What do you think?
Rate this book
Doyle & Acton #10
Murder in the Blood
This homicide case featured aristocrats as far as the eye could see, between the Russians and the Spaniards—and Acton, of course, who was supposedly investigating the others but seemed a little too deferential, for Doyle’s taste. Why wasn’t her husband moving in on the killer? And why did she have the sense that she was standing on the outside, peering into a world where there were no laws and no explanations—only birthrights, forged in ancient blood.
219 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 10, 2019
68 people are currently reading
145 people want to read
About the author
Anne Cleeland
36 books473 followersAnne Cleeland writes a contemporary Scotland Yard mystery series that is featured in the Amazon top 100 best sellers. She also writes a historical series of stand-alone books set in the Regency period. A member of International Thriller Writers, The Historical Novel Society, and Mystery Writers of America, she lives in California and has four children. www.annecleeland.com; @annecleeland.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews
April 10, 2020
The usual mixture of humor, charm and a bit of confusion can be found in Murder in the Blood. This time Cleeland combines several of her past murder categories; honor, containment, spite, and just cause .
With Lord and Lady Acton facing the investiture of a new title, Doyle is horrified to realize just how bad baby Edward's antecedents really are.
Lord and Lady Acton are helping Williams investigate a murder that seems related to the sex crime ring detailed in past books. This time they realize there is a mastermind who is in the clean up stage and for a change it is not his Lordship. He is busy with his own containment plans. Why Acton even bothers I will never know, since the "thick as a plank" Doyle always figures it out. This time his plan is particularly horrendous and if I were Doyle I would be packing my bags.
Ever since the jaw dropping Murder in Thrall I have been addicted to this series. The only way these books could present a stranger, more amusing take on Scotland Yard is if the characters were werewolves or vampyres. (They AREN'T).
I presented Murder in Thrall as a book club choice because I wanted to go outside the box. I know several members who have since read all of the books. so take the hint, read the first for sure and as many of the others as you can. Of course Murder in the Blood can stand alone on its own merits as Cleeland does her usual fine job of presenting the back story.
My only quibble with the book are the typos. (Yes i know, this review is probably filled with them)
With Lord and Lady Acton facing the investiture of a new title, Doyle is horrified to realize just how bad baby Edward's antecedents really are.
Lord and Lady Acton are helping Williams investigate a murder that seems related to the sex crime ring detailed in past books. This time they realize there is a mastermind who is in the clean up stage and for a change it is not his Lordship. He is busy with his own containment plans. Why Acton even bothers I will never know, since the "thick as a plank" Doyle always figures it out. This time his plan is particularly horrendous and if I were Doyle I would be packing my bags.
Ever since the jaw dropping Murder in Thrall I have been addicted to this series. The only way these books could present a stranger, more amusing take on Scotland Yard is if the characters were werewolves or vampyres. (They AREN'T).
I presented Murder in Thrall as a book club choice because I wanted to go outside the box. I know several members who have since read all of the books. so take the hint, read the first for sure and as many of the others as you can. Of course Murder in the Blood can stand alone on its own merits as Cleeland does her usual fine job of presenting the back story.
My only quibble with the book are the typos. (Yes i know, this review is probably filled with them)
September 18, 2019
Another fantastic read!
Yeah, you guess it, I’m a big fan of this series! 😍
A good mystery, I only started to get a clue at the same time with Michael, lol.
I don’t expected that, but nothing surprise me with this aristocratic lot’s behaviour anymore! 🙄
Not too many victims here, however the story have a strong connection with previous books.
And I found something about Michael which is really disturbing.
I hope he keeps his promises to Doyle, if Doyle didn’t find out what his planning was and he executed his plan, I’m not sure if I still going to like him.
Thankfully he doesn’t carry on with his nasty plan this time...
❤️
Yeah, you guess it, I’m a big fan of this series! 😍
A good mystery, I only started to get a clue at the same time with Michael, lol.
I don’t expected that, but nothing surprise me with this aristocratic lot’s behaviour anymore! 🙄
Not too many victims here, however the story have a strong connection with previous books.
And I found something about Michael which is really disturbing.
I hope he keeps his promises to Doyle, if Doyle didn’t find out what his planning was and he executed his plan, I’m not sure if I still going to like him.
Thankfully he doesn’t carry on with his nasty plan this time...
❤️
November 7, 2021
It was fun to get back to this series after a break. It does have unusual features including dreams where ghosts impart information to the red headed very Irish Doyle, so I like it best in small doses. I do not lose the thread as the individuals and situations they find themselves in are distinct and quite original. The very real love Doyle and Acton have for one another is central to the crime detecting that goes on in these books.
September 14, 2019
Series: New Scotland Yard/Doyle and Acton #10
Publication Date: 9/10/19
Number of Pages: 219
I always look forward to each new release in this series. It has captured me even though it is totally different than anything else I prefer to read. Once I get a new book, I can’t put it down until I am done. Acton is a dark force with which to be reckoned. He is a peer of the realm, and a high ranking member of Scotland Yard – he’s also not above manipulation and a bit of lawbreaking himself when it comes to seeing his version of justice done. Meaning, he’s a bit of a vigilante. He’s incredibly smart and very, very cunning. So, it is always a delight when the ‘dull’ but ‘fey’ Doyle thwarts his best-laid plans. There are usually a couple of ‘mysteries’ going on in each book – one a police case and one involving some machination that Acton has cooked up. Sometimes the two are related and sometimes they are not.
The fallout from the last case is still impacting the Metropolitan Police Force. They are grossly short-handed because of all of the corrupt members of the force that have been removed and everyone is carrying a double workload. So, imagine the surprise of Williams and Doyle when Acton shows up at the scene of a murder they’ve been assigned to investigate. Then, Acton interviews the witnesses/suspects and he’s – gasp – polite and subservient to them.
As the investigation continues and they learn more and more about the case, they determine that the murder is connected to a series of vengeance murders stemming from the last big case. Somebody is pulling the strings, but it cannot be the one that it so obviously appears to be. So, if not him – who – and more importantly – why! The case takes many twists and turns before all is finally revealed and the real mastermind is identified and the reason revealed.
At the same time, Doyle has become more and more convinced that Acton has something else going on and she has to figure out what it is – and stop it – before something worse happens. This time it is a doozie – and Acton is actually relieved to have Doyle discover his plot so he doesn’t have to carry it out – but it was a near thing.
As I said above, I love this series, but I will suggest that you not read this book as a standalone. At least read the first book or the first couple of books to learn about Doyle and her ‘gift’, Acton’s obsession and protectiveness, and their relationship. Understanding those things will really help you appreciate how far they have come – and will help you understand some of the nuances in this book.
I thoroughly enjoyed the read and hope you will as well!
Publication Date: 9/10/19
Number of Pages: 219
I always look forward to each new release in this series. It has captured me even though it is totally different than anything else I prefer to read. Once I get a new book, I can’t put it down until I am done. Acton is a dark force with which to be reckoned. He is a peer of the realm, and a high ranking member of Scotland Yard – he’s also not above manipulation and a bit of lawbreaking himself when it comes to seeing his version of justice done. Meaning, he’s a bit of a vigilante. He’s incredibly smart and very, very cunning. So, it is always a delight when the ‘dull’ but ‘fey’ Doyle thwarts his best-laid plans. There are usually a couple of ‘mysteries’ going on in each book – one a police case and one involving some machination that Acton has cooked up. Sometimes the two are related and sometimes they are not.
The fallout from the last case is still impacting the Metropolitan Police Force. They are grossly short-handed because of all of the corrupt members of the force that have been removed and everyone is carrying a double workload. So, imagine the surprise of Williams and Doyle when Acton shows up at the scene of a murder they’ve been assigned to investigate. Then, Acton interviews the witnesses/suspects and he’s – gasp – polite and subservient to them.
As the investigation continues and they learn more and more about the case, they determine that the murder is connected to a series of vengeance murders stemming from the last big case. Somebody is pulling the strings, but it cannot be the one that it so obviously appears to be. So, if not him – who – and more importantly – why! The case takes many twists and turns before all is finally revealed and the real mastermind is identified and the reason revealed.
At the same time, Doyle has become more and more convinced that Acton has something else going on and she has to figure out what it is – and stop it – before something worse happens. This time it is a doozie – and Acton is actually relieved to have Doyle discover his plot so he doesn’t have to carry it out – but it was a near thing.
As I said above, I love this series, but I will suggest that you not read this book as a standalone. At least read the first book or the first couple of books to learn about Doyle and her ‘gift’, Acton’s obsession and protectiveness, and their relationship. Understanding those things will really help you appreciate how far they have come – and will help you understand some of the nuances in this book.
I thoroughly enjoyed the read and hope you will as well!
June 30, 2021
I still want to slap both Acton and Doyle, but I still like their mysteries! And, strangely, thier relationship! LOL
May 19, 2024
This one was a bit more revealing of Acton's inner thinking and I can't say as I was too happy about it, or that Doyle was either.
But alls well that ends well.
Still enjoying it but I'm starting to think the vigilantes are outnumbering the law abiders. Certainly they are outnumbered if you add the 'actual' bad guys to the list too.
And Doyle's helpful ghosts? Well (as with the book 8), it turns out they aren't always there to be helpful.
I'm not sure how much further I want to go into the series. They are still fun, but it's getting beyond ridiculous.
But alls well that ends well.
Still enjoying it but I'm starting to think the vigilantes are outnumbering the law abiders. Certainly they are outnumbered if you add the 'actual' bad guys to the list too.
And Doyle's helpful ghosts? Well (as with the book 8), it turns out they aren't always there to be helpful.
I'm not sure how much further I want to go into the series. They are still fun, but it's getting beyond ridiculous.
September 13, 2019
Outstanding! It’s surreal that Murder in the Blood is the tenth novel in the Acton and Doyle Scotland Yard mysteries and this book takes the series to a new high. Kathleen Doyle, Lady Acton, has her hands full with more than just a murder to solve. There are a myriad of plot twists that she has consider and untangle to prevent a series of unfortunate schemes and events from occurring.
The pace of the story was very tense the main characters are working to unravel and connect how a recent murder is connect to a prior conspiracy that has lead to a series of arrests of highly placed governmental and law enforcement officials. Someone has been murdering the once well-regarded council members, who were the ring leaders of a sex trafficking ring exploiting new immigrants to London. As Acton and Doyle follow the clues, they discover another underlying twist that involves a blood feud involving Spanish aristocrats and revenge.
The elusive and complex Lord Acton is still holding discovery close to the vest and is plotting to take some matters in hand. His decisions can have some various serious and irreparable consequences if Doyle cannot decipher in time the cryptic messages from her dream visitors.
there are moments of levity as well, both Kathleen and Michael remain true to their authentic selves...marriage, religious conversion, parenthood, etc., had not evolved into a overnight epiphany for a 360 change in their characters. They are both still learning to trust and communicate with each other in way that does not override the other's core self.
The secondary characters are so richly-developed, I felt a huge measure of relief for three of the characters who, unknowingly, had the sword of Damocles hanging over their heads. It was wonderful to see Reynolds and Hudson play great supporting roles rather than as sneaky servants. It was also enjoyable to see an appearance by the snooty Dowager Lady Acton, her character's motivations are still rather vague.
Overall, superb reading and now the agony of waiting another year for the next book.
The pace of the story was very tense the main characters are working to unravel and connect how a recent murder is connect to a prior conspiracy that has lead to a series of arrests of highly placed governmental and law enforcement officials. Someone has been murdering the once well-regarded council members, who were the ring leaders of a sex trafficking ring exploiting new immigrants to London. As Acton and Doyle follow the clues, they discover another underlying twist that involves a blood feud involving Spanish aristocrats and revenge.
The elusive and complex Lord Acton is still holding discovery close to the vest and is plotting to take some matters in hand. His decisions can have some various serious and irreparable consequences if Doyle cannot decipher in time the cryptic messages from her dream visitors.
there are moments of levity as well, both Kathleen and Michael remain true to their authentic selves...marriage, religious conversion, parenthood, etc., had not evolved into a overnight epiphany for a 360 change in their characters. They are both still learning to trust and communicate with each other in way that does not override the other's core self.
The secondary characters are so richly-developed, I felt a huge measure of relief for three of the characters who, unknowingly, had the sword of Damocles hanging over their heads. It was wonderful to see Reynolds and Hudson play great supporting roles rather than as sneaky servants. It was also enjoyable to see an appearance by the snooty Dowager Lady Acton, her character's motivations are still rather vague.
Overall, superb reading and now the agony of waiting another year for the next book.
October 28, 2019
Needs an overhaul
This is hard. I love Doyle and Acton, Reynolds and little Edward. Williams is a knocker, and Munoz needs to get over herself. The Dowager Lady Acton is deliciously cold, plus the various ghosts that waylay Doyle can be insightful as well as amusing. And yet, I have to admit, that after ten books, I am getting a little tired of the same ongoing investigations, as well as the ‘dumb’ Doyle typecasting. Surely by now she should have developed some competency in investigating, and not relying on her abilities to sort the wheat from the chaff, so to speak.
It is becoming an act in frustration to see very little character growth from the characters, although one can argue that Acton has experienced some growth, when Doyle and Williams act like they are still in high school (emotionally), Munoz is still a catty, jealous - bordering on bitter - stunner who is looking for a sugar daddy, while Acton is still pulling all the strings like the Machiavellian mastermind he is, seemingly without any consequences. I need more from a series than stagnant characters.
However, I’m hoping that in the next book, with the investiture, that we might skew more into the realm of Doyle learning to navigate the upper echelons of society, as well as finally getting down to business with her mother-in-law. Plus, I doubt that Sir Stephen has gone away for good. Also, Doyle has yet to uncover/discover the link that Williams has to the Acton family. Surely that needs to be dealt with soon. There are a myriad of directions the author could go in to breathe a bit of fresh air into a series that I’m starting to feel is becoming stagnant.
I was not a huge fan of this latest case that, like all their other cases, ties in with the corruption, blackmail and murder of the Council, etc. It’s just becoming tedious. Yet I appreciated delving further into the Acton family, especially because of the donnybrook between Doyle and Acton at the end. Finally, there is a true bit of conflict in their ‘perfectly foine’ marriage, and I loved it.
3.5 stars ⭐️
This is hard. I love Doyle and Acton, Reynolds and little Edward. Williams is a knocker, and Munoz needs to get over herself. The Dowager Lady Acton is deliciously cold, plus the various ghosts that waylay Doyle can be insightful as well as amusing. And yet, I have to admit, that after ten books, I am getting a little tired of the same ongoing investigations, as well as the ‘dumb’ Doyle typecasting. Surely by now she should have developed some competency in investigating, and not relying on her abilities to sort the wheat from the chaff, so to speak.
It is becoming an act in frustration to see very little character growth from the characters, although one can argue that Acton has experienced some growth, when Doyle and Williams act like they are still in high school (emotionally), Munoz is still a catty, jealous - bordering on bitter - stunner who is looking for a sugar daddy, while Acton is still pulling all the strings like the Machiavellian mastermind he is, seemingly without any consequences. I need more from a series than stagnant characters.
However, I’m hoping that in the next book, with the investiture, that we might skew more into the realm of Doyle learning to navigate the upper echelons of society, as well as finally getting down to business with her mother-in-law. Plus, I doubt that Sir Stephen has gone away for good. Also, Doyle has yet to uncover/discover the link that Williams has to the Acton family. Surely that needs to be dealt with soon. There are a myriad of directions the author could go in to breathe a bit of fresh air into a series that I’m starting to feel is becoming stagnant.
I was not a huge fan of this latest case that, like all their other cases, ties in with the corruption, blackmail and murder of the Council, etc. It’s just becoming tedious. Yet I appreciated delving further into the Acton family, especially because of the donnybrook between Doyle and Acton at the end. Finally, there is a true bit of conflict in their ‘perfectly foine’ marriage, and I loved it.
3.5 stars ⭐️
September 28, 2019
Amazing beyond my high expectations! Wow! Anne Cleeland has stunned me speechless this time around! I was totally caught off guard by Lord Acton's mind-blowing protocol! He was ready to do the unthinkable & could have been an unforgivable deed! Fortunately, his
"Fair Doyle"
had managed to pull him away from leaping into the abyss!
Why have I been so cryptic here? Just showing off my ability in writing something with a hint of mystery 😝 And I did realize I failed! My clearest message was to please pick up this fantastic series and begin from Book 1 Murder In Thrall. Trust me. Anne cleveland won't disappoint. Sharing one of my favorite scenes:
Why have I been so cryptic here? Just showing off my ability in writing something with a hint of mystery 😝 And I did realize I failed! My clearest message was to please pick up this fantastic series and begin from Book 1 Murder In Thrall. Trust me. Anne cleveland won't disappoint. Sharing one of my favorite scenes:
"Since Master Edward is so young, Hudson was wondering if perhaps he should wear his christening gown for the occasion."
Holy Mother, thought Doyle in extreme alarm; she'd already resolved to hide all photographs of Edward's Baptism—when he had been required to wear the luminous and ancient lace gown—because the poor boyo shouldn't be forced to lose every thread of self-respect at such a tender age.
"I think a simple suit-of-clothes, rather," Acton replied.
Gratefully, Doyle expressed her approval of this plan.
"Much better—who thought to put boys in dresses, anyway? It's inhumane, is what it is."
"Yet the Irish do," her husband teased.
"Kilts are a completely different sort of thing," she replied, very much on her dignity. "It's a cultural heritage."
Acton reached to retrieve his fork from the baby's quick hands. "Perhaps Edward should wear a kilt, instead."
September 30, 2019
In their tenth outing, Murder in the Blood follows Scotland Yard husband and wife investigating team DS Kathleen Doyle and SIO Michael, Lord Acton as they uncover the circuitous, many-pronged plot which resulted in what initially seems like a simple homicide.
This time, Acton, who brings to mind a mashup of Tom Hiddleston’s gorgeous good looks with some of the personality quirks of Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock, is in danger of straying very far from the rule of law in his mission to promote the greater good.
Meanwhile, as the ever-intrepid and lovely Doyle is scrambling to prevent Acton from crossing the line, she struggles to understand what conspiracies, real and imagined, are coming to bear as threats to her family’s emotional health and physical safety.
Well-crafted and fraught with nuanced ethical dilemmas, Murder in the Blood weaves together newer themes of class and privilege with the series’ continuing themes of workplace relationships, sex trafficking and political corruption.
As with the previous books in the series, the plot of Murder in the Blood takes place over roughly a week’s time. While it doesn’t take long for the complex dominos of the murder to reveal themselves, it’s the sleuthing couple’s fascinatingly complicated and increasingly messy domestic life which shares more of the stage this time, with Acton’s Downton Abbey-like family seat and its inhabitants playing a key supporting role. Add in a couple of tiaras, one old and one very old, and the resulting perfection is a pleasure to read.
