old, he arrives in California after his parents are killed in a Modoc Indian attack on their wagon train. Driven by grief and rage, young Wells joins a militia led by the historical figure Ben Wright, participating in a brutal massacre of Modoc people, an act that haunts him for decades.
The theme and style of the book revolve around moral reckoning, historical authenticity, and emotional depth. It has beautifully captured the essence of guilt, historical injustice, and the often-brutal realities of the American West during the Gold Rush era. The story excellently weaves historical events, such as the California Gold Rush and the extermination campaigns against Native tribes, with Alex’s journey as a prospector, rancher, lawyer, and flawed family man.
History is full of blood and terrible crimes. As always, winners tell the stories, so most don't know what happened. This book shows just a small part of the truth. Many other dark stories across the globe have been lost forever. This book is for anyone who cares about truth and history. It’s not long. It’s not hard to read. But it stays with you.
The same happens with protagonist Alexander Wells, a 76-year-old lawyer in 1911 reflecting on his life in Northern California since the Gold Rush. He found out from Dr. Baxter that he had a brain tumor, which made him feel like he didn't have much time left. Around the same time, Ishi, who people called the "last wild Indian in California," showed up. Because of these two things, he felt he needed to write his life story. The narrative delves into his life, starting in 1852 when, as a 17-year-old, he arrives in California after his parents are killed in a Modoc Indian attack on their wagon train. Driven by grief and rage, young Wells joins a militia led by the historical figure Ben Wright, participating in a brutal massacre of Modoc people, an act that haunts him for decades.
The theme and style of the book revolve around moral reckoning, historical authenticity, and emotional depth. It has beautifully captured the essence of guilt, historical injustice, and the often-brutal realities of the American West during the Gold Rush era. The story excellently weaves historical events, such as the California Gold Rush and the extermination campaigns against Native tribes, with Alex’s journey as a prospector, rancher, lawyer, and flawed family man.
History is full of blood and terrible crimes. As always, winners tell the stories, so most don't know what happened. This book shows just a small part of the truth. Many other dark stories across the globe have been lost forever. This book is for anyone who cares about truth and history. It’s not long. It’s not hard to read. But it stays with you.
April 23, 2025
White Poison: A Tale of the Gold Rush by Harris is a searing, unflinching reexamination of America’s westward expansion, told through the voice of a dying man haunted by a life shaped in violence. Beginning with the protagonist's final days, the novel peels back layers of personal and national guilt, recounting a lifetime of complicity in the genocidal brutality that defined Manifest Destiny. What sets this story apart is its refusal to romanticize the American frontier- it strips away myths to reveal the horrors buried beneath the gold rush, including the heart-wrenching massacre of thousands of Shasta Indians in 1851, a tragedy lost to most official histories.
Harris masterfully entwines historical fact with literary imagination, offering readers a protagonist whose internal torment mirrors the moral rot at the heart of settler colonialism. Through vivid accounts of massacres, broken treaties, and lifelong emotional reckoning, the novel invites reflection on the deep psychological and generational tolls of conquest. Each character carries their own scars- some seek redemption through law, religion, or service, while others, like Wells, are crushed by guilt that no amount of penance can relieve. Harris’s storytelling dares readers to question the sanitized versions of history they were taught, and to sit with the unease that truth often brings.
Painful yet necessary, White Poison is a book that forces its audience to confront the buried atrocities of America's past. It is emotionally devastating, particularly for descendants of the Native people it honors, yet profoundly important. Harris doesn’t offer easy answers, only the raw truth that redemption, if possible, must begin with remembrance. In doing so, he delivers a haunting, unforgettable novel that challenges complacency and urges historical clarity.
April 24, 2025
White Poison: A Tale of the Gold Rush is a hauntingly powerful novel that strips away the myths of the American West and exposes the raw, painful truths buried beneath gold rush glory. Through the memoirs of Alexander Wells, a dying man reckoning with his past, Harris crafts a story that is both deeply personal and historically expansive. The novel’s emotional weight lies in its unflinching portrayal of settler violence, the psychological cost of genocide, and the elusive nature of redemption.
Wells’s journey—from orphaned teenager turned Indian fighter to guilt-ridden elder seeking moral clarity—is both tragic and redemptive. Harris’s prose is beautifully evocative, and his characters are complex, flawed, and deeply human. The story seamlessly blends historical fact and literary fiction, with the mysterious massacre of the Shasta tribe in 1851 serving as the chilling heart of the narrative.
What sets White Poison apart is its moral depth, emotional intelligence, and refusal to romanticize history. It is a novel that challenges, educates, and ultimately transforms the reader. For those willing to face the dark truths of America's past, this book is not just recommended—it’s essential.
Thank you,
Happy Reading.
Wells’s journey—from orphaned teenager turned Indian fighter to guilt-ridden elder seeking moral clarity—is both tragic and redemptive. Harris’s prose is beautifully evocative, and his characters are complex, flawed, and deeply human. The story seamlessly blends historical fact and literary fiction, with the mysterious massacre of the Shasta tribe in 1851 serving as the chilling heart of the narrative.
What sets White Poison apart is its moral depth, emotional intelligence, and refusal to romanticize history. It is a novel that challenges, educates, and ultimately transforms the reader. For those willing to face the dark truths of America's past, this book is not just recommended—it’s essential.
Thank you,
Happy Reading.
May 7, 2025
White Poison: A Tale of the Gold rush by Michael Harris is a book that is full of historical events that took place in Northern California. Michael’s writing skills are evident in the way that he has weaved in different facts and fiction in varying eras in his story. This book will definitely arouse numerous emotions in the reader and especially the poisoning of the Shasta people. Alexander Wells, appears to be the protagonist in the book and he can be seen battling feelings of guilt, self-worth, shame etc. He is a man that has gone through it all. However, he tries to redeem himself but unfortunately I can say that this was futile in the end. One portion of the story that stood out to me was Charlie. He was Alexander’s son but he was not neurotypical. Even though it appears hard for Alexander to embrace him in the beginning, he eventually warms up to him. I love that the author has broken the read into chapters considering that it is a fairly long one. At the end, he also provides references that the reader can refer to. I can recommend this read to people who enjoy historical fiction!
May 6, 2025
Surprised that this was a work of fiction
While reading White Poison, I found myself believing this was a true account. The author writes in such detail and in words that regular people use that it seemed like it had actually been written by the main character. It wasn't until the author's note at the end that I realized it was fiction.
While the name can be misleading, I found this book fascinating. Although it takes place during the time of the gold rush, the gold rush itself is only a small part of the book. The main thread throughout the story is the horrid treatment of the Native Americans as the white people pushed them further and further west. This book is not for the faint of heart as the author provides vivid details.
Although this is a novel, the author incorporates many historic accounts to paint a ghastly picture of the slaughter that occurred. This is a must-read for history buffs but especially for those who are interested in the stuff left out of the history books.
While reading White Poison, I found myself believing this was a true account. The author writes in such detail and in words that regular people use that it seemed like it had actually been written by the main character. It wasn't until the author's note at the end that I realized it was fiction.
While the name can be misleading, I found this book fascinating. Although it takes place during the time of the gold rush, the gold rush itself is only a small part of the book. The main thread throughout the story is the horrid treatment of the Native Americans as the white people pushed them further and further west. This book is not for the faint of heart as the author provides vivid details.
Although this is a novel, the author incorporates many historic accounts to paint a ghastly picture of the slaughter that occurred. This is a must-read for history buffs but especially for those who are interested in the stuff left out of the history books.
April 24, 2025
Michael Harris' epic novel White Poison is a quiet masterpiece of the blood-stained history of late nineteenth-century northern California told through the voice of Alexander Wells. On the verge of death, Wells is compelled to write his life story. He discovers he has a brain tumor and will soon lose his mental capacity, likely leading to his death. Being an orphan at 17, he joins a militia band and helps massacre Modocs in 1852, including women and children. He marries and faces loss and pain.
White Poison: A Tale Of The Gold Rush by Michael Harris, is an intriguing recollection of a historical event forgotten. His sentences are as carefully written. Harris is skilled in describing everything from lust to rage to compassion. The book not only catches the reader's attention, but it completely captivates them
White Poison: A Tale Of The Gold Rush by Michael Harris, is an intriguing recollection of a historical event forgotten. His sentences are as carefully written. Harris is skilled in describing everything from lust to rage to compassion. The book not only catches the reader's attention, but it completely captivates them
June 5, 2025
I could not put this book down! It was so exciting and interesting. I really felt like I was there - in the old Wild West with all the fears and ignorance and prejudice and also the natural beauty.
I loved the main character, Alex, with all of his flaws. I liked seeing his journey from a young and innocent teen into a vengeful young man then seeing him mature through his pain and friendships and reflections into a respectable and regretful adult.
I learned so much about Northern California during that period of time, it was all new to me and I’m kind of hooked now, I want to get my hands on some of the books that the author references and learn more.
Thank you so much for sending me this book Michael Harris! I loved it and I know that what I read will stay with me for a long time!
I loved the main character, Alex, with all of his flaws. I liked seeing his journey from a young and innocent teen into a vengeful young man then seeing him mature through his pain and friendships and reflections into a respectable and regretful adult.
I learned so much about Northern California during that period of time, it was all new to me and I’m kind of hooked now, I want to get my hands on some of the books that the author references and learn more.
Thank you so much for sending me this book Michael Harris! I loved it and I know that what I read will stay with me for a long time!
March 19, 2022
I was absolutely floored by the way this book moves forward, by the pacing, impact, and poetry of the sentences, and by the meticulous and authoritative research that adds further depth and meaning to the rich characterizations. I intend to read everything this important writer gives us and I have ordered the rest of his books. If you are a writer, there is much to learn from this author. If you are a reader, you will likely be pulled into the urgent action as I was. The subject matter is brutal and true. It is also interesting that this book was self-published. I want to be clear about this: it is a masterpiece.
October 31, 2023
captivating as wellThe account is so believable as chilling
The account is so believable. The author entwined facts with literary license into a biography that weaves the best and worst of humanity to document the slaughter of native people in the northwest. Guilt with hope of redemption titillates the protagonist to a resolve that never reaches satisfaction. As a descendant of native people who were murdered and pushed to near extinction this account brought me to tears.
The account is so believable. The author entwined facts with literary license into a biography that weaves the best and worst of humanity to document the slaughter of native people in the northwest. Guilt with hope of redemption titillates the protagonist to a resolve that never reaches satisfaction. As a descendant of native people who were murdered and pushed to near extinction this account brought me to tears.
October 25, 2020
Good writing, but not for me. Full confession: I abandoned it halfway through.
July 19, 2020
It's worse than immodest -- it's downright embarrassing -- to review my own book. It smacks of bragging and begging at the same time. But I dare any of you to read "White Poison" and say it's anything but an exciting Old West yarn and a polished work of literature. And it should be read, I immodestly insist, as widely as possible, especially here in California -- not just because I would profit thereby, but because this is a book that speaks to our own times, when some of us are finally trying to face up to the racist and murderous aspects of our history.
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews