Review forthcoming in Publishers Weekly. Novelist Skirbell offers up five essays, each a meditation on a particular story from the Talmud. Based on the introduction I was pretty excited about the idea of fanfic for the Talmud but this turned out to be more literary analysis and spiritual meditation than imaginative retelling of Talmudic parables. For those of us less familiar with the original corpus of texts upon which Skibell is reflecting, the essays wander to the point of confusion. But study groups looking for commentary that ties the personal and the present-day to these ancient texts may find them worthwhile to digest in reflective discussion.
In five essays (why not six? Read the opening pages and find out), Skibell brings the rabbis of the Talmud to life, turning them from plaster saints to sages with very human weaknesses.
For example, one essay addresses four rabbis who have a mystical vision, one of whom (ben Azzai) dies. What's wrong with ben Azzai? Skibell examines other references to him in the Talmud, including a reference to his refusal to procreate, and suggests that he is one of these pious but impractical people who is "too busy receiving the Torah to live by its precepts." Since ben Azzai "has got one foot in the world to come already' it would make sense that he would enter that world at the slightest provocation.
This one is not for the casual reader. I think it requires some work to understand the stories that the author links together from the Mishna and Gemara of the Talmud. Interesting, but a little esoteric for me.