This time, Acton, who brings to mind a mashup of Tom Hiddleston’s gorgeous good looks with some of the personality quirks of Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock, is in danger of straying very far from the rule of law in his mission to promote the greater good.
Meanwhile, as the ever-intrepid and lovely Doyle is scrambling to prevent Acton from crossing the line, she struggles to understand what conspiracies, real and imagined, are coming to bear as threats to her family’s emotional health and physical safety.
Well-crafted and fraught with nuanced ethical dilemmas, Murder in the Blood weaves together newer themes of class and privilege with the series’ continuing themes of workplace relationships, sex trafficking and political corruption.
As with the previous books in the series, the plot of Murder in the Blood takes place over roughly a week’s time. While it doesn’t take long for the complex dominos of the murder to reveal themselves, it’s the sleuthing couple’s fascinatingly complicated and increasingly messy domestic life which shares more of the stage this time, with Acton’s Downton Abbey-like family seat and its inhabitants playing a key supporting role. Add in a couple of tiaras, one old and one very old, and the resulting perfection is a pleasure to read.
September 19, 2019
5 stars Called to investigate an apparent homicide on the grounds of a visiting professor, Sargent Kathleen Doyle and Detective Inspector Thomas Williams are shocked to discover the victim is a witness who had come forward and named names in one of their biggest cases. The unearthing of a widespread scandal in the Health Council which proved ties to corruption has left many high officials at the Met itself sitting in jail. Could vigilantes tired of waiting for progress in the case have taken the law into their own hands as a string of recent murders have targeted the very people who were once running it. Doyle is hard-pressed to drive home that justice still needs to be served and that taking the law into ones own hands is not the way. Unfortunately for her the company that she keeps, be it her illustrious husband who just happens to be Chief Inspector Acton and her best friend Williams have other ideas. Between trying to solve case, care for her infant son keeping these two on the straight and narrow takes the patience of a saint. The delay in proceeding against the potential suspect by the Chief Inspector is enough to give Doyle cause to believe that there is more afoot (once again) than she is being led to believe. The rules of the law apply to everyone but suddenly surrounded by many who believe it doesn't apply to them has Doyle looking very close to home. Refusing to harbor the thought that "a bloodline will tell" may just be her first mistake.
September 21, 2019
3.5 ⭐
The murder mystery was just OK. I'm tired of reading about the sex trafficking, money laundering, revenge and containment murders from the same case that now spans 10 books. This time members of the disgraced council are being murdered. I would like to see a completely new mystery. The characters are becoming too formulaic. Doyle still behaves like an idiot for most of the book and I don't understand what Acton sees in her. Sure she comes through in the end but getting there is so exhausting. The most interesting part of the book was the upcoming investiture. Unfortunately the book ended before the big event. I found that disappointing. IMO the plots are becoming too repetitive. I don't think I'll auto buy them anymore. I'll wait for the reviews first.
The murder mystery was just OK. I'm tired of reading about the sex trafficking, money laundering, revenge and containment murders from the same case that now spans 10 books. This time members of the disgraced council are being murdered. I would like to see a completely new mystery. The characters are becoming too formulaic. Doyle still behaves like an idiot for most of the book and I don't understand what Acton sees in her. Sure she comes through in the end but getting there is so exhausting. The most interesting part of the book was the upcoming investiture. Unfortunately the book ended before the big event. I found that disappointing. IMO the plots are becoming too repetitive. I don't think I'll auto buy them anymore. I'll wait for the reviews first.
October 5, 2019
ANOTHER FASCINATING STORY!!!!
I really love this series. It is so imaginative and riveting! You never know what the underlying direction it is going to go in. One thing that always enchants me is the love story between Kathleen and Michael... He would do anything to keep her safe, even if it is unorthodox. This was another fascinating story with twists and turns everywhere like usual!! I also enjoyed the way the book ended.... With Michael and Kathleen together and Reynolds and Hudson looking out for them! Can't wait for the next book to see what shenanigans this interesting couple get caught up into next.
I really love this series. It is so imaginative and riveting! You never know what the underlying direction it is going to go in. One thing that always enchants me is the love story between Kathleen and Michael... He would do anything to keep her safe, even if it is unorthodox. This was another fascinating story with twists and turns everywhere like usual!! I also enjoyed the way the book ended.... With Michael and Kathleen together and Reynolds and Hudson looking out for them! Can't wait for the next book to see what shenanigans this interesting couple get caught up into next.
October 9, 2019
Amazing, I thought the author had nicely finished off the mystery angle when to my surprise there was more to come! I should have known better as even in this latest offering the author, Anne Cleveland, continues to add twists and turns you never saw coming. I really liked the progression of Acton and Doyle’s relationship as it seems that even though Lord Acton really loves Kathleen, deep down he is still skeptical of her “extra abilities”. At first she is incensed, but handles it in typical Doyle fashion which leads to a deeper understanding and connection in their marriage. I continue to look forward to their continuing partnership and their growing array of family and friends.
November 8, 2019
4.5 Stars
rounded up to 5 Stars.
February 22, 2021
SPOILER ALERT
Once again I finish a Doyle and Acton installment having had to remind myself as I read that this was a contemporary 21st century tale. The vernacular used by Doyle combined with the cliches and malaprops and the old world culture of the aristocracy make for confusion in the time and the story. Once again there seemed a light meal of substance in the plotting with prior cases of sex- trafficking and drug-running mixing it up with an unclear vigilantism by Spanish servants of the English corrupt council members for whom the police were dragging their collective feet. The climax of which occurs at the baptism of Elena's baby where Munoz's grandmother and Acton manage aristocratic stares of power to end the murders. I did not end up with an understanding of the whys of the case.
It seems the story may be the need to strengthen understanding in the relationship of Doyle and Acton. Throughout there is the usual confused thinking by Doyle as to the actions of Acton. He is working at something that she cannot get a handle on, and it concerns her. In her dreams a dead copper and a crazy Acton ancestor fight to convey their knowledge of upcoming events or just rant. It all comes together when the medieval Knight ghost tells Kathleen of the existence of a true tiara, and she and Reynolds go to the Archives room to a well where she will find the treasure. Acton finds them. When she reveals how she knew of the treasure, he doesn't believe her, and she requires a discussion of her abilities and his handling of them. They meet at the pond where they have a heart to heart. He thinks she has extraordinary powers of perception and that her unconscious mind puts together things she hears and sees or dreams to come to conclusions. In no way does he think she sees and talks to ghosts. She sets him straight. She also reveals that she knows he is acting from his "murder in the blood" character in eliminating all who suspect or know of her extraordinary ability to sense when someone is lying. He is not to kill DI Thomas Williams whom she had told of her ability once. She understands he has already done away with another policewoman who was pursuing Doyle to determine that she had the ability. He is not to kill Gabriel or Lizzy Mathis who have guessed some of it. They will simply laugh off any references to her ability in the future. He is afraid of her vulnerability to criminals who would want to use her and would use Edward or him to get at her. She reassures him they can thwart any of these dangers.
The main purpose of the novel seems to be to establish the sanctity of Doyle and Acton's match/marriage. As if the connection and forced marriage that Acton perpetrated in the first book was fated, and that to ensure the continuation of the family they were meant to be together. And that Hudson and Reynolds are there to keep the couple and Edward protected. Additionally Doyle faces multiple ceremonies during the story: a marriage, a baptism and an investiture in which she will become Countess Aldwych, an event which she grouses about frequently. The fact of her part in the aristocracy of the Acton family is a sore point. A lovely way to end the story and to bring some clarity to the otherwise weird story. I think the book could have used a better editor, as time and again I had to reread a sentence to make sense because of extra words or jumbled order. The use of peculiarly hyphenated word phrases was also weird. Hopefully future installments will have clearer dialogue between Kathleen and Michael and they won't dance around each other's actions and abilities.
Once again I finish a Doyle and Acton installment having had to remind myself as I read that this was a contemporary 21st century tale. The vernacular used by Doyle combined with the cliches and malaprops and the old world culture of the aristocracy make for confusion in the time and the story. Once again there seemed a light meal of substance in the plotting with prior cases of sex- trafficking and drug-running mixing it up with an unclear vigilantism by Spanish servants of the English corrupt council members for whom the police were dragging their collective feet. The climax of which occurs at the baptism of Elena's baby where Munoz's grandmother and Acton manage aristocratic stares of power to end the murders. I did not end up with an understanding of the whys of the case.
It seems the story may be the need to strengthen understanding in the relationship of Doyle and Acton. Throughout there is the usual confused thinking by Doyle as to the actions of Acton. He is working at something that she cannot get a handle on, and it concerns her. In her dreams a dead copper and a crazy Acton ancestor fight to convey their knowledge of upcoming events or just rant. It all comes together when the medieval Knight ghost tells Kathleen of the existence of a true tiara, and she and Reynolds go to the Archives room to a well where she will find the treasure. Acton finds them. When she reveals how she knew of the treasure, he doesn't believe her, and she requires a discussion of her abilities and his handling of them. They meet at the pond where they have a heart to heart. He thinks she has extraordinary powers of perception and that her unconscious mind puts together things she hears and sees or dreams to come to conclusions. In no way does he think she sees and talks to ghosts. She sets him straight. She also reveals that she knows he is acting from his "murder in the blood" character in eliminating all who suspect or know of her extraordinary ability to sense when someone is lying. He is not to kill DI Thomas Williams whom she had told of her ability once. She understands he has already done away with another policewoman who was pursuing Doyle to determine that she had the ability. He is not to kill Gabriel or Lizzy Mathis who have guessed some of it. They will simply laugh off any references to her ability in the future. He is afraid of her vulnerability to criminals who would want to use her and would use Edward or him to get at her. She reassures him they can thwart any of these dangers.
The main purpose of the novel seems to be to establish the sanctity of Doyle and Acton's match/marriage. As if the connection and forced marriage that Acton perpetrated in the first book was fated, and that to ensure the continuation of the family they were meant to be together. And that Hudson and Reynolds are there to keep the couple and Edward protected. Additionally Doyle faces multiple ceremonies during the story: a marriage, a baptism and an investiture in which she will become Countess Aldwych, an event which she grouses about frequently. The fact of her part in the aristocracy of the Acton family is a sore point. A lovely way to end the story and to bring some clarity to the otherwise weird story. I think the book could have used a better editor, as time and again I had to reread a sentence to make sense because of extra words or jumbled order. The use of peculiarly hyphenated word phrases was also weird. Hopefully future installments will have clearer dialogue between Kathleen and Michael and they won't dance around each other's actions and abilities.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 20, 2021
I'd rate this book 4.5 stars and if a couple of plot points had played out with a bit more detail, it would have been a solid 5 stars for me. This was another entertaining read in this series; repetitive themes, if you've read any of the other books, but entertaining none-the-less. When the body of servant is found in the garden of Spanish aristocracy living in London, Doyle is left trying to put the pieces together behind her even more secretive than normal husband. With great care and caution needing to be taken, there's intrigue at every corner as suspects and victims are not who they seem, unravelling a plot that goes deeper than it appears at the surface level and can seemingly be traced back to Spanish upper crust families. Doyle, once again, is assisted by her ghostly visitors who warn her that a baby is in danger, causing her to question her son Edward's safety as Acton's anxiety levels soar through the roof. A dire warning is given and an ancestor from Acton's line makes an appearance.
There was a lot of double play in this book with characters not being as they appear, which made for a slightly more confusing plot with an ending and revelation that didn't quite do it justice. This being said, it kept me guessing throughout the book. I got the impression that maybe the corruption and trafficking ring story line is finally being brought to a close (thank goodness - I was starting to worry that this angle was going to go on forever and that it would be Book 20 and we'd still be getting suspects and plots that tie back to the case to end all cases). There's the usual elements that are sown throughout this series: Doyle not having a clue what she's doing for the most part and having information revealed to her by other sources and Acton being super secretive and having his own game played out, etc. The usual secondary characters pop up throughout the story, particularly Munoz due to the Spanish element of the case and her new love interest being on the scene. Several of these characters are also worse for wear as well as Commander Tasza remaining missing so something else is afoot.
The snippets at the start of the chapters are missing in this book. There's a small section of the story from Acton's point of view, which I loved and I wish this happened more frequently. I found that there were a couple of plot directions that were carried on throughout the book but unfortunately weren't completely followed through with. A ghost making frequent appearances seemed to just disappear and the reason for their presence never extensively explained. In fact, there was a sentence or two about them towards the end and that was that. Without spoiling anything, however, this led to a fantastic couple of scenes at Trestles that was a highlight of the story and caused Acton and Doyle having it out a wee bit (which was loooooong overdue). There was also a lot written about Acton's investiture as the current Earl was close to passing. It was a bit annoying to have so much of the plot bring this up but for the story to cut out before the blasted ceremony even happened. As a fan of this series, I felt ripped off, especially since bread crumbs were dropped from the beginning of the book.
A couple of story lines and corresponding characters cropped up in this book that I'm sure will continue into the next novel in the series. While I would have liked a bit more detail about a couple of plot points that were throughout the story and then seemed to be ignored by the end, it was still a good read. I'll be continuing with the series.
There was a lot of double play in this book with characters not being as they appear, which made for a slightly more confusing plot with an ending and revelation that didn't quite do it justice. This being said, it kept me guessing throughout the book. I got the impression that maybe the corruption and trafficking ring story line is finally being brought to a close (thank goodness - I was starting to worry that this angle was going to go on forever and that it would be Book 20 and we'd still be getting suspects and plots that tie back to the case to end all cases). There's the usual elements that are sown throughout this series: Doyle not having a clue what she's doing for the most part and having information revealed to her by other sources and Acton being super secretive and having his own game played out, etc. The usual secondary characters pop up throughout the story, particularly Munoz due to the Spanish element of the case and her new love interest being on the scene. Several of these characters are also worse for wear as well as Commander Tasza remaining missing so something else is afoot.
The snippets at the start of the chapters are missing in this book. There's a small section of the story from Acton's point of view, which I loved and I wish this happened more frequently. I found that there were a couple of plot directions that were carried on throughout the book but unfortunately weren't completely followed through with. A ghost making frequent appearances seemed to just disappear and the reason for their presence never extensively explained. In fact, there was a sentence or two about them towards the end and that was that. Without spoiling anything, however, this led to a fantastic couple of scenes at Trestles that was a highlight of the story and caused Acton and Doyle having it out a wee bit (which was loooooong overdue). There was also a lot written about Acton's investiture as the current Earl was close to passing. It was a bit annoying to have so much of the plot bring this up but for the story to cut out before the blasted ceremony even happened. As a fan of this series, I felt ripped off, especially since bread crumbs were dropped from the beginning of the book.
A couple of story lines and corresponding characters cropped up in this book that I'm sure will continue into the next novel in the series. While I would have liked a bit more detail about a couple of plot points that were throughout the story and then seemed to be ignored by the end, it was still a good read. I'll be continuing with the series.
October 30, 2020
I'm addicted to this series, although by the tenth book, there is a certain sameness to the story line. Kathleen Doyle, redhead, Irish, charming, and Michael Acton, handsome, aloof, aristocrat, and Doyle's superior in Scotland Yard, not to mention also her husband. They work together to solve the many murders that seem to be occurring all around them, along with a cast of interesting characters. Acton is secretive but Doyle has unusual abilities to perceive what he is trying to hide. After many twists and turns, and references to previous plots in earlier books, this one ends in a surprise. A very entertaining series and I'm ready to start #11.
August 7, 2021
Just Keeps Getting More and More Over the Top
The Doyle and Acton mysteries are progressing with Acton getting more and more obsessed with his wife and Doyle getting more and more power over his schemes and behavior. Enough said. I like these books even though their plots are getting more and more unreal over time. Just to repeat--for new readers it's crucial to read these books in order beginning with Book 1.
The Doyle and Acton mysteries are progressing with Acton getting more and more obsessed with his wife and Doyle getting more and more power over his schemes and behavior. Enough said. I like these books even though their plots are getting more and more unreal over time. Just to repeat--for new readers it's crucial to read these books in order beginning with Book 1.
August 16, 2021
Loved It!
This book settles many issues permeating the previous books! History and current happenings and problems! It is important to read the books in order because of relationships and events. The murders are a continuing story threading through each book, most coming from the first book.. The original events had many tentacles and we are learning about many of them. Each book has its own story, with no cliffhangers. Major problems need a long time to be solved!
This book settles many issues permeating the previous books! History and current happenings and problems! It is important to read the books in order because of relationships and events. The murders are a continuing story threading through each book, most coming from the first book.. The original events had many tentacles and we are learning about many of them. Each book has its own story, with no cliffhangers. Major problems need a long time to be solved!
December 30, 2025
excellent edition to the series!
I love this series because the plots are so well constructed each book builds on the proceeding books. I was able to figure out one of the key aspect of this particular mystery, although I did not correctly, figuring into its place in the overall plot. I’m looking forward to starting the next book in the series. The series of mysteries is like potato chips. You just can’t eat one.
I love this series because the plots are so well constructed each book builds on the proceeding books. I was able to figure out one of the key aspect of this particular mystery, although I did not correctly, figuring into its place in the overall plot. I’m looking forward to starting the next book in the series. The series of mysteries is like potato chips. You just can’t eat one.
July 14, 2020
This is another addition to a great series, history, blood feuds along with a little paranormal thrown in for spice. Doyle comes across as not too bright, but she is smarter than she believes and gets the mystery solved in the end.
July 18, 2020
I have loved this series since 'Thrall'...a fun and humorous take of Scotland Yard and the aristocracy. This mystery brings together many of the different types of mysteries and past villains alive and dead as Lord Acton awaits his investiture. DO READ THESE!!!
May 15, 2020
3.5 stars. It's ok but the first book was the best.
June 16, 2020
Doyle is such fun talking to ghosts and somehow staying one step ahead of her husband. No ghastly murders in this one nor was she ever in danger--I kinda like that.
September 15, 2020
Great ending!
Finally, Kathleen and Michael are equals. Perhaps now we won’t always be told the story, but we can watch it ravel.
Finally, Kathleen and Michael are equals. Perhaps now we won’t always be told the story, but we can watch it ravel.
October 4, 2020
Engrossing Read
One of my favorite fictional couples have another great adventure. I hope Doyle and Action continue to solve mysteries for a long time
One of my favorite fictional couples have another great adventure. I hope Doyle and Action continue to solve mysteries for a long time
February 2, 2021
Always challenging
Good books are hard to find. These have all been excellent a d when I did an author i like I am very loyal
Good books are hard to find. These have all been excellent a d when I did an author i like I am very loyal
Read
September 7, 20219/11/19 ; 2/16/2021
August 27, 2025
I read this one last year but lost my written review. All I remember is that the quality of this murder mystery is consistent with all the other reads in this the series and that I've enjoyed it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